Preview

What Are The Arguments Against Child Soldiers

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
668 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Are The Arguments Against Child Soldiers
Currently there are 300,000 male and female child soldiers ranging between the ages of 6 and18 that are illegally recruited to fight for approximately 30 conflicts around the world. Child soldiers are targets for state-run armies, paramilitaries and rebel groups because of there vulnerability, age and size. Once recruited and trained they are known to commit acts of murder, rape, mass killings and mutilation. There is a debate whether or not children should be prosecuted for their war crimes. Child Soldiers are perceived as innocent and vulnerable but this is the problem. The motive for these armies and rebel groups to recruit these children is because of their place in society. Prosecuting child soldiers is a way of protecting the children. We also need to consider the fact that there are children who do volunteer to join the army. …show more content…
This is a motive for the state armies and rebel groups. We are basically giving these armies and rebel groups an advantage. They will use the children as an excuse to commit war crimes knowing that there will be no consequences and potentially cause more atrocities. If the court was less forgiving and set rules and guidelines for all children this world would be a safer place. For example if a child around the age of eight was involved in causing a mass killing he should be trialled as an adult because he did something wrong and therefore needs to be accountable for his actions. The punishment of children shouldn't be as harsh as an adult but still give the child a time to reflect on his actions and learn from his mistakes so when he does complete his sentence he won't be a danger to society.This will help prevent the recruitment of child soldiers because the armies and rebel groups will know that everyone involved in war crimes will face

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    You sit in a trench and wait for your orders to come. You look left and right to see your comrades sitting with you, but they aren’t grown men and women, they are children. Your mind is unsteady and lightheaded from the drugs you were given. When you look out of the trench you see children only eight years of age marching into a village and burning everything down to a smoldering ash. Some children do it for protection others doing it for their religion. Hundreds of lives were taken when the village burned down, and it was all at the hands of children. Child soldiers have been in existence for years. People believe that child soldiers should be punished for their crimes and put into jail, but why? Why would you put a little one in jail when they were told what they were doing was right? These minors have not been given the proper chance to live a life to the fullest of their potential.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is estimated that a third of all child soldiers are girls ("Facts About Child Soldiers | Human Rights Watch", 2008). They are often used as 'wives ' (i.e. sex slaves) of the male combatants. The use of child soldiers is prohibited under many International laws such as International Human Rights Law, International Criminal Law, and International Humanitarian Law ("Child Soldiers International - International Standards", n.d.). Although these laws clearly state that the use of child soldiers is illegal, it hasn’t stopped the rebels and even some governments from using child soldiers. The use of child soldiers predominantly strikes Sub-Saharan Africa as well as parts of Asia and South America. “Today, there are more than 250,000 children who have been recruited to participate in armed conflicts worldwide” ("The issue - The Roméo Dallaire Child Soldiers Initiative", n.d.). Why? because children are easier to condition and brainwash. They don 't eat much food, don 't need paying much and have an underdeveloped sense of danger so they are easier to send into the line of fire. As part of their recruitment, children are sometimes forced to commit atrocities to a family member - thus breaking…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Child soldiers shouldn't be prosecuted as adults for their actions. Instead they should be rehabilitated. Instead they could be rehabilitated. With rehabilitation it could help them heal from the damage caused for such trauma. Others argue that they still have done the crimes and it wouldn't be right, especially for victims, to let them free. The children shouldn't be blamed for what they are forced to do, the people authority should have punishment for having child soldiers. Giving child soldiers adult consequences for their actions would be insensitive and more damaging. Their brain isn't fully developed, making them easily manipulatable. Child soldiers shouldn't be persecuted instead of rehabilitated.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To illustrate, an article called “Kony’s Killers”, written by Samuel Okiror, says “[Child Soldiers] killed, maimed, mutilate, attack camps, abducted children, rape, slavery, torture and pillaging” (Okiror Para 2). This piece of evidence stated helps prove the claim, as it shows all of the merciless things that child soldiers have done. Criminals in America have gone to jail for a quarter of the reasons stated, yet there are still arguments whether child soldiers should be pardoned for all the crimes they committed. Additionally, another piece of evidence that supports the claim from an article written by Gregory Warner states, “… He forced many children to kill people” (Warner 3). This suggests how not only did the young soldiers inflict crimes, but forced other children to do it themselves.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not many people echo the idea that child soldiers should be prosecuted for their horrific crimes, but these people are wrong. An example could be Omar Khadr, it states in the article, The Child Soldier on Trial at Guantanamo (2015)”... Khadr threw a grenade that killed Speer and wounded others”(pg1) This is one example of horrible crimes because not only did he kill one person but he wounded others. This situation then escalated into a full on fire fight. Another example of this is from the story written by Ishmael Beah, A long Way Gone, it states,” ‘We burned about three…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Justice systems are struggling to determine whether child soldiers should be treated as victims or predators. Some say if a child soldier is considered too young to fight then, he or she should be too young to be held criminally responsible for serious violations. Child soldiers lack the mental maturity to fully understand the implications of their actions.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine if you were forced to kill others for whole years of your life, seeing the people bleed out each and every time as they struggle to hold onto life.This is what child soldiers are put through almost every day. In some parts of the world, such as Sierra Leone. There is tremendous disputes over child soldiers. Everyday hundreds if not thousands of child soldiers are drugged, abused, and brainwashed to kill others in the battlefields of Sierra Leone and countries alike. Now after all this, these children are being captured by governments across the world and are being prosecuted for their crimes…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child soldiers are causing harm to a countless number of people. These children are being used as suicide bombers. “Over the course of the past decade child soldiers have been responsible for some of the most brutal acts in war time.” Child soldiers can cause more harm because they aren’t always held accountable.” Children are not prosecuted. This could be an incentive for the commanders to delegate to them to commit war crimes as they know there are no consequences.” Although they killed thousands of people, they shouldn’t be accountable because they’re just…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First and foremost, the consideration of whether or not to help children is the issue. Many of them suffer from drug addiction and are basically brainwashed. To help the mass amount of child soldiers, we should give them amnesty. But we can’t just let them loose into the world because they can all still be dangerous. As the Armed & Underage article states, “They don’t complain, they don’t expect to be paid-and if you tell them to kill, they kill.” This is to show that if they are to hear the word kill, they’ll kill. Of course others may say differently. Personal research has been conducted and has…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The use of child soldiers is one of the most blatant abuses of international human rights. There have been a number of treaties that have tried to prohibit these practices, but the use of child soldiers has become more prominent and occurs in approximately 75% of conflicts around the world. Primary causal factors of recruiting children are: social disruptions due to globalization, disease and war which has resulted in further global conflict and generation disconnection which has created a pool of possible recruits and technological improvements with fire arms becoming smaller and lighter allowing children to be more effective. With low draft turnout, conflict leaders see the recruitment and use of children to be a economic benefit. It is low…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thousands of children are serving as soldiers in armed conflicts around the world. Boys and girls serve in government forces and armed opposition groups. They may fight as front-line combatants, suicide bombers, mine sweepers, sex slaves, and spies.Many are abducted or recruited by force, while others join voluntarily, believing that armed groups offer their best chance for survival. We are working to prevent the use of child soldiers and to hold accountable the people who send children to fight. It threatens the core of the United Nations, and the heart of our world's future: Children. The US Child Soldiers Prevention Act prohibits the US government from providing…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Would you like it if your children where taken from you to become a child soldier, well in Somalia children have been taken to become child soldiers. They are getting prosecuted for it as well, child soldiers should not be prosecuted for this.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The use of Child Soldiers is inhumane because they are forced into the military at a young age, taken away from their families, and used on the front lines. Most of these kids are forced into the military at a young age. No matter how young these children are, for mostly non-state armies, they are are told to kill innocent people (“The Invisible”). These boys and girls are at youngest around 8 years old and at oldest they are around 17 or 18 years old (“11 facts”). Some countries known to use underaged children are: Afghanistan, Colombia, India, Iraq, Israel, Libya, Mali, Pakistan, Thailand, Sudan, Syria, Yemen, and many more countries follow that practice (“11 facts”).…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child Soldiers Inhumane

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages

    War violates every right of a child, right to life, right to be with family, and right to be respected. UNICEF conducted a survey by interviewing 1,505 children in Sarajgus Africa. It found that 97% of these children experienced shelling, 20% of them had terrible dreams, 55% of these children have been shot by snippers and 66% have had near death experience; this resource is published by “The State of The Worlds Children”. Although there's a lot of controversy on if the use of child soldiers is humane, many agree that its very wrong that people still use child soldiers today. And many agree that children aren't meant to experience these traumas, and they may suffer the rest of their lives from experiencing this at such a young age.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child soldiers are killed if they do not do what is asked, and are brainwashed into doing things. For example, if a child soldiers defies orders or does not do what they are told, they would often be killed on the spot according to invisible children. This shows that child soldiers should not be prosecuted for their war crimes because they should not be responsible for doing what they are told to save their own life. In that situation, the choice is clear. They are just doing what they are told to prevent from being shot or stabbed resulting in death. Also, another way they are forced into committing these crimes is with the use of brainwashing. As said before, child soldiers are often fed drugs and alcohol to brainwash them into thinking what their commanders want them to think. This clouds their judgment and forces them to do what they are told because in that state of mind, they do not do what they want to do and do not make their own decisions. They are forced to believe that what they are told to do is right. It is the same thing as drunk driving. One might know it is not a good idea, but, under the influence of drugs or alcohol, they believe it is the right thing to do. If they are forced into committing crimes, even though they might not want to, why should they be put behind bars for the misdeeds of their commanders? In conclusion, child soldiers often have nothing to do with their actions and are forced into doing what they are told. Either because they are killed if they do act as wanted, or if they are brainwashed into believing that they want to do these things. For these reasons, child soldiers should be given…

    • 1731 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays