Preview

A Comparative Analysis of State and Church Relations in Mussolini's Italy and Hitler's Germany

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3599 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Comparative Analysis of State and Church Relations in Mussolini's Italy and Hitler's Germany
Totalitarian Regimes, Unit 3 A Comparative Analysis of Church and State Relations in Mussolini's Italy and in Hitler’s Germany. Richard Rothwell

This report will explore the relationship between Church and State in both Mussolini's Italy and Hitler's Germany. The position of the church prior to change of government will first be taken into account, providing both a better understanding of the events that followed, the societies in question and their perception of church and government. Figures of government opposition will be researched. The levels of intolerance will be looked at in each country and a search for reasons behind each dictators approach to religion. Hopefully by the end of researching the subject, an informed conclusion on the subject will have been reached that identifies the cultural differences of society and the ideological tenets of State that for a while dictated the place of the Church and its role to the populace.

A Modern History of the Catholic Church in Italy in the 19th Century

The unification of Italy saw a restructuring of Italian government and power. Prior to the late 1800’s Italy didn’t function as a nation with a central power base, it was a network of small independent provinces, with Pope Pius IX being the only authority with power extended beyond the province.
The unification or ‘il Risorgimento’, could be characterised as the evolution of a clandestine social agenda, with its aims to create a new centralised government free of papal dictate, and to become a nation strong enough to rid itself of Austrian occupation, which ruled Italy through the strength of The Holy Alliance. (Derrick Murphy, 2008)
From the 1820’s onwards, the next half century saw alliances made and broken and states’ independence won and taken away. However, the agenda to consolidate the provinces was pushed forward with steady progress over time. Government figures also

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    In the period 1896 – 1915, the condition of Italy was relatively in a terrible state in many ways with various political, economic and social problems that hindered the country’s progress. Italy’s Liberal Governments during this period were generally very unsuccessful in dealing with these inherited and growing problems clearly contributing to the end of Liberalism in Italy. More so, the Liberal Government under the rule of Giolitti saw Italy progressing in some circumstances regarding the socio-economic concerns. Nonetheless, it is very comprehensible that the Liberal Governments lacked solving the problems that they faced.…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1815, Italy had just emerged from Napoleonic rule and was completely divided into nine separate states; with different rulers and different cultures. By 1848, these states had progressed towards, albeit merely to a limited extent, some kind of national unity – national unity meaning the feeling of being united and together as one country. It could be argued that the lack of success in the reception of Giuseppe Mazzini’s ideas was the most substantial reason explaining this slow progress; though some would say that it was mostly down to factors such as the power and influence of Austria, poor communication within Italy, or its weak military. Through analysing the evidence, it would appear that the main reason for the slow progress of national unity within this time frame was poor communication.…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mazzini’s ideal was that Italy should be unified ‘from below’. He wanted the people of Italy to rise up from their high-powered oppressors, while still maintaining the opinion that if monarchs were prepared and wanted to fight against the Austrian domination, then they should be supported and not hindered. He wanted a ‘brotherhood of the people’ to all move toward greater social equality (Denis Mack Smith described him as having ‘contempt for xenophobia and imperialism) so that all of the people of Italy would unite in order to unify their country. Mazzini also stressed that Italy should be unified ‘by its own efforts’, wanting to avoid any outside help- especially from France- in fear that they may just replace one outside domination by another. However, the limited appeal of his ideas were shown when Italy was eventually united and done more-so from above than it was below- he was described as being ‘disgusted’ by this and criticized the new Italian unified state, describing it as a ‘dead corpse’. It could be argued that Italy could have been unified earlier under Mazzini’s watch if it had not been for how his ‘one overriding aim’ distracted from the main goal of a united Italy.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Prince reflects the context of Florence’s limited military and economic power in a fragmented Italy and threatened by surrounding states and country…

    • 1311 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unification of Italy Dbq

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After the Congress of Vienna Italy consisted of six separate states. Controversy over whether or not Italy should be unified stirred up during the mid to late 1800’s. The unification of the Italian states was an ongoing debate for quite some time. During the years of the debates people found the unification to be positive change, a negative change, and some had different opinions for their own certain reasons.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The conditions that led to this new form of Political government were distinctive to Italian urban life. By the 14th Century, Italy was divided into many principalities surrounding city-States. The cities were an integral part of life in Italy due to commerce, and Italians were the first to reap the benefits of new and increasing trade due to their favorable geographic position in the Mediterranean Sea. Because there was a constant political and class struggle in the cities, Italy lacked a central authority of power. In cities such as Florence, Pisa, and Milan, the age-old rival between Pope and Emperor played itself out. The Guelph party supported the Pope, while the Ghibbiline party supported the Emperor. Civil wars were fought in the cities and ended with a despotism system of ruling, either with an oligarchy or an autocracy. The forming of these authorities was crucial, because peace is essential for trade, and the surplus wealth from commerce is what led to the growth or art and literature, which began the Renaissance.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    How did Black Death and World War II affect religious beliefs in Europe, with a focus on the effects it had on both the Roman Catholic Church and Jews?…

    • 4285 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many similarities exist between German fascism, or Nazism, and Italian fascism. For example, both fascist movements were brought into power after facing very similar problems. One of the major problems that both countries encountered was a post-war economy teeming with instability. Germany's fragile economy was undermined by widespread unemployment, hyperinflation, and burdensome reparation payments, while Italy's economy was just as delicate. In addition, the Great Depression brought both countries even further into economic collapse. Another problem that brought about fascism in the two countries was post-war peace settlements, especially the Versailles Treaty. While the Germans were exasperated by the exorbitant reparation payments forced upon them by the Allies, the Italians felt betrayed by the peace settlements for denying them the territory and status they deserved. Another problem that the two countries faced was their dissatisfaction with their existing governments. Many Germans were disgruntled with the Weimar Republic for signing the humiliating Treat of Versailles, while many Italians were apprehensive of the chaos within their parliamentary regime. Lastly, widespread fear of revolutionary upheaval and the expropriations of a Communism system also caused many Germans and Italians to identify with fascism.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Italy - Research Paper

    • 10545 Words
    • 43 Pages

    After the decline of the Roman Empire, it took what is now Italy over fourteen centuries to become unified and drive out foreign rule. The state of Italy was formed following the Italian unification movement, known as Risorgimento. Italy installed their first Parliament and declared the Kingdom of Italy in 1861. (Killinger, 2002)…

    • 10545 Words
    • 43 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Benito Mussolini outlines several essential characteristics of his preferred political ideology, Fascism, in what has become known as the Doctrine of Fascism. In this paper, Mussolini outlines his vision of the ideology, and explains the major issues that Fascism will address once it becomes the leading political system in Italy. Mussolini’s major points as outlined in the Doctrine included an extreme emphasis on nationalism, organization and modernization of the state, persistent focus on religion, life as a struggle, and the notion that individuals exist only for the improvement of society as a whole. Wolfgang Schieder, after reviewing the Doctrine of Fascism, explains Mussolini’s success based on it and clarifies what exactly Adolf Hitler adopted from the Italian Fascist ideology to incorporated into his own Third Reich.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another reason for Italian Unification failure was the influence of Austria over Italian provinces. Austria had very strong domination over Italy. It had agreements with Ferdinand, king of Kingdom of the 2 Sicilies, and helped the pope maintain his kingdom. Only Piedmont Sardinia wasn't influenced by Austria. The rulers of Parma, Modena and Tuscany were directly or indirectly related with the House of Hapsburg. The ruler of Naples had concluded a treaty with Austria. The Pope of Rome was the supporter of Austrian policy. In this way, Austria was the real master of Italy. They helped to destroy the success such as in Modena and Parma where their leaders fled for safety. However, the Austrian army always, quickly defeated the revolutionaries causing the revolutions to fail.…

    • 819 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    However, more importantly in my opinion, the end of the war revealed that Italy lacked the diplomatically-savvy leaders because, as “the ruling coalition included many divergent points of view, her traditional system of government made this almost inevitable”.10 The public was confused about national interests and began to question whether the traditional system was really the best, be it the Liberals, the Socialists or the…

    • 2729 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    • How did Stalin change the government and the economy of the Soviet Union? • What were the origins and goals of Italy’s fascist government? • How did Hitler rise to power in Germany and Europe in the 1930s? • What were the causes and results of the Spanish Civil War?…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Communism and Fascism

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Europe around the 1940s, there were two major forms of government in the world, communism and fascism. The major nations that used these government forms include Germany, Italy and Russia. All said nations benefited very greatly from the use of these ideologies whereas both ideologies have many of the same principles and basically just as many opposing principles. The similarities and differences vary greatly in the fields of social and economic influences and the impact on religion throughout the areas. The basic principle of communism is that it depends on the government’s control of industry while Fascism is based on the pride of the society and on violence to create the ideal society through the eyes of the leader.…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Doctrine of Fascism

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Benito Mussolini’s, Doctrine of Fascism, the identity of the recently popular movement is formed into a coherent set of rules and guidelines. The ideals of Fascism are stated upfront, and no matter how difficult to understand, the contemporary fascist acted in obedience to them. The government of Fascism, already in full force, needed this document to ensure people understood the severity of the movement. As an Italian, Mussolini appealed to his audience and wrote this doctrine for many purposes. He bore a sense of nationalism which definitely shined through in his writings. As stated before, the Doctrine creates an identity for the Fascist “personality” and gained support from anyone who simply desired change.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays