Preview

The Pros And Cons Of Arming Teachers

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1320 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Pros And Cons Of Arming Teachers
Arming Teachers: Increasing Potential Harm On April 20th, 1999, two high school seniors, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, shot and killed thirteen innocent students at Columbine High School after a bomb they set earlier that day failed to detonate. This tragic event inspired many to make changes in school systems around the country, yet since Columbine, there have been more and more school shootings, all leading up to the recent Parkland shooting in which seventeen people were killed. Michael Roberts, an author at Westword wrote, “The Parkland incident was at least the 208th school shooting to take place in Columbine's wake.” 208 school shootings in just nineteen years does not make schools look safe. Also, these shootings have had a massive …show more content…
Many ideas have been brought up, but the United States government seems to come to a standstill because no one can agree on what solution will work best. One idea that has been growing is arming teachers in schools to stop the threats right in their tracks. Upon first hearing this suggestion, most people think it sounds completely absurd. After considering both sides, however, the argument starts to make more sense and may not be as ludicrous as one may have thought. Even the president of the United States is calling for arming teachers. Although the topic proves worthy of debate, schools should remain gun free because students may feel uncomfortable thus affecting learning, it could potentially be more dangerous to students, and there are other ways to prevent school …show more content…
First of all, if a teacher were to conceal a gun at their side, a lot of potential for misuse may arise. For instance, in a demonstration or simple showcase to students of the firearm, shots may be fired accidentally. If those who are armed unconsciously switches off the safety, disaster may strike. Another considered idea was locking a gun in a safe, but this could pose just as many dangers. Teachers who do not pay close attention to the safe could risk a student meddling with it or stealing a key which allows a potential break in, thus allowing a student to get ahold of a gun more easily to turn on other fellow students. Not only do safes allow the potential for break-ins, but if they are stowed in a very secure area, teachers may not have enough time to get to the safe and unlock it before it is too late. Now if a shooter enters a school and begins firing, even if a teacher obtains access to their gun in enough time, another major problem arises. Teachers will need to find and to lock down on one specific target while the rest of the school runs. “Even police officers with years of training still have doubts -- and make mistakes -- during critical moments at crime scenes. Deciding when to open fire and who to fire at during adrenaline-filled moments is tough business,” (USA Today). Armed teachers, with no real life experience in shooting a criminal, will face

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Despite the numerous parents and staff that are in favor of the new transition of teachers with guns there are a few that are not as adaptable with this change as others are. Teachers such as Ms. Moffis that stated, “Traditionally in this area, schools have already been a very safe and welcoming community,” referring to teachers having guns in the classroom, she added, “Nobody’s ever thought about needing that kind of thing at school.” This coming from a town that is well versed in handling guns within their own community and training their children at an early age the proper understanding of firearms.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Arming teachers is a very tough topic to talk about. The first documentary that we watched showed a school that teaches students how to react in a shooting situation, and also arms teachers. I believe that this school is going a little overboard with arming the teachers. The program to train children in self defense is a good idea though. I'm not saying that we should constantly live in fear of a school shooting, but defense training would be a good workshop to do with students. They brought up a very good point in this documentary when they mentioned physical education classes, and the lack of benefits from. I believe that a self defense class would be very useful to ready students for their future. This could help them not only defend themselves…

    • 261 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Sam Cooperman Theses: Teachers should be allowed to carry guns in public schools. Protection of students Response time in a school if there was a situation More knowledge and training for adults in a crisis situation Adults are able comprehend and conceptualize a situation. 1.…

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children at Sandy Hook Elementary School were helpless when Adam Lanza walked in with three guns and shot twenty kids and six adults. As a result for not letting teachers carry some type of weapon, teachers and student are getting shot. The only Thing that students have for defense is any object that is in that room, but that doesn't compare to a gun.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Secondly, it may be argued that if a teacher has a gun the students will be kept safe from an invader. However, a gun on school property creates safety hazards, which could lead to a teacher or student being caught up in an altercation, and the absent-minded firing of a gun makes a dangerous environment for the impressionable youth to develop in. As president Randi Weingarten and his Michigan counterpart, David Heckler, state, having firearms in schools create a potential hazardous set of conditions that could result in a negative outcome. (CBC) Schools are supposed to be a place safer then…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Teachers in 18 states are now carrying guns in school! After a recent study in the news that left many people questioning about, whether teachers should carry guns at school or not. My opinion is that they should not bring guns to school because it could accidentally go off. If this occurred it could affect a child's learning long term and their home life. This could also attract teachers for the wrong reason.…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Picture a class of twenty elementary students hidden under desks around the classroom, and the teacher is begging the children to stop sobbing. Down the hall the sound of gunshots ring out the sounds of people screaming and begging for help can be heard. The shooter is moving closer and closer to the area and all the innocent soon to be victims are defenseless. There is nothing in that classroom that is going to stop what is about to happen. Now imagine a teacher with a handgun that could at least scare off the shooter, or deter them from advancing into the room. Many people frown upon teachers being able to carry a handgun on school grounds, but if they only knew that the thing they frown upon could possibly be saving their kids life. It makes perfect sense that teachers should be able to carry a handgun if and only if they go through the proper training and tests.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What message does it send if we suggest through armed school personnel that our minds are not enough? “Clearly our students and staffs need to study, work, and play in safe surroundings; chances of having any breach of security need to be diminished. However, classroom teachers are not called to perform such duties.”, Lloyd E. Sheaffer. The students need to know that they are safe and with guns on campus they fear they are not safe. Kids also have a conscious too they know when something's up they will not feel safe with their conscious telling them they have guns around them. Today's teachers build emotional connections with their pupils; they encourage feelings of trust and confidence. Guns and other excessive security measures do not make kids feel safer and they increase their perception that they are unsafe," she said. If they have to go through metal detectors or pass by an armed guard, they believe they are not in a safe…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Teachers should be able to carry firearms at school. “the arming of teachers would have a greatly immediate impact on violent behavior in schools by criminals.” (Ayoob). As Ayoob says, there wouldn’t be as much violence in schools if teachers and staff were trained and had weapons. The teachers that would be armed will need to go through a mandatory training, the same training as police and security guards. “For the concept to work, teachers would have to voluntarily offer to carry and pass strict…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should teachers be able to carry a gun on them during a school day working environment? With proper training and lessons.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    No student would ever want to be put in a terrifying situation of being in a school shooting. Parents worst fears are taking their children to school one day and not ever being able to see them again, well teachers are here to prevent that, if only people would understand. Students want to be able to feel safe at school they don't want to have to worry about stuff that only happens every once in awhile. When students feel safe at their schools they are going to have a great time and will want to go back. However, if they don't feel safe they are going to hate school and aren't going to want to go back. Our teachers are great people that want to have us come learn, that is why it's important we give them the right of carrying concealed weapons. The push to put guns in the hands of the educators isn't going to end anytime…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article “Philosophizing With Guns” Gubler argues that letting students bring guns onto campus would enhance the likelihood of suicide, domestic violence, assault and accidental discharge. Students that can openly carry guns to school will have more opportunities to cause violence. University administrators take into consideration that it would be better to have students carry guns into classrooms than to have them deposit them in lockers so they do not misfire. Gubler says, “So now, people who cannot be trusted to safely transfer their weapons to lockers will instead carry them into spaces of learning.” (Gubler). She is asking why are we allowing students that can not properly handle a gun carry them into heavily populated…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    America is widely known for having a fascination with violence and is a “gun – happy” country. However, this love for firearms has led to tragedies untold and horrifying truths about the mental state of individuals as revealed in the Columbine School shooting incident. Major and minor causes collectively led up to this event and bring up the question of whether or not this tragedy could have been prevented. The NRA play a key part in the debate over gun control, and parents play a vital role in instilling future generations with respect for handguns and being involved in their lives. Though there is room to consider a grey area guns continue to be the instruments used to sow sorrow resulting…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gun-free zones put students in danger, but if we have guns allowed in school that only teachers can carry around. Claire Caulfeild said “because law enforcement can’t be the first responders, the first responders are those at the event…like teachers or parents.” Teachers and trusted parents should be able to carry guns. If you have a gun and something dangerous happens you will be the first to help. First responders won’t get there before it happens. Having a gun at your side would be very good to have.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Ohio had a bill passed so students can't carry on public campuses. Ohio had an attacker and the man was killed within minutes of running his car into the building and pulling a knife on students. If there is a gun man and many students have guns and open fire on the shooter there could be cross fire that could kill innocent people.” (Pittsburg Post-Gazette, Dec 20, 2016, p.1). Some people think this but, if there was a designated person in the areas and there was an attacker the person carrying the gun could stop the attacker hopefully before the damage is done. Adrian Burns said( Nov 6, 2016, p.1) “Schools want to arm teachers to help defend the school. In Ohio there are 175 staff members with guns. They have the staff have guns just incase a student or someone comes into the build and starts shooting people the school wants the teachers to shoot the shooter before they kill more people.” That is if the designated person is not the one attacking people. Some people want to know who the designated people with the guns are but if everyone knows who is carrying the gun and if an attack began to happen, that criminal would be going after the person with the gun first so the attacker does not have a threat. Julie Turkewitz and Troy Griggs said “In the past 25 years violent crime has decreased dramatically. 44 million americans owned 192 million guns in 1994 and now it's 55 million americans own 265…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays