Preview

Similarities and Differences Between Britains and Jamaica's Political System

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
819 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Similarities and Differences Between Britains and Jamaica's Political System
Rummel describes political systems as “the formal and informal structures which manifest the state’s sovereignty over a territory and people”. Now, sovereignty in politics is said to be concerned with the ‘right’ of a given country to have national control over a country’s territory. Norman Grindley and Anthony Woodburn, in an article published in the gleaner on February 14, 2002 describes a political system as “one which seeks to identify and satisfy the demands of its citizens as best as possible.” They also mentioned that the mandate of a political system is to maximize the utilization of all resources in order to arrive at society’s desired goals. Combining both definitions, we can say that a political system is the formal and informal structures which gives a state the right to have general control over a country’s territorial space and its citizens, by aiming to satisfy the demands of those citizens by making the best use of all available resources. The Westminster system originates from the Palace of Westminster, the home of the British House of Parliament. It is an adversarial two party system that utilizes a single member plurality system. The plurality system is where voters simply place a mark next to their preferred candidate. The candidate receiving the highest number of votes wins. This allocation rule is referred to as "first past the post." Grindley and Woodburn noted that each nation has adapted, adopted or created a system of government that is considered consistent and compatible with its citizen’s socio-political-economic, cultural and environmental needs. They also hypothesized that each political system varies according to its philosophy and culture. I share their perspective. Thus, we can infer that Britain and Jamaica has political cultures which defers. In their article, Grindley and Woodburn identifies Jamaica’s political system as “the export model of the British Westminster-Whitehall model.” They pointed out that Jamaica adopted this

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Westminster is the location of the Houses of Parliament, where the majority of political decisions (other than those for devolved states) are made for the nation. The current Westminster electoral system is First Past the Post (FPTP) which is used for general elections every 5 years (due to the new fixed-term parliaments brought in by the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition.) The FPTP system is constituency based, each person votes for a representative for their constituency and whichever party wins the most constituencies gains governmental power. First Past the Post works on the basis of a plurality of votes, that is, that the winning party need only gain the most votes out of all parties to gain power, they do not need an overall majority (50%+.) The need for a strong and stable government is through the need for a government to easily be able to pass legislation and for them to be able to withstand a full term in office.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Assignment 2 2014 2015

    • 480 Words
    • 3 Pages

    M2 – Compare the electoral processes used at different levels of government in the UK.…

    • 480 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    A modern nation-state such as Britain prides itself upon its strong democratic values, yet it is easy to question whether the individuals we elect, the people to whom we give our support and legitimize, are truly the ones with power. Has power shifted away from the individuals we elect in recent years? Has power ever truly been in their hands? To effectively begin answering such questions it is vital to lay out a theoretical framework in regards to what power entails. Steven Lukes’ three-dimensional approach to power allows for an analysis of power that goes beyond the decisions made in Parliament by those we elect, as well as attempting to understand the less obvious, preference-shaping nature of power. It is important to note that whilst it is perhaps difficult to effectively gather, or identify empirical evidence for the third-dimension of power, problems similarly arise when attempting to do so for the first and second face power; however from a theoretical standing the three-dimensional approach enables a much more thorough examination of where power lies in Britain today.…

    • 2677 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Additional Member System

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When defining elections, Lynch (2004: 33) states that it is ‘at the heart of the democratic process.’ The main political activity for most people is to vote in an election. Through electoral process, governments are being chosen and elected before holding certain position in the office. To conduct such activity, an electoral system is needed.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In government the key stage of direct government representation comes from MP’s, these are the elected representatives from each of the constituencies who are voted into government in separate elections. The electoral system we have in the UK is debated whether it is a form of Parliament that is representative of its constituents. The first past the post system used in the UK is a system where the amount of votes gained within a constituency for a candidate has to have the most votes but not necessarily a majority. This then means the same for the amount of MPs who form parties, the amount of MPs voted in.Generally the party with a majority of constituencies can form a government but in the 2010 election a coalition has to be formed in the absence of a majority. Although this can be unfair to smaller parties this often creates strong government. Alternative vote (AV) is another electoral system by which voters place the candidates in their constituency in order of preference. After the count of first preference votes the candidate with least drops out and the second preference votes of those who voted for said candidate are redistributed. This process continues moving down preferences until a candidate has a…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Born on February 6,`1945 in St. Ann Parish, Jamaica. Bob Marley helped introduce reggae music to the world and remains one of the genre's most beloved artists to this day. The son of a black teenage mother and much older, later absent white father, he spent his early years in St. Ann Parish, in the rural village known as Nine Miles. Marley lived in Trench Town, one of the city's poorest neighborhoods. He struggled in poverty, but he found inspiration in the music around him. Trench Town had a number of successful local performers and was considered the Motown of Jamaica.A local record producer, Leslie Kong, liked Marley's vocals and had him record a few singles, the first of which was "Judge Not," released in 1962. While he did not fare well…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jamaica is a constitutional parliamentary democracy. The fusion of United States and England's governments is apparent simply from this name, with democracy relating to the U.S. and the parliament…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Governments play a large part in our lives. We are so used to their role, that much of their influence goes unnoticed. Governments differ from country to country, but their influence remains. Canada is a democracy with a parliamentary system of government. The United States of America is also a democracy but with a presidential system of government. Canada's parliament consists of the Queen, the Senate and the House of Commons. In the Canadian parliamentary system the Prime Minister is the Head of Government and is also a member of the House of Commons. The Prime Minister is the leader of the winning party in the federal election. This person is appointed by the Governor General as the Prime Minister. Even though they are appointed, they are elected first. The American system of government is established by the United States Constitution, which provides for three separate but equal branches of government: legislative, executive, and judicial. Together, these branches govern the country. In the American presidential system the President is the head of government and chief executive officer. Both Canada and the United States are representative democracies with a federal structure. I prefer The Canadian parliamentary system of government over the American Presidential system of government. The leader of a political party in the American presidential system of government may only be reelected once. The leader of the political party in the American presidential system of government is not a member of Congress (legislative branch). As well, Voters must wait for regular elections to unseat an unsatisfactory president or member of Congress. In this essay the three branches of government, elections in the United States and Canada, the Head of State, similarities and differences to both systems of governments and the strengths and weaknesses to both systems of government will be examined and explained in depth for a better understanding of both the Canadian Parliamentary…

    • 1969 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today power is exercised by the leaders of that political party which currently holds the greatest number of seats in the House of Commons. These seats are contested, usually at four- or five-year intervals, in general elections at which almost all persons of eighteen years and over are entitled to vote. The general election selects individuals. However, political party organization and discipline are so extensive that it is almost impossible for a candidate to be elected who does not represent a major party. In effect, individuals are elected in a party, not a personal capacity. When they get to Westminster they are expected to vote according to party loyalty rather than personal preference or conviction when these clash. A highly developed system of 'party whips' ensures that, in most instances, the Commons votes on party lines. Thus effective power is vested in the party rather than in a collection of individuals. Political parties are all-important. We even speak of a two-party system of government, implying that the struggle for power is between two leading parties in the state who alternate in government. Since the 1920s these have been the Conservative and Labour parties. Such a system was a recognizable feature of British political life in 1867, but not in 1780.…

    • 7456 Words
    • 30 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Despite its flaws the ‘First past the post’ electoral systems for general elections suits Great Britain”…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first of the four systems I will analyze is the current method of voting in Canada – First Past the Post (FPTP). Named as a reference to horse racing, FPTP voting systems elect candidates simply by who got the most votes in an electoral riding. FPTP has many distinct advantages; it provides voters with a simple and easy to understand voting system, it often gives way to majority governments (Reynolds, 2003, pp. 28) which allows for the easy passing of legislation, and perhaps most importantly, gives voters a clear link between themselves and Parliament, in the form of their MP. However, many notable disadvantages exist in FPTP systems. Primarily, the results of a FTPT system rarely accurately reflect the wishes of the voters. Because a…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With different political party systems there can be very different outcomes when it come to the satisfaction of voters with their political parties. The difference between Canada’s multiparty system and America’s two-party system is an unmistakable illustration of this. In this essay I will demonstrate how Canada’s representative democracy is better than America’s with respect to the number of political parties in each system because in America; fewer voters’ opinions are covered and politicians are attempting to win a greater percentage of votes at an expense.…

    • 2292 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Each and every country has its own unique culture or tradition. So does Jamaica. Jamaican culture encompasses religion, Jamaican lifestyle and Jamaican society as a whole. Jamaican culture is what defines its people .Their past is full of fascinating stories. Whether they were part of enslavement and oppression, the Jamaicans are survivors.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    PESTLE Analysis of UK

    • 22108 Words
    • 144 Pages

    The UK adheres to a democratic, parliamentary system of governance known as the Westminster system. This system…

    • 22108 Words
    • 144 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Macionis and Ken Plummer discuss the multiple ways in which political activity exceeds or tries to do away with established practices. Whilst they claim that a political system tries to resolve controversy within a system of rules, their chapter “Power Beyond the Rules” describes politics as an entity which is a disagreement about goals and the means to achieve them.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays