Preview

Reflection On Native American Land

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1047 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Reflection On Native American Land
RESOURCE EXTRACTION ON NATIVE AMERICAN LANDS
Andrew Kalmey This August 2012 article “Tapping Into the Land, and Dividing its People” describes the controversies of whether the Blackfeet tribes should allow oil companies on to their 1.5 million acre reservation on order to drill for oil. This issue causes divide within the peoples on the reservation because of their Blackfeet beliefs of how the land is living and very sacred and whether or not to go against those beliefs in order to gain jobs and wealth overall. The two different parties within this issue are the Blackfeet tribe verses the modern oil companies. Specifically the natives in this reservation were upset because their land is sacred and living in their perspective so they don’t want oil companies pushing them aside to ruin their peaceful area. On the other hand there is the problem of high poverty in this region. Unemployment …show more content…
First off Ms. Pauline Matt is concluded as a credible source for her view on the issue on oil drilling on the Blackfeet reservation. She is a known member of the Blackfeet tribe and her ancestors have lived on this sacred land for centuries, in addition she also has lived here her whole life and stays true to the past her native tribes morals and beliefs about their land. http://missoulian.com/news/local/blackfeet-women-make-pilgrimage-to-call-attention-to-hydraulic-fracturing/article_65b5a5ac-e43e-11e1-89dc-001a4bcf887a.html
From the opposite side of the issue, Ron Crossguns was also concluded as a credible source for explaining his view about fracking on the Blackfeet reservation. He is a member of the Blackfeet Oil and Gas Department. He is also a source from an interview that was put into documentary about the blackfeet.
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Bear Pipeline Case Study
    • 199 Words
    • 1 Page

    Bear Pipeline Case Study

    One recent autumn evening while I stood in line to comment at a public hearing about a proposed natural gas pipeline through Virginia, I befriended an inspirational environmental advocate by the name of Bear Redstar. Bear grew up in a Lakota family as a part of the Dakotas’ seven Sioux tribes. Bear’s initial exposure to the destructive potential of a pipeline occurred while he worked as a welder for ExxonMobil on the Trans-Alaska Pipeline, where he witnessed the steel pipe rupture and release crude oil into the environment. Upon his return home, he advocated alongside Native American community members against the Dakota Access Pipeline. A few months ago Mr. Redstar, moved to Roanoke, Virginia, again facing the trouble of a pipeline. He and I were at the public hearing to warn the Appalachian community of the risks associated with a pipeline.…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Dakota Access Oil Pipeline Analysis
    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page

    Dakota Access Oil Pipeline Analysis

    The issue displayed in the article is the legality of the construction of the Dakota Access oil pipeline through Native American lands in North Dakota. The author and I believe and claim that the construction of the Dakota Access oil pipeline should be halted. The reason I hold these views is that the pipeline neglects the protection of the future and the past. This is supported by the fact that the pipeline is planned to be constructed through a river where 17 million people obtain their drinking water from, posing a threat to millions if the pipeline were to break. In addition, if the pipeline were to be built in this location, it would neglect the treaty rights given to the Native Americans when they initially settled there.…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Dakota Access Pipeline Project Analysis
    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Dakota Access Pipeline Project Analysis

    Ever since the project was invested the Indigenous people have begun their protest to protect their tribal land, by also gaining help from other tribes and or ethnicities. The pipeline was supposed to go through a town called, “Bismarck”, but the company that runs this operation rerouted the pipeline, which now runs through the Sioux reservation. As you can see, the population of Bismarck was able to have a say in this project, because the majority are white, they had that impact on the Sioux nation prioritize not have a chance to have their say, but were forced to accept the fact that is where the location of the pipeline will be. Adding on to this, there has been various protestors also known as the “Water Protectors’, with the help of other ethnicities and environmentalists, trying to help stop the construction from occurring still. These protestors have been trying to defend their land from being destroyed by the government, because of them protesting negative outcomes approached, “Law enforcement officers tried to blast the protestors away with water cannons in 25-degree weather and employed other ‘less than lethal,’ though still harmful, dispersal methods. One protestor may lose her arm as a result of injuries suffered from the violence” (Thompson). The ignorance actions the government made, made these negative outcomes towards the Indigenous people who in which they’re already taking more from them then they already had in the beginning to begin…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Gasland Josh Fox Analysis
    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Gasland Josh Fox Analysis

    These people were going through many problems like they could not use tap water due to hazardous contamination present in the tap water, their pets are chemically burned, they were getting sick and some of them could not even step out of their houses due to polluted air. But their main problem was nobody who actually could help or could make difference would listen to them. In this kind of situation their voice being heard by the entire nation was half battle won and Fox does exactly that for them. However I was little disappointed when I did research to verify the validity of supporting evidence presented in the movie. Only somewhat credible evidence shown is the EPA representative, however, he doesn’t make a formal statement hence does not contribute in a meaningful way. Another piece of evidence he used was lab reports of the fluid in the jar that was handed to him by an unknown person who could have possessed if from anywhere. Since this source was not trustworthy, Fox should not have been used the result to support his theory that fracking is reason of contamination. Fox claimed that chemicals used in fracking polluted the river with dead fish; but according to Energytribune, even before Gasland was shot, EPA reported that it was due to toxic build up, the result of discharges from coalmines. It is true that there are some…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    A Very Brief History: The Navajo's Land
    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A Very Brief History: The Navajo's Land

    They grew corn, beans, squash and melons. They hunted and ate Kaibab squirrels, black tailed jack rabbits, small pigs, peccary, horses, buffalo and sheep. They baked kneel down bread, Navajo cake, Navajo pancakes, blue “dumplings”, blue bread, hominy cookies, and squash blossoms stuffed with blue corn mush and pinon leaves. They also steamed and roasted corn. They harvested wild fruits and vegetables such as pinon nuts, corn silk, wild berries, wild onion, Navajo spinach (bee weed and pig weed), wolf “berry”, wax currant, sumac grapes, juniper oranges, yucca bananas, and Navajo tea (telesperma). They also traded for deer, squash seeds, tumble mustard seeds, pinto beans, goat, goat milk, and goat cheese. In special occasions they would have wild edible clay, wild potatoes, mimosa, sagebrush, and juniper…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Standing Rock Persuasive Speech
    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Standing Rock Persuasive Speech

    Hey Xoe, please talk to your following about Standing Rock. More people need to know about what’s happening, because it’s horrible. It seems as though our native people are losing once again. Police are tormenting them on their land. I’m not sure if you know about what is happening, but I feel like it’s important to know, or to educate as many people as possible on the subject. A short summary of this situation would be that there is a an oil pipeline being put through the Standing Rock reservation in North and South Dakota. If you didn’t know oil pipelines have high rates of leaking which would cause the Native Americans living there not be able to use the natural water sources such a lake and rivers. The pipes also will most likely exploded,…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Wk2DrillGripp
    • 821 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Wk2DrillGripp

    The stakeholder’s moral failings come only thinking of the revenue that mining would bring and not the effect on the environment. The beauty of the Green Valley will change with industrial growth. The involvement of politics may play a role since the land is public and owned by the government. Bureau of land Management is in charge of issuing permits for drilling, and some people think that they are catering to particular political groups.…

    • 821 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Sioux Nation Case Study
    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Sioux Nation Case Study

    Custer made its way into the Black Hills as an investigation of rumors of gold in the area. The investigation proved that the area was rich in natural resources such as its suitability for grazing, cultivation, mineral, and timber resources. The investigations findings gained widespread circulation, and there was soon pressure from the public on the United States government to open up the Black Hills area for settlement. For a while, the government used military force to prevent settlers from entering the Black Hills area. However, this only lasted a short period of time. Eventually, the government decided that the military should no longer provide resistance to miners attempting to occupy the Black Hills. These orders were to be carried out without any notice to the Sioux Nation. As more settlers began to flood the area of the Black Hills, the U.S. government felt that the only course of action that was sensible was to attempt to purchase the land from the Sioux. When the negotiations failed, the U.S. resorted to military…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Fracking
    • 718 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Fracking

    The stakeholders in the fracking process are the companies Buckeye and Forestar. The CEO of Buckeye, Jerry Spalvieri, is an independent explorer and really believes that Northwest Georgia will give up liquid riches. (1) He thinks northwest Georgia is a good area to gamble, because where there is gas, there is usually oil and other moneymaking liquids close by. Buckeye has leased 7,500 acres of mineral rights in Georgia allowing them to unlimited drilling on these properties. (1) Buckeye is debating on two different locations in Dalton, Georgia to do some drilling. Buckeye has dug more than 250 wells and has hit the jackpot a half-dozen times across Oklahoma and Tennessee. (1) It is very obvious that this company knows what its doing. Forestar, a real estate, timber, oil, and gas company out of Texas is also interested in the area around Dalton, Georgia. Forestar has mineral rights for 67,000 acres in Floyd and Chattooga counties. (1) This company actually started drilling in Cave Spring in May. Many companies out of Tennessee and North…

    • 718 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    An Argument Against Drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Reserve
    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages

    An Argument Against Drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Reserve

    America’s rank as the world’s leading superpower gives the nation unsurpassed clout throughout the rest of the world, but as the old saying goes “With great power comes great responsibility.” Many other nations not only rely on America’s economy for their own country’s survival, but they also look up to America with a hopeful sense for the future. The founding fathers of this great nation had excellent insight into the authority that America would one day possess, and thus they attempted to set many precedents that would lead the way for the nations that would choose to follow America’s example. Still today, every move that the American nation makes is carefully scrutinized by the other nations of the world. So, it is crucial that the United States ensure that as it moves forward, it does so with a noble and future oriented perception of its goals. Thus, drilling for oil in the Alaskan National Wildlife Reserve would be a colossal mistake for the United States, because drilling would be detrimental to the pristine indigenous environment, it would have little or no beneficial impact on the American or Global economy, and would poorly exemplify the ambitions that America should have.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    What Are The Pros And Cons Of Fracking
    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages

    What Are The Pros And Cons Of Fracking

    The motion put forward by organizers was entitled “Fracking in the Karoo – for and against…” Prof Philip Lloyd, from the Energy Institute at the Cape Peninsula University of Technology, made his viewpoints of fracking being beneficial very clear to the public. One of his main points used to convince those present at the debate to side with him, was the fact that the evidence showing that the sub soil water would be contaminated if fracking were to go forward, is insufficient to warrant enough concern. He describes the water present there today as “brackish and contaminated with natural uranium radio-activity”, and therefore in reality fracking would not be solely responsible for the potential toxicity of the water if it is allowed to happen.3 He goes as far as to say that even if the water were to become contaminated from the drilling, it would still be able to be consumed by humans, without damaging their health. Professor Lloyd provided the various benefits of fracking too. Job creation is one of the biggest benefits as thousands of workers would have to be employed for the project. Then there is also the potential for South Africa to move up in the ranks as one of the leading countries in gas reserves in the world. (second to countries like China and America.) Ivo Vegter, a popular journalist, shared Lloyd’s sentiments and added that, “A developing country (like South Africa) cannot afford to have a pathological distrust of capitalism or industrial development.”…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Fracking Pros And Cons
    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Fracking Pros And Cons

    Hydraulic fracking for some is a dream come true. For others, it is a nightmare. The act of extracting oil and natural gas from shale rock layers from within the earth has environmentalists pulling out their hair and politicians jumping for joy. The contamination of groundwater, air and land is constantly being brought up in debates. The government on the other hand argues that it only causes minimal harm and the benefits, like job creation and individual wealth, far out way the cost.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Tar Sands Essay
    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Tar Sands Essay

    Throughout my travels in Canada, I’ve met many people with differing opinions on the issue of the “Tar sands” or “Oil sands” (I shall use both unambiguously) development. Environmentalists (like myself) and concerned citizens in Canada, as well as the international community, decry that the largest industrial energy project on the face of the planet is destroying future generation’s right to clean soil, water, air, biodiversity and most importantly a stable climate. As well as strong local economy, the current economic setup of the tar sands’ development is to focus on export to foreign countries, leaving Canada with no energy security and a weak local economy. My opinion on this issue is to stop the further development of the tar sands. I will outline the “true” facts of the tar sands and the negative impacts they will cause.…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Oil and Gas Exploration
    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Oil and Gas Exploration

    Indigenous communities across the globe have been victims of unwarranted exploitation by private investors in the search for among others oil and gas. Whenever governments and oil companies intend to enrich themselves from the oil revenue, history has indicated that voiceless citizens are subjected to inhuman treatment and torture, deprivation of their indigenous community rights, disruption of their once peaceful way of life, destruction of forests and bushes, noise pollution and clearing of community shrines just to name a few. This is despite the undisputed fact that when all this is done, some “primitive individual”, who is supposed to enjoy the protection of the state, is directly or indirectly affected and mitigation measures are not put in place. After the experience of the Niger Delta and whatever happened there, communities have taken a vow to confront their enemies. The drafters of international oil and gas policies, municipal laws and regulations governing the oil and gas sector, in their wisdom and in acting ex abudanti cautella, introduced the concept of community compensation because they foresaw a conflict in the making. However, whether this requirement is often adhered to by oil companies and private investors is another long story. But the question is and always shall be, has the oil company ever tried to put itself in the shoes of these local communities and feel the pinch of eviction from one’s aboriginal land without an iota of compensation? Are oil companies run by human beings who know or ought to know the laws governing oil exploration? I know the answer. The oil process, as my friend keeps on telling me every time I raise this issue with him, is an el classico clash between Mbuta and Omena and that I am the most insane person he knows in Kenya if I expect omena to win the match. But is that the law?…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Should The Dakota Access Pipeline?
    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Should The Dakota Access Pipeline?

    Of course there is the Native American tribes who protest the pipeline because the plan is for the pipeline is to go straight through their territory. To being there was just a small protest mainly with the native Americans of the local tribes peacefully protesting the building of the pipeline but after one A-list Hollywood celebrity was arrested on October 10th, which so happened to be National Native American day, Shailene Woodley the star of The Divergent Series, was arrested while protesting with the tribe members and her arrest was streamed live all over the internet for the world to see. After her arrest more people tuned in to find out exactly what was happening at Standing Rock. Since Woodley’s arrest thousands more people have gone up to Standing Rock to stand alongside those protesting this pipeline. Among those who joined in the protest are thousands of military veterans, chairman Dave Archambault II, Chief Morgan Littlesun, and many of other people from around the country. These protests even brought Sioux and Pawnee tribes together after centuries of hating each…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics