Pro/Con Immigration reform
RESOLUTION: The United States should Issue visas to illegal immigrants.
PROS
1: CLAIM: Guest workers are primarily here to benefit the agriculture and the high tech sectors of the economy.
WARRANT(S):
-In 2007 about 70% of jobs for working in agricultural fields are filled by foreign born which thus improve our economy.
IMPACT(S):They increase agricultural and high tech sectors of economy because they take jobs that can't or won't be filled by non immigrants in the US.Thus they are able to improve the economy.
2:CLAIM: Mexico relies on the US dollar to bring in and increase or benefit the economy.
- Mexico relies on immigrant family money to families here because the money goes towards the government as well.
If we don't allow immigrant workers to work in the US it could hurt relations between the US and Mexico. It could also hurt the mexican economy.
CONS
2:CLAIM: An overpopulation can decrease jobs.
WARRANT(S):
- The overpopulation or the wave of immigrants that came in 20 years ago did no aid in stopping or decreasing immigrant flow
IMPACT(S):
-This will cause a big mass flood of immigrants and can cause overpopulation.
1:CLAIM: It will encourage immigrants to migrate to the US.
WARRANT(S):
20 years ago there was a tidal wave of immigrants due to the granting of visas.
IMPACT(S):
This will attract more immigrants and will cause a decrease in jobs and be a danger to the economy. Immigrants can be good but too many can be dangerous.
3:CLAIM: We will have to pay for more immigrant workers retirement money.
WARRANT(S):
- This will decrease government funding and money and decrease the economy.
IMPACT(S):
-This will hurt the economy and also hurt the foreign countries in which the immigrants are coming from because they will not receive money from their own people.
PROS
1: CLAIM: Guest workers are primarily here to benefit the agriculture and the high tech sectors of the economy.
WARRANT(S):
-In 2007 about 70% of jobs for working in agricultural fields are filled by foreign born which thus improve our economy.
IMPACT(S):They increase agricultural and high tech sectors of economy because they take jobs that can't or won't be filled by non immigrants in the US.Thus they are able to improve the economy.
2:CLAIM: Mexico relies on the US dollar to bring in and increase or benefit the economy.
- Mexico relies on immigrant family money to families here because the money goes towards the government as well.
If we don't allow immigrant workers to work in the US it could hurt relations between the US and Mexico. It could also hurt the mexican economy.
CONS
2:CLAIM: An overpopulation can decrease jobs.
WARRANT(S):
- The overpopulation or the wave of immigrants that came in 20 years ago did no aid in stopping or decreasing immigrant flow
IMPACT(S):
-This will cause a big mass flood of immigrants and can cause overpopulation.
1:CLAIM: It will encourage immigrants to migrate to the US.
WARRANT(S):
20 years ago there was a tidal wave of immigrants due to the granting of visas.
IMPACT(S):
This will attract more immigrants and will cause a decrease in jobs and be a danger to the economy. Immigrants can be good but too many can be dangerous.
3:CLAIM: We will have to pay for more immigrant workers retirement money.
WARRANT(S):
- This will decrease government funding and money and decrease the economy.
IMPACT(S):
-This will hurt the economy and also hurt the foreign countries in which the immigrants are coming from because they will not receive money from their own people.