Preview

Pork Chop Hill

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2089 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Pork Chop Hill
The film Pork Chop Hill, starring Gregory Peck, is an American made movie that depicts the true story of the battle of Pork Chop Hill in the Korean War. As one of the last battles of a war, which reached no conclusion the significance of Pork Chop Hill is one that is difficult to describe. Tactically, Pork Chop Hill had no conclusive purpose whatsoever – it did not provide any offensive or defensive advantages to either side of the war, nor did it lead to any type of supply road. The leadership in the film recognized the lack of importance that Pork Chop Hill had for them in the fight and consistently asked themselves why they are wasting their men and valuable supplies for a location of such little importance. Contrarily, strategically, to …show more content…
Halberstam informs us in The Coldest Winter, that the Chinese were infamous for their ability to reposition and move troops nearly invisibly due to the fact that the United Nation forces never knew where and when the Chinese would going to be striking next.2 Halberstam goes on to mention that the Chinese soldiers wore white parkas that would allow them to blend in with the snowy terrain and drop to the ground each time American patrol planes flew overhead in search of the enemy.2 In other words, the Chinese always had the upper hand in regards to their capabilities of maintaining the element of surprise, and yet, the primitive bugle with its high-pitched noise hat resonated across the valleys, destroyed this element of surprise each and every time they used it. The audience of Pork Chop Hill took note of this based on the reactions expressed by the American forces every time they heard the dreadful sound of the bugle. As soon as they heard the noise, they were able to strategically prepare themselves for the attacks that were about to come, every time the horn was sounded, the Chinese gave away their position and the fact that attacks were on their …show more content…
Private Franklin is an African American soldier who introduced to the audience when they first start charging the hill. After repeated attempts to hide from the fighting and Lieutenant Clemens pushing him onward, another African American soldier, Corporal Jurgens, is tasked with keeping Franklin in line. Throughout the film, the audience observes two different perspectives of these soldiers and the reasoning they have behind their actions.5 Corporal Jurgens tells Private Franklin that he has an invested interested in the performance of his fellow African American because he hopes one day back home they can be treated with equality if they perform well in Korea.1 Halberstam explains that it was not until the Korean War when the U.S. Army started to desegregate the forces and the audience of Pork Chop Hill sees evidence of that with the appearance of these two African American soldiers.2 However, even desegregated units were difficult for African Americans because, as Private Franklin explains to Lieutenant Clemens, “I don’t want to die for Korea. What do I care for this stinking hill? You wanna see where I live back home? I sure am sure I ain’t gonna die for that.”1 Truth be told, as Lieutenant Clemens points out, not many of the soldiers had a reason to fight in Korea. Most American soldiers, Halberstam explains, did not even know where Korea was at the outbreak of the war let

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    As one of the most famous battles of Vietnam, the battle of Dong Ap Bia provides a useful case study for the concept of mission command. Infamously known as Hamburger Hill, the high casualties and subsequent abandonment of the mountain caused critics to question the decision of military leaders. As with many battles in Vietnam, the commander, LTC Honeycutt, contended with the enemy while attempting to exert control with incomplete information in jungle-covered mountains. Although he was generally successful in fulfilling the six imperatives of mission command, it does not prove decisive to the U.S. Army’s ultimate victory. LTC Honeycutt’s approach to mission command is both lean and blunt, focused on success in combat.…

    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay “Foot Soldiers of the Revolutionary Army” by Gary B. Nash, the authors of the book tell of a Private Joseph Plumb Martin that kept a diary that details the life and hardships that the soldiers endured. Martin writes, “The army was now not only starved but naked. The greatest part were not only shirtless and barefoot but destitute of all other clothing, especially blankets.” (Gary Nash 124) The blacks were involved given the chance to receive freedom, which did not follow through completely. Although the colonies needed men for the army, these two simple sentences exposed the truth that people didn’t know at the time and even now.…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Joseph Miller, a former slave, enlisted in the Union army under the promise from the federal government that his family would be given food, shelter, and clothing, in exchange for his service as an enlisted soldier.21 However, when Union soldiers ordered his family to leave the tent they occupied, Miller wrote he “told him [a soldier] that I was a soldier of the United States. He told that it did not make any difference.”22 These types of empty promises made by the Union government were only slightly referenced in the film, such as the pay of African American men, $10, versus white soldiers, $13.23 Downs writes about these empty promises in his essay, stating, “the military often fail[ed] to pay black soldiers, or paid them less than promised.”24 This is seen slightly in the film, however, the film portrayed it as a one-time occurrence, rather than a continuous pattern of failing to pay…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the beginning of the book private Archie Lemon thinks about the war that suppose to “end injustice,” and that he doesn't mind getting killed, because the people coming after him will live in “happiness and peace” (23). Such a false propaganda is recognized by soldiers fifty pages later. They realize that the war “was brought about moneyed interests for its own selfish ends,” because idealism and patriotism have nothing to do with the war. They call it brutal and degrading, and, “fools who fight, are pawns shoved about to serve the interest of others” (96). March in the 30s recognizes of what the war becomes in the twenty first century; a character name Sergeant Theodore Donohoe back then sees the war as a business (because today it is fought for the territory or land resources); he states that in order to get anywhere in it, one has to adjust oneself to its peculiarities and “play the cards the way they fall” (30). Unfortunately, not a lot of soldiers have learned or will ever learn how to play this game…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Olson and Randy Roberts confront the difficult question of who was ultimately to blame for the complete destruction of the villages of Son My. The military named the village of Son My containing My Lai, My Khe, and Co Luy ‘Pinkville’ in reference to the color designated to the region by combat maps. Pinkville resided in the Quang Ngai province; an area known to the military to be largely occupied with Viet Cong and Viet Cong sympathizers. U.S. military and civilian leaders were beginning “to view the war in terms of territorial conquests, not the attainment of the villagers’ support”. Charlie Company 1st Battalion, 20th Infantry under Captain Ernest “Mad Dog” Medina and Lieutenant William Calley arrived in Quang Ngai in 1967. Olson and Roberts immediately point out the emphasis the company’s training had made regarding obeying orders at all costs. Right away they raise the question of whether or not there is a conflict between following the orders of superiors and following one’s conscience. Paul Meadlo, a rifleman in C Company, recalls what he took from his training: “…you’re trained to take orders from the first day you go to that damned service, and you come back and, all right, you want to try some people that had to take orders”. To make matters worse, C Company’s leader of the 1st Platoon, William Calley was incompetent. All four sources agree on the fact that Calley was painfully ordinary and demonstrated the bare minimum of what was necessary of an officer. He could hardly even read the military maps. His promotion to Lieutenant came at a time when there was a shortage of second lieutenants, but most certainly not because he was well qualified. As the platoon moved throughout Quang Ngai, his poor leadership was evident. He constantly got his men lost and Captain Medina often referred to him as “Lieutenant Shithead”. Aside from being an evident poor leader, the company was becoming discouraged and frustrated by the guerilla-style warfare the VC…

    • 2693 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “‘Keep the window shades down,’ Sweet said as I stowed my gear and found a place to sit. ‘We don’t want people seeing you and panicking over a train of Japs.’ That did it. ‘Sir,’ I said. ‘ You wrong to call us Japs. Japs are the ones who bombed Pearl Harbor-the enemy, not us. We’re Americans.’” (Salisbury, 97). In this quote, Eddy shows lieutenant Sweet who he is and how he defines himself and his colleagues. Eddy stated that he was an American, and that this is how he defined himself all along. Although punished for speaking back to a higher rank, Eddy spoke out and showed who he was, and that he wasn’t afraid to do…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hamburger Hill, also known by ‘Hill 937’ or ‘Ap Bia Mountain’, refers to a battle fought between May 10th and 20th of 1969 in the Vietnam War (Sorely et al). American troops fought to defend a relatively insignificant hill in the South of Vietnam. The object of the attack was to eliminate enemy forces and to obtain enemy weaponry (Vowell et al). It gained significance mostly because when the casualties were reported in the United States, they were misrepresented, resulting in a public outcry (Summers et al). The monetary and human cost that was expended during the battle with what seemed to be very little gain for the South Vietnamese or the Americans enraged those whose taxes and loved ones were paying the price.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    When the soldiers first got there, they were nervous because it was their first time fighting in a war. Everything was new to them. When Jenkins died, they got hit with the harsh reality of war. After the sorrow from his death had passed, they joked around with each other all the time and were carefree. They did not realize that everything they did had a consequence that could lead to them going home or not. A Vietcong questioned Peewee and Peewee told him accurate information about himself and almost got killed. The soldiers were all so young and inexperienced so they panicked when something bad happened and ended up making a mistake. Richie missed a mission, so he went with a different squad to do what they were assigned. The soldiers were so frantic that they accidentally fired on their own platoon and killed more than a dozen American soldiers. As the novel progressed, the soldiers gained more experience and learned how to handle situations better when under pressure. Perry’s squad went on a pacification mission and said, “They were supposed to think we were the good guys… I didn’t like having to convince anybody that I was the good guy… We, the Americans, were the good guys” (112). They could not comprehend that anyone would think that the Americans were not trying to help. When the village burning happened, all of the men were confused as to why anyone would do such disturbing things like cutting off a baby’s head. During that time, Richie faced his first face-to-face encounter with a Vietcong that almost shot Richie. When an icky situation actually happens, one forgets all of his/her training and panics and/or draws a blank. Richie ends up going to the recovery hospital because he was injured and he loved the experience. It was calm and relaxing. Although Perry completely dreaded going back to his squad from the recovery hospital, he was thankful that he got a “break” from the war.…

    • 2407 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Battle Of Osan Essay

    • 2393 Words
    • 10 Pages

    The battle of Osan is one of the worst defeats by the United States of America to the North Korean People’s Army (NKPA) during the Korean War. The battle of Osan, the first battle of the Korean War, showcased a poorly equipped, under-trained, unorganized and undisciplined U.S. Army force. A rough estimate of sixty U.S. soldiers killed, up to twenty-one wounded and eighty-two captured. Despite the low causalities, the loss at the battle of Osan would lead to the deaths of nine hundred and twenty-two killed and over twenty-four hundred additional prisoners or executed at the Battle of Taejon that would subsequently follow. The purpose of this paper is to explore the possibility of an alternate outcome if the American forces won the battle of Osan against the NKPA. I will examine the Battle of Osan by applying the four steps of battle analysis in order to provide an alternate outcome. During my research, I discovered that many historians blamed budget cuts for the defeat at the Battle of Osan however, I assess it was the lack of Intelligence of the battlefield.…

    • 2393 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Men joined the Marine Corps for many reasons . . . I’d joined up to dodge the draft and ended up being sent to war” (Brady 8-9). This brief yet poignant statement begins the story of how James Brady ended up serving in the Korean War. As a young adult the draft was being reinstated and Brady did not feel the desire to fight in a war. He and a few of his friends decided instead to join the Platoon Leaders Class with the Marines, which had students spend two summers at the marine Corps Schools in Quantico, Virginia. After these two summers, graduates would become Lieutenants, but they could not be drafted. Shortly after Brady graduated, the war began in Korea and his class learned they had to prepare to be sent out. The Coldest War: A Memoir of Korea is a first-person narrative of Brady’s life during the war, including his time as a platoon leader, his interactions with other members of the military, and his own personal thoughts during this time.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Going After Cacciato

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Through meeting Li Van Hgoc the reader learns the "true enemy" in the novel. According to Li Van Hgoc, "The land is your true enemy." He mentions that the soldier is the representative of the land and the land is also fighting a battle. Through listening to Li Van Hgoc at the "tea party" the platoon…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie “Glory” discloses the story and history behind the 54th Massachusetts Infantry. This infantry became the first black unit to fight in the Civil War for the North. The unit was formed up of black soldiers; some Northern freemen, and some were slaves that had escaped. The leader was General Robert Gould Shaw, the son of one of the top Boston abolitionists. The men of the 54th Regiment proved themselves worthy of the freedom for which they were fighting for and to gain the respect of their fellow white soldiers they fought with. Although the white soldiers fought along their fellow Black soldiers, there were often discrepancies in communication and treatment, that led to character development throughout the movie.…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the primaries, Fred Lundin had determined that Thompson could win the general election by capturing big margins among three important demographics: blacks, the Irish, and Germans. None of these groups has been particularly pro war.” (Krist.81).having such a big support base alone off the three races especially the African Americans he especially knew how to satisfy what the African American community and live up to their need. With the knowledge and early help of his father whom “fought the slave-owning rebels at Mobile Bay” in his time. (Krist.71). All in all, he did not need the support of the white people, when he had such support from the people who really needed attention. In this case Krist shows how much he is able to achieve without trying to hurt the African American community, in which is believed the tone he sets towards him is quite respectable, even with his failed attempts at keeping the militia out of the picture for…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Generally summarizing the Korean War as in Blair’s Forgotten War – At the end of World War II the western half of the world (the Capitalist side) and the eastern half of the world (the Communist side) divided the Korean peninsula into two nations, the northern half communist and the southern half American occupied and capitalist. The two nations were divided at the 38th parallel. The Korean War itself began when the communist North Koreans invaded their South Korean neighbors by advancing over the 38th parallel boundary, on the 28th of June 1951 when the North Korean army, using Russian equipment and advisors, had conquered much of South Korea, a poorly equipped and poorly led U.S. Army came to the rescue of the South Koreans. President Truman had basically stripped the U.S. Army’s equipment and manpower down to nothing for budget reasons, believing that his military advisors spoiled, dumb, and “big spenders”, (sparing no expense to win a battle). Truman believed that he could do better than any military official. General Douglas MacArthur, on whom Blair spares no criticism, had been overseeing the occupation of Japan, and was a decorated general during WWII in the Pacific theater, he was the obvious choice to be appointed commander of the U.S. forces which were to hold back the North Korean army at Pusan – the tip of the Korean peninsula. MacArthur was in command of…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cold Mountain

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Frazier suggests that the war damaged Southerners both personally and politically. Frazier’s characters are rarely supportive of one side or another. After three years of conflict, many are disillusioned with what they consider to be the selfish motivations of both sides. In particular, the inhabitants of Cold Mountain are presented as guarded, insular, and narrow-minded.…

    • 1817 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics