Preview

Nietzsche: Relationship Between Ethic And Morality

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1448 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Nietzsche: Relationship Between Ethic And Morality
Stella Natalia
English 1A
Prof. Jeffries
October 18, 2013
Ethic and Morality
There is a close relationship between morality and ethics but they do not mean the same thing. On the other hand, anti-morality and anti-nature are aspects, which negate vital instincts. Friedrich Nietzsche is a renowned philosopher who criticized social laws, religion, and honorable in a radical manner. Nietzsche argues that, “anti-nature refers to the idea of allowing human beings to coerce others into adopting their beliefs and morals” (Friedrich 404). Friedrich Nietzsche had a personal belief that morality is anti-nature. In fact, Nietzsche states that, “Every naturalism in morality-that is every health morality-is dominated by an instinct of life” (349).
…show more content…
Ideally, Christians are rational beings who do not have such morality. Indeed, very few Christians would identify with Nietzsche’s argument since his ideas discourage Christians from following their religion. Notably, Nietzsche’s argument that religion alters human nature by allowing Christians to adopt different aspects of life that prevent them from celebrating life is misguided. This is because Christians have morals that allow them to enjoy their lives just like any other person. In fact, his argument is not universal since it only addresses Christians thus leaving a significant population out. Assuredly, Nietzsche discourages people from adopting religion’s doctrines that alter human passions but encourages people to follow their human desires (Jacobus …show more content…
In fact, the act of satisfying individual responsibility is a moral behavior that resides outside the premises of religion. Actually, some philosophers like Murdoch claims that religion improves right morals by instilling a conviction and belief of doing the right things while out of control. Indeed, religion plays a noble role of encouraging humans to abide by the code of ethics set by the government or any relevant institution. In fact, Murdoch asserts that religion plays a huge role in generating someone’s morals by instilling the urge to remain focused on individual objectives. She further confirms that human nature accommodates the aspect of fulfilling one’s responsibility. With this argument, we can derive that religion does not alter human nature and that responsibilities propel human beings to decide and behave in a certain manner. Again, this assertion is stronger than that of Nietzsche, which claims that religion inhibits human

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    religious based ethics with the new social ethics promoting reforms (Ch. 23 p. 730). The battle…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “Religious ideas so pervade U.S. society that they provide the foundation of morality for both the religious and the nonreligious” (Henslin, (2015). I cannot identify myself with a religion, however I believe that it gives me idea of morality and humanity. Especially in GCU I can see that religion has a powerful role in people’s loves and affects many ways of their life. Religion is one of the agents of socialization which influences person’s orientations in life. Although it teaches people values, moralities, I believe that there are different groups or agents of socialization could cause almost same (good) impact on the person. Do you agree?…

    • 115 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    But what inspires morals to be created as opposed to our natural, rational thinking? Collins argues that social rituals produce these moral feelings. By doing this, the people partaking in the unifying rituals, which creates group solidarity. Their shared experiences allowed them to achieve accomplishments in a contractual society such as creation of businesses, and citizen's rule abiding tendencies. Social rituals allow people to feel like they belong among other members of society. When people believe that they are members of something, then they do their best to make that society or organization functional. Furthermore, social rituals create moral ideas, and symbolic symbols which Collins says is the basis of religion. That being said, religion is the link to social solidarity. Religious beliefs are important, not because of what they claim but the fact that people can be brought together underneath…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eng103 1ST Essay

    • 1310 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It is quite obvious that Nietzsche strongly believed that Christianity has nonetheless, demean our human rights by being one of the “founding fathers” of morality. Nietzsche claimed that morality is anti-nature, thus the creator of such a “self-torturing” principle, that…

    • 1310 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “[Individual] is not made for society, but society is made for the [individual]. No institution can be good which does not tend to improve the individual” (Fuller). The purpose of this quote is to show what society is about. Society has been part of our lives ever since we were born. They helped raise us to become who we are today. They taught us all the things that we learned to help us get by on the adventurous passage called life. They either gave us blessings or taught us lessons to prevent making mistakes; they also taught us to learn from those mistakes to become wiser. There are many social factors that can help the individual become a better person than they were in the past to benefit them now and in the future. One of those factors is religion.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    An issue in today’s society is discrimination. For consistency I will define discrimination as anything that denies a group of people from any universal privileges. A few examples of this would be racism, LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bi, Transgender) rights, and sexism. These issue have been present through all points in American and World History, normally putting the white adult heterosexual male as the most privileged and discriminations putting everyone else below him. In the twenty-first century measures have recently been taken to correct for the unjust treatment of those other than white males for factors out of their control. These factors of course include skin color, sex, and sexual orientation. I feel Nietzsche’s On the Genealogy of Morality…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Joad argues that religious people has a conscience within them that determines the bad, the good and the consequences that will follow. To follow God and act as his servant you must follow the Ten Commandments and the Bible. Joad says that religion makes it easier for people to follow the social contract and think about the consequences such as hell. " The conclusion is that morality, which is simply the habit of acting in a manner of which other people approve, is not natural to man; on the contrary, it runs counter to his natural interests, frustrates his natural desires, and requires him to surrender his natural rights"(Joad 175). Man's natural instincts will most likely go against the social contract of society. For example in class Professor Wilson asked the class "If there was a God but no Heaven or Hell would you still live your life the way you do now or would you change the way you live knowing there would be no consequences of going to Hell?" About ninety-percent of the class raised their hands saying that they would change the way they lived. In this small survey done in class, it shows evidence to support Joad's argument. If there was no Heaven or Hell you would not have to abide by the social contract that religion typically follows. You would not have the subconscious decisions to follow the Bible and Ten Commandments, now knowing that there is no consequence of going to Hell. I do not feel this is fair. God performs many miracles and helps us everyday…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pope John Paul II states that our freedom and God’s law is most noticeably present in our conscience. When we set our freedom against the moral law, we risk deviating from the teachings of the Church or even contradicting them entirely. Some theologians have gone as far as to state that the conscience is simply a guide to give a general view of the man’s life, rather than “the sanctuary of man, where he is alone with God whose voice echoes within him” (John Paul II 55). Some also state that the Church’s intervention in the life of the faithful is the true cause of the conflicts in our conscience, which could be solved by allowing Christians to make their own decisions regardless of the moral law. This idea falls under scrutiny, however, as it proposes a double standard for the moral law. To support this argument, one must separate the inherent truths of the moral law so as to not conflict with the yearnings of the individual conscience.…

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    moral action in duty for its own sake, the other in the maximization of human happiness;…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because of this dilemma, philosophers have tried to create a secular ethic in order to avoid it. But, according to Kai Nielsen, “Religious morality… may have its difficulties, but secular morality, religious apologists argue, has still greater difficulties.” He then explains that without some great consequence, or without any bigger purpose for living morally, then there would be no reason to live morally, or to even define what morality consists…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Nietzsche’s aphorisms 90-95 and 146-162 he attacks what he believes to be the fundamental basis of the “slave” morality prevalent in the Judeo-Christian tradition as well as other religions and societies. From the beginning, he distinguishes the two different types of moralities he believes to exist: the “master morality”, created by rulers of societies, and the “slave” morality, created by the lowest people in societies. The former stresses virtues of the strong and noble while looking down upon the weak and cowardly. This type of morality, however, is not as widespread as the “slave morality” that has been adopted by so many religions. Nietzsche looks through the psychology and logic of the “slave morality” to determine its virtues and origins.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Christopher Hitchens, a British-American writer and journalist once said, “Human decency is not derived from religion. It precedes it” (Quotes About). Human decency comes from the morals that people learn. There are good and bad morals, but human decency can only be established through good morals. One of the most influential yet controversial ways morals can be learned is through religion. Other ways it could be learned is through older generations, life experiences, and through culture. Religion can cause a lot of difficulties when it comes down to making the right decisions. It should not interfere with one’s morals and ethics. Religion is not needed in a person’s life to teach good morals.…

    • 1797 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gone

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Thus far, we have spent the beginning of the semester exploring numerous questions concerning the relationship between religion and ethics. For this first paper, it will be your job to tie together several of the readings that deal with this relationship. This paper requires you to do several things:…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Quite recently in history many philosophers have begun to disagree with rule-governed ethical systems. These philosophers have four major criticisms about these systems. The first is that they lack a motivational component. Critics claim that action based ethics are uninspiring and boring, and that by creating a mentality of mindless conforming, they fail to motivate and inspire action. The second complaint is that the theological-legal system that action-based ethical systems are modeled after is no longer appropriate. In the days of old, the notions of right and wrong where drawn from cultural views on God. In modern days, ethics has been detached itself from it’s theological roots and has lost it’s original appeal, thus calling for a better system to reject this model and guide it’s followers onto a better path. Critics also dislike how action-based ethical systems overemphasize autonomy and neglect the communal context of ethics. Pojman states, “It is in communities that such virtues as loyalty, natural affection, spontaneous sympathy, and shared concerns arise and sustain the group. It is out of this primary loyalty that the proper dispositions arise that flow out to the rest of humanity. Seeing how people actually learn to be moral and how they are inspired to act morally is vital to moral theory itself, and this seems, has everything to do…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Nietzsche: the Conscience

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In his second essay of the Geneaology of Morals, Nietzsche attempts to identify and explain the origin of the conscience. He does not adopt the view of the conscience that is accepted by the “English Psychologists”, such as Bentham, J. Mill, J.S. Mill and Hume, as the result of an innate moral feeling. Rather, it is his belief that the moral content of our conscience is formed during childhood under the influence of society. Nietzsche defines the conscience as an introspective phenomenon brought about by a feeling of responsibility, in which one analyzes their own morality due to the internalization of the values of society. This definition holds the position that the conscience is not something innate to humans, rather it has arisen through evolution. In light of this, this paper will give insight into how Nietzsche reaches this conclusion, as well as what results from it. In order to do this there will be discussion of guilt, punishment, the will to power and implications from society.…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics