Preview

Minie Ball Pregnancy Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
598 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Minie Ball Pregnancy Summary
Minie Ball Pregnancy Ch.9
The book specifically mentions two women who fought during the war. The first one went by the name of Albert D.J. Cashire pretending to be a man, and there is a quote in the book on page 196 that reads, “[i]n handling a musket in battle, […] he was the equal of any in the company.” She fought in forty battles and was active in veterans groups for decades after the war. She was discovered to be a woman, and not a man, in the year 1911 while she was working as a handyman in Illinois. She was hit by a car, and in the hospital they found out that she was a woman, and she was sent to an insane asylum after that where she was forced to behave more femininely. Her real name was Jennie Hodgers.
The other woman was named Sarah Emma Edmonds who chose to reveal her gender in 1884. Jennie Hodges has a plaque that denotes her wartime name and her birth name, but in all there were around 400 women who fought in the war.
…show more content…
The minie ball pregnancy is of course another odd story, which I really doubt happened. Even if a projectile passed through a man's reproductive organs then through a woman's and was fertile, the damage to the woman's body would probably have been so great that it would cause a miscarriage. Furthermore, the book said that the two went on to have more children. I would think that if a man were hit in the right location for such a story to be possible, he would not be able to have children any

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Flexner explained us on her book “Century of Struggle” how women contributed to the Civil War by becoming soldiers, spies, and spending time and energy healing the sick and wounded. According to her book “women frustrated by their limitations in society entered into the army as soldiers. Approximately 400 women tied up their hoops and pulled up pants to serve”(145). The women of the Civil War are best remembered for their colorful hoop skirts. Perhaps it is hard to imagine how the women soldiers successfully managed to enlist. The women first picked male names; it was probably really easy to enlist in the army because recruiters, both Northern and Southern, did not ask for proof of identity. These women soldiers bound their breasts, cut their hair, and learned how to smoke cigars, and some even wore false mustaches. With loose uniforms and lack of facial hair the women could pass as young men. Women soldiers deserve remembrance because their actions display them as uncommon and…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the Civil War, she decided it a patriotic duty to enlist in the Union army. She was one of only approximately 400 women that actually successfully made the enlistment. At the time, women were not allowed in the army, but the physical evaluations were not extensive enough to catch the imposters.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The main point I find after reading the article “Women and the American Revolution” is that women during Revolutionary War times had the same issues as women today with many more piled on top. Many women today are stay at home mothers like the women were then but they have more freedoms now. If a woman wants to serve their county by joining the military it is accepted now but it was not then. Women then were not even expected to give their opinion on many matters. The few women known to have served in the military during the Revolutionary War were said to be disguised as men when they did so.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women's Army Corps (WAAC)

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Women also played a significant role in the military. According to government records, more than 265,000 women enlisted in the armed services of the United States over the course of the war, all as volunteers. There was vocal opposition to female participation in the war effort at the beginning, but it gradually changed as the war raged on and the need for qualified personnel, regardless of gender, increased.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women also fought in the war. When I say that women fought in the war you might think they actually fought in the war, well some brave women took their…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Women's Role In Ww2 Essay

    • 1810 Words
    • 8 Pages

    A countless amount of women carried out different roles in the army, either serving as United States…

    • 1810 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many women contributed as nurses and spies. Others enlisted themselves and dressed as men to fight in battles and march with the soldiers. Also, there were many women who took on male roles back home, such as working in factories and other business around their community. And of course, there were the kind women who worked to help the soldiers from home. They would sew clothing for the soldiers as well as make homemade goods. Finally, there was the amazing organization of The Sanitation Commission, which was considered a huge help to the soldiers who were wounded or just all around depressed. To end, there were very many roles in the war that occupied…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Revolutionary Mothers

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I believe that the author did an outstanding job of presenting the information in this book. Many authors would have tried to intertwine these women’s stories in order to make the story more interesting as a whole. Instead she sets aside a chapter to different groups she wants to go into detail discussing. For instance, she doesn’t try to compare and contrast the women who were on the home front to the women who followed the armies. Instead, she helps you realize the importance of both by devoting…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women in the Revolutionary War had various roles that affected the war in ways that benefited the Patriots greatly. Women fought on the battlefield, took over jobs for men that were unable to do those jobs, and did things for the soldiers on the home front. A handful of women bravely fought alongside of the men in the Revolutionary War one of which is known for her wit and bravery, Deborah Sampson. Deborah went undercover as ‘Robert Shirtliffe’, because men would not allow her to be a soldier as a women she risked exposure and went…

    • 1732 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tuskegee Airmen Roles

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The women’s roles were mainly stay-at-home moms or busy working moms. However, many women wanted to join the army as well. Not very many women got into the army as it was still incredibly racially segregated. On the other hand, there were some African-American women who got into the army. Their main jobs were to be nurses; some of them, if they were lucky enough, managed to get roles that some of the men played. Some of those roles include infantry, tank support, and copilots in military planes. Speaking of men, their roles were a little different than the women as they got most of the heavy-duty jobs. As a result, they usually got jobs that paid a little more and were let into the army easier, too. This kind of ties into today's culture as well. It may seem unfair, but men are still paid a little more than women are. One thing that is better in my culture today than the culture during the World War II time period is that everyone has equal rights and equal job opportunities, no matter the race or skin color. That means that African Americans have the same job opportunities as white people and that they should never be rejected just for how they…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The November 30th lecture states, “Women were not allowed to put on equipment and pick up a gun.” (November 30th). In addition, DuBois stated, “Action and leadership were reserved for men. Inspiration and assistance was women’s province.” (DuBois, 188). However, there were women who did fight in the Civil War because they disguised themselves as men. One of the many women who cross-dressed as a man was “Albert” Cashier. When Cashier was discovered to be a woman, she was diagnosed with mental illness. Fighting was a man’s job, and women who fought were seen as unethical or even sick. Such cultural backlash reinforced the idea that violence was gendered and the domain of men…

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women have always been judged, we have been called sensitive, emotional, vulnerable, pathetic, sentimental, and, many other labels invented by society. I mean, is being sentimental a bad thing? No, it’s not, it’s completely normal to have emotions, everyone has emotions. Mary Anne Bell symbolizes how women are capable of being part of a war and finding interest in subjects in which society would consider “Only meant for men”. Tim O’Brien is not a feminist, I believe that he is making an argument discussing how women should be treated equally as men, no gender labels nor excuses. O'Brien says, “If Mary was a man it wouldn't be a big deal”. No matter what gender soldiers are they lose their innocence. War changes soldiers into completely different people and damages them mentally even causing them to commit suicide.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Since women’s husbands were out in the battlefield, women also wanted to contribute in a way or another to the American Revolution. That is why they did not take into consideration the hardship and sacrifices they had to go through while serving. Women in the Revolutionary War were just the same as women today; all they wanted was to work on their own and be independent; all women do not want to depend on any man at any time. Nurses were really crucial in the battlefield and they demonstrated to be capable of handling hard situations. Despite the risks women had to confront they always provided invaluable contributions in helping those who were injured and saving their lives. A good example of a nurse who is very well-known is Margaret Cochran Corbin. According to Lieberman, Margaret refused to let her husband go alone. Since her nursing skills would be valuable, she was allowed to accompany his unit as a camp follower (Lieberman, 2). Margaret not only performed domestic tasks for her husband, she also nursed the wounded and provided emotional support. Margaret Corbin was very dedicated to her assigned tasks just as any other women and always managed to nurse the wounded troops making evident the important role women played during the war. Lieberman stated that Margaret not only performed the tasks mentioned above; when she saw her husband dead, she stepped up and fired the cannon taking her husband’s place in the battle (3). Margaret was determined to help the army and avenge the death of her husband. This brave woman showed definitively her great skills and vigor of firing a gun. Margaret displayed how women are not inferior to men and how she not only performed domestic tasks and nursed the wounded but she also stepped out and fought against the enemy replacing men. Women were of significant value to the army. “it profited…

    • 1884 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In order to change their appearance they wore baggy clothing and a lot of layers in order to hide their breasts and then would cut their hair short to resemble a male and put dirt on their faces. At least 250 women disguised themselves and took part in the war. Women took part in almost every major battle that was fought. For example women fought in the Battle of Shiloh in April 1862. During this battle at least six women fought including confederate Loreta Velazquez who also took part in the battle at fort Donelson. Most of these women joined along side of a male relative or spouse. Women that were disguised typically remained undetected unless they became wounded or were killed. Some women were still able to be a part of the war without disgusting themselves as men. Many women helped jobs pertaining to the military without actually being on the front lines. These jobs included everything from helping on hospital ships, to cooking and serving meals for soldiers. Some women came on as laundresses but ended up tending to the sick, cleaning guns and even teaching soldiers to how to…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unable to serve because of their sex, they posed as men by cutting their hair short and binding their breast with bandages (The Roles of Women in the Revolutionary War). Many women, to keep up with the facade, would adopt masculine titles. Ann Bailey was a female soldier who enlisted in 1777. She used the name Sam Gay as her alias. Her identity was soon uncovered a few weeks later and she was arrested and imprisoned. Bailey’s determination pushed her to enlist for the second time, where she was discovered and imprisoned again ( The Roles of women in the Revolutionary War). The misconception that men are more courageous than women is proven wrong time and time again. The Revolutionary War pushed women out of their comfort zone and urged them to show their courage by fighting the…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays