Preview

Louis Riel and Candian Sovereignty

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
554 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Louis Riel and Candian Sovereignty
Louis Riel is arguably Canada’s most ambiguous hero. Riel was the representative leader of the Francophone martyr to English imperialism. The controversy between whether or not Louis Riel was a traitor or saviour was escalated on November 16th 1885 when Riel was hung. This controversy has lasted for over 125 years and brought about much debate as to how Louis Riel should be exalted. Through radical political efforts and motivation to fight for the people of the North West, Louis Riel represents a connection between Indigenous people and Euro-Canadians. Riel often used religious influence to govern his political decisions but later in life slowly started to fade out of the shadow of the Catholic Church. Riel acted as a political leader for the Metis people through the creation of a provisional government which acted as a temporary government for the people of the Red River. Louis Riel’s actions throughout his life that lead to his exile, execution, and exaltation all play and important role in defining Canadian political identity as well as French-English relations and Metis identity to this day. Riel’s execution exemplifies his life’s work, which has played a significant role in the definition of Canadian identity.
In late August 1969, Riel emerged as the leader of the Metis People. He immediately moved to overturn the first coherent plan for Metis response to confederation (which was motivated by Metis aboriginal rights), with a new plan by Riel that was more motivated by Catholic and French rights. There was much conflict in the Metis community as to how they should respond to foreign oppression.1 After a collective decision by the community, Riel
1. Gerhard Ens “Prologue to the Red River Resistance: Pre-Liminal Politics and the Triumph of Riel’” Journal of Canadian History Association, Volume 5, No. 1, 1994. (111-1123)

was voted into power and “historians have generally regarded the first initiative as a failure” (Ens 1994, 114), and attribute it’s

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    This article by Hans Carlson presents a political and legal progression by the James Bay Development Corporation that essentially alters the native Cree’s relationship to their land. Starting in Quebec, from 1971 to 1975 the Grande River Hydro-electric Complex started the construction on four dams in eastern James Bay, publicized to provide electricity to the Quebec grid. Living off the eastern James Bay land is the people of the Cree which began fighting for the rights to the land as the assembly of these dams would induce large changes to their spiritual and physical ties. The Cree who have been dependent on the land for survival argued to the superior court that before and after confederation the natives held the rights to James Bay area and the building of the dams infringed upon these rights. Also, proclaiming that living off the land was more than just a physical commodity but a spiritual tie that was engraved in Cree history and way of life.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The North-West Metis Eventually Rebelled in the end In the summer of 1884, the Metis sent delegates to Montana, US, Where Riel was expelled and had his job as a teacher. The Metis delegates complained to Riel about the livelihood of the Metis in Canada. Riel was motivated and strongly suggested to return and lead the Metis to make improvements on their current life conditions. Riel’s return designated an uprising rebellion between the Metis and the government.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some scholars like Sprague (Canada and the Metis: 1869-1855) fail to explain the dispossession of the Metis and the Riel Resistance, and continuously emphasize that Riel had a historical role,…

    • 197 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Canadian Riel Timeline

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages

    February 1875 The Canadian government grants an amnesty to all Metis, except Riel, who participated in the 1869-70 turmoil. A grant of amnesty to Riel is conditioned on him accepting a five-year banishment from Canada.…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    actions, so he organized bands of Métis to confront them. He later formed the Métis national committee to fight for Métis concerns about their land. He then occupied Fort Garry. That is what triggered the Red River Rebellion. Riel wanted to make sure that his people would retain their rights and traditions. In order to do so Riel set up a provisional government. Angered by recent events the Métis drew up a list of rights. Riel later led a party of armed Métis to Shultz home and took members of the Canadian party to Fort Garry. Thomas Scott was executed by a Métis firing squad because he went against the provisional government. Throughout and after this rebellion there were many terrible results. Riel got banished by the Canadian government for five years. The members of the provisional government that Riel set up were granted amnesty. Thomas Scott was executed which made the government see Riel as a felon. Riel was wanted by the government. Riel feared his life so he ran…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Peter Russel’s work he identifies that a majority of First Nations Canadians “identify with Canada and have an allegiance to it, but they also identify with a historic nation (Russell 232)”. Then there are causes being presented that conflict with the loyalty and dedication to their historic nations and culture, should a banner of Canadian nationalism present itself, it is likely the former will prevail (Russell 232). During the conferences and documented by the video “Dancing Around the Table” there were two quotes that spoke true and emphasized the frustrations of the First Nations people, “the exercise now is not about frank and open discussion, or understanding and appreciation of other peoples’ concerns on the basis of respect and dignity, it has become all of a sudden the question of power and who exercises it (Bulbulian “Dancing Around the Table”).” Just a day after Premiere Rene Levesque confirms that this is a problem, however that it needs to be the First Nations people who are responsible in acquiring power to appropriately negotiate as equals, because it is ultimately the political process (Bulbulian “Dancing Around the Table”). Considering these words were said by one of Quebec’s premiers spoke volumes, because the two groups that possess a dual sense of national identity is both the Quebec and First Nations people (Russell 232). The concerns mentioned by the First Nations representative which is only later confirmed by Rene Levesque demonstrates that what was now occurring, was a dance around the table. There was no genuine or real desire to meet the demands and concerns of the First Nations people, rather than an attempt to humouring them and integrating them into Trudeau’s vision for Canada. This feeling is later confirmed a representative stating that,…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Louis Riel's Legacy

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Louis Riel was a leader in many different ways. He lead a blockade to stop the lieutenant-governor William McDougall from retrieving the Red River territory from the Metis. The Metis then took control of Fort Garry, which was the major trading post for the Hudson's Bay Company. Riel could also speak many different languages which was convenient for communication with foreign people for trading purposes and treaties.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Through Riel’s trials of mental instability and forthcoming battle, he remained strong and dedicated to his people. Returning to the nation that would eventually kill him, Riel showed that his heart rested in Rupert’s Land, and he wanted nothing but to protect his people’s language, religion and culture. For his bravery and unyielding effort over the course of a decade, I believe Louis Riel is a hero to Canadian culture and its…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It could be argued that it was his Metis heritage, Ojibway on his mothers side of which he was well aware, that led him to focus on the Natives of the west in his work, but he was also French-Canadian, a Quebecois.(The Big Chief pg 3 and archive source) Natives were doomed, in need of dire support, especially when compared to French-Canadians in Quebec which is why, despite this split heritage, he may have been partially motivated to help the Natives because of a sense of family, coupled with his love of helping others, that resulted in his focus on the Natives.(hughes 304) He did, after all, call them his “poor Metis also my poor Indians” when referring to them suggesting he felt he was responsible for them.(hughes and something else) When fundraising ”he pleaded the case of the Indians” and told others about the terrible conditions in which they lived. it was said he “took a special interest in the Metis living in the poorer quarters of the city[Winnipeg]” and that “his heart was not in his task” when “there were no indians under his care.”(FOOTNOTES) He wanted to help them so much that he was delighted “whenever he saw his poor Indians so interested in what he was teaching them”(mackinnon) because he wanted to help them, not just by giving them things, but by giving them understanding and faith.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Riel was born as a hero and wanted to fight for his people to protect their beliefs and Metis distinct culture. In the transfer of Rupert's Land from the HBC to Canada in 1869, Riel saw a big opportunity to establish the Red River Settlement to a province.Through Confederation the province could join Canada to establish rights for the Francophone and Metis people. The Federal government would help them since they are a new province like they did to other provinces. He protected Metis from the Red River resistance because the Canadians/British killed most of the Buffalo, which the Metis depended on. Riel also protected the Metis from the surveyors who were here to measure…

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    On s’est mis à parler de l’État du Québec et la législature du Québec a pris le nom d’assemblée nationale a la fin des années soixante” (Balthazar, 1992, 7). This was an outstanding moment for French Canadian nationalistic pride due to the fact that finally it seemed that as a society they we’re being recognized as significant within Canada. This was an important development towards the goal of decolonization, because it more or less finalized the colonizer, colony mentality and proved that Quebec was an individualistic society that was not as much of a stranger in their own land. It allowed for the French speaking individuals of Quebec to feel as though they belonged and had a position within Canada as a whole not only Quebec. Both the women’s liberation movement and the Quebec decolonization movement of the 1960s were wrought with social justice, change and developments. They both pushed boundaries and gained a lot of ground in very short period of time, which allowed the individuals within the movement to gain more confidence and pride throughout their…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Louis Riel Hero

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Some may see Louis Riel as a villain because of his initiatives taken against the government. Riel was the leader of two major rebellions. The first rebellion was the Red River Rebellion of 1869. There was a need for the rebellion when the Métis, people with half-native and half-European descent, have had enough of being taken advantage of. Land speculators and surveyors at the time laid out square townships and disregarded the strip lots the settlers were used to have. Rupert's Land was purchased without any consultations with the settlers in the area. The Métis called for Riel, who was the leader of the Métis in the prairies at the time. After unsuccessful deliberations, Riel commenced the rebellion at Fort Garry, where they seized munitions. Riel created a provisional government in the area and tried to negotiate with the Canadian government as much as possible. To add to the adversity, Riel executed a person who went against his provisional government: Orange Lodge member Thomas Scott. When false news and rumors spread westward about Scott's execution, Riel was recognized as a felon and was wanted for arrest. This particular event led the government to see Louis Riel as a national villain.…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Metis Essay

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout Canadian history, the Métis have struggled to gain recognition as a distinct people, particularly from the Canadian government. Often, they were described as being Métis only by virtue of their mixed ancestry, with their own unique identities being ignored. This was seen by many as a sign of impurity, and the Metis were treated negatively as a result. The Canadian government did not recognize the rights of the Métis; rather, the government legislated over the Métis as Indians when it was convenient to do so, or classified them as distinct from Indians when it was more advantageous. This proved to be extremely problematic. At last, in 1982, Métis rights were recognized under section 35 of the Constitution Act. However, as stated…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Louis Riel: A Hero

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Louis Riel, a central figure in the Red River Rebellion and the North West Resistance, played a large part in the creation of Canada as we know it. A controversial figure, he is considered either a hero or a traitor depending on which side of the fence you stand. Louis riel is a hero because he stood for his people against the tyrannical Canadian Government, was influential in the creation of Manitoba and he lived and died for what he believed in. At the same time, by putting Riel on a pedestal we fail to see his flaws and forget to analyse his life with a balanced view. While Riel was certainly a hero, in order to truly know the legacy of the father of Confederation it is important not to overlook his mistakes, flaws and failures.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Peace Shall Destroy Many

    • 3613 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Métis, and war going on around them. These beliefs come up within two characters in…

    • 3613 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics