1.28.13
10th Lit/Comp Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, please take a look at the woman sitting in front of you. Take a good look. This woman, Mrs. Mary Maloney, sits here now, nearly 8 months with child, facing prison. Look at her eyes, pleading for help. Begging for the understanding. This woman could not have possibly known what she was doing when she struck her husband, detective Patrick Maloney. In that moment of temporary insanity, she made a mistake caused by the many hormones coursing through her body. On the night of his unfortunate death, her late husband had given Mrs. Maloney some shocking news. He informed her that he was leaving her for another woman. Upon hearing this news, Mrs. Maloney undoubtedly went into shock; a trance almost. "When she walked across the room, she couldn't feel her feet touching the floor. She couldn't feel anything except a slight sickness. She did everything without thinking." [Dahl] She had just received life changing news. She stopped thinking. She thought of nothing except the betrayal of her husband. As her husband crashed to the floor, this poor woman realized what she had done. Being the wife of a detective, she knew what her punishment would be if anyone found out. She tried to cover up her crime; establish an alibi. Not for herself, mind you. No! For her baby. For the child that was already doomed to a life without a father. "What were the laws about murderers with unborn children? Did they kill them both -- mother and child? Did they wait until the baby was born? What did they do? Mary Maloney didn't know and she wasn't prepared to take a chance." [Dahl] She wanted to protect her baby as best as she could. Lastly we will look at the fact that gave Mrs. Maloney away to begin with. While the detectives were eating the leg of lamb, the weapon used to strike Mr. Maloney, they heard a slight giggle. "And in the other room, Mary Maloney began to laugh." [Dahl] When questioned, Mrs. Maloney confessed what she had done, all the while still laughing madly. Now tell me, what mentally sane person would confess to murder while laughing? One wouldn't. I have made my point. Submitted my evidence. Stated the facts. Mrs. Mary Maloney had lost her mind when this unfortunate crime came about. Is a crime committed under that type of shock-in this unstable condition-worthy of prison? I think not. Mrs. Maloney was simply doing what she, at the moment, thought was the right choice. Any woman upon receiving news as was delivered to her that night would not be in her right mind at all. A woman with child would be even less stable. That is why today, I plea that Mrs. Mary Maloney should not go to prison, under cause of temporary insanity. Thank you.
Sources:
Dahl, Roald. Lamb to the Slaughter. New York City. Harper's Magazine. 1953.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Maloney is innocent, there are some statements that were made that could make the assumption that she is guilty. According to case files, Detective One stated, “ You know just as well as I do he used to fool around from time to time.”(Dahl). Giving her a reason to be angry at him and cause her to do something by the heat of the moment. But, due to the fact that Mrs. Maloney is pregnant, it would be hard for her to use an instrument like the one mentioned, or use as much force as needed to kill Patrick Maloney, as stated by Detective Three. Mr. Maloney made her a pleased wife and gave her no suspicion as to if he was being unfaithful or…
- 806 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Not only did Mr. Maloney say he wanted to leave, but the reason must have been extrememly disturbing to Mary. Although the book did not state why he wanted to leave, a movie made from the book of Lamb to the Slaughter says that he was in love with someone else. Mary was going to cook a hole leg of lamb for dinner that night. When she went to retrieve the lamb leg from the freezer she just realized the reality of what was going on. She was furious. The lamb was frozen solid, like a rock. Mr. Maloney was in the living room facing the opposite way towards the window so he coldn't see Mary. Mrs. Maloney came up with an idea. With no hesitation, she walked up behind her husband and hit him over the head as hard as she could with the frozen solid leg of lamb. Mr. Maloney is…
- 381 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The Peggy Hettrick case has been a cold case for decades. The case from 1987 has been a mystery. August 10, 1998 Timothy Masters was charged for her murder. Timothy was released and charges were dismissed on January 22, 2008. The roles in this case were hard to follow. The prosecutor who has the role to present the state’s case against defense had to prove that Timothy’s knife collection, his drawings, failure to report seeing body, and the time frame of the crime was reasonably why he was the suspect in the murder of Peggy Hettrick. The police took several years trying to build a case and didn’t come up with much. Timothy Masters’ defense attorney, who has the job of representing the accused and to prove him innocent. They petitioned new trials due to the fact of lack of evidence. The original trial did not have the DNA and the defense attorneys had not been informed of other suspects. One of the other suspects was Richard Hammond. Richard Hammond also had a prior record of filming females in 1995. Hammond’s place of residence was 100 yards from the scene of murder with his bedroom facing the scene. Hammond committed suicide two days after arrest. The evidence of the prior suspect and reports from experts that said Masters was not guilty was enough for a judge to allow a new trial. The judge, who has the role to ensure justice and holds the ultimate authority and is responsible for balancing the rights of the accused and the interest of society, ruled that with all the evidence that was withheld a new trial would be allowed. The new trial found Timothy Masters not guilty and released from jail. Later the judges ruled in wrongful conviction and Timothy was granted millions.…
- 422 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
She had a drink prepared for her husband before he walked in the door, would sit quietly until he was ready to speak, and continually tried to offer him comfort when she saw he was distressed. Yet, Patrick Maloney, her late husband, yells at her before telling her greatly upsetting news, before callously telling her not to make a scene because “It wouldn’t be very good for my job.” Any person would find this news very upsetting, and making her pain about him would drive us over the edge. Temporary insanity is a rare phenomenon, but her husband’s callous disregard and knowing what would happen to her as a divorcee caused Mary Maloney to plunge into a state of madness. She wrongly perceived herself as having no choice but to kill her husband. After hitting her husband with the murder weapon, a leg of lamb, Mary recalls that “She came out of it slowly, feeling cold and surprised, and she stood for a few minutes, looking at the body, still holding the piece of meat tightly with both hands.” This does not sound like the actions of a cold blooded murderer. It rather sounds like someone who did something not even themselves expected, as if they were detached from their body. It appears that Mary is in shock, unable to believe what she may have done, as many insane people do when told of their…
- 995 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
On July 30, 2001, Andrea was indicted on two counts of capital murder for the deaths of Noah (seven), John (five), and Mary (six months),but not for the deaths of her other two children, Luke (three) and Paul (two). In this paper we will discuss Andrea Yates behaviors, treatments and court case where she was found not guilty by reason of insanity.…
- 893 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Mary Maloney is very devious. In the stories, “The Landlady” and “Lamb to the Slaughter”, the antagonists are both devious, but one is more devious than the other. Mary Maloney is more devious because she made the police eat the lamb and she pretended to not know that Patrick was dead.…
- 376 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Mr. Maloney had asked Mrs. Maloney to sit so he could discuss his wishes to get a divorce. She never expected this night to take a turn like this, so when he told her this she was in disbelief. She did not want to face reality so she got up out of her chair and grabbed the lamb leg from the freezer to make dinner. Mr. Maloney said he was leaving and to not make dinner. Then, she picked up the lamb from the table and bashed it into his skull. The back of Mr. Maloney’s head was completely shattered. She realized what she had done, but showed not even a glimpse of remorse across her face. She murdered him in cold…
- 601 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
“When a man is denied the right to live the life he believes in, he has no choice but to become an outlaw” (Nelson Mandela). This quote expresses that each person is cable of circumventing the law to believe what they cerebrate is true and just. This however, is not implicatively insinuating that everything they do is veridical or ending with the best consequences. In the following short stories “Harrison Bergeron”(Kurt Vonnegut), “On the Sidewalk, Bleeding” (Ed Mcbain), and “Lamb to the Slaughter”(Roald Dahl), all the characters have thwarted around the law to get to what they believe in is postulate. A theme can also be illustrated that resisting oppression could lead to calamitous consequences.…
- 159 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
I believe that Roald Dahl wants us to think Mrs. Maloney is a victim. I think this because in the story Mrs. Maloney looks to be a nice, kindhearted woman who is devoted to her husband, even though he would ignore her presence when she was speaking to him. "I think it's a shame," she said, "that when someone's been a policeman as long as you have, he still has to walk around all day long." He didn't answer. Although Mr. Maloney ignored his wife and was not interested in what Mrs. Maloney had to say she still continued to speak to him a respectful manner. When Mr. Maloney decided to tell Mary that he was leaving her for another woman she tried to deny his words in her mind. “And he told her. It didn't take long, four or five minutes at most, and she sat still through it all, watching…
- 435 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
While there is a plethora of negative that have come out of this evil murder, there is some positive. The Tate family came together to become pioneers in the victims’ movement; After battling depression, Doris, Sharon’s mother, worked on passing California Proposition 8. This propositions “allowed crime victims the opportunity to speak in court, by reading a “victim impact statement” during the sentencing…
- 718 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“Even before she killed Patrick Maloney she said she sat there with a dazed of horror, correct?” Her lawyer said “yes that’s actually correct, why?” I replied “Because that's just a well giving sign that she was fixing to make the worst decision in her whole entire life. Do I seem to be wrong” Marys lawyer said “Well i suppose so, but thats just because she needs to get some help that she needs!”…
- 808 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Julia Fairfield killed an innocent child. The newspaper confirmed that the baby had been “strangled, and its body thrown into the water” (Thompson 43). Miss Julia is of high society and had no regard to her own child. Fairfield chose to have relations with a black man not taking into account the consequences of her actions. Fairfield knew that if anyone found out she slept with a black man that she would never get married and no man would ever touch her.…
- 702 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
At one time or another, everyone on this Earth will go through a challenging circumstance that they must survive. This could be as small as a bad grade on a test or having to do something you don’t want to do. But these situations can also be as big as the loss of a loved-one or even being stranded on an island. So during these times, how does one survive their Circumstance? An individual can survive any circumstance through hope, resilience, and an understanding of the importance of life.…
- 649 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The recent debate on the banning of the popular book, The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, from a public school is nothing new in the literary world. J.D. Salinger’s novel is the second most challenged book in history (Doyle) because of its crude language, sexual references, and questionable content. In reality, Holden is a character to be respected for his rash views on the world and the political madness of it all. Holden may not always have the most moral ideas, granted he’s a teenage boy and their thoughts are never the most moral and innocent. The wish to keep your child’s innocence protected by shielding her from such literature is understandable, though it’s equally important to remember the reality of the situation, and that the elimination of the questionable scenes would have taken the importance from the book. The Catcher in the Rye is a lesson within itself of morality and the teenagers of America, and should continue to be taught in the Ferndale School District.…
- 1290 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Out of the many female characters in To Kill A Mockingbird, Calpurnia plays a mother like roll, she has many views about the Tom Robinson case and the Maycomb town, and she has many of he characteristics and opinions shown in the novel. Calpurnia played a major roll in the novel because she was a mother like character, her views about Tom’s case and Maycomb illustrate what it is like where the book takes place, and last but not least her characteristics and behavior.…
- 745 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays