Preview

International Commercial Surrogacy: A Feminist Approach

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3339 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
International Commercial Surrogacy: A Feminist Approach
International Commercial Surrogacy: A Feminist Approach.
The globalization of wage labor is no longer novel; it has become a main facet in an increasingly interconnected world. From call centers to clothing factories, the scope of labor being outsourced and sought out in different countries around the world is constantly magnifying. In a neoliberal world where virtually all industries are in constant search for new terrains for cheap labor, there has emerged another global enterprise commonly known as, “reproductive tourism.” Reproductive tourism entails the expansion of the fertility industry beyond country borders. Couples, usually from wealthier parts of the world, seek out solutions to their infertility, such as egg donors and surrogates,
…show more content…
As previously noted, in India, the women who undertake surrogacy come from impoverished backgrounds and use it as a means to alleviate their circumstances. A lot of them do not have a proper education and so, neither ask about nor are told the full implications of their choices. This also makes it rather easy to underpay them for their services and given the lack of legal enforceability of the contracts, they have little recourse to attain their rights. Moreover, because clinics are largely self-regulated, women are not guaranteed proper healthcare during and after the pregnancy, especially if there are any health …show more content…
In a neoliberal world, the economic and political position India occupies is a direct result of global norms and practices that put a few a countries at an advantage to the detriment of the majority. Hence, ensuring the welfare of these women is an international responsibility. The global community must seek ways to lessen inequality and distribute resources more equitably in order for all governments to have the adequate resources to provide for their citizenry. While this approach is not politically feasible given the current reality of the world, this is what national governments and the international community at large should be looking towards. It is not sufficient to regulate surrogacy and pretend this actually cultivates meaningful agency for the women

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    “I grew to love her; she was my child!” cried Mary Beth Whitehead in a desperate attempt to keep her child. This emotional battle between the surrogate mother and the client cast a disturbing light on the ethical and legal concerns regarding surrogacy. Is surrogacy ethically permissible? Mass media coverage associated with Baby M’s case normalized the use of surrogacy in the U.S. (Markens 174). However, different methods of surrogacy bring about different consequences. Types of surrogacy include genetic, total, full, commercial and altruistic surrogacy. Full and altruistic surrogacy promotes a positive relationship between the parents, surrogate, and society while international surrogacy, in the form of commercial surrogacy, can cause a negative…

    • 1894 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The majority of parents claim to select gender solely for the reason of sex linked illnesses. Although this might be true in some countries, others are abusing this knowledge to select gender for non-medical reasons. For instance, in countries such as China, where men carry the ancestral line, the families prefer boys instead of girls. Girl fetuses are often aborted after finding out the sex through an ultra sound. Yet, with the newer technology of IVF and PGD, it permits an easier way of gender selection. After PGD, the desired gender embryo is implanted in the woman’s uterus (Gender). However, by not even giving female embryos a chance, it is promoting sex discrimination and cultivating a gender imbalanced society. In China, there are approximately 62 million “missing” women and girls due to sex selective procedures (Hvistendahl). As the population of the female decreases the male population skyrockets. This all results in kidnapping and female trafficking, who are later sold as brides to men (Gender). Dr. Nisker, a PGD pioneer, presumed that sex selection or PGD would be used mostly by infertile couples. He states, “Fifty-eight percent of the calls were from fertile couples. I never thought for one minute this would be used by fertile couples”. Unlike what he had thought, he found the facts to be shocking (Gonda). The practice of gender selection for nonmedical purposes is unethical…

    • 1924 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    What is the reality of surrogacy today? Is it the miracle of helping couples complete their families with a baby? Is it pushing technology to surpass Mother Nature so that infertile couples or same sex couples can have a child of their own? How far will we go as a country, a nation, or a world to ensure a couple has a baby? Are the motives surrounding this process in the best interest of the families and the baby? The reality of surrogacy is the demand. With demand comes great responsibility and with the demand for surrogacy growing so rapidly, we have a responsibility to ensure the safety of the surrogate, couples seeking surrogacy and the child. To ensure safety, laws and regulations must be implemented not only state wide but nationally as well.…

    • 1457 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    this act, as it goes against their religious beliefs. Most religions believe that God, is the sole…

    • 1487 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In modern society, homosexual couples (woman and woman, man and man) have become much more comfortable and open about their sexuality that many of them want to have a family of their own through either surrogacy or in some countries where it is legalised, adoption. However, in Australia the legalisation of commercial surrogacy for homosexual and heterosexual couples is prohibited. A surrogate mother is referred to as a woman who bears a child for another woman (Farlex Inc. 2013, The Free Dictionary). Women usually become a surrogate mother because they receive compensation in one form or another from doing it; others do it because a family member cannot produce a baby of their own. Homosexual couples tend to use surrogacy as an option to have a child of their own, as compared to adopting a child. Due to commercial surrogacy being illegal in Australia, it has driven homosexual couples to other countries such as India where the surrogate mothers are not as healthy as the ones…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As surrogacy becomes more popular, legal problems proliferate. The more people turn to commercial surrogacy the more problems can come along, because surrogacy is not private or protected by anyone. No background checks on anyone dealing with the surrogate mothers or family getting the children. A big problem; the mother can try to deny the adoption after the mother gives birth. Once a women signs in becoming a surrogate mother, all rights automatically remove. A surrogate mother's job is to carry another couple’s child until birth, maybe a friend were born from a surrogate mother, would people think differently if it were them? On that note, nobody needs to feel or think they are unloved and or unwanted because the parents and child have different DNA. Surrogacy causes many issues, therefore, the procedure should be terminated and against the law with no loopholes around it. With that, surrogacy is extremely inhumane due to the fact, IVF makes artificial babies, then sells them to other…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Surrogacy In Canada

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The court’s ruling means the federal government is unable to license fertility doctors, explains Levitan, leaving intended parents and surrogate mothers largely dependent on lawyers to ensure they stay within fertility regulations. It took more than 8 years and 28 million dollars of Canadian taxpayers money to adopt this reproductive legislation! Assisted Human Reproduction Canada (AHRC) was established in Vancouver on January 12, 2006, to administer and enforce the Assisted Human Reproduction Act (AHR), which became law in March 2004. Although the act regulates the use of assisted human reproduction, there is no acts protect the privacy, give psychological support, and promote the social cognition to assisted human reproduction technique. The ethnical problems always come with those who are misinformed about the surrogacy process. People often misunderstand things they don’t understand or if they feel it have nothing to do with them. However, given the lack of health clinic support, it is hard to guarantee the right to the baby who are born with assisted human reproduction. In short, it is a long term to gain the social recognition and…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some view this payment as a type of prostitution, and “surrogacy is decried as exploitation of a woman’s body, as classist and sexist, and the marketing of babies” (Abrams, 2015). Usually, during the contract process the infertile couple must state the amount of money being paid to the surrogate and the intended uses for which the money is meant. Sometimes the law restricts the money to be used for medical fees, cost of living, and legal fees. If any issues arise with the compensation of a surrogate mother, the problems must be reported. If the court finds any compensation to be out of order, some states may see the arrangement as baby-selling or prostitution, and jail time may even be…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cafs

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Surrogacy arrangements involve not only the commissioning couple and the surrogate mother, but the resulting child as well. Accordingly, it is argued that the society has a right to prohibit surrogacy in order to prevent children being born in undesirable circumstances. It is further argued that such arrangements are in reality contracts for the purchase of a child, which are quite unacceptable.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are so many children that are in need of a family to raise them and care for them. There is no national policy on surrogacy. Laws for surrogacy arrangements vary from state to state. The U.S. does not regulate surrogacy, but a few individual states have their own laws. For example, in Florida, surrogacy is only allowed if the commissioning mother cannot physically carry a pregnancy to term (Planning Parenthood, 2009). People who are looking to adopt must meet certain criteria to make sure that the child is placed in a good home, which is best for any child and their…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unlike Rothman, Vida Pantich author of “Surrogate Tourism and Reproductive Rights” does not regard surrogacy as baby-selling, nor is she convinced by arguments that suggest separating children from mothers is detrimental. Instead, Pantich claims that the argument should be aimed towards the global perspective because commercial surrogacy no longer just concerns women in one county, across the globe couples are crossing borders to find surrogates at a much cheaper price than developed nations (275). As a result, the Pantich claims that the real argument lies on whether commercial surrogacy exploits women in underdeveloped…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Infertility

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are few cases where the conventional options cannot be used for having a baby. In such cases, couples can solicit the assistance of a third party to provide sperm, egg or carry a child for them. This is termed as ‘surrogacy.’ Women without uterus or with uterine diseases or with hysterectomy done can choose surrogacy for having a…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The surrogate motherhood controversy has been an ongoing battle for many years with two different sides giving their viewpoints. This has created much of a battle over recent years. Surrogate motherhood controversy has stirred up many critics and authors viewpoints to justify whether surrogacy should be practiced at all and if it should be legalized. While interpreting and analyzing the debate on whether surrogacy has ethical or moral values, or if it has turned the creation of a child into a new form of commodity to individuals, especially the women who bear the child for childless couples.…

    • 3706 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hca 322 Week 5 Assignment

    • 2523 Words
    • 11 Pages

    When one or more persons contract with a woman to gestate a child than relinquish that child after birth to the person or couple is known as surrogacy. It is a course of action that goes outside of natural reproduction. For some, it is the only method of having children, extending family. Surrogacy has been stirring up many controversies over the years. Ethics, morals, laws, religious views, etc. have played a major role in the issues that follow the topic of surrogacy. Laws and regulations pertaining to surrogacy vary from state to state. Some states have no enforceable laws towards surrogacy, while others only permit surrogacy contracts that are uncompensated arrangements and gestational agreements (Trimarchi, 2011). Some states prohibit same sex couples from entering into any form of surrogacy contracts. In this paper, I will be address the legal and ethical issues involved and other aspects of surrogacy.…

    • 2523 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    However the ethical issue remains concerning whether a female who 's being paid for her surrogacy is exploiting infertile couples and entering the agreement for money. Others begin to see the infertile couple as exploiting the surrogate 's body and taking advantage of a female who needs money. Another issue, a couple that would adopt a child would be rigorously screened and be assessed to their suitability. This would not be the case with surrogacy. Some people who would be restricted from adopting could avoid this process by using a surrogate. One of the key issues is with regards to surrogacy is it is impossible to determine the risks involved in the surrogacy process. A surrogate needs to be informed of the potential risks to her health and the possible psychological trauma she can suffer. There should a moral requirement for all parties involved to consider the welfare of the child born into any agreement. However, surrogacy raises the debate of people’s “right” to have children. If we refuse the option of surrogacy, are we discriminating against the infertile?…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays