Preview

Comparison of Ancient Mesopotamian and Egyptian Art

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1427 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparison of Ancient Mesopotamian and Egyptian Art
The artworks of Ancient Mesopotamia and Ancient Egypt are both strikingly different and similar at the same time. Consistent is the theme of serving the different gods the two cultures believed in. In Mesopotamia the various city-states each had their own protective deity, and in Egypt they sometimes differed from one dynasty to the next. Whatever the case, with the beginning of kingdoms and rulership came the need to justify a position of power and establish a hierarchy. And as more time passed came also the human need to leave an impression on their world. Looking at the example of the statues of Gudea from the Neo-Sumerian period and the Temple of Ramses II from the New Kingdom of Egypt in the 19th dynasty, will show how both rulers of these times chose to commemorate their life's work and what insight those choices give current civilizations into the mind-set of their respective cultures. The "Seated statue of Gudea, holding temple plan," also known as "The architect with a plan," is an excellent example of the Neo-Sumerian ruler's attempt to immortalize, but more importantly, to ingratiate himself to the Gods. Constructed around 2100 BCE, this statue is but one of a series of more than 20 diorite (extremely hard, difficult stone to work with) statues commissioned by Gudea the fourth ruler of the Sumerian dynasty of Lagash. Headless and sitting very upright on what appears to be a stool (as opposed to a thrown), the statue stands roughly at 2'5" tall, nearly life size. He is dressed in a kaunakes, or "thick cloak," with his right shoulder left bare and cuneiform inscriptions covering both the skirt of the cloak and the stool. The hands, with elongated fingers, are clasped as if praying, and his bare feet also with elongated digits, are resting together. On his lap sits a temple plan drawn on a tablet. Even though the proportions of the statue's fingers, toes, and presumably the head (other statues of Gudea have oversized heads) are off, there is a certain

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gudea was a ruler of Mesopotamia and focused his efforts on rebuilding the temples of Lagash; he was also rather vain in insisting that statues in his likeness were created and placed throughout the remodeled temples. This particular statue is crafted from Diorite and shows him in a seated position with some Sumerian text inscribed in his robing detailing the actual temples he renovated and his identity. It differs from the statue of Memi and Sabu not only in its choice of construction material but also in the fact that Gudea most likely had this and many others made to congratulate himself and preserve his honor throughout time. There's good chance that Memi and Sabu did not ask for their statue to be created but it was made anyway according to primitive religious and burial…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this time period, scribes were valued for their ability to read and write, but they lacked the divine status and authority of the king. As a result, this statue has a more realistic figure cut from native stone, and it lacks the grand symbols noted in Khafre Enthroned. In fact, the scribe has a sagging chest and protruding belly. He humbly sits on the floor with comparably less adornment. Although the statue is more realistic, suggesting the scribe was a less respected figure, his obesity might indicate that he had a relatively comfortable life and high position compared to the laborers of the time.…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From 3500-1500 BCE, Mesopotamia and Egypt emerged as two of the first river- valley civilizations. Although they came to be around the same time, they became different in their cultural aspects, such as universal views and classes, and economies due to differences in commerce.…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamia vs. Egypt

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Despite the fact that both Mesopotamia and Egypt were first developing around the same time, natural forces and the environment caused variations in many cultural developments such as political systems, religious views, and much more. Their biggest differences were dependent on the river-valleys they lived in and how that affected the way they managed agriculture, as well as their view of their gods. One similarity that Mesopotamia and Egypt did have was that both civilizations developed a system of writing and keeping records.…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mesopotamia and Egypt were two of the very first civilizations dating back to 3500 BCE. Their cultures were very similar, but were very different. In what ways were their cultures similar and different? Mesopotamia is similar to Egypt in that both were based around a river system and they both created their own form of writing. These two civilizations are very similar, but they are also different in that their structures are used for different purposes and Mesopotamians invented more important things.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the life of Egypt and Mesopotamia there were similarities and differences. There are comparisons in culture, social class, and gender. Also parallelism in their religions existed however, the differences found, clearly define them as individual entities.…

    • 560 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the ancient world there were many different aspects to developing culture. The Mesopotamians, Hebrews and the Egyptians shared many characteristics while at the same time differed greatly. Considering their views towards gods, social order, and life after death, one can discover the lives of the ancient people. Illustrations of their literature, art, and architecture help reveal this information. Although these different civilizations had similar living conditions, the way that they developed different aspects such as gods, social order and beliefs about life after death resulted in completely diverse cultures.…

    • 1446 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the Agricultural Revolution, the rise of civilizations scattered around the world, each one having various features that formed from their people and the land. Two civilizations that honed similarities and differences, Mesopotamia and Egypt, grew and adapted alongside river valleys—the Tigris and Euphrates rivers and the Nile respectively. Both civilizations turned to control and unify their people through ideas of class hierarchy and kingship. However, Mesopotamian life differed from Egyptian life, consisting of troubles in their crop production, negative viewpoints about death in their religious beliefs, and more restrictions for slaves and women.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Geological features can positively and negatively effect the development of a nation or a region. Ancient civilizations such as ancient Egypt and ancient Mesopotamia drastically relied on the resources rivers provided for them. Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamian both had similar and different reasons and benefits for using the rivers.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Art Paper Outline

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Fist, the “Seated statue of Gudea” is from 2150–2100 B.C. the Neo-Sumerian period. It is a 44cm tall Diorite statue. The description at the museum mentioned that this sculpture belongs to a series of diorite statues commissioned by Gudea, who was a Mesopotamian king. He rebuilt the great temples of Lagash and installed statue of himself in the temple. The posture of this statue is, an upright seated way on a throne like chair. It has its hands folded on its lap. It also is wearing a turban looking headwear with curls. It has a calm expression, large almond shaped eyes. It is wearing a draping robe. It has Sumerian inscription which lists the various temples that Gudea built or renovated in Lagash and names the statue itself, "Gudea, the man who built the temple; may his life be long."-Metropolitan Museum. The proportion of the figure seems to be odd. There is no neck, awkward sized feet, and the head is too large compared to the…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In ancient Egypt stone was widely used, however in Mesopotamia this was not available to them so brick and wood was mainly used. While Mesopotamia and ancient Egypt have differing forms of visual art, they are similar in many ways. Both have used architect as a form of visual art. While they differ within structure, they are very similar in their purpose. The ziggurats and pyramids alike, which lay at the center of the cities, were greatly important in giving the leaders, whether gods or kings, commemoration. In addition to using architect within the culture to bring light to the high status of their kings, they also used sculptures within their art to give praise to royalty. While in ancient Egypt the actual human anatomy was used to portray the royal status, in Mesopotamia the use of animals were used to signify “human roles.” In addition to these similarities, Egypt and Mesopotamia “both observed naturalism.” Influence from the Sumerian style, helped both express the reality of their…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Early civilizations were built near rivers because of the many resources and advantages of the rivers. RIvers could provide transportation, food, drink, and fertile soil. Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia were two river valley civilizations, and were very important to the beginning of mankind in the historic-era. A river valley civilization is deeply affected by the river it is situated upon. The river can affect all aspects of the life in the civilizations, including political aspects, economic aspects, religious aspects, social aspects, intellectual aspects, and architectural aspects. In Egyptian society, the Nile river was very consistent and predictable with its flooding, rather than Mesopotamia, where the Tigris and Euphrates rivers were very sporadic with their flooding, and caused Mesopotamian societies to be very different. One major difference between the Egyptian and Mesopotamian societies, was the government. In Egypt, there were many peasant villages all under one king, the Pharaoh. In Mesopotamia, there were city-states with kings to govern smaller areas because of the hectic rivers that surrounded Mesopotamia. There were also a lot of similarities between the two civilizations. They both had very religious centered societies and had polytheistic views. Also, they both traded a lot, and even fought wars over trade.…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout Egypt, during the middle empire art evolved as a symbol for power and permanence featuring straight lines and powerful figures; as time passed art evolved again morphing from simply representational images of man to the more idealized and anatomically correct style of Roman art. As art became more and more prevalent through the late 3rd and early 4th century’s artists began to focus more on anatomical perfection and realism borrowing artistic elements from other cultures such as the Greeks. Though the artistic styles of ancient Egypt and early Roman art vary widely, the underlying symbolism remains the same. This is clear in both the Egyptian Sculpture Vizier (Figure 1) and the Roman sculpture Bust of and Unknown Man (Figure 2). Where the ideas and concepts of both sculptures are essentially the same, their vastly different styles are evident of the time periods in which they were made.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rough draft: Two of the first civilizations were Mesopotamia and Egypt the both faced a similar problem the flooding of the rivers. In Egypt they used the flooding to help grow there crops. In Mesopotamia they completely blocked there flooding and had no way of telling when it would. Overall I think Egypt dealt with the rivers best.…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ancient Egypt was the birthplace of many world-changing inventions. Hundreds of years before the Chinese invented paper, Egyptians invented the use of papyrus to make a paper-like material on which to write. In fact, the word “paper” comes from the Greek word for papyrus. Papyrus was ahead of its time, more so than the Mesopotamian method of writing on clay tablets. Egyptians made the design of the chariot better by making it lighter and faster and changing the position of the axle. Mesopotamians didn’t even have experience with horses until they were invaded by the Assyrians in 1400 BC. Egyptians built the Great Pyramids of Giza, which is the…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays