Preview

Argumentative Essay

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
569 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Argumentative Essay
College Athletes: Should they be paid for play?
Andriana Shanklin
Dr. Mary Rose Kasraie
Research and Writing: ENG 215
October 19, 2011

Should college athletes be paid to play?

The issue of whether or not college athletes should be paid for play has been a heated debate across the nation for years. Most would say that college athletes are already paid to play by the scholorships that they are given such as free tuition, meals, books, room and board. However, some would say that college athletes are being taken advantage of by the coaches, universities they attend and the NCAA because of the career ending injuries, lack of being able to support themselves off of campus and the lack of a complete education. There are many pros and cons to this heated debate and as we have seen in various reports and statements from the NCAA on why college athletes should or shouldn’t be paid to play. According to the NCAA student athletes are supposed to be students first and players second. The arugment is that because the players are supposed to be preparing for a future as a professional in something other than sports. The NCAA reports that many athletes receive grants and aides more than $100,000 in their careers. Another argument that the NCAA has is that the only sport that actually yield revenues are large Division 1 programs and the other programs actually cost more to run. Lastly the NCAA state that almost all NCAA championships lose money. So let’s look at paying for pay from this prospective, yes student athletes don’t have to pay for tuition, books, room/board, meals are all paid for but what about clothing, entertainment and basic necessities are not. In addition an athletes schedule is fulled up with practice (no less than 12 hours a week), academic commitments and games when does a student athlete have time to work to take care of the rest of his needs. Additionally, when student athletes get professional athlete injuries while in school who

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    “The college sports industry generates $11 billion in annual revenues. Fifty colleges report annual revenues that exceed $50 million. Meanwhile, five colleges report annual revenues that exceed $100 million,” (Mitchell & Edelman). The money collected by the NCAA, goes towards the sports and the programs, not the players themselves, however, the NCAA says that “Student-athletes are at the heart of the NCAA’s mission,” (NCAA). “Some athletes and their supporters believe that college athletes deserve some type of financial payment for their services and contributions to their institutions, an opinion that has lead to player-initiated lawsuits, court cases, and strikes,” (Garcia).…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Student athletes need money just like any other college students, and many of them need it even more. According to Steve Wulf, many college athletes come from disadvantaged backgrounds (94). This means that while the free tuition is nice, they are still going to need money for other expenses that every college student faces. The NCAA finally realized this recently and decided to allow athletes to have a job earning up to $2000 during the school year…

    • 3415 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    After doing some research over a year ago and taking another look at this issue now, the question about paying college athletes has stayed the same. The debate whether to pay college athletes or not arose in the 1980s after Southern Methodist University was caught paying football players for their services. Upon discovery of these infractions, SMU was administered the “death penalty”, including loss of scholarships and no participation in bowl games for five years. The controversy surrounding paying college athletes seems to have risen from this unfortunate circumstance and has been cultivated into a huge social topic today. Following the SMU scandal in the late 1980s the NCAA rewrote their guidebook that describes an athlete’s role in an academic institution. According to the NCAA, “Student-athletes are students first and athletes second. They are not university employees who are paid for their labor” (NCAA.com). Looking at the arguments made by the NCAA, they make a valid point in showing how athletes are “compensated” for their participation in sports. According to the NCAA, “Many [athletes] receive athletics grants-in-aid that can be…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some colleges make more money than others. This graph shows the schools with the most profit in their sports programs. Somebody could say that the athletes bring in an enormous amount of money. According to Jeff Dorfman, a professor of Economics at the University of Georgia, only a few collegiate sports actually bring in money. Therefore, an athlete in a sport that isn’t very profitable wouldn’t make nearly get as much as an athlete in a very profitable sport. Along with the sports being very profitable they also have to pay for an even larger variety of different things. Student athletes should not be paid because of the money that would be paid to them. The money that they would be paid could be used to advance other things in the university such as better libraries, science labs, fixing up the dorms, or even improving their athletic facilities. Although the athletes put a lot of time into their schooling and sports the benefits they are given is equal to what they are giving and being…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why should kids be paid for doing a professionals job? The debate on whether or not to pay college athletes is a debate that has been argued for quite some time. Due to the lack of positive results, and a surplus of negatives, this should not take place. There is no way to muster up a fair system to pay the athletes while keeping everyone happy. Also, paying players will distract them from their academics due to them knowing that they can make money playing sports. Lastly, the athletes already have an opportunity for money with scholarships. Therefore, in order to keep college athletes happy and focused on school while still giving them an opportunity to receive scholarships, the students should not be paid for their athletic performances.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We often look at college athletes as miniature stars. The question is, why should student’s athlete get a paycheck for playing amateur level sports? Athletes complain about how they do not get enough for playing a sport. They are forgetting that they are being rewarded with a half or full scholarship. The main goal for these athletes is being academically successful. Not who has the best jump shot or who fumbled a ball, that does not matter. The essence of playing college level has been taken out of place, now replaced with the mindsets of professional athletes. Did they forget? You are not professionals. The love of the game has been through extortion for the love of money. Paying college athletes will lead the students astray from what they attended the institution to accomplish in the first place, that is, to earn a degree, not to gain a compensation.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion there are very many things and aspects we can argue here. The only thing that is right is that college athletes should be compensated. Coaches make way too much money along with the school its self with all of the advertisements. When the black market is up people are not playing fair and everyone is fighting for the right to play. College athletes work too hard to not get paid. College athletes should be…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For years the question, “Should college athletes be paid?” has appeared in the debatable world. College athletes across the nation have argued that they deserve compensation for the particular sport in which they participate in. “We deserve a check for what we do,” Southern Miss football player, Urell Johnson stated. “Win or lose, our sport is our job. We work all day, every day. If you think about it, the athletic department brings in the most revenue to the university.” Non-athletes, such as students (like myself) and faculty, have disagreed with the idea of reimbursing athletes who are still in college. Paying college athletes would be absurd, being that it would be too expensive, produce avaricious athletes, and most of all, it would be injustice to every other young adult attending college.…

    • 2104 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, let’s consider how expensive the life of a college athlete can be. Playing sports is like a full time job. Most college athletes don’t have time for a real job. Most college athletes get recruited far away from their home. Their parents or family may not always be able…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I used to argue vehemently against paying college athletes. Tuition, room, board and books were compensation enough. And even if, increasingly, it wasn’t enough and virtually every kid who accepted a scholarship was in the red before Christmas of his freshman year, the notion of pay-for-play was at best a logistical nightmare (Wilbon). Where would the money come from? How could you pay college football players but not baseball players or members of the women’s field hockey team?(Wilbon). Also how would pay men in a way that wouldn’t violate…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essentially student athletes receive a full paid education and all they have to do is represent their college in their respective sport. College athletes do not have to worry about the cost of housing, textbooks, student loans, and meal plans. According to Institute For College Access & Success, “in the state of Pennsylvania 71 percent of students leave a public four-year institution or private non-profit four-year institution in debt. The average debt is $32,528.” A cost like that is a major burden on a student who may not get a job straight out of college. After looking at it from a different angle, plenty of college students would be psyched to play a sport for four years if it meant they would not be in debt (US…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Student athletes should be compensated for their work, as they are the sole reason for the Athletic Program’s surplus in revenue. These athletes are working for the schools and are doing a service to the college that seems to go unnoticed. Colleges are using these athletes to boost their respective reputations and bring in revenue while not compensating these athletes for their work. Everywhere else athletes are paid, so why shouldn’t college students too? Some critics may argue that these student-athletes are amateurs, and if paid then are becoming professional athletes. The minor league for baseball could be considered an amateur sport, although they do receive pay according to the team’s revenue.…

    • 872 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    People are debating many controversial issues locally and globally. One controversial issue, which is relevant today, is whether or not college athletes should be paid or not. One side argues college athletes should be paid while others argue why they should not. For the NCAA this has been a popular topic. People began to discuss this topic when college athletes started to receive special treatment and compensation from scouters to insure that those players would sign with their team when they went onto the professional league. There are many interviews and articles debating this issue of whether or not college athletes should be paid. Weinstock argues that college athletes should…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The common argument to college athletes being paid is that they are “Student Athletes.” Taylor Branch the writer of The Shame Of College Sports agrees that the NCAA makes “Student…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The System for college athletes isnt perfect, and needs to be worked on, a big problem we cannot seem to agree is how to compensate the student-athletes who drive the NCAA. I would like to start off with a question. Are college athletes being compensated enough for the effort they put forth today? Every Day they wake up early and represent their university whether they are putting in work in class or on the field. Each student-student athlete generates tons of money for their university and they don’t see a dime other than their scholarship that may or may not been renewed every year. Keep that question in mind while reading this essay, and form your own opinion.…

    • 2491 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays