Preview

Arguing Fetal Tissue

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
938 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Arguing Fetal Tissue
Running head: Arguing the Use of Fetal Tissue 1

Arguing the Use of Fetal Tissue
Kris Gilley
TSTC-Abilene
14/FA Anatomy & Physiology I (BIOL-2401-46WI)
Dr. Rita Daniel

ARGUING THE USE OF FETAL TISSUE 2
Arguing the Use of Fetal Tissue Since the mid 1980’s research as existed and has been continuing worldwide on the use of fetal tissue and brain disorders. The most prevalent research is that of Parkinson’s disease. An over view of this research consists of the following: Parkinson’s disease affects the part of the brain known as the substantia nigra. Those with Parkinson’s disease suffer from a deterioration of neurons that yield the neuro­transmitter dopamine, which is vital
…show more content…
Working in the medical field for the past 17 years I have dealt with patients with the diagnosis. Watching how they struggle and the frustration they face on a daily basis has to be exhausting for them. I feel that we are in great need of further research for many medical ailments and diseases. Questioning the use of fetal tissue definitely strikes a nerve for many. And it is such a sensitive subject which has a power house of backing much like that of the Catholic Church whose view is that a life begins at conception. Where others say it’s not a life before the third trimester. I myself do not condone the use of farming fetal tissue. I don’t see why we cannon have access to the fetal tissue which has been aborted. Why not use that tissue and gain from it all that we can. How much is it costing to dispose of such tissue? I can see where it can easily be regulated by the government and possibly save tax payer dollars in disposal fees. These are fetuses that are electively aborted. The number of elective abortions in this nation in 2011 was 1.06 million. How many experimental transplants could have taken place using this viable …show more content…
Currently there is product that is used in wound care that is derived from the cells of infant foreskin. These
ARGUING THE USE OF FETAL TISSUE 4 cells are extracted and then duplicated and grown for reproduction and used to heal wounds. The cells collected from one specimen can grow enough cells to cover a football field. This could be a blueprint for the use of fetal cells and mass production with fewer hosts. This may also help eliminate the body rejecting the transplant tissue and the loss of transplanted tissue due to tissue death. This is such a controversial topic and hit really “hit’s a nerve” with so many. Whether you feel life begins at conception or later in the pregnancy really has no baring and is of little argument if we are using already aborted fetuses. There would be no monetary gain to the mother, there would be no incentive to abort a fetus, and it will merely be an alternative to disposal of the aborted fetus. Why waste what is readily available and could potentially enrich and lengthen the lives of those

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Abortions, this unethical practice of terminated unborn fetuses should be outlawed. The reasons are abortion is murder and life begins at conception, so unborn babies are human beings with a right to life and If women become pregnant, they should accept the responsibility that comes with producing a child.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everyday, innocent, harmless fetuses that could soon be laughing children are being brutally destroyed. One form of abortion is to cut the fetus into pieces with serrated forceps before being removed, piece by piece from the uterus by suction with a vacuum aspirator. Another form consists of bringing the fetus feet first into the birth canal, puncturing its skull with a sharp instrument and sucking out the brain tissue. The body parts, such as the head, are given letters, rather than refer to the parts as what they are. In my opinion this is for the doctors who cannot face the reality of what they are doing. The remains of the fetus or embryo, as the case may be, are put into everyday, plastic buckets and then sent to a dumpster where these precious bones and limbs are disposed. However, how and when an abortion takes place are matters of little importance to pro- abortionists and other defenders. Even former abortion practitioners from varying backgrounds and religions have a new view on abortion. These changes of heart were caused by psychological, religious and scientific reasons. One doctor, Dr. Bernard Nathanson, performed 60,000 abortions and supervised 10,000, before scientific evidence and the use of an ultrasound, convinced him he was promoting and participating what he now calls "the most atrocious holocaust in the history of the United States." Other doctors refuse to perform legal abortions, saying they should save lives rather than destroy…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A dispute of morals, ethics, science, saving lives and taking lives all wrapped up into one article! The article I am referring to is “The Ethics of Fetal Tissue Transplantation”, by Scott B. Rae. This article covers strong points such as science, laws, ethics, restrictions, and alternatives. With all the information presented in this article I find it extremely unethical to use fetuses from voluntary abortions to assist in medical care.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is an age-old question. The pro-life versus pro-choice debate has been argued for many years now. The stem cell debate is a similar concept, but the biggest difference is in most states a fetus can be aborted until they are 20 weeks old (editors, shape.com)! Whereas, embryonic stem cells come from embryos 3-5 days old. A common misconception with embryonic stem cells is that the child is getting taken away from their mother. This is because embryonic stem cells come from leftover vitro fertilizations so the cells would have gone to waste but instead are gone to help other people. These fertilization centers often have extra frozen cells. Many consider not using these cells is a waste (cirm). An important aspect to note is the difference between a fetus and an embryo. An embryo is an organism from the moment of fertilization to the 8 week mark. Whereas a fetus is from 8 weeks to the moment of birth (O’brien).According to Theresa Ellefson, mother and biology teacher, “ although I think that the pros of embryonic stem cell research outweigh the cons, I am not the mother of the embryo, and if I was it might alter my opinion.” This is a common opinion with mothers because they know how many benefits can come from the cells but they also do not want to volunteer their eggs. Although embryonic stem cells are not directly taken away from mothers, they are still sensitive with giving up their…

    • 2096 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When most people think about a fetus, the first thing that comes to mind is innocence. Due to the views on a fetus, experimentation is not publically endorsed. People can be uninformed about fetal experimentation, which can lead to rumors of conspiracy revolving around the research. If people would take a step back and learn about fetal tissue exploration, then these fabrications would not longer take place. Just like anything within the research field, there are going to be pros and cons. The pros outweigh the cons, then the research should then be justified, even if it is on innocent fetal tissue. With this knowledge of tissues is rising, this causes many studies to show more potential cures for illnesses, with enormous potential, and gives…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cell therapy and organ repair is a significant issue because most human organs and tissues do not regenerate spontaneously. Several categories of stem cells can be used in regenerative medicine including embryonic, fetal, and adult stem cell. Not all stem cells are of equal interest for clinical applications, because they are not able to become different specialized cells. Fetal and adult stem cells are undifferentiated cells, which can be found within fetus or in adult tissues or organs. They have limited self-renewal and are multipotent, which means that they can differentiate in several types of tissue cells. Although adult stem cells cannot be expanded in culture indefinitely, their use does not present ethical problems. The majority of…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main thesis of the Chapter is the ethical, moral, and political concerns regarding experimentation on human embryos. In the chapter, Philosopher Bonnie Steinbeck argues that embryos have a moral value, but do not possess a moral status. In her argument, moral value is when good reasons can be used to justify a being’s existence rather than objectifying it, and moral status is a being’s ability to have its own interests. For example, the ability for a being to feel pain. One would assume that a being would chose to not endure undue pain and seek to avoid it. Since embryos are not yet sentient, they cannot feel pain. In the late 1900’s Congress refused to authorize legislation for embryonic experimentation, even when the Ethics Advisory Board…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The evidence has been shown and now it is up to the Supreme Court to determine whether or not the law violates the 14th amendment and puts an undue burden on those women seeking an abortion in Texas. The larger issue here is that many other states are also following suit with Texas, which proves that this is something the Federal government may need to spend more time on. Federal government must also hold those responsible who break the laws concerning the obtainment of fetal tissue. Those people must suffer the consequences for breaking the law and jeopardizing the benefits that fetal tissue research can provide to science. These articles have served the purpose to shed light on the real effects that laws have on people and how breaking them can lead to a suffering of an entire people. One can only hope that the Supreme Court will decide what is actually best for Texas and the United States as a…

    • 1951 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Research has continued for many years into the use of adult stem cells and found that they are replaceable and could be used for the purposes of treatment and research without the destruction of embryos. In terms of reproductive cloning, it has never been proven that it is safe enough to try on the human race. Multiple studies involving mammals, such as rats, have found damage to both the cloned child and the surrogate mother. “In animal experiments to date, only approximately 5 percent of attempts to clone have resulted in live births, and a substantial portion of those live-born clones have suffered complications that proved fatal fairly quickly.” Some of the medium-term consequences, including premature aging, immune system failures and sudden unexplained deaths, have already been demonstrated in cloned mammals. The cloned child and surrogate mother are subject to health complications for the rest of their lives, including that the surrogate mother’s ability to reproduce in the future may be inhibited. Also, in the medical field, the patient’s consent is required for most procedures, however it is impossible to obtain…

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Exploring the specific controversies that are prompting debate overall, it is clear that the use of embryonic stem cells for research has been viewed as an ethical quagmire due to the fact that it calls into question protecting the life of a fetus. In the process of embryonic stem cell research, the cells needed for creating new tissue are taken from the blastula produced 3 to 5 weeks after the fertilization of the human egg.[iv] As such, many laymen and professionals alike argue that the practice destroys life and is…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    it is believed by some people that as soon as the ova has been fertilised by the sperm that is is alive. This belief contradicts the accepted theory that once the foetus has a heart beat it is alive. A foetus only has a heart beat around 6~8 weeks into the pregnancy. This is a large gap as people in most places can legally get an abortion in the first 6 ~ 8 weeks of pregnancy but not after the 8th week. However some groups belief that sense the ova is fertilised and the foetus is alive that its should not be allowed to have a termination at any point during the pregnancy. To do the majority of stem cell research it is necessary to have the abortion so that the stem cells can be extracted from the bone marrow of the foetus. Because groups of people belief that abortion is wrong, stem cell research progresses…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From a scientific point of view, if a woman has an unwanted pregnancy, the fetus is nothing more than an alien growth of tissue in her body and it should be removed as doctors would remove a wart, a cyst or a tumor. If, on the other hand, the woman wants to carry her baby to the point in which the fetus takes on the significance of any other non-vital part of her body, for example, a finger, her tongue, her breast, or for any other reason it would have to be removed in order to save her life then from a scientific view it should be removed. Scientists use abortion because they say that the embryo is not "alive" like human cells, but just a human life in the first stage of human development. To disagree with this, in order to prove the point that they are destroying human life, is to stop the advancement of science. Scientists also use aborted embryos to perform stem cell research for the betterment or advancement of modern medicine. They believe that by continuing in stem cell research that it will greatly benefit us in the future. Scientists say that the knowledge gained, can help in the creation of cures and preventions for disease's. With stem cell research we could also be more knowledgeable about the human body in general. It is not scientific to deny a medical service which would save thousands of women each year simply because some women abuse it. Nobody is suggesting that we ban prescription drugs simply because some people abuse them. The…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are reasons why it is unethical such as it goes against the constitution. The 14th amendment states that “all men are created equal with certain unalienable rights. Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” meaning no one should be deprived of their life. A lot of people believe there is no person at the point of conception but, there is. At that point there is a makeup of a unique genetic code which each and every one of us have. When you abort a fetus you are depriving it of life it will not have the liberty or the happiness as stated in the constitution and the fetus is unable to defend itself.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abortion - title

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Each human has the potential to act in a way that is exemplary and innovative. By doing so, they make positive contributions to the world. Unborn babies are a manifestation of this potential. Therefore, it is fair to say that aborted babies are robbed of the opportunity to make a positive contribution to the world. Imagine if great men, who changed the course of history, like Albert Einstein, Mahatma Gandhi, or even Barack Obama were deprived of the chance to help shape the world as we know it because they were aborted. Where would we be now? We do ourselves an injustice when we deprive the world of brilliant scientists, fearless heroes and loving friends. Unborn babies have the right to life and to fulfill an unknown destiny.…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    And as old problems have been overcome, new ones have arisen to take their place. One of the major ones is vascularization of the tissue. The difficulty in providing blood supply to the newly constructed tissue is a major obstacle. The endothelial cells need to be coaxed into building a vascular network that penetrates the engineered tissue. Though a lot of research has been done in this arena, the sizes of the vessels prove to be a hurdle that is yet to be overcome. This is true especially for highly vascularized tissues like the liver. There also remaining the question whether the new organ or tissue will be similar to the natural tissue functionally. E.g. the liver should detoxify the blood and also secrete bile as well as regulate nutrients. The skin should grow hair and allow for other transport mechanisms. These questions prove that a lot remains to be discovered especially about the mechanisms of growth factors and molecular signaling. There is no doubt however that the perspective with which the world views tissue engineering has changed a lot. The idea of growing living flesh out of nonliving materials and cells following engineering principles no longer seems like a fantasy. Artificial Skin and cartilage approved for use by FDA as off-the- shelf products have already helped thousands of patients. 50 million people in US alone have undergone some type of artificial organ therapy. Several tissue engineered products like bronchial tubes, cornea, bladder, blood vessels and valves are already undergoing clinical trials. Thus considering the exponential growth of this field, it would be safe to say that further research into this field will open up fresh avenues. Equipped with adequate knowledge of biology, eventually it may be possible to attain the goal of a fully vascularized organ that is identical to the natural one both functionally and…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics