Preview

Analyzing Jonathan Safran Foer's 'Let Them Eat Dog'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
864 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analyzing Jonathan Safran Foer's 'Let Them Eat Dog'
Analyzing “Let Them Eat Dog” Jonathan Safran Foer’s article, “Let Them Eat Dog”, makes a compelling argument. Foer proposes that dog, like other animals, is as fairly consumable, nutritious, and deserving to be eaten as the rest of the meat found in the deli aisle. For a serious argument, the article keeps the reader interested with a humorous technique and alliteration. Foer presents the long history of dog-consumption, how that has changed, and how in present-day, having dog in our diet would benefit us, not only nutritionally, but economically and socially. At the start of the article, taken from his humorously titled book Eating Animals, Foer puts forward his witty writing style, saying, “eating ‘man’s best friend’ is as taboo as a man eating his best friend.” He presents a true point. Foer continues to exemplify his clever style with alliteration in the first paragraph, referencing Gordon Ramsay saying “you’ll never see a puppy peeking out of one of his pots.” Alliteration and humor invite the reader into his argument, making the piece interesting and fun to read. Foer does, however, maintain a serious outlook on the subject of eating dogs.
After the introduction, Foer questions the ethics behind the disagreement to canine consumption by bringing up humanity’s long standing history of devouring dogs. The two main
…show more content…
To get the reader less repulsed, he mentions the great civilizations that once ate dog for nutritional or religious reasons. He notes how the great thinkers, such as Hippocrates ate dog meat as “a source of strength.” Foer’s droll writing comes back out when he alludes to the Chinese raising the breed “the black-tongued chow, for chow”. Later in the article, he inserts a Filipino recipe for stewed dog, which sounds very appealing. His style paired with human history is enticing to the reader’s comfort level about this taboo

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    "…the meanest, ‘baddest' dogs in North American Pop Culture have been, without a doubt, pit bulls." Even though this stereotype exists, she challenges it by giving her own relation to pit bulls. "To me, Ahab, is a regular family dog: a joker and a couch potato, hungry for affection and table scraps, gentle and patient with ear-yanking children." She is able to state the real trouble and give information on what is being done to help the subject. "Currently, Canadian animal experts and organizations are lobbying for more comprehensive dangerous dog legislation – something that holds owners of all breeds accountable and doesn't penalize responsible owners of maligned breeds." I feel George is rhetorically effective over all with it comes to her essay, "Pit Bull, Bum Rap?" She gets her position across and leaves you thinking about what can be done to solve the…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pico Iyer’s uses heat in various ways throughout his essay, “Inner Climate”. Iyer starts out by describing how heat in our outward climate causes changes. He then talks about how our “inner waters” (694) need to be tended to before our “outer environment” (694) can be healed. He concludes by telling us about his own small changes that may not change the world, still have a small impact on changing things slowly.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wallace can show us on one hand how huge a tourist attraction the Maine Lobster Fest is, tell us in salivating details what one can find to nosh on, and every detail right down to how long you can expect to stand in line for a freshly cooked lobster and how much you can expect to spend for it. But then he also wonders how many people would line up for a Nebraska Beef Festival in which the attendees stand and watch trucks of cattle drive up and unload to be slaughtered on “the World's Largest Killing Floor.” His tinges of sarcasm work to help soften the blow of his pointed questions. Foer had to choose a more unusual approach because of the utter repugnance at the thought of eating the very animals we let sleep in our beds, ride in our cars, snuggle with on our sofas, and buy all sorts of pricey foods, toys, and other things to make their lives cushy. He knows from start to finish, that despite his clear and concise argument, he's convinced no one. He goes so far as to quote George Orwell's Animal Farm as he states, “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” This quote seems to be the crux of his argument. Dogs are more equal than other animals, perhaps because they are slavishly devoted to their human owners, at least in the United States. He valiantly tries…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beware: World War I

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    ______ 1. The circumstance that creates the main conflict in “Beware of the Dog” centers on a…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cited: Heng, Liu. "Dogshit Food." _Fiction Since 1976._ Trans. Deride Sabina Knight. N.p., n.d. 366 - 378. Print.…

    • 809 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animal Bloodlust Analysis

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Papps initiates his case with an anecdote to describe the “brutal scene” in which pit bulls are “trying to tear each other to pieces.” This intended start was to hook the reader into the piece, coupled with the use of enlarged text and pictures depicting pit bulls labeled as “dangerous” behind bars, alludes to the point that they have no place in public, only belonging to euthanasia clinics that would end their “bloodlust”. From this, the reader is invoked with a sense of fear and perspective to the grandeur of the issue at hand, made to be shocked and weary of the breed as Papps attempts to distort their views on pit bulls. Smith also utilizes the prison motif for his pictures in his piece, to further stress the idea of “pit bulls are being used as weapons” but differing in his objective. He aims to objectify the dog in this case, where they serve no more than mere “weapons and aids for criminal activities” so that the audience feels less squeamish of the newly imposed laws regarding their stay in Victoria. This is contrasted by Papps’ representation of the dogs, calling them “super killer dogs” that were “trained to kill”. He demonizes each breed, which leads to a similar action Smith intended for the audience—in that, to distance the audience from these dogs, moving them away from sympathizing with the dogs which further bolsters the arguments of both authors.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    People tend to pay as much attention to food as they do brushing their teeth. I urge you, however, to take a step back, slow down, and really think about the food you eat. Eating is a complex thing. It may surprise you. And when you actually think about eating, you will eventually come to think about eating meat. This is no accident, meat has it's pull on humanity. And on our world. The choices we make matter. According to the best-selling author Jonathan Safran Foer, eating the meat we know "is certainly the single worst thing that humans can do to the environment"(457). Foer has been recognized by Rolling Stones Magazine and Esquire for his many accomplishments. In one of his works, "Against Meat", Foer covers the relationship of meat and…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Intro: This essay will investigate and explore the similarities and differences between the linguistic and presentational techniques used to have an effect on the reader used in two articles with the shared topic of pets. The first article is by two women who call themselves 'Barking Blondes', the use of the word 'Barking' having two meanings: one relating to the sound dogs make and secondly referring to madness. This may be because they are slightly eccentric dog lovers. The formal online newspaper blog article is called 'Dealing with the death of a pet', and it informs, advises and entertains the two audiences of pet lovers and non-pet lovers; non pet lovers simply just finding it entertaining to read about the extremities that eccentric dog lovers reach. It includes sarcastic and hyperbolic language that progressively becomes mocking which makes the article humorous. The second article is ‘Confessions of a cat sitter’ by Chris Pascoe. It is an informal magazine article that is aimed at cat owners and lovers, and readers of ‘Your Cat’ magazine, which aims to inform and entertain. In contrast, both articles have the same purpose, both have a sarcastic tone at points and both are humorous. The ‘Barking Blondes’ article is formal whilst Chris Pascoe’s writing style in the article is casual and informal.…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once upon a time the poorest fed dog in America was the farm dog left to fend for itself for food. These dogs, undernourished bags of bones, were once so common they almost became symbolic of impoverished rural America. Today vast numbers of those small farms have vanished. With them have gone the gaunt, hollow-eyed hounds that greeted every farm visitor with a hungry, ill-tempered bark.…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Let them eat dog

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The analysis is based on the essay by JONATHAN SAFRAN FOER titled “Let Them Eat Dog”. This essay debates a topic that at first glance would seem to have a logical answer of no but the author provides many reasons that may make you wonder why is no the answer. What would your response be to the question should we eat dogs?…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The German Shepherd Dog

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dogs are considered to be the world’s most common pet. In the course of human history, millions of domesticated dogs have been kept either as companions at homes or helpers in various needs. They are loved not simply on account of their unparalleled display of intelligence and perceived usefulness, but also because they are the kind of animals that are able to establish long-term relationships with man. As a matter of fact, man’s fondness for dogs is something that manifests frequently. If one were to take a stroll at a park or jog on a beach, one is almost sure to find someone taking his or her pet dogs for a walk. As indeed, one can rarely find a house in the neighborhood that is not a home for a dog or two. The military and police forces use them to track persons or things, inasmuch as shepherds seek their help to protect herds from wolves and other threats. If these say anything about them, they only show that dogs play a very important role in human affairs no other kind of animals can perhaps fill.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animals, author Foer states that “ Like abortion, where it is impossible to definitively know some of the most important details and that cuts right to one's deepest discomforts, often provoking defensiveness or aggression”. Although the physical benefits of consuming a dog can easily be proven or stated, the emotional side of this argument cannot simply be solved, if possible at all. The argument behind the morality of eating a dog has been taking place for a very long time. Many of the individuals who believe in the banning of consuming dogs argue that dogs are a higher tier of animal than the other types of animals we consume. This is simply not true. While one might argue that the majority of America would not consume dogs even if dog meats…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The research article The Psychology of Eating Animals is about how psychologists examined the psychology of why people eat animals. According to Loughnan, Bastian, and Haslam, the characteristics of the consumers of animals (people), the animal that is being consumed, and the eating (behavior) needed to be studied in depth. From the researchers in this article, the studying of moral behaviors when faced with everyday moral situations can expose our personality characteristics, cognitions, and emotions. This can explain why we do what we do, how we feel about the things we do, and what we believe is right or wrong. The focus of this article was to ask people to self reflect on why they eat meat, how they feel about eating meat, and if why they…

    • 1885 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    We participated in a Foer virtual interview where Foer himself answered some of the questions presented by us. This was a great and valuable experience since the author of the book, Eating Animals, that we read in class will be answering some of our own questions. Unfortunately the microphone and video did not seem to be working so he didn’t get to our question till the very end. It was very inspirational because Foer provided insight into our questions. Specifically when he said that you don’t necessarily need to stop eating meat but look into where the meat comes from and buy from meat processing companies that perform any cruel treatment. This shows that is more that one way to improve your eating habits. One doesn’t not have be a stern oppose to meat eating if he or she like to eat meat. If he or she wants to eat meat, Foer simply says that you should know where you are getting your meat and try to get it from organic companies.…

    • 314 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    These two major viewpoints can be further analysed by looking at varying perspectives and the symbolisms and functions attached to dogs in particular, which explains why different groups react differently. Harsh critics of the Yulin Dog Meat Festival would view dogs as man’s best…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays