Preview

Wilson, Treaty of Versailles Essay Example

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
510 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Wilson, Treaty of Versailles Essay Example
The strength and effort of opposition forces as well as the ineptitude and stubbornness of President Wilson led to the Senate defeat of the Treaty of Versailles. The opposing senators wanted to add reservations onto the treaty, but Wilson’s would not have it. This caused Wilson to kill his own treaty with some help from opposing senators. Opposing forces killed the Treaty of Versailles in many different ways. They believed the treaty did not satisfy pre-war hopes for peace (Doc B). One political group even opposed the treaty. The group that hurt the treaty was the Reservationists, led by H.C, Lodge. This political group though the only way to get this treaty passed was to add their own rules onto the treaty. These reservations were thought of as negative by President Wilson and led to the treaty’s ultimate defeat. Another party, the Irreconcilables, believed in isolationism, and did not support the treaty because it contradicted their beliefs. As you can see, more and more senators are turning against the treaty and killing it. A majority of the Senate opposed the treaty because they believed involvement in the League of Nations would lead to foreign entanglements (Doc E). Some people in Europe even criticized the treaty because they believed it would be degrading for Europe (Doc F). The main question of this era was would the American people allow total control by one international organization (Doc A). President Wilson killed his own treaty, not because he wanted to, but because he was forced to by the reservations put on his treaty. Some of his fourteen points were used in the actual treaty like the League of Nations. Wilson believed the war was the war to end all wars, and we were not supporting the treaty that would do just that (Doc C). Wilson was so dedicated to this treaty that he was pushing for his treaty (without reservations) even while he was on his way out of office (Doc G). Wilson also believed that joining the League of Nations on our own terms

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    After reading Thomas A. Bailey’s article on “Woodrow Wilson Wouldn’t Yield”, I feel this quote best represents exactly what Woodrow Wilson stood for. He was a man who wanted peace and would not yield for anyone or any country unless it was best for him and our country. In Tomas A. Bailey’s article, his argument that Wilson’s fourteen points and most notably the League of Nations wasn’t passed not just because of the points themselves. But because of Wilson’s failure to see little changes and revisions to his plans, the League would have fallen through, instead of pitfall in the Senate like it did. “On March 4, 1919 - 39 Senators or Senators-Elect, more than enough to defeat the treaty-published a round robin to the effect that they would not approve the League of Nations in its existing form. Bailey also argues that Wilson’s character, in that his huge desire for morality and idealism, we also much to blame for his stubbornness in keeping the League of Nations unrevised or compromised upon.…

    • 541 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ap Euro: Mchapter 26 Outline

    • 8194 Words
    • 33 Pages

    * President Wilson saw the problems that arose with the treaty and placed hopes in the League of Nations…

    • 8194 Words
    • 33 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conservative Republicans hated the league of Nations and refused to approve the treaty. As result, Wilson’s allies gained an edge in bargaining so that Wilson could meet American interests. This includes maintaining the Monroe Doctrine. France decided to give up claims for the Saar Valley which is a part of Germany. In exchange for this, Britain and America agreed to the Security Treaty which meant that both the US and Britain would defend France if Germany invaded again. Italy wanted Fiume, but debate led to it not getting established. Japan demanded China's Shandong Peninsula and also the German islands of the Pacific it had seized during the war. After Japan threatened to walk out (since they had the bargaining advantage), Wilson accepted a compromise in which Japan kept Germany's economic holdings in Shandong and pledged to return the peninsula to China at a later time. When Germany was forced under the Treaty of Versailles in June 1919, they were outraged which made Wilson remove more of his Fourteen Points to make it more acceptable. A quote from The New Republic entails, “Instead of expressing a great recuperative effort of the conscience of civilization, which for its own sins has sweated…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States had entered World War I against many wishes of the American public, which made the ratification for the peace agreement an even more difficult task. Woodrow Wilson justified American involvement by claiming that an Ally victory would ensure a new world order. The war would be used as an instrument to "make the world safe for democracy". However, many Americans, government officials, and even the Allies did not agree with the progressive ideals that would be enforced to attain the peace that Wilson had desired and promised. This was made evident when Wilson's negotiations for the peace treaty were criticized and rejected by the leaders of the other Allied nations and isolationists. Even when Wilson acknowledged objections against his proposals, he refused to accept any compromises or different versions of the treaty. Therefore, both the inflexibility of Wilson and strength of the opposition forces led to the defeat of the Treaty of Versailles.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In order to understand the situation that led to the defeat of the treaty, it is necessary to identify what the sticking point was. In this case it was Article X of the Treaty which would commit US troops to involvement in foreign affairs if another member of the league was threatened. While President Wilson called this a war of keeping the world safe for democracy so he could justify having sent troops over to Europe in the Great War (Document C) many viewed it was a marriage of America to Foreign entanglements (Document E). However Document E shows a figure labeled "US Senate" bursting through the window trying to stop this marriage. The main issue in the senate was the commitment of US troops to foreign conflicts. This issue caused Henry Cabot Lodge to lead the Republicans in the house to demand that Wilson edit this provision of the treaty. In response to this demand Wilson urged Democrats in the Senate to accept no compromises and to only offer to ratify…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. The Treaty as you can imagine received enormous opposition. Henry Cabot Lodge and Alfred Beveridge strongly denounced the treaty, especially Article Ten which called upon the US to support League actions. Wilson campaigned vigorously and gave 37 speeches in 29 cities in a span of only three weeks. He declared that US soldiers should not have died in vain. After a dramatic speech in Colorado, Wilson collapsed. His health had been poor for six months and the strain of the trip was too much. He was rushed back to Washington and a few days later had a massive stroke. For the next year and a half he was incapable of running the government but was protected by his wife and closest advisors.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During the years when the World War I took place Wilson entered his second presidency term. At the beginning he planned to keep United States out of the war but after Germany killed thousands of people and started to attack U.S. merchant ships he changed his view. At that time, President Wilson saw Germany as the enemy. Therefore, he build an army of four million troops and sent half of them to France and that’s when for the first time Wilson reached out to Germany with the message to end the war peacefully without the need of someone to win. He had a vision of self-determination for all nations. Later, he publicized the Fourteen Points to be used as a peace maker. Not only did he come up with peace terms, but he also stated ways to make the…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    President Wilson's own ineptitude and stubbornness is what led to the Senate's defeat of the Treaty of Versailles, rather than the strength of the opposing forces. Even Wilson's closest and most trusted advisors could not sway his stance. Wilson was strong in his stance and incorporated the idea of the 14 points. While it is true that opposing forces contributed to defeat the treaty, it was Wilson's unmovable position that led to its ultimate defeat in the Senate.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Explain what factors led to the defeat of the ratification of the Treaty of Versailles and how it…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wilson’s egoism lead to his refusal to become a leader in the negotiations to change the terms of Article Ten. Ultimately, this lead to the Treaty of Versailles’ death. Before the first Senate vote on the Treaty of Versailles, President Wilson and Senator Gilbert M. Hitchcock privately worked out a series of reservations that would allow for a compromise between the Reservationists and the Internationalists. Continuously, Hitchcock urged Wilson to go public with the reservations they had worked out (Bailey, 188). Instead of taking Hitchcock’s advice, Wilson simply said, “let Lodge compromise” (Bailey, 189). Wilson refused to be the one to step-up and start the discussion between the Reservationists and Internationalists to get the Treaty passed. In fact, Wilson believed that Lodge should have started to compromise first. If Wilson had put his ego aside and focused on what was important, the Treaty of Versailles would have been passed, but his stubbornness and refusal to become the leader he should have been caused the Treaty’s death. For the same reason Wilson did not step up and start negotiations between the two sides, he also did not step up to try to continue negotiations Lodge started. After the first vote on the Treaty of Versailles, Senator Lodge started secret discussions with Democrats in order to negotiate a compromise. However, Senator Borah found out that Lodge was taking part in these negotiations and accused him of treachery. Lodge had to stop the negotiations because of Borah’s accusations and his threat to re-elect a majority leader (Bailey, 189-199). If Wilson had stepped in between Borah and Lodge, the negotiations could have continued between the two parties and the majority of the Senate would have been able to agree on a version of the Treaty. If Wilson had put aside his ego and desire for Article Ten to be exactly as he had written it,…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    League Of Nations Dbq

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages

    President Woodrow Wilson, went up against Senator Henry Cabot Lodge who was the Republican majority leader and chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee. The Treaty of Versailles, and with it the League of Nations, was rejected by the US Senate. As a result, the United States refused to play a role in preventing the overthrow of Europe by Adolf Hitler during the World War.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The History of Nothing

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages

    D) The failure of ratification was largely due to the formidability of conservatives who disliked international obligations laid out in the treaty as well as liberals who believed that the treaty did not provide for a peaceful future. Wilson’s personal stubbornness only was a small part of these two conflicting forces.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Treaty of Versailles was defeated because of the opposition of both the conservatives and the liberals and Woodrow Wilson’s political ignorance. There are two types of Conservatives, the Ultra conservatives and the moderate conservatives. Both disapprove of the treaty in one way or another. The Ultra conservatives also known as the irreconcilables oppose to the treaty and are not willing to compromise. The Moderate conservatives also known as the reservationists had doubts about the certain aspects of the treaty, mainly the League of Nations, but they are willing to compromise. The Liberals opposed to the treaty and refused to accept it because the liberals think that the treaty is one of revenge and retribution, which will only lead to another war. Wilson’s political ignorance and unwillingness to compromise led to the ultimate failure of the treaty of Versailles. The conservatives, both ultra and moderate, the liberals, and Wilson’s political ignorance and inflexibility all led to the failure of the treaty of Versailles.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many historians view the Treaty of Versailles as a flawed peace and even as one of the causes of World War II. “We arrived determined that a Peace of justice and wisdom should be negotiated; we left the conference conscious that the treaties imposed upon our enemies were neither just nor wise.” admits Harold Nicolson, a member of the British delegation.…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carleton argues Wilson was not responsible for the failure of joining the League because Carleton felt that even if Wilson had agreed to the Lodge Reservation, how sure are we that by Wilson joining in, it would have been enough for America to get in the League? Carleton points out, “Under the Lodge Reservation, every signatory nation had to accept them before the United States could become a member” (194). He uses this proof to support his claim that if Wilson had agreed with the Lodge, but the U.S. still didn’t make it into the League because not all fifteen nations agreed to let us in, would we still be blaming Wilson? Carleton also states that if Wilson was as stubborn as he was made out to be, then he would have been a joke for a president. He was accused of not understanding world politics but in that day, what American statesman understood world politics more than Wilson? Carleton also dismissed the fact that Wilson was accused of not being able to compromise. He stated “If the truth of this accusation must rest on Wilson’s attitude during the Treaty fight, and I think it must, for he showed remarkable adaptability in other phases of his Presidency” (194-195). Given the situations Wilson was in as a president, from the stroke to dealing with the League, Wilson has had no choice but to adapt and compromise with certain situations. Carleton ends his claim with the focus more on Lodge because he procrastinated votes on the treaty for two weeks and made it…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays