Preview

U.S. vs Asian School System

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1043 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
U.S. vs Asian School System
Andre' Umansky

Two Systems into One

In the past twenty years the United States school system has been accumulating quite a bit of criticism. Evidence shows that the United States has been lagging exponentially compared to almost all the industrialized countries. This specifically refers to Asian countries that are statistically blowing the U.S. out of the water. Recent survey results in the universal subject of math show us that the U.S. eighth graders have fallen behind, while the twelfth grade level showed only slight improvement (appositive). This means that the U.S. students are barely floating above water, where as, Asian students have built some sort of super boat (appositive). Yet we all recognize that not any one device is perfect, and are usually leaking water in the most unnoticeable spot. Before one realizes the problem, the boat is sinking. We would potentially look at these education systems as extremes of each other. Each education system being on the different side of the spectrum. Both systems having faults and advantages. Taking the positive aspects from both sides and merging them together, a harmonious education system could be established (verb phrase).
The article "Japan's School System" tells us that in an Asian classroom students will feel an incredible amount of pressure starting from grade school and up, while U.S. teachers are too afraid to raise the bar because of potential discouragement of the student. We examine evidence from the article "Strengths, weaknesses, and lessons of Japanese education". A negative of the Asian school system, is the conformity that must be upheld. This achieves better education because it becomes the "thing to do". When everybody is on the same curriculum there is no other choice but to follow the herd. While conformity creates better math students, it demises the aspect of creativity and individuality. The boat may float, but not posses any inspiration or differentiation from the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Today in America education is not highly valued in our society as it were in the past As our education value decline other country in Asia (such as China, Japan, Korea, India, Pakistan, e.t.c) excel over us. After reading the article “Why They Excel” by Fox Butterfield I began to understand some of the reason why Asia excels. Butterfield clearly state that American students are not doing as well as Asia student because American family are not getting involve/supporting in their children school life. And also it’s hard work, motivation, and how we’re raised. I believe this is true because many Americans have lost their value of hard work to succeed in life; instead they rely on talent alone.…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most important things that can be drawn from this article is how to blend the best parts of each schooling system. If there were a way to utilize a student’s potential without erasing all individuality, or to take away a student’s fear of failure, it would solve a lot of problems in not only American schooling, but in flawed systems all over. Intelligence and creativity are not opposites; they coexist in many students and simultaneously aren’t found in many others. If there were a way to somehow mix the teaching methods of Eastern and Western countries, the discussion on fearing failure and struggle would not have to exist anymore. Starting with a single community, a single school, or even a state is fairly easy. It definitely isn’t impossible. But changing a whole nation, let alone several, will take a lot of work. Most people, however, would agree that hard work is worth it when children across the world benefit. The issue at hand is not punishing children who are afraid to try, but rather making it so that they don’t have to…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Kindergarten, elementary school, middle school, high school and university, millions of students are herded through the same education system independent of their differing levels of intelligence and skills. The limited funds put into the education system are spent on providing a generalized education, which is geared towards moving everyone through the system that inevitably hurts both the academically and non-academically oriented. Some argue that America’s education system is based far too much on standardized testing, allowing others to determine their academic strengths and weaknesses. But the issue is that every year students go through standardized testing, are told their results and then the system simply continues with business as usual. A system where students are placed in separate schools based on their interests, intelligence, and abilities is highly discouraged in most of the country because everyone wants to believe that they are above average.…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Yet he does not speak Korean beyond a few words. It is evident from direct observation that a student such as James typifies the perception of the Asian as the model-minority. He is hard working, deferential, respectful and obedient. Yet signs of his Americanization are also evident, the most obvious example is his adoption of a Western first name in place of his birth name. From these specific, individual observations, certain conclusions can be reached that will be helpful to the educator. It is generally true that White and Asian student performances are relatively similar, far exceeding the scores of black, Hispanic, and American Indian students. In mathematics, Asian students usually outperform white students. Strategies for closing the gap include changed beliefs and attitudes of parents, families, students, and teachers; cultural responsiveness; greater opportunities to learn; effective instruction; and more family and community involvement. Yet these generalizations can be just as harmful as helpful. The Asian group is anything but homogenous. Asian Americans are one of the most diverse groups that you will find in the world. There are more within-group differences than are between groups. One of the problems with the model-minority myth—where all Asians are seen as economically and educationally successful—is that its it based on the successes of very small groups of people. There is a huge range of differences within the Asian American community. For those Asian families who believe strongly in education and formal education, their values are more apt to mesh with mainstream America. They tend to achieve in the schools. Members of Asian groups with less formal education have a harder…

    • 3080 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    To be an American is like being a child. Children are held back by their mothers, just as Americans are held back by their own government. Our healthcare system is not only extremely expensive, but almost useless, and our educational system doesn't get our kids anywhere. As great as America may seem, our educational system is flawed and our healthcare system is getting us nowhere.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is this deadly routine really necessary?” (Source A). Traditional education has been monotonized and homogenized to exploit a child’s moldable mind with the goal of creating an upstanding, economically-sound citizen. This tyrannical, oppressive force called school compartmentalizes students and encourages them to accept a routinized life. Mathematics and English are the dictators of a student’s career.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Group conformity is highly regarded. Japanese society embraces cultural homogeneity and training for uniformity forms the heart of Japanese education. Children are trained through group life at school to master the competency to conform to the group norm which is strictly required as a member of Japanese society. Students are encouraged to develop strong loyalties to their social groups and their class.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Japan, I attended the American School in Japan (ASIJ), a select, highly diverse international school an hour from downtown Tokyo. While I was young, I found it easy to appreciate attending school with expatriate students from different pockets of the world and being immersed in Japanese culture alongside my peers. Put simply, most students were inherently in the “same boat”, establishing common ground from which to form friendships. Differences in race, ethnicity, religion, and background were championed, even at a young age, and never…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the people of Asian came to American for reasons such as a better life for their families, more income, and a better education they stood out because of their focus, hardworking efforts and high respect for their elders. One of the biggest stereotypes toward the Asian race is the success they have in an educational environment by achieving high test scores, academic awards and punctual about turning in all work assignments. Education for Asian children is a major reason why most immigrants come to American because in American it is easier to better education and a greater chance to succeed in life. Many adults in American was taken by surprise when they realize how respectful Asian children and adolescents had toward them. For many Asian…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Asian American

    • 2112 Words
    • 8 Pages

    American schooling may contradict the fundamental cultural beliefs of Asians because it emphasizes individualism and competition, while the ethnic identify of Asian children is often based on their relationship to the group and allegiance to family.…

    • 2112 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the major problems in America today is the overwhelming incidences of inequality in the schools, particularly the differences between schools in the suburbs and the urban school system. This inequality is jumping off point, if left unresolved this problem will continue to contribute to the growing strain on the economy. It will lead to an increase in the numbers of teen pregnancies, the unemployment rate, the number poverty stricken individuals, and a trend of drug or alcohol abuse in these communities.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Today new school reforms have been formulated. These reforms are created to form individuals into becoming financially advanced and globally competitive persons. The very means to gauge the progress of the new reform is through test scores. Standardized tests and the test scores are now tantamount to accountability, transforming the educational system into a dehumanized market institution. The school is seen as a capital investment and is now measured according to financial value. Today 's school reforms have seemed to do away with the notion of schools "helping to create people who are fully developed as human beings and as democratic citizens." (Tyack D. 1997) However, amidst the prevailing regress in today 's education and contentions on reforms, Americans hold schools as the means to change and influence society. No other institution in the culture is solely devoted to developing mental powers, and the existence both of powerful means of psychological and political influence through the organized media and of an intellectually complex culture and economy amply justifies, and indeed compels, a focus on the effective use of one 's mind. Furthermore, intellectual training is eminently useful: it opens means to educate oneself in any sphere of interest or importance. Without it, one is crippled. With it, one can gain, on one 's own, that comprehensive learning that so attracted the predecessors in the past. The belief is still the same: "education holds the key to the future". Indeed, the future of the United States of America, of any similar country, depends to a huge extent on what goes on in the schools, whose membership (teachers and studies) comprised a large percentage of the nation 's population. Any reform, any revolution – of ideas, of hearts and minds, of attitudes – could very well take root in the school system. The school is obviously the most potent vessel of the development of a pole and its culture. The…

    • 2596 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Education, the pride and passion of many United States citizens, is an issue in the United States that has drawn scrutiny over past fifty years. The United States is no longer viewed as the leader of Education, as it may have or may have not once been viewed. We are falling behind countries like Japan, China, and other countries in most subjects. In order to try to close the gap in education between us and the countries that are on top in the education world; we have implemented laws, such as the No Child Left Behind Act. Some may suggest that we need to adapt more of an Asian-style approach: “US education system requires an ‘Asian’ overhaul-for example, longer school days, more frequent short recess periods, and an earlier introduction of vocational focus.” (Spellings 2010, 68)…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Stevenson, H., & Stigler, J. W. (1994) Learning gap: why our schools are failing and what we can learn from Japanese and Chinese education. New York: Simon & Schuster.…

    • 2414 Words
    • 69 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In one the New York Times Bestseller book, The Smartest Kids in the World, after a comprehensive analysis of the world’s top education system, Amanda Ripley clearly describes the differences between the Finland’s “Utopia” model, a system built on trust in kids, highly trained and autonomous teacher, and effective school management, and South Korea’s “pressure Cooker” model, a system that demands hard works from the kids in an ultra-competitive environment which usually worned out the students. She then explain how both country score very high in the PISA, although they have different approaches. After carefully reviewing both countries’ approaches, I found the Utopia model of Finland is very intriguing and Malaysian education system is also moving slowly toward the Utopia model through the implementation of Pentaksiran Berasaskan Sekolah (PBS)…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays