Since the mother is talking about her daughter's history, it makes the story more personal, because she witnessed all of her history. The story shows how the mother viewed her child, and how her child grew up. The point of view comes from a person who truly and unconditionally loves her child, and would do anything for them. She mentions all of the grief, anger, and sadness her daughter Emily went through. The theme of the story is the bond between a mother and daughter, and it is more personal and loving because the mother explains their lives.
The narrative structure of the story is based on certain flashbacks to Emily's childhood, as her mother remembers them. This shows just how great of a love Emily's mother had for her daughter, who despite everything, still tried to do the best thing for her daughter, given the circumstances. Flashbacks give a personal view into events that happened, through a person who was there. The mother explains her anger and despair for some flashbacks, such as when her child was away at the asylum and when she was with her paternal family. The flashback of when Emily became a comedian was a happy one for her mother, who remembers the joy and excitement in her daughter during that time.
If the point of view had been different, the whole story would have been affected. If Emily's point of view had been given, then it would have been more bleak and dismal, because she was not a happy child. She would, of course, have shown even more joy than her mother when she became a comedian. If the social worker had given her point of view, it would have been impersonal and of course from an outsider, so not warm or loving at all.
The point of view and narrative structure of this story are very crucial to the comprehension of the theme and the thoughts and feelings meant to be felt by the reader. The theme is the bond of a mother and daughter, and is shown throughout the story, through flashbacks and certain areas of point of view. Change in the point of view would have ruined the affect given by this author.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
"I stand here ironing" is about a mother reflecting on the past she shared with her daughter Emily. Their life consisted of many unfortunate events beginning with Emily's father abandoning them at a very young age. The mother couldn't afford to spend much time with her to provide enough love and affection as she struggled to make ends meet. This lead Emily to have a rough childhood plagued with illness, insecurity and unhappiness. Although she had a difficult childhood, Emily blossoms into a comedic genius which puzzles the mother but also assures her that Emily will find her way in the world without assistance.…
- 1741 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
This gives the story sort of mysterious sort of view. We don't read Emily's thoughts or reasoning but of her actions. This gives the audience outside looking in point of view. The story teller also gives us the town's people reactions to the main character deeds. The story teller recounts the events in Ms. Emily's life: how her father force her first love away, trying to kept her father's dead body, and the mysterious departure of her latest beau. Not knowing all the detail grabs our attention until the end of the story. Then it let us draws our own conclusion. This not only where the stories contrast, the personalities of the main characters are vastly…
- 718 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The perspective greatly impacted the mood throughout the course of the story. Most of the story happened in the mother’s mind. Even though this doesn’t actually affect the mood of the story, the story would have never made sense without a first person perspective. Also, you can tell her emotions when she has the flashbacks, like when she tells of something she wishes she had done for Emily, you can tell she feels guilty. “What in me demanded this goodness? And what was the cost, the cost to her of such goodness” (Olsen 211). “Twice, only twice, when I had to get up for Susan anyhow, I went in to sit with her” (Olsen 212). This shows that the mother wishes she had been a better parent for Emily. This is how the perspective of the story affected the mood in the short story I Stand Here Ironing.…
- 679 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“I Stand Here Ironing” written by Tillie Olsen is a short story about a mother who has a daughter during the Great Depression, and the father leaves her to care for…
- 981 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The story begins with a woman ironing her daughters dress. It causes her to recount the life she as provided for her daughter Emily. As she considers her actions she wishes that she had done some things differently. Unfortunately, the depression era had left her with very few choices if any at all. So to survive and provide for her children the mother, abandoned by her husband, had unintentionally, not protected nor not made the best choices for Emily. Several times, during the course of Emily childhood the mother would leave her to the care of other, a few of these times for extended stays. The mother knew that some to these situations were not to Emily’s best interest but she would leave her just the same. The outcome would mold Emily into emotionally, mentally, and physically deprivation. It also caused Emily to lose the beauty she was born with which resulted in self-esteem issues. This might have been the reason for the conflict she had with her siblings, the siblings that she helped to care for who were younger than her. Even thought Emily had a low self-esteem and grow to be frail, sickly, and nonchalant, she discovered that she had talent as a comedian after winning a talent show at school. Emily became a comedian and preformed at other schools, colleges, and community fairs. With new confidence and growing in maturity Emily’s acquired a beauty all her own. The mother observed this as she completed her ironing and prepared for bed, than she wondered why she even worried at all. She figured out that even though she helplessly made mistakes along the way raising Emily, causing for many imperfections in her child whom was now nineteen, that she still had the power to reassure Emily of herself worth. She still had time to be a better mother.…
- 478 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The setting takes place during a time of struggle and hopelessness in the United States, the Great Depression of the 1930’s. The birth of Emily, in this trying time, made for a much needed contrast to the sense of despair in the air. “She was a beautiful baby. The first and only one of our five that was beautiful at birth (312).” Here, it’s apparent the joy that every first-time mother has. This effervescent sentiment only lasts for eight months, though, when Emily’s father abandons his family. For a young mother living in those times, that is devastating. Being a single-parent mother in the 1930’s was unheard of and extremely taboo. She’d be seen as an outcast and a failure to her family. In her mind, the only option was to leave Emily to her ex-husband’s family, in order to make a better living herself and her daughter. Upon Emily’s return, at the tender age of two, the mother hardly recognizes her and sees her in a new light. The baby who was once beautiful is no longer. “I hardly knew her […] All the baby loveliness gone (313).” The culmination of separation, as well as the angst and disappointment that she felt for Emily’s father has taken effect and is now transferred to her daughter. Everything about Emily, from her appearance to her walk, now reminded…
- 2099 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
While I sympathized with both Emily and the Mother, I was able to relate to Emily more. Perhaps it is because she and I are the same age and due to this I can see more of myself in her. We are both at the same stage of life where it is hard to see the big picture of things because there is so much we have not explored in the world. For Emily, her outlook and even her mother’s opinion is that Emily might not ever get the opportunity to do this because of where she came from. This is supported in the text when the Mother states, “She has much to her and probably little will come of it” (Olsen, 239). Due to this, I can see why Emily has self-doubt. Children look to their parents or the adults in their life for guidance and assurance. I am sure it was hard for Emily to have confidence in herself when those around her did not possess confidence in her. As a result of a lack of a clear support system, the wedge between mother and daughter deepened. Perhaps it became so deep that Emily felt forgotten by her…
- 1363 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
At first, seemed a very naïve and weak girl in a big scary world, with society constantly nipping at her heels, but, as she lives, she learns to take life as it comes and try her hardest to do her best. Which at that time was not an easy task. The strength and love that the mother exhibits constantly keeps the idea of hope with the reader. The character of the mother is a determining factor in her attitude towards her daughter. As her character changed, so did her feelings about Emily. In the beginning of the story, the mother talks of how sorry and regretful she is of her daughter’s childhood. She looks at her unfortunate daughter, Emily, with pity, first of all, because of her uncontrollable circumstances in society. Despite the mother’s self-incriminating thoughts, the dents in the mold of their relationship were made by the harsh circumstances of their lives.…
- 788 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The point of view of the story is a third person. The amount of information the reader knows would be somewhat that of a typical townsperson, since we do not find out right away what is really going on inside of the house, or have a deep view into Miss Emily’s feelings. From this point of view, we see things as how they would appear to a townsperson or viewer.…
- 1029 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
First, Emily is stubborn and unbalanced mentally, physically, and emotionally because of the obstacles she has undergone within her lifespan. Emily wanted to convert her per-civil war self, which was a traditional one, practiced slavery, lived in a wonderful mansion, and cared for money; as such corresponded with her father. All her life it seems that she was raised at a standard that was above the rest. By living such a secluded and controlled life it set her up for the happenings in her future.…
- 469 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In "A Rose for Emily" Faulkner begins the story with the death of Miss Emily Grierson, giving the reader the first glimpse into the main character of the story. By using an objective point of view an author turns the reader into a jury, so that the reader is able to interpret the story, and draw conclusions when given enough information. An Objective point of view is when the narrator assumes the position of an observer, detached from the narrative. Faulkner decidedly chose this point of view to intimately show how gossips think. Only from this view could we hear their negative thoughts they have of Emily. The town gives the reader an impression of our main character. “When miss Emily Grierson died, our whole town went to her funeral: the men through a sort of respectful affection for a fallen monument”(21). Emily coming from a well known popular family the town was always concerned with the family’s actions. After many generations the town began to lose hope in the family because of their attitude. With the town losing hope in the family it gives…
- 1295 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
It is through Emily’s reflection and review of her life that allows us to see how age has not withered Emily. No matter what events have happened over the years, may it be the death of her son or the death of her husband, Emily stands strong and is undefeated by them. She tells herself bravely, “It’s all over now. It’s all past, it can’t be changed…” and still continues to look forward to living. The death of these two people in her life did not make her cling incessantly to the people around her, in fear of losing them. Instead, age and experience has taught her to let go of some things in life, one of which is her daughter, Doris, who was supposed to stay with her at Emerald Hill. This time, Emily’s willingness to let go and allow the children to make their own choices paid off. She was able to maintain a good relationship with her only daughter and is satisfied to know that Doris is living happily in America. Her willingness to let go also brought her closer to her remaining 3 children, who are willing to come back to Emerald Hill to visit her frequently with her grandchildren even though all of them moved away. Towards the end of the…
- 1803 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
2. What does the title of the story suggest about the townspeople’s feelings toward Miss Emily? Why do they feel this way about her? (Or: What does she represent to them?) Is there anything ironic about their feelings?…
- 349 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the short story “A Rose for Emily” there is a unique type of narration used to show the events that take place in Miss Emily’s lifetime. Throughout the story the narrator bases their narration on a “we” perspective as though speaking for all of the townspeople. This is necessary in order to get the same feeling that you get throughout the story with all of the facts provided. By using the perspective of all the townspeople, the narrator creates a feeling where the reader knows what everyone in the town is thinking of Miss Emily and how they depict everything that is happening in her life. All of the town gossip and such is presented through the narration.…
- 1519 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Miss Emily finds herself to be very alone after the death of her father and is willing to do what she has to do to keep someone she loves in her life. In the beginning of the story Faulkner writes that after Miss Emily loses the two sweethearts of her life she is seen very rarely. This showing that Miss Emily was lost because her two loves were gone. After her fathers death the women and minister call the house to send their condolences and Miss Emily refuses to believe that her father has past away. She kept claiming that " her father was not dead (104)." Three days after Miss Emily's father passes on she finally broke down and let them dispose of the body. Miss Emily didn't want to accept the fact that her father had past on because she was so close to him and he was all she had.…
- 857 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays