Choose a partner with whom to work. Discuss each question, finding specific evidence from the text that supports your response. Write thoughtful notes on your responses and the evidence (please cite all examples by paragraph #).
1. How does Swift portray himself throughout the essay? In what places does he reveal an egotistical persona? (tone, attitude)
2. How does Swift dehumanize the people in this essay? What is his purpose in doing so?
3. How does Swift make himself appear to be an expert? (ethical appeal)
4. Why does Swift focus on the benefits of his plan before giving us the details of it? (organization)
5. What point is Swift trying to make about landlords in paragraph 12? (diction)
6. What can you infer about the social and political conditions in Ireland from the essay?
7. How does Swift ironically criticize Catholicism in paragraph 21?
8. Paragraphs 21-28 detail the advantages of Swift’s proposal. What criticisms of society are implied in these paragraphs?
9. Does Swift hold out any hope that Ireland will be able to save itself without resorting to his “modest” proposal? Hint: reread paragraphs 29-30. What does Swift really want the Irish to do?
10. Reread the final paragraph. What is ironic about Swift’s comment about his own family?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In his renowned pamphlet, “A Modest Proposal,” Jonathan Swift brings attention to the poor conditions in Ireland. Being a native of Ireland, Swift remained loyal to his country. Upon noticing the terrible conditions in Ireland, he took it upon himself to address the issues at hand. Among these issues, involves the sickly and insufficient children in his homeland. Incorporating statistics to support his claim, Swift attempts to persuade his readers to support his outrageous plan to solve a dire situation. As a result his “logical” and preposterous plan created mixed reactions in both the past and the present.…
- 98 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Swift wrote his proposal for those that were tired of looking at poor children of Ireland. He starts out explaining the situation in Ireland regarding single poor mothers that have three to six children and can not afford to feed or clothe them. The children of the poor are a burden and a disgrace for Ireland. He suggests that a certain number of the kids be set aside for breeding and the rest be auctioned off for consumption when they reach a year old. Swift backs his proposal with six key points. One, there will be a reduction of "papists" in the country. Two, the poor will have some valuable assets to help them with their economic needs. Three, the new goods will burst economy. Four, the parent/s will gain money and will not have to support their children year after year. Five, "would bring great custom to taverns." Six, there would be a greater incentive to marry and better child rearing practices.…
- 692 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In “A Modest Proposal”, Jonathan Swift reaches out to the readers about social problems that the great town and county are going through. I believe Swift is trying to tell the readers in a satirical way that the government and political party are not doing anything in the country to solve the social problems. Swift believed the only way to catch their attention was to write the essay “A Modest Proposal”. Swift used satire in his essay to inform people of Ireland how high poverty, hunger, and death rates were not getting any help from the government.…
- 449 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The tone of this essay by swift is ironic because he talking about his proposed plan to eat baby’s.…
- 725 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In order for me to accept the validity of Mr. Swift’s sudden change in opinion I had to re-read this article and noticed where he made statement of “I am not so violently bent upon my own opinion as to reject any offer proposed by wise men, which shall be found equally innocent, cheap, easy…
- 403 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
One way Swift is able to encourage the reader that the persona he creates is a creditable source he attempts to convince the reader that his persona is a worthy person of his country. He appeals to…
- 330 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Taking on the persona of an intellectual economist, Swift attacks England for their ignorance, criticizes the Irish for their submissive ways, and on a deeper level, censures the reader who embodies all that disregard the cruelties of the world.…
- 1309 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
1. The persona in which Swift adopts for the modest proposal is that of someone concerned for the greater good of the land, Ireland, on the very outskirt of reading. Although as one dives into this proposal, they become bombarded with irrational means of dealing with this assumed problem; the plentiful source of beggars in Ireland. One becomes consumed with disgust yet intrigued by its soundness in reasoning. Swift creates a tone that juxtaposes its message, which further confuses the reader in his irrational yet balanced argument. On one hand he seems psychotic, on the other he appears to be a profound visionary.…
- 549 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
He wrote about how the British are controlling every aspect of their lives with no moral obligation. Swift uses the literary devices to help “stir the pot” for those who end up reading the critique. He uses the idea of satire to almost make fun of the poverty that was going on in Ireland. He makes a statement regarding children that is quite outrageous and disgusting. He talks about an american friend that told him a child is “most delicious, nourishing and wholesome food”. (Swift) He continues to speak about how you can beef them up to make them bigger and more nutritious before you kill them and eat them. “and in a solar year if tolerably nursed increaseth to twenty-eight pounds” (Swift). He recommends this to anyone who is struggling for money and needs to do something about it. “I grant this food will be somewhat dear, and therefore very proper for landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the parents, seem to have the best title to the children” (Swift). This statement is satirical but even more controversial. It was not typical for something satirical of this nature to be out there at this time and this created quite a reaction, which most authors love. We can compare how Swift looks at the poor to how we look at the poor and hey contradict each other. He looks down at them, cracks jokes at them, speaks poorly of the poor while most of the…
- 1051 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In Jonathan Swift 'sA Modest Proposal, the tone of a Juvenalian satire is evident in its text. Swift uses the title of his essay to begin his perfect example of a Juvenalian satire. Swift gives a moral justification to the dehumanization of the Irish and attempts to provide 'logical ' solutions to their problems. Despite Swift 's use of belittling language towards the Irish, he uses positive strategy to make his true point known. Swift declares children as the underlying cause of the parents ' inability to obtain a successful occupation. Swift 's scornful disregard for infants is one ploy in attracting the attention of the population. Swift uses a rhetorical style that causes the reader to loathe the narrator, who is depicted as a member of…
- 1334 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
nothing, during a time of famine, to help the Irish people. Swift’s proposal has six main…
- 704 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Although, Swift presents his arguments in this essay his overall purpose is to not persuade the reader into agreeing with him, instead his purpose is to entertain his audience through the use of satire. His proposal to kill and eat newborn children sounds so incredibly morbid and wrong that the reader will not be able to take Swift’s arguments seriously. For example, at the beginning of this essay he talks about a beggar’s lifestyle…
- 488 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
One of Jonathon Swift’s most famous works, “A Modest Proposal” needs to be read after the reader gets a little familiar with Swift himself and why he wrote it. Once you realize the situation and the author’s unique writing ability and thought process the proposal seems a little less farfetched and less sickening. I am in no way in agreement with the proposal just more understanding of where it came from and why he did it. The meaning of the proposal takes a major hit when the situation at hand takes a twist from Swift’s personal situation.…
- 422 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The author seems to start off the poem with a generalized essay format, but as the work progresses the format becomes redundant. He then moves on to the body paragraphs where he talks about the conditions in which people are living and then he goes on to introducing his modest proposal. This gave the people an idea on how to deal with the suffering they were encountering with their children. While the proposal tried fixing various problems it in turn also degraded women at the same time. Swift’s focus was to make their children less of a burden on them, and more useful to the public and the country. Swift’s goal was to gather the underprivileged children and ship them off to rich landowners who could afford…
- 1388 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
SWIFT HAS SOMETIMES BEEN seen as a champion of liberty. In his essay ‘Politics vs Literature’, however, George Orwell took a different view. ‘Swift,’ he wrote, ‘was one of those people who are driven into a sort of perverse Toryism by the follies of the progressive party of the moment.’ At best Swift was ‘a Tory Anarchist, despising authority while disbelieving in liberty.’ At worst he was a reactionary, opposed not simply to sham science, but to all science, and even to intellectual curiosity itself. Orwell also portrays Swift as a hater of the human body and an authoritarian. ‘In a political and moral sense,’ writes Orwell, ‘I am against him, so far as I understand him.’ Yet no sooner has he written these words than he goes on to declare that Swift ‘is one of the writers I admire with least reserve’.[1]…
- 644 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays