Preview

A Critique of "Who Needs College?"

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
748 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Critique of "Who Needs College?"
Meaghan O’Hare
Professor Haytham Mahfoud
LIBS-3003-02
September 22, 2013
A Critique of “Who Needs College?”

In her essay “Who Needs College?” Linda Lee addresses the issue of whether or not a college education is necessary in order to have a successful life. Lee believes that too much importance is placed on going away to school and getting a degree when it is very possible to find a job and learn valuable life lessons without it. While many would strongly oppose her position on this topic, it has been proven time and time again by numerous individuals that a bright future is well within reach without having to obtain a degree.

Going to college is considered to be one of the most important parts of a person’s adult life. Lee focuses on this unnecessary pedestal that the college experience is put on. Kids treat it as an excuse to party and do not place the same level of importance on it as their parents do. Lee had this realization with her own son when she thought about how she was “paying $1,000 a week for this pleasure cruise” (52). This lead her to pull her son out of school until he was ready to go back and be serious or find a job to occupy his time more efficiently. Her son went on to have many different jobs. They were not the most glamorous, but taught him independence and how to be responsible with his own money. Lee argues that this life path got her son to a fulfilling place where he was enjoying what he was doing and had found a good job where a promotion was in his near future (2). This end result is typically why students go through college in the first place.

Throughout the essay, Lee uses multiple statistics in order to back up her position. This is useful because it helps the reader understand that the point being made is a valid one.
Lee goes on to make references to people ranging from her hair colorist all the way to Bill Gates to prove that a degree is not necessary to go places in life (52). It is helpful that she also



Cited: Lee, Linda. “Who Needs College?” Perspectives on Contemporary Issues: Readings Across the Disciplines. 4th ed. Ed. Katherine Anne Ackley, Boston: Wadsworth/ Gengage Learning, 2005. 51-52. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Marty Nemko’s article, “We Send Too Many Students to College,” he analyzes and questions whether college is truly worth the money. Marty “holds a Ph.D. specializing in the evaluation of education from the University of California, Berkeley, and subsequently taught there” (martynemko.com) as well as published five successful books. In addition to his novels, he previously was a columnist at San Francisco Chronical and The Atlantic Monthly, also a contributing editor at several other well-known companies. Nemko’s purpose is to convey the idea that, even though there may be reasons one would attend college, the complications overshadow the benefits. He adopts an impassionate tone in order to convince his adult audience to take a hard look at whether it is worthwhile for their children to attend college.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    College education essentially is the key to success in the future. It opens many doors of opportunity and allows us to explore every option available. It is common for students in high school to wonder if college education is really important. Many high school students don’t enjoy their school life, so it is little wonder that when they have the chance to leave education many of them are tempted. However the importance of college education, as well as the huge differences to high school, should not be overlooked. College education can provide a student with many more new and exciting opportunities that they never would have had if they drop out at high school. College education is important because you need a degree in order to get a good job or a stable career. I’d like to talk of some of the benefits that furthering your education can provide, and as well as the joy it can bring to each and every one of us.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “College Isn’t For Every One” W.J. Reeves argues that half of the students going to a four-year college should not be there. Reeves states that some of the reasons for this is because colleges have open additions it lets just anyone get in to their school even if they do not deserve to be their . Reeves other reasons are that the students just don’t care anymore whether it’s just reading the class book or as easy as showing up to class but they don’t so they must not care. He also blames the schools for grade inflation since the students are not doing good .They lower the bar to make them seem like their doing ok. The solutions Reeves gives us are stricter entry’s in to college to weed out the ones that really don’t want to be there. The other ones are in high school sign up for trade classes or instead of a four-year college some teens need to look in to a two-year school.…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In America higher education has become an expectation of high school teachers, advisors, and parents for students to obtain a successful life and prosper in their field of study, no matter the conditions, after graduating high school. In this article, “Are Too Many People Going to College,” written by Charles Murray, he feels that not everyone is meant to earn a college degree, even though society thinks otherwise.…

    • 593 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lee described how her child grew up and “graduated” on time (par. 14). In her motherly aspect, this is positive; however, kids grow to be mature at different rates and the further mature kids do have an easier time succeeding in college. The mature college kids do not think of college as a time to beige drink, oversleep, or drive recklessly as individuals may label the college experience (par 10).…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Larry Cuban, a former social studies high school teacher, superintendent, manages to compress the mantra that has been repeated for several of years with his article entitled, “Why Everyone Shouldn’t Go To College”. He accomplishes this by giving us countless of interesting facts about the reality of college and life. He argues that the annual college tuition seems to be extremely expensive, that may not worth the amount of money you’re paying.In addition, he makes note that college graduates working at manufacturing places that don’t need college diplomas, in order to complete their job. Furthermore, he makes clear that one might be a high school dropout or graduate of high school and can still be highly…

    • 117 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, focusing on college earnings Owens and Sawhill state, “Someone working a STEM job (science, technology, engineering, and math), with only a high school diploma can expect to make more over a lifetime than someone with a bachelor’s degree working in education, community service and arts, sales and office work, health support, blue collar jobs, or personal services” (Owen & Sawhill, 2013). Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill talk a lot about the benefits of having a science, technology, engineering, or mathematics career, but also how beneficial it can be to pursue in a higher education socially and mentally.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Getting an education, nowadays, seems to be an option rather than a need. After graduating high school, most students ask themselves: “Why should I attend college”? Some of them argue that continuing their education is not necessary to achieve economic stability; however, is it all about how economically stable a person is? Michelle Obama certainly knows the answer. At “Bowie State University Commencement Speech” Obama reminded all her audience the importance of getting an education to help build a brighter future for our communities as well as next generations.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine if every student made it to college. Jobs would be plentiful, homeless folks would become less in numbers, and the acceptance rates for jobs would be much higher. Now, consider this. From ages twenty-five to thirty-two, twenty-two percent with a diploma from high school are living in poverty, in comparison to six percent of college-educated adults, today (“The Rising Cost of Not Going to College”). This is a real problem in today’s nation, but can be prevented. Students not only have better chances of getting a job from receiving a college education, rather than just a high school diploma, but their average yearly pay is also much higher. A college education is a necessity to students in our nation, because of increased chances of being accepted to jobs of your choice and background, and receiving a much higher annual pay.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I Beat The Odds Analysis

    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages

    This assemblage of data provided a partial explanation as to why college is such a rude awakening for many students. Until that threshold in life, many students have been pampered until the mere mention of work sends a message of premonition. That rude awakening, nonetheless, would be much preferred for children living in the circumstances of Michael Oher in I Beat the Odds. In their augmenting years, values of work and determination were deeply instilled. Not particularly those of schoolwork, unfortunately, because many had absent parents not too concerned with the upbringing of their children. Rather, life on the streets grew values of dedication to oneself and their intended destination in…

    • 1815 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    College is optional. Linda has good points on why you shouldn’t go to college, but it’s the student’s choice to go or not to go. She is suggesting to students that there are the same or more opportunities without a college degree, than there is for students without a degree, which is not correct in most cases.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    For WP3, I am planning to research and synthesize the perspectives on the value of a college education. In the core reading “The Story of an Hour”, by Kate Chopin, Mrs. Mallard is tired of being a housewife and is longing for more, like a college education or career. With this in mind, I plan to research the value of a college education and the many perspectives on it. I also plan to provide information on why so many college graduates are unemployed. I believe this issue is in relation to my core reading because so many people are longing for more, like a college education. While prices of colleges are skyrocketing, many college…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    essay

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this article, I read about the reason why teenagers want to attend college. According to the students, “The primary reason for going to college is to get training and skills that will lead to a job, and let them make money”. I also learned how white and black college students differ and how they handle everyday life situations. The passage also states how mothers handle the concerns of their kids when they go off to college.…

    • 402 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ENG 125 Week 4 DQ 2

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There can be no denying the importance of a college education for countless individuals. H...…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    She raises questions as: "Are teenagers today prepared for life after school?" The school system and parents should be working together to raise educated students. Schools should be accountable for instructing students to be knowledgeable about the world around them. It should be a joint effort between parent and educator to train the next generation of children to be independent and prepared for the real life. One of the topics discussed is whether university student would be able to handle the sense of responsibility and maturity that comes from having a job. When someone puts their head down to achieve their goals by themselves, as an independent adult, their outcome will reflect what they learned in both college and "real life school". Similarly the Northeastern University economists Paul E. Harrington and Andrew M. Sum argue the most pressing problem facing the university graduates today: overeducation on one hand and malemployment on the other. The reality is that more and more college graduates are stuck in low wage and low skilled jobs. Also, this article contains an example of a certain graduate student S.F. who got a degree in Network and information-technology administration, and after he couldn’t find a job, the Eastern Michigan University gave him a job as a custodian in the student center. This very example makes us consider the value of the university degree and ask ourselves whether the degree is really needed in order to become successful and financially stable in the future or it is just a way to manipulate the hard working students and make business based on their effort and hard…

    • 741 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays