Preview

A Comparison: Hull House in the 1890's and Putting on Style

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1680 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Comparison: Hull House in the 1890's and Putting on Style
“Hull House in the 1890’s” and “Putting on Style” demonstrate and explain two very different yet very important parts of American female history. While “Hull House in the 1890’s” shows the struggles and efforts made by women in order to break down barriers and gain political power in a male dominant political society, “Putting on Style” portrays the rebellious and socially changing world of female adolescents. Though “Hull House in the 1890’s” and “Putting on style” come from opposing views of reform movement and social evolution respectively, both of the articles depict two incredibly important changes that have helped shape the female role in American society today.
Each article had a completely different center of focus. While “Hull House in the 1890’s” theme was how women’s political power in America began to change, what women did with that power, and how the hull house was a large factor in them gaining this barrier breaking power, the theme of “Putting on Style” reflected the change in economic and social aspects of the newly established adolescent age of life. Though both themes were incredibly different, they did share a theme of independence and autonomy. Sklar focuses on the autonomy of strong women fighting for access to politics who are trying to prove to American society that they’re opinions are important and should be heard. Peiss, on the other hand, showed autonomy in a completely different aspect. Rather than already having that independence, Peiss spoke of how young women were fighting for their social independence and autonomy, but instead of fighting the American society, as did Florence Kelley and her followers in “Hull House of the 1890’s”, they were fighting their parents.
Another major difference in themes of these two articles is unity and division amongst social classes. In “Hull House of the 1890’s” Sklar speaks of how through the Hull House, women of all sorts of social classes came together to unite and support one another.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Contains a thesis that addresses the changing ideals of American womanhood between the American Revolution and the Civil War and addresses the extent to which these ideals influenced the lives of women.…

    • 470 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the ages women have been stricken with often male-made oppression in many forms on the long, difficult road to their eventual initiation into equal rights. Some aspects of women’s rights today were obtained by questionable means in the past. One such act of liberation by questionable means was the introduction of a class of women in the 1920s known as flappers. These flappers were the beginning of a new wave of sexually and intellectually liberated women. Women of this age wore short skirts and revealing clothing in addition to cutting their hair into bobs and smoking and drinking publicly. These women were also outspoken in many areas, including matters of art, society, and politics. (“The changing values of a new generation”)…

    • 948 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The “New Woman” concept that was growing in the 1880’s was a new advancement in the battle for women gaining respect and notoriety in America, the New Woman “agitated for suffrage and reform, pursued higher education, and made modest gains in the professional world.” (pg.374) This wasn’t the only type of reform women were also beginning to delve into athletic activity such as riding bicycles, or shopping in department stores (which was perceived as tiring) and playing golf, reshaping what was considered appropriate behavior for women. The new woman came to fame first through negative recognition, “Critics insisted that voting, higher education, and athletic endeavors would damage women’s health and undermine their femininity and that professional women’s work and increased personal freedoms would harm the middle-class family ideal.” (pg. 374) Most of these critics broadcast there opinion through illustration, depicting these new professional women to be the aggressors and appear manly in size and structure in satirical cartoons, completely flipping the ideal family structure around. Some critics viewed the new woman’s persona and body to be physically attractive, portraying them as beautiful and statuesque such as the famous Charles Dana Gibson who became an icon for new women as a symbol of the new age of American femininity emerging. Charles Dana Gibson otherwise known as The Gibson girl, portrayed as “independent, athletic, educated and confident.” (pg.375) The Gibson girl gained popularity quickly and appeared on more than just ring media, she appeared on jewelry, calendars and even had her clothing and hairstyle imitated across the nation by multiple social classes and races. The Gibson girl was a seductress, using her…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hollitz Chapter 11

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages

    1. The first essay clearly shows the impact that an ideology of domesticity on women in New England in the 1830’s. The writer at first calls this time period a “paradox in the “progress” of women’s history in the United States”. During this time apparently two contradictory views on women’s relations to society clashed, unusually, those two being domesticity, which essentially limited women, giving them a “sex-specific” role that they must abide to, this mostly being present at the home with their husbands and whatever kids they may or may not have had at that time, and feminism, which essentially tried to remove this domesticity, trying to remove sex-specific limits on women’s opportunities and capacities, trying to get them an increased role in society, not be defined to the home, and not have any limits on what they could do, and most of all be equal to men. This is because in New England, women were victims who were subjects of the painful subordination that came as an add-on with marriage during this period, as well as in society. They also experienced a huge disadvantage in education and in the economy, as well as the denial of their access to official power in their own churches, and impotence in politics. Essentially, the wife at this time, was defined by her husband, and she in no way, shape, or form could have a role that was more significant than her husband, let alone even as much as her husband in the societies that were present, and that they were a part of during this time period, best demonstrated by New England in 1835. She couldn’t sue, contract, or execute a will on her own, and divorce may have been possible, but quite rare. In fact, the public life of women was just about minimal, and none of them voted. Looking back, it was actually worse then than in 1770, as thanks to universal white male suffrage that was present during this period, their roles in society became heavily conspicuous, and in the…

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    1920's Flappers

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As men left to fight in the Great War in the late 1910's, women in the U.S. and all over Europe found themselves necessary to make the homefront function, i.e. women had to fill the holes in industry and social life that the absence of men created for them. It is at this time that the flapper appears; a new kind of woman with short, bobbed hair, shorter skirts and freer clothes to match her new, freer lifestyle. It is no wonder that the vote was given to women during this time, as the idea of gender equality became a reality in its necessity.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jane Addams was undoubtedly one of the most influential and prominent female figures in the United States in the late 1800s and early 1900s. She single handedly changed the face of social reform among poor immigrants living in Chicago during this time period, and was also regarded as a catalyst for influencing positive community relationships between the poor and the wealthy. Although she was the centerpiece of numerous other reforms during this time, her progressive-era ideals on social reform policies and arguments over immigration, labor unions, women’s rights, Americanization, and government regulations revolving around the Hull House in Chicago may stand out most prominently. Addams consistently argued about themes ranging from women’s reforms and women’s activism, to immigrant workforce conditions and violent crimes of the settlement houses. But her agenda on Americanization and integration of the poor immigrants living in the Hull House were the most highly debated and critiqued, as many of these settlement housing programs encouraged and favored Americanization and integration among its residents, essentially squashing the “old world” cultures of the immigrants. But Addams’s settlement house, Hull House, had a much different approach regarding Americanization, integration, and the immigrant’s cultural background. The Hull House was not a medium for Americanization amongst the immigrants, but rather laid a foundation to encourage the immigrants to embrace and conserve their cultures.…

    • 1762 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Separate Spheres

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout the 1700’s, men and women were confined to culturally predefined spheres of responsibility. “A woman’s place is in the home” was the prevailing opinion in America under the Separate Spheres ideology during the eighteenth century. Women were thought to be biologically inclined to excel in the domestic sphere of childrearing and homemaking while men were thought to be biologically inclined to excel in the public sphere of economics and politics. Some early feminist pioneers like Abigail Adams and Mary Wollstonecraft were the first feminists to test the boundaries. Women were not content to be relegated solely to the domestic sphere and under the guidance of pioneers such as Adams and Wollstonecraft began to challenge the idea of Separate Spheres and start an eventual merging of those spheres.…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Kyvig supports his topics with specific events such as the birth of the automobile, the welcoming of women into the political world, and the mass numbers of immigration that flourished the country. He goes in depth on how automobiles changed Americas take on life inside and out of factories and states that, “In 1920 barely one household in three possessed a car, though this represented a dramatic increase from one in thirteen at the outset of World War I. Automobile ownership tripled during the 1920s, and by decade’s end four families in five owned one” (Kyvig p.27). He recognizes and promotes the welcoming of women into the political world to surge democracy and better the economy as stated in the text, “The establishment of national prohibition and woman suffrage at the very outset of the 1920s created a strong sense that the new decade marked a fresh beginning for American society” (Kyvig p.6). He also speaks of the multitudes of immigrants that flourished the country and characterized the states to be a “Melting Pot” of cultures. All of these components helped to create the American Dream that each and every citizen strives to attain. Kyvig does a spectacular job in educating his audience in events like these and many more throughout the book.…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In American history, women have had a profound role. Whether it was the lack of freedom or the excessiveness of their decisions, women have shaped what America has become and what it will continue to grow into. Daphne Spain explains in her article entitled “Women’s Rights and Gendered Spaces in 1970s Boston,” how “During the 1970s feminists in Boston declared their rights to their own bodies by establishing women's health clinics and domestic violence shelters. In doing so, they wrote a modern chapter in the distinguished history about how women have shaped the city. Almost one hundred years earlier, in 1877, the Women's Educational and Industrial Union opened on Boylston Street as a center to promote women's intellectual and economic independence.' Elite and middle-class women of the era also sought a role in urban politics. (Spain, 1)” This seems ironic due to current politics, but aside from that, there have been women’s rights movements for centuries to protect. However, as…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Take a close look and notice how society has changed in the last century. One hundred years ago, women were not able to vote, obtain proper education, or even speak up for themselves. In today’s society, things are quite the contrary, women are going to college more than men and we even had a woman run for president. In Susan Glaspell’s short story “A Jury of Her Peers,” she illustrates the constant struggle for women in the nineteenth century and how women as a whole were underrepresented. Glaspell wants the reader to see how confined some women in the nineteenth century were in their traditional gender roles.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from…

    • 36856 Words
    • 130 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender Socialization

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Sapiro, Virginia. (1999). Women in American Society: an introduction to women’s studies (5th ed.) New York: Mc Graw-Hill.…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender roles in America throughout the 1900s have arguably undergone their most drastic shifts than any other century. While a shift in a mindset that focused more in equality was marked by the passage of women’s suffrage in 1920, the Popular Front movement that occurred from 1890 through 1934 and amid the Great Depression was an often overlooked, although an important, turning point for civil rights as a whole. With the start of the World War II in 1939 and men fighting overseas, the economic stimulus of wartime created jobs for women while men fought overseas. What was it that gave these women the power and courage to stand up for what they thought was right? How did they begin to transform what most considered a perfectly expectable part of society? By looking at writings, photos, and other works by prominent progressive women over the last century, we can get a real perspective on how gender roles have come so far. This paper aims at discovering how gender roles have progressed, what changed them, and who the main proponents of this change were. While social and economic pressures clearly set the path for changing gender roles, discontentment among women with their social status and the push by particular women from the ground up within the greater context of a civil rights overhaul set the precedent for a more equal America and shifting gender roles.…

    • 5251 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Dolls House

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    How would you like to live in a society in which you were subjected to live for a man and not yourself. A Doll's House by Henrik Ibsen tells the story of Nora a wealthy woman and the struggles she as well as the other female characters in a male dominant society face because of their gender. In this essay I will discuss how the women in Ibsen's society scarifies themselves in order to remain in there gender roles.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Let’s start with the beginning. In the opening of the book the authors express the reasons for writing this book. First, they tried to fix the previous history that contained little if any records of women in the factories. The others are to show how the incorporating of women in industrial work went. To fully grasp this they needed to show how men and women coped while working alongside one another and annotate their differences in ideals. Something unique about this book is that all the essays use verbatim, the spoken words of those women who work in the factories day in and day out. These essays coming from these industrialized women push into new terrain as women, for the first time show how their sexualized worlds mold their way of thinking. And again, coming from the women themselves.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays