Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

William Bradford versus John Winthrop

Good Essays
1307 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
William Bradford versus John Winthrop
1. William Bradford (1590-1657) was one of the leaders of colonial America. Bradford arrived at Cape Cod on November 11, 1620, on the flagship Mayflower. He was one of the authors of The Mayflower Compact. His greatest contribution to early writing is his History of Plymouth Plantation, 1620-1647. Bradford and Winthrop both demonstrate an exegetical habit of mind. In their different ways, both Bradford and Winthrop and Bradford demonstrate that the Puritans see themselves creating a new center in the New World, from which their values would radiate outward.

William Bradford 's history of the Pilgrims, in Of Plymouth Plantation, sheds a uniquely different light on life in colonial New England. Bradford 's account depicts many hardships that had to be overcome by the Pilgrims, before their ideal land began to take shape. Bradford describes arriving in New England in the late fall as fatal for many of the Pilgrims. The first winter took its toll on the colonists. Forced to live on the boat, many people died of scurvy or starved. When they finally were able to stay on land, they found the Indians less than sociable, and the land too rugged to develop large farms. The Pilgrims kept their faith though, and with time, the Lord blessed them. They made a pact with the Indians, learned how to grow native crops, and developed industries. William Bradford believed that God helped them through His bountiful grace, and turned the New England wilderness into a Heavenly Paradise. Some factors that will be considered include: how Puritan beliefs affect William Bradford 's interpretation of events, the representation of Puritan theology in the above mentioned text, and how Puritanism forms the basis for Bradford 's motivation in writing.

In Bradford 's text, there are numerous instances in which his beliefs affect his interpretation of what happens. In Chapter IX (nine) of "Of Plymouth Plantation", entitled "Of Their Voyage...", Bradford tells of another ship passenger named John Howland. At one point in the trip, the Mayflower came upon a violent storm. The winds of the storm were so fierce, and the seas were so high, that all the sailors and passengers had to "hull for divers days together". During this storm, a young man named John Howland was thrown into the sea, and as Bradford tells us, "it pleased God that he caught hold of the topsail halyards which hung overboard and ran out at length". Howland

caught hold of a rope, and "though he was sundry fathoms under water", he held on until he was hauled up. Bradford reasons that the man was saved because he was blessed by God. He goes on to say that he "became a profitable member in both church and state, implying that John Howland was one of the so called "Puritan Saints". To the Puritans, Saints were people whom God was to save, so these people received God's blessings, and

therefore were profitable in Puritan society Representation of Puritan theology is also heavily prevalent in Bradford 's "Of Plymouth Plantation".

Included in Bradford 's writing are numerous Bible quotes, and praises to God for anything going right during the Puritans voyage. In the chapter called "On Their Voyage...", Bradford tells of the condition of their ship. Due to the number of storms encountered during the voyage, "the ship was shroudly shaken, and her upper works made very leaky; and one of the main beams in the midships was bowed and cracked, which put them in some fear that the ship could not be able to perform the voyage." After much consideration by the mariners, they decided to continue on with the voyage, rather than turning back to England. As Bradford put it, "So they committed themselves to the will of God and resolved to proceed." Also in the same section, after they landed "they fell upon their knees, and blessed the God of Heaven who had brought them over the vast and furious ocean, and delivered them from...."

Throughout the whole piece, there is much praise for God, and numerous bible quotes from Bradford. Many of the reasons for Bradford writing "Of Plymouth Plantation" stems from his Puritan beliefs. For one, he wanted to establish a link between his Mayflower group (the group that traveled over the sea), and all future groups of Puritans. Right at the end of Chapter IX ("On TheirVoyage..."), right at the end of the section, Bradford gives us a speech. He begins, "May not ought the children of these fathers rightly say ". Our fathers were Englishmen which came over this great ocean, and were ready to perish in this wilderness; but they cried unto the Lord, and He heard their

voices and looked on their adversity" etc. Let them therefore praise the Lord." He wanted to show that what his group did was "great". They endured the persecution of the Anglicans in England, and then sailed over an ocean to an untamed land, and established a colony.

Bradford 's story is one of hardship; the kind of hardship that the Puritans believe shows God is testing them. Bradford wants the future Puritans to never forget the hardships that his group had to endure. Bradford has a sense that what his first group of Puritans did was grand, and thus he wants to justify the acts of his group. Bradford also wants to quell any questions or fears that any investors might have had.

Bradford 's Puritan background influences a great deal of "Of Plymouth Plantation". His beliefs sometimes affect his interpretation of events, as in his telling us of Thomas Morton. His Puritan beliefs also form the basis of the purpose of his writing. Still, Bradford manages to accomplish a great deal in this writing. He does immortalize the struggles of his Puritan camp at Plymouth, and he does a good job of accurately

depicting the events during those same struggles.

2. John Winthrop (1588-1649)

One of the founders of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, Winthrop arrived in 1630 aboard the flagship Arbella. As governor of the Colony, he established the center of government at Boston. Winthrop began writing his Journal in 1630 and continued it till his death. On board the Arbella, he prepared his famous sermon "A Model of Christian Charity."

While en route to the New World on board the Arabella, John Winthrop wrote a sermon entitled "A Model of Christian Charity,"(The Norton anthology, 107) in which he outlined the purposes of God for New England. Winthrop had a deep understanding of God's divine purposes for the colony. "We shall be a city set on a hill," he said of Boston - where the church was the center of life during those early years of the city's history. He described a harmonious Christian community whose laws and government would logically proceed from a godly and purposeful arrangement.

John Winthrop also believed that this new form of government would help bring about a "Golden Age" and that one day all the nations of the world would copy this form of government: "We shall find that the God of Israel shall be among us, when ten of us shall be able to resist a thousand of our enemies; when He shall make us a praise and glory that men shall say of succeeding plantations, 'the Lord make it like that of New England.'"

But Winthrop also gave a warning: "The eyes of all people are upon us, so that if we deal falsely with our God in this work we have undertaken, and so cause us to withdraw His present help from us, we shall be made a story and a byword through the world."

Winthrop set out clearly the revealed purposes of God and warned that the success or failure of their endeavors would depend on their dedication to the ideal of selfless community. History shows us that this ideal was never realized, however, Winthrop laid the foundation for generations yet to come.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Of Plymouth Plantation” by William Bradford is history about the founding of the Massachusetts Bay Colony and the lives of the Puritan colonists. He was a Puritan who sailed to Plymouth. He began to attend meetings of small group of Nonconformists and later, he joined them. The Nonconformists sailed to find land where they can be free to worship and live according to their own beliefs. After several years, William Bradford became governor of Plymouth Colony, and he was elected as a governor at least thirty times. During the sailing, and after arrived at Plymouth, there were several conflicts shown as internal and external.…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During a time period of religious intolerance in England many people sought acceptance of their beliefs. In the early 1600’s a group of English emigrants, led by John Winthrop set to further purify the Christian faith. These colonists came to be known as the Puritans and settled the Massachusetts Bay Colony, with the help of Winthrop as a leader. Winthrop acted as an astounding governor for these settlers during the early years. He also had a unique view on how a nation should be organized. All of Winthrop’s principles were based on his writings in, “A Model of Christian Charity”. The overriding concept of his was that Puritans should act as if they were a “city upon a hill”. Because of the Puritans’ advancements in education and other things, they were able to set a good example and successfully create John Winthrop's ideal of a "city upon a hill" that has carried a lasting impression into the modern world.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In America’s initial founding, the two of the most vocal groups were the Pilgrims and Puritans. Within these two groups, William Bradford and John Winthrop are both recognized as authors that helped shape the American literary traditions. Bradford was raised in a radical nonconforming Protestant of rural northern England which was where he earned his allegiance and whom he accompanied on their exile out in the lowlands early in the 17th century. As a Pilgrim, his most famous work was “Of Plymouth Plantation”.…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Of Plymouth Plantation was written from 1620 until 1647 by William Bradford. Bradford addresses in his writing some of the frustrations that the Pilgrims along with the Puritans went through on their voyage to the new world. These people were put through such miserable conditions and the author delineates this in his writing. He also displays a persistent theme, which is God is there for the ones who need him. This helps with showing the purpose of William Bradford’s writing. Although there may be hard times ahead or there are currently some kind of conflicts God is always there for the ones that look to him for guidance. Bradford wants people who need direction to read his writing and know that just like the Pilgrims and Puritans God is…

    • 137 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 17th Century Of Plymouth Plantation was about the pilgrims coming to Early America’s land. The Pilgrims were “On a dangerous voyage across the ocean.” they also had a person on the ship that died, “William Butten died from the harshness of the voyage.” When they…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The American Dream

    • 3069 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Kelso, Dorothy H. "William Bradford." The Pilgrim Society. 18 May 2005. Web. 22 Nov. 2010.…

    • 3069 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    William Bradford

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages

    William Bradford's most well-known work by far is Of Plymouth Plantation. It was a detailed history in manuscript form about the founding of the Plymouth colony and the lives of the colonists from 1621 to 1646.[46] It is a common misconception that the manuscript was actually Bradford's journal. Rather, it was a retrospective account of his recollections and observations, written in the form of two books. The first book was written in 1630; the second was never finished, but "between 1646 and 1650, he brought the account of the colony's struggles and achievements through the year 1646."[47] As Walter P. Wenska states, "Bradford writes most of his history out of his nostalgia, long after the decline of Pilgrim fervor and commitment had become apparent. Both the early annals which express his confidence in the Pilgrim mission and the later annals, some of which reveal his dismay and disappointment, were written at about the same time."[46] In Of Plymouth Plantation, Bradford drew deep parallels between everyday life and the events of the Bible. As Philip Gould writes, "Bradford hoped to demonstrate the workings of divine providence for the edification of future generations."[47] Despite the fact that the manuscript was not published until 1656, the year before his death, it was well received by his near contemporaries.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The New World was not without its conflicts as evidenced in the many disputes the Puritans such as Bradford and his Separatists along with Winthrop and his Congregationalists had with other parties who were regarded as dissenters. The causes of such disputes did indeed vary but the inherent reason under all of them was thought to be the Puritan leaders’ defensive nature along with their desire to interpreting history so as to make it compatible with Calvinistic theology. This thus brings varying discrepancies in the early American literature such as those of Thomas Morton and William Bradford who describe similar events but with varying points of view thus reaching different conclusions.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Winthrop was part of the aristocracy of the colonies that would be the United States. He, as well as the local government were strictly Puritan and adhered closely to the bible. John Winthrop was the prosecutor in the case against Anne Huthchinson. She was on trial for teaching her own version of Puritan teachings that were not directly from the Bible all the time. She was accused of heresy and slenderizing the church.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    William Bradford

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages

    3.Did you know before reading this article that many of the immigrants and explorers were young - under 25 years old? Some were even teenagers. How old was Bradford when he left England? How old was he when he arrived in America? What does that say about his character?…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within this novel, there’s certain environmental, political, environmental, and cultural relationships developed between Natives and Pilgrims. Philbrick wrote that the pilgrims first landed at the New World in 1620. “For sixty-five days, the Mayflower had blundered her way through strong storms and headwinds.” (Philbrick 1) It was for sure a long, hazardous trip, however they eventually set foot on land and set up a settlement at a place called Cole’s Hill in Plymouth, which was originally a Native settlement.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Coming into the Americas with no or very little knowledge, can be difficult for those who were immigrants who happened to be John Smith and William Bradford in this situation. They both said to have faced a hardship voyage through the Atlantic Ocean, but for them it was all worth it since they would be arriving in a land that has no leadership and they were ready to take upon that position. They believed that life would be easy for them in the new world, but eventually they faced a storm of reality. Smith and Bradford came to the New World with different ideas in mind such as their reasons, attitude, and lifestyle. Both coming from the same region, they compared in difficulties such as dying of starvation and encountering Native Americans.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Captain Jahn Smith and Governor William Bradford were two influental leaders in the New World during the early 1600s. They both established a colony and they attempted to attract settlers with writings. Their writings were intended for different audiences and they both had different purposes. John Smith’s writings were intended to bring people to the new world. He wrote a pamphlet to the people in England and told about all the good things about New England. In his pamphlet he tried to persuade people to join him in the new land and how he promised the New England was better than England. John Smith's audience was intended for people from England, and possible settlers.Though,William Bradford's writings were intended for different audiences and he had a different purpose than John Smith. William Bradford's audience was intended for the future generation. He wrote a diary about his actual experiences in Colonial America,he discussed in his diary about the many hardships he faced. Both wrote of their experiences in America,were Europeans,and desired to settle the land. John Smith and William Bradford were two important people who led to the settlement in America. They were fine leaders who made survival possible on this new land. They created relationships with the natives and won and lost some with their own men. They led their men across the ocean to settle on lands that were never previously settled by Europeans. They had all of their crew adapt to the new land and form relationships with the natives.If it was not for these two men's great leadership skills, their crews would have died and America would not be the same.Without the decisions made by Smith and Bradford, nobody would have survived in the New World. They took control and found food and shelter. They also made sure all their sick were taken care of when nobody really wanted to do this job. Smith and Bradford made it possible to make a small colony on a land they have never seen.These men…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    William Bradford is of great significance to American history because he plays a big role in how America started off including being the Governor of Plymouth for many years. Another reason for why Bradford is significant to American history is that he played a major role in the “First” Thanksgiving as he had had a similar feast to celebrate his second marriage.…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    To begin, William Bradford was the leader of Plymouth, which was one of the earliest colonial settlements in the United States. Thomas Morton was there around the same time; however he was just a settler. Bradford became very popular throughout the colony and demonstrated his talents when writing “Of Plymouth Plantation”. Morton was known for his pieces, “New English Canaan” and “Manners and Customs of the Indians”. Both authors did their best to describe the events which took place in the colonies and show their views of the Indians. However, William Bradford and Thomas Morton had a different view of the Native Americans from both of their first sightings.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics