Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Why Is Asians Silent in Class

Good Essays
836 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Is Asians Silent in Class
Why is Asians Silent in Class?
: Silence is Virtue

College in United States, especially in N.Y.C, is very fascinated place for learning. People called N.Y.C as cultural melting spot. More than one hundred cultures and various people are making one big culture, as well as in college. Some people said that class in N.Y.C seems like U.N association, because people from six continents gather together and study. Although it is totally joking, it is not unavailable to see like that way by people who live out of U.S. However, among the group of the students in a class, some students seemed that they are not fit in the class well—it is Asians. Unlike Americans, Asians are known to be silent and apprehensive when it comes to class participation. Jun Liu studies this situation and enumerates the possible reasons as to why Asian students prefer silence. “Silence is open to interpretation, its meaning, its structure, and its functions are culture-laden.” Its interpretation is also culturally defined. (Liu, 189-190) That is why people with an “expressive culture” such as those from the United States, are constantly seeking possible opportunities geared towards self-expression. While people who grew up in a country with a “receptive culture,” such as China, feels less need to display themselves to others (Liu, 190). An example would be the Japanese, “who seem to hold words in lower esteem than do other members of other cultures.” In Japan and many other Asian countries, "the emphasis is on listening rather than speaking, on intuition rather than explanation, on synthesis over analysis” (Liu, 191). In American classes, silence is usually viewed as “absence” or lack of communication. However, in an Asian classroom setting, silence is expected and encouraged as a sign of respect for their teachers and classmates. Due to the generally large class sizes, teachers usually prefer that students do their inquiries or discuss issues after class so that the entire class period can be devoted to a well-organized lecture (Liu, 191). Silence in classrooms is totally acceptable in Asian cultures. It is sometimes taken as a sign of appreciation for high-quality questions, as the answers to these questions might take some time to think about. Silence during lectures may also indicate students ' attentive listening and active thinking. But in the American culture, it may well be interpreted as the result of a boring or uninteresting class in (Liu, 192). In Liu’s study, many of the students revealed that their silence inside the classroom sometimes meant showing respect for teachers and classmates, especially when there are a lot of students in class, and it sometimes meant agreement and harmony with others ' opinions (192). Other Asian students in the study also maintained silence when they did not understand their teachers or could not follow the lecture, because they knew that someone in class would speak up, explain or ask the same questions they had in mind. (Liu, 192) In this way their silence would serve as an opportunity for others ' participation, in which questions and issues shared by those students who were silent are answered and addressed. Therefore, to some Asian students, being silent in class is better than speaking up, (Liu, 193) especially since they are also afraid of saying the wrong answer, being laughed at for giving the wrong answer, being scolded by the teacher, or being labeled as a show-off. Another important factor when it comes to silence is power. “In many mainstream classes such as content courses in U.S universities, Asian students are in the minority, and their minority status extends beyond the classroom.” Due to their minority status, Asian students would use silence in their respective class as a shield for self-protection through invisibility, or as a way of belonging, to show their conformity and harmony with the majority, a behavior rooted in Asian culture. (Liu, 193) Therefore, it is possible that most of the reasons why Asians are silent in class are culturally related, for in Asia, speaking up is also sometimes given a different or double meaning by the listeners, causing fear for Asian students to express themselves.

Works Cited
Liu, Jun. Asian Students’ Classroom Communication Patterns in U.S. Universities: An Emic Perspective. Westport, CT: Ablex, 2001. 30 Oct. 2009 http://books.google.com.ph/books?id=8o7NAz- EybgC&pg=PA193&lpg=PA193&dq=why+asians+are+silent+in+class&source=bl&ots=N61MriWlND&sig=ng3NQfSaSJfK4NJgMI69dTKU23I&hl=en&ei=t37xSpeZGYSOkQXr1YSZBw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=7&ved=0CBoQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=why%20asians%20are%20silent%20in%20class&f=false.
Macionis, John. Society: the basics. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. 30 Oct. 2009
The observation took place between Oct. 26(Monday) and Oct. 30(Friday).
“The number of participation” includes both questions and answers that instructor asked.
Each class has up to 35 of students.
Following is Asian students in classes.
|Mon |4 |
|Tue |2 |
|Wed |2 |
|Thu |4 |
|Fri |3 |

[pic]

Cited: Macionis, John. Society: the basics. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. 30 Oct. 2009 The observation took place between Oct

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Growing up Asian in America by Kesaya E. Noda deals with growing up culturally different in America. There are some important components of a culture like identity, beliefs, values, and dialect. These components are influenced by our family, friends, social environment, and the community we live in. In her essay, Noda talks about dealing with knowing and defining herself. She explains that there are two mindsets for her. The first one, inside, which she is totally comfortable with and feels accepted, and the other one, outside, which she thinks that other people don’t understand her and are often ignorant to her.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They are very shy to begin with and extremely scared when ask to speak in front of the class. This is probably due to parenting because at a young age social life was nonexistent. Every day it is a routine of coming home from school and straight to homework or any extra activities that the parents have line up for them. For example, piano lessons or house chores are usually what the parents have for them to do. There is very little times that Asian Americans get to play with their friends. Most likely thru their early teens to college, they end up with a few friends or groups that they hang out with. As they get older and become successful, their self-esteem gets higher and now they become more confident of themselves. It is probably because they have been through so much when they are younger that after they get older and achieve their goals they are happier in life. “These experiences of competition and discrimination can also lead to a greater sense of unity and solidarity” (Le).…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    People all around the world have different communication styles based on their culture legacies. I, too, am affected by my Chinese culture when I communicate with others. In the chapter “The Ethnic Theory on Plane Crashes” in Outlier, author Malcolm Gladwell discusses the importance of cultural legacy on communication. Many of the plane crashes can be explained with “mitigated speech” by plane officers, meaning “any attempt to downplay or sugarcoat the meaning of what is being said” (194). People’s cultural legacies significantly influence a person’s ability to communicate effectively with other people, and thus might cause misunderstandings and tragedies.…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In her article, “Facing the Culture Shock of College,” Kathleen Cushman argues that first generation college students struggles fitting in with other students due to their backgrounds and cultures. She supports her claim by first describing what first generation college students have to face on a daily basis. Then, she interviewed “16 first generation college students from around the United States” for evidence to support her claim. She makes a connection in which students try managing to get a college degree while they are being judged because of their background and culture. For example, Raja, the son of Palestinian immigrants, tries to get A’s on all of his tests to assure them that he is “not a clown.”…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many Asian American students are immigrants or first generation Americans as Butterfield state in the article “Don Lee, 20, is a junior at Berkeley. His parents immigrated to Torrance, Calif, From South Korea when he was 5, so he could get a better education. Lee said his father would warn him about the about the danger of wasting time at high school dances or football games. Instead… for fun on weekend, my friends and I would go to the town library to study.” So the Asian student have a lot of support and pressure to better themselves, because their parents gave up a lot to move here to help them. Therefore the student can not let their parents down. Asian parents have high expectations their kids will make…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The reading is about the stereotype regarding Asian Americans as a model minority. The literature review shows a lot of different opinions about why people stereotype the Asian Americans. First, there is a widespread saying that the academic success of Asian American students is because of the hereditary differences in intelligence and Asian cultural values. Moreover, some people say Asian American children are more sensitive to please their parents and they are more likely to be influenced by their parents. In my opinion, it has something to do with the culture values. Asian American parents always have high expectation on their children and they invest a lot in their children’s education. Recent study reveals human capital family, culture…

    • 145 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Thought among Asian Americans there are seemingly similar cultural traits, such as strong family tie, collectivism, emphasizing on education attainment, preserving traditions. However, Asian subgroups are not homogeneous because they come from countries with distinct cultural and linguistic patterns, and their immigration to the U.S. has been shaped by many dissimilar cultural realities that do not apply to Asian-Americans as a whole. In addition, each Asian subgroup is very in culture, tradition, and religion identity, have different socioeconomic characteristics as well they face new challenges and LEP barriers as they try to improve…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am not bothered by silence. For all the noise I make with my friends, I am still not comfortable talking about my feelings in front of others-- especially not classmates. I could sit in the quiet for hours if that is what the class demanded.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Communication is essentially the most important skill that any human being will ever have to learn. Communication includes approaching other human beings in verbal or nonverbal contact. In the Twenty-first-century, many academic environments are changing the way students learn. Schools are not a hierarchal model of a teacher in charge of a class of students. An example of a hierarchal model of education involves a teacher handing out an assignment and students completing the assignment, with no questions asked. In this particular hierarchal model, communication among classmates is often discouraged. Today, many academic environments are taking an equality approach to education and learning by working in small groups or teams of about 3-5 fellow…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States is thought to be the nation of immigrants and a melting pot, which immigrants from all over the world come to the US to settle in. In particular, Asians comprise about 5% of the US population and it is considered the fastest growing minority group in the United States. Asian Americans are often overlooked in the media and the Asian American speech have only recently received attention from the media. Nowadays Asian Americans are being portrayed more in popular media pieces. However, these media representations tend to be stereotypical, often portrayed as negative. The stereotypes of Asians range from martial arts master to hard working, diligent nerds. Even though Asian Americans resided for 4,5 generations, Asians are still…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Traditional Classes

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Lack of teacher and peer interaction is detrimental to the learning experience. In the traditional class not only is the teacher available for questions and feed back but also fellow students can share advice and…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pangu Creator

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages

    For example, Chinese culture places its values more in faith in personal relationships than in written rules and procedures for structuring interactions, while American culture values written rules that presumably apply to everyone and are assumed to produce fair, reasonable procedures and decisions. From Pangu’s legend, it seems that there is a common thing in Chinese and American culture, i.e., the hope for goodness and the courage to fight for it. From the beginning of world creation, there was always a hint of formal hierarchy in which they know their position and the customs for behavior in the situation. American cultures have the wishing of informal, egalitarian government where importance of social rankings minimizes. Throughout the Pangu creation myth, Chinese culture taught people to fight against the dark side and evil for a bright future, as evidenced by the frequent uprising against evil government in Chinese history. Both American and Chinese cultures value courage and determination. But the ways to show these values seem different, American culture taught people to directly discuss controversial topics and press personal opinions about what they consider the truth. In traditional Chinese culture, people usually do not like to confront face by face, but tell the difference in opinion in indirect ways. This culture difference could sometimes cause misunderstandings between…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    It seems that often in today’s society when we think of the typical public school classroom, images of chaotic behavior, chattering students and paper being thrown quickly come to mind. This behavior, while not uncommon should not be the norm, there is a solution. The first three behaviors that we will address is the seemingly ever-present excessive talking, laughter and general outburst. It seems that no matter how many times the lights are turned off, names of students are written on the board, recess or free time taken away students continue to use their voices out of turn in excess ways, making instruction and learning difficult.…

    • 1704 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One of the main reasons that talking in class while we are not supposed to is disrespectful is because the teacher is in charge of the class and we are supposed to follow directions correctly. Teachers are there for them to help us but we need to cooperate and make it easier for the teacher to teach and for the student to learn. If a teacher has to tell the class to be silent more than three times there is a problem because that means that the students are totally disrespecting the teacher by not listening to her, choosing to just ignore her. Students should never ignore a teacher’s order during class because we are at school to learn and the people who are going to help us learn are the teachers, therefore, whatever they do has a legitimate reason and we should always see it in a good way. Another reason why it is disrespectful to talk during class is because there are some students in class that are trying to learn and by talking, we are interrupting their learning environments. When a teacher is trying to teach and a student interrupts the class talking to their friend the teacher has to stop the class to tell that student to stop talking; wasting class time that is valuable for some…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American culture is very different from the Chinese culture. for example, there is a famous Chinese quote, “Think twice before acting.” which means people have to think carefully if their language, action is appropriate, to say it in another way is that people should not be too open. But that does not work in united states. American culture is the opposite of the Chinese culture, in american culture, people should be open. It is really important to learn and accept the american culture but it is also very hard. When I tried to accept all the culture differences, i was very uncomfortable with the culture differences. But it’s so important to accept the culture differences, all the people around are using this culture, and i have to accept these culture differences in order to better understand other people and make more friends. Because of these reasons, I pushed myself to accept the culture differences and i finally accepted. After i accepted the cultural differences, i am able to better understand and go into the American…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics