Preview

Where Did Charles Murrays' Logic Go?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1289 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Where Did Charles Murrays' Logic Go?
Where did Charles Murrays’ Logic Go?
In the article by Charles Murray, “Are Too Many People Going to College?”, Murray raises interesting and controversial topics. Murray is suggesting that maybe school counselors should not encourage every student to attend a four year university for their B.A.. Instead that they should only encourage those students that are in the correct percentile in linguistics and that their career goals require them to do so. Murray also, believes that a student should not try to acquire a B.A. based on economic grounds, but that they should go with what they really want to do instead. He also believes that children should receive all their core knowledge in their K-8th grade years. Although I agree with Charles Murray up to a point, I cannot accept his overriding assumption that all college students are 18 year olds fresh out of high school. And even more so I disagree with Murray’s suggestion for high school guidance counselors and his thoughts on maturity.
By Murray focusing on the assumption that the target group is 18 year olds fresh out of high school, Murray overlooks an important and ever growing group of students, which are the non-traditional students. Many of these students have not been in school in years, maybe only had a few years of high school, or like me had no high school at all and received a G.E.D. instead. Therefore, these students are missing valuable skills that are an asset for a college student such as writing and studying skills. As a non-traditional student and after reading Charles Murrays’ article and analyzing his thoughts and opinions on these young students, I can’t help but wonder what his thoughts and opinions are of us. Do we even fit within his narrow sights? Do we have a right to be here? These are a few of the questions that I would like for Murray to address, but since he doesn’t even consider that there are other age groups enrolled in college then we will have to wait until he realizes his



Cited: Murray, Charles. “Are Too Many People Going To College?” They Say/I say with Readings. Ed Gerald Graff, Cathy Birkenstein and Russell Durst. 2nd ed. New York: W.W. Norton, 2012. 222-42. Print

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Marty Nemko’s article, “We Send Too Many Students to College,” he analyzes and questions whether college is truly worth the money. Marty “holds a Ph.D. specializing in the evaluation of education from the University of California, Berkeley, and subsequently taught there” (martynemko.com) as well as published five successful books. In addition to his novels, he previously was a columnist at San Francisco Chronical and The Atlantic Monthly, also a contributing editor at several other well-known companies. Nemko’s purpose is to convey the idea that, even though there may be reasons one would attend college, the complications overshadow the benefits. He adopts an impassionate tone in order to convince his adult audience to take a hard look at whether it is worthwhile for their children to attend college.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In recent discussions of “The College Dropout Boom,” David Leonhardt made some interesting points on the works of society and it’s modern day views on education. Many of the ideas he presented were controversial to me, considering my previous perspective of social status’ having nothing to do with someone’s chances at graduating college. However, there are many ideas in which he presented that I agree with, such as the belief that obtaining a college degree doesn’t necessarily promise a well-paying job. Growing up in a household where nobody has ever earned a college degree, I can say personally that it is extremely important to have one, regardless of the immediate outcome. It’s better to be safe than sorry.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Owen And Sawhill Analysis

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In the most recent debates regarding higher education, a particular issue of whether a liberal arts education can benefit students is relentless. While most people directly connect a liberal arts education to a bright future in terms of a career, others argue against that. On one hand, Sanford J. Ungar strongly believes that despite some hardships that come along with college, everyone should take the opportunity to go. On the other hand, Charles Murray, Stephanie Owen, and Isabel Sawhill suggest that it can depend in terms of money and only those that are academically capable and enjoy learning should attend college. My view is that although some students…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Long restless nights and large amounts of debt created by thousands of people to attend college for a better career and cause. Numerous people of different ages, races and backgrounds have considered if college is beneficial to them or not. Two educated women, Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill, authors of “Should Everyone go to College?” published in 2013 by the Brookings Institution emphasizes factors that encourage people to consider whether or not college is actually for them. Owen and Sawhill used arguments, pay scale data, emotional and logical appeals, statistics and examples to help readers determine if attending college is sustainable to achieve or a bad investment. People should consider their finances, career choice, and self-motivation before considering whether college is best for them. Education can be the solution of our economic crisis. Eventually, education can help our economic system…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    University degrees are commonly expected these days which is replacing high school diplomas. Everyone in this generation thinks that going to university is a must, which raises their standards. Nichols discusses that American universities are killing the abilities of the students as he states: “The most important of these intellectual capabilities, and the one most under attack in American universities is critical thinking” (72). Relationship between students and professors is very informal these days and that is why students hesitate to ask any question to their professors, but they communicate with them through email, no matter how simple the question is. Nichols mentions that in early times, high school diplomas was the requirement for the jobs but nowadays it is replaced by a master’s degree and because of this, students are going through a financial crisis. He states that “Students are going broke running around in this educational hamster wheel, without learning much” (75). Nichols argues that American universities should be seen as the place form where students can get higher education, but students are seeing universities as a place where they can spend their four years with their friends and enjoy their life as Nichols expresses that “They…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article, "Should Everyone Go to College?" by Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill, they clearly state that not everyone should go to college, and individuals who do go to college make more money. Both of the authors are part of The Center on Children and Families at Brookings Institution. Stephanie Owen is a senior research assistant while Isabel Sawhill is a senior in economic studies and co-director of the institution. This article was published May 18, 2013. The intended audience is the people from the CCF Institution and people who are unsure of their future in education or career. Since they are both Senior of the institution they must be experienced in this type of work.…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Do We Have College

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cited: Menand, Louis. “Live and Learn: Why we have college”. The New Yorker. Summer 2011.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay Are Too Many People Going to College? Charles Murray states that while more people should be gaining a liberal education in their high school years, not as many are so prepared for a college degree. Students are not being given adequate information about the history of the world around them during their formative years, and are instead made to wait until they move on to college. Students who score a higher percentiles are more likely to enjoy the constant research and studying, but for most average students, coursework is a major source of stress over a class that may not pertain to the career the want to pursue.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On June twelfth of 2001, Linda Lee wrote an article for the Family Circle stating a case against college. Lee attempted using pathos, ethos, and logos to persuade her readers that college is not a necessity in a child’s future. However, numerous of these appeals can easily be contradicted by somebody as simple minded as a high schooler.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Charles Murray beliefs are that yes and no ‘’too many people are going to college’’, why does he believe this? You ask yourself. Well in his perspective many people go to college for the simple reason that they believe a B.A will get them a higher-paying job. Satisfaction also plays a very big role in choosing whether to go to college or not. Some people would rather go to college to get a B.A to get a high paying job than choosing their dream job that doesn’t pay so high. In conclusion Charles Murray believes people are pursuing a college education for the wrong…

    • 105 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Larry Cuban, a former social studies high school teacher, superintendent, manages to compress the mantra that has been repeated for several of years with his article entitled, “Why Everyone Shouldn’t Go To College”. He accomplishes this by giving us countless of interesting facts about the reality of college and life. He argues that the annual college tuition seems to be extremely expensive, that may not worth the amount of money you’re paying.In addition, he makes note that college graduates working at manufacturing places that don’t need college diplomas, in order to complete their job. Furthermore, he makes clear that one might be a high school dropout or graduate of high school and can still be highly…

    • 117 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    children freedom

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I thought that the author’s argument was inspiring. I can really relate to what the author was trying to convey. I remember when I was younger my education was forced upon what was given to me and I had no choice of what I was learning. But attending college I feel that I have as much freedom to pick any classes I want most of the time with the days and time. Just that as an adult you have more responsibilities, know what needs to be done and timing. To me in today education children are very lucky to have the education system we have today because children have the right to do whatever they want in the classroom such as freedom of speech and chose of the action. I also feel like out…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One significant truth most would rather choose to ignore is that not everyone should be able to attend college. I am quite aware that many might perceive this statement as being quite cynical, but the truth remains that not every individual is equal in motivation and achievements. The quality of the nation’s intellectual workforce would be critically undermined if everyone got the chance to attend college.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    College Life on Students

    • 2142 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The purpose of this paper is to give an explanatory synthesis to the 2007 article “ The Gradates by Louis Menand. “The Graduates” was about the hardships college students endure. According to Menand, attending colleges can place a tremendous amount of stress on a student. He claims students beginning college tend to over analyze, set unnecessary goals, have a fifty percent dropout rate, and have an abundance of college campuses to choose from, and why Americans have the highest expenses for higher education. In this explanatory synthesis, I will go into an extensive and thorough explanatory synthesis of Menand 's viewpoints of the college dropout rate, an abundance of colleges for students to choose from, and the high cost of a college education. I willGo further into detail of the issues talked about by Louis Menand in “The Graduates” by using national statistics, as well as pros and cons related to Manand 's argument.…

    • 2142 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though the pressure on the professors to lower standards is very strong, there is little pressure put on students to perform to the standards that college used to be defined by. John Holt insists that school does nothing but corrupt young students and make them less curious, wise, and intuitive than they were before. College used to be a rite of passage for the few chosen intellectuals who would choose to broaden their horizons by means of further education. Higher education no longer gives students the knowledge they will need to succeed in the real working world. College has become so lax that students merely get an extension of their high…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays