Preview

Was Ludicrous Justified

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
695 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was Ludicrous Justified
Although these workers had been facing many hardships, their actions during the demonstration had been ludicrous.I believe that the actions of the authorities had been justified. This is because, the authorities and government had the fear of a communist uprising much like that of Russia in 1917, the potential conflict between the two sides with and against the argument, and the strikers had been causing many cases of property damage.
Firstly, the reason the actions of the authorities had been indeed justified, is due to the fear of a communist revolution much like that of Russia’s in 1917, overthrowing the Russian emperor Tsar Nicholas II and his entire family from the power. The fear of Canada becoming a communist country had irradiated from many political figures, this is because a communist nation lacks creativity, rights, and has reduced incentives to work hard. Communism is considered to do more evil than good, it gives everyone an equal opportunity regardless of the effort one puts in over another, it also lacks andy type of creativity as everyone works the same, and
…show more content…
This is because, the authorities and government had the fear of a communist uprising in Canada to impose the union, the potential conflict between the two sides with and against the worker’s union, and the strikers had been causing many cases of property damage.Therefore, the authorities had taken the most immediate action, much like the“Bloody Saturday” that had left thirty strikers injured left two dead could have been easily avoided by the authorities taking much more tactical action, nevertheless their prompt action had sure suppressed the conflict between the two parties, but not the strikers with the union. I can justify that the authorities actions could be justified for the aforementioned

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Following Gouzenko’s brave confirmation about Soviet spies being apart of the Canadian military, the Government proceeded and attempted to seek for more information about the accusations presented before them. As they came aware of the involvement between the Canadian military within the Soviet spy union, the government induced powers to detain, interrogated suspects and overall arrests became more harsh. The reputation of Canada’s military was lost from the dishonourable people involved, leading to civil liberties. Prompting the military to attain control and inclusive power. Resulting in Canada becoming more vigilant and attentive when applying rules and enforcing orders. Forming the identity of Canada, as past leaders and protectors showed their strength by implementing laws forcefully. Guaranteeing security for Canada at the time and for future circumstances. The specification of Canada had been emphasized by higher anarchy displaying control as the Gouzenko affair changed the playing field and displayed courage throughout that…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sparking a massive movement that left the mills without most of their employees, the strikers and the Industrial Workers of the World spearheaded an organized strike that would result in some of their demands being met. However, the terms in the collective bargaining agreement to end the Lawrence strike of 1912, while beneficial for the workers, were short-lived and untenable with declining participation in the pursuit of increasing workers’ rights within the Industrial Workers of the World and an almost immediate…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the early part of the 1930’s, most workers strikes ended in a whimper. Growers were working with the law enforcement and developed a track record of terminating strikes easily with little or no pushback.4 This was due in part because the newly formed WUIL was comprised mostly of amateurs who had no experience in striking, nor did they have any idea how to plan strikes or the leadership to execute it.5 Further, once the Mexican Mutual Aid Society succeeded the WUIL, it too was ineffective in its leadership.6 The continuous lack of trailblazers needed to endure the long…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    4 People were not only losing their jobs but they were losing their family and friends. The doctors could not save the people who died in the coal mine, however they could have prevented another horrible mistake. Health research was not as advanced as it was now, and new diseases kept popping up causing mayhem among the people. The Red Cross scandal which involved the organization putting HIV infected blood in patients caused commotion and distrust all over Canada.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    the Winnipeg General Strike is one of such events that have made an impact on Canadian…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reform 19th Century Essay

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The government support of the monopolies and violent methods used to control unions significantly halted the labor movements that attempted to correct what they viewed as faults in monopolies.For example the use of militia men and pinkertons to forcefully remove the unions during the carnegie strike. Despite the efforts…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The workers' rights seemed to be more than an important issue to the strike situation. Among many things at hand here, a factor that comes into play is the working conditions. The machines being used in the mills were far from safe as one could easily become injured by the fast moving cranks and pullys. The amount of work they had to do and the time in which they did it is more than impressive to me. It is easy to see how the workers were pushed to the limits of strike. On top of all of that they were getting paid minimum wage for this invigorating work. It was clear that a change had to be made and it took these workers to unite to get it done. The workers rights maintained the strike as it was these rights that were in question in settling the strike. After all, this…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    What was happening in the year 1919? Well, the First World War had finished, and the soldiers were returning home. The Depression would not come for approximately ten more years. So why weren’t people happy and life brimming with opportunity? What was happening that would lead to such labour and social strife? Relations between Canadian workers and employers were becoming explosive. The Canadian working class was being treated without any social justice. So they had one choice, to stand up and make their voices be heard because if they did not fight, resist, organize and unify to get the power to control their own lives then they would have had to wear the exaggerated look of captivity. Was what happened to Winnipeg an attempt of a revolution? The Canadian working class wanted a revolution, which they deserved, and had the right to strike against the government. For example, the government promised returning soldiers jobs and more money but they did not receive what they were promised and people were being paid extremely low wages compared to what they deserved. Also, minorities were being treated unfairly. They were paid even lower wages then the average wage. Lastly, working conditions were not at all suitable. Workers were risking their lives to make enough money to pay for food.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The strike was the result of many causes, including the increased suffering of Canadian workers. This pain was elevated because of Canadians who returned from the First World War, and could not find jobs because of the difficult economic environment. In addition, plant closures, high unemployment and poor work conditions also contributed to the causes of the general strike. The common goal of the strike was to promote the idea of collective bargaining and to achieve better wages for workers.…

    • 251 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    War Measures Act

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The War measures act protected the citizens by creating fear, detaining enemy aliens and arresting individuals that might have been a threat to Canada. Fear is a contributing factor because with the amount of RCMP/ Military soldiers made it virtually impossible to obtain important information during the world wars and impossible to succeed in an act of terrorism. During the October crisis a terrorist group named the FLQ terrorized Quebec but with the quick actions of the government and the deployment of many Canadian soldiers. Just a few weeks later the FLQ gave up and bargained for their lives…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As Canada was looking for more funds they raised the tariffs on items coming from other countries to promote the purchase of Canadian goods. However, this had the opposite effect and caused Canada’s exports to drop a staggering 67 percent. Not only did this lead to some Canadian businesses closing but, many people were laid off from their jobs. This led to people having to find different jobs which treated its employees much worse. This is exactly what happened to Irene Duhamel, who ended up working in a sweatshop, she described the conditions, “It was so hot in the factory. All the windows were closed to keep in the humidity so the cotton would stay soft. It could get as hot as 105 degrees. You worked mindlessly without stopping.” She had to work 11 hours week and only earned a little over 8 dollars for the week. The government did implement rules to look into the behaviour by big companies however, this overlook was not too thorough as one worker describes, "The law has holes big enough for millionaires to crawl through, and company laws that permit the fleecing of the public on one hand and the sweatshops on the other." This showed that the decisions the government was making were creating more problems instead of solutions.…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This was working towards the idea that in order for a revolution to be successful it must transform humanity completely and to do that everyone must willingly be a part of the resistance. It was a form of insubordination that alerted the government to discontent within the citizens but gave them no formal cause to take action against the resisters. An example of this is East Germany in the 80s. A series of conflicts over wages and housing policies led to workers threatening to strike in June 1953. This unhappiness in the workplace did not fit in with the Communist ideology of taking pride in your work and therefore instilled a sense of fear within the state when faced with a crack in the system. Following these strikes, East Germany settled into a state of conservatism, everyday resistance never quite reaching the same heights again, but the idea that it could again happen was enough to keep the government worried. This is substantial evidence that everyday resistance can be effective when executed correctly and in a state of highly controlling…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There a lot of fighting after this between the military an the workers and caused a up to 75 people being killed. On December 10th the strike had been called off after the UMWA ran out of money. Despite all this the workers demand was not met and the workers on strike were replaced with new workers.…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I agreed with you because not only the working class not only had to deal with the horrible working conditions and poor lifestyle, but also with their own government who did not care in the abuses until they revolt. This shows us that their leaders did not know how to control its own country and…

    • 56 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Teacher's Strike

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The seed of the strike was sown a year before when Fr. Al decided to fire five trouble-making teachers. Before letting them go, he gave them every opportunity to save their jobs. The sister in charge of education met with them, and also their lawyer too, and he called them one by one and tried to tell them to change their ways. Their ways were, in general, liberal. They were always complaining, and criticizing the Sisters. There was never a problem regarding wages because their wages were exactly double that of what teachers in government schools were being paid. There was never a question concerning working conditions, because our facilities are first rate. In every way, Fr. Al…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays