Preview

Was Indian Resistance Justified?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
622 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was Indian Resistance Justified?
The natives lay on the cold, damp earth, taking in their final breaths, before their hearts ceased beating, and came their demise. The Wounded Knee Massacre was one of the biggest and most violent confrontations between the Native Americans and the American people and government. It claimed as many as 300 or more of the 350 Indian lives in Wounded Knee Creek, South Dakota, and half of those killed were women and children. It was the final major clash between the Native Americans and the U.S. military, and it finally proved that white men are the “true savages” of humankind. Yes, the Native Americans’ resistance was justified. White Americans brought many atrocities upon the Native American people. The white men gave them unfulfilled promises, purloined their lands and decimated their people. Prior to the Wounded Knee Massacre, the United States government gave the Native Americans many unfulfilled promises. They seized the lands they previously promised to allow the Native Americans to keep. They promised that they would be respected and indiscriminate in American society and safeguard the peace. They also were guaranteed that their culture and sense of pride would not be lost. None of these promises were kept. Over time, the government took their land and massacred their people. One example would be the Wounded Knee Massacre where many Indians were killed in an event characterized by genocide. It never got better for the Native Americans, and even to this day their sufferings continue.
In the years before the Wounded Knee Massacre the United States government continued to annex (or seize) the Indian's lands. This incited and spread the support of the Ghost Dance Spiritual Movement. According to the Ghost Dance’s teachings, Jesus Christ had returned to earth in the form of a Native American. He would “eradicate the disease” - in this case the white people, animals lead to extinction by the whites would return and the spirits of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Nate Murray Wounded Knee Massacre – Black Elk Speaks, The Butchering At Wounded Knee History and background How it started: In years previous to the massacre the US government had been seizing large portions of the Native American tribe, the Sioux’s lands. Bison herds had reached near extinction and the treaty promises to the Native Americans protecting reservation lands were not being met. It was during this time that news spread among the reservations of a Native American prophet by the name of Wovoka. Wovoka believed that Jesus Christ had risen as a Native American and prophesied that the dead Native Americans would soon join the living in a world in which the Indians could live in the old way surrounded by plentiful Bison.…

    • 2600 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Wounded Knee Massacre (1890) followers of the Sioux tribe identified their beliefs had been shattered, felt like the Ghost dance was their only hope, everybody who thought the Ghost dance ceremonies beliefs; authority wanted would be returned and the white people would go away. The whites shove westward opposing with the Indians and their values. As the end result of the clash blood-stained encounters took residence and the white pilgrims were triumphant and the government controlled Native Americans properties to lesser lots. The government reinforced assimilation which was the plot to bond Native Americans philosophies with whites. Assimilation is the method of any set of individuals being immersed into alternate beliefs. The assimilation had one goal in mind; rule was for all Native Americans to live and perform like white Americans. The white settlers sensed their way was the best way; but it wasn’t. Assimilation motto was “kill the Indians and, save the man”. A key undertaking, was the Homestead Act; delivered and approved 160 acres of allowed acreage to any civilian who was the head of the…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    was around this time that the idea of “Manifest Destiny” was an established belief of the Europeans. They now felt destined to take all land from the Atlantic to the Pacific. This resulted in the Native Americans being separated from their home. To this day the social effect of this treatment has made the Native Americans very upset. They still try to preserve their treaty rights and want to resume their native and religious customs.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Wounded Knee Massacre took place on December 29, 1890 near Wounded Knee Creek, in South Dakota. Both, the New York Times and the London Times have published articles on this event. However, their interpretations of the event are quite different. It is interesting how the same event can be portrayed in two completely contrasting ways. Specifically, the New York Times justifies the American's actions towards the Native Americans, whereas the London Times portrays the American's actions as unacceptable towards the Native Americans.…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Trail of Tears was a harsh and inhumane event that happened in the 1830’s. Indian tribes were forced off of their land and they were involuntarily relocated to what is now Oklahoma. There was fear and resentment among the white settlers when it came to their Native American adversaries. They were a different kind of people than the whites when it came to how they lived, spoke, dressed and as well as their religious beliefs. This unfamiliarity with them led to the settlers believing that they were better than the indians and that they should leave the land and be forced to live in an ‘indian land’ if they refused to conform to Christianity as well as learn to speak English. However as more and more settlers flooded into the area, the land became more and more coveted. They no longer cared how civilized the indians became; they wanted them gone (Brief History of the Trail of Tears).…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Wounded Knee was a massacre that killed many Sioux Indians. This occurred on December 29, 1890. All happened when soldiers wanted to arrest the Sioux Indians. The main reason was for the soldiers to arrest the chief. As they tried to arrest him there began a intense fight against the Indians and soldiers. This went on for many months, during theses months much happened Such as many deaths, ghost dances and what happened at the end.…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Wounded Knee Massacre came after a battle between the United States and the Sioux. The Sioux had won the battle and clearly the United States were not happy. The Wounded Knee Massacre started with soldiers from the United States that were sent to this tribe to arrest the leaders because the Indians had different beliefs. They started with a man named Sitting Bull who was killed in the process. The United States were sent back and a man named bigfoot was in charge now. A fight between a soldier and an Indian broke out and a shot was fired from an Unknown side. The Indians could have done something to try to prevent this but the United States soldiers and government were the ones that started this because they attacked…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indian Removal Act DBQ

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages

    government’s forced removal of Native Americans was a shameful act in American history due to what the Natives were subjected to. As documented by heaps of historians, the Trail of Tears was one of the saddest periods in the history of Indian tribe neglect. “Andrew Jackson had placed Indian removal at the top of his administration's priorities." (Hershberger 1) With this notion came the inevitable Trail of Tears. The Trail of Tears is known to man as a collective of removals that targeted Native Americans. Before the Indian Removal Act of 1930 being signed into law, Native Americans were able to take up residence all over the nation; notably more so in the south of the U.S. as dozens of Indian tribes were removed from the north in earlier years. The Trail of Tears focused on removing all Native Americans from their homelands and pushing them to the northwest of the Mississippi River. This area was designed by Andrew Jackson and his men. Even more, the territory did not hold the necessary resources that the Native Americans needed to thrive. This led to many Natives scavenging for supplies and suffering hardship from not having the appropriate materials that they had needed to live and excel in life. While en route to their new native territory, hundreds if not thousands suffered from starvation, disease, exposure to foreign illnesses, and alike elements. Again, this was a time for the Native Americans that was nothing but sheer chaos. It was as if the plague was occurring, but it was only affecting the Natives. When all was said and done, this act was responsible for both thousands of deaths and thousands of displaced Native Americans all around the…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Elk Dream

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When the battle of Wounded Knee happened – which cannot really be called a battle, but more a bloody massacre – the Indians were not doing anything that could have been considered attacking the white men, or even controversial. They were doing a ghost dance, because they were fearful about what the white men were going to do to them. They wanted help from their deceased ancestors in the protection from the white men. But the white men had forbid them from dancing too much, and so took it as a threat, and released fire on the Indians. They massacred all Indians present, which were mostly innocent women and children. The massacre at Wounded Knee is kind of a touchy subject to me personally because I have visited the grave site in the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation and have seen firsthand the devastation that the massacre had on the people, and even how they remember it still today, and mourn for the dead…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It was a short-lived treaty as the flood of migrants came into the newly bought land grants. The Americans had not only betrayed the Indians, but they had also decided to ruin them through uncivilized violence. In Ohio, Native Americans formed a confederate to fight against the settlers since their pleas were muted by the US government. The Battle of Fallen Timbers pursued and Native Americans were forced off their land. At the Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890, the US army shot and killed 300 (mostly unarmed) Indians as they had wanted to take away their guns on the reservation.…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even after the Supreme Court ruled it unlawful for the government to remove the Native Americans from their lands, President Andrew Jackson refused to enforce the law resulting from the ruling. From this action, the US government forcibly removed around 16,000 Cherokees from their land and forced them to walk the Trail of Tears. Around 4,000 of them perished on the 2,200-mile journey; starting at the southwest to Indian Territory, now called Oklahoma. However, the terror didn’t end once they had been relocated against their will. Cultural Genocide was committed against them next, the government forced the married couples to remarry in western attire, cut their hair, and forced the children to attend a boarding school away from their families to learn how to speak and write in English. The government’s excuse for these violations was they were trying to “Kill the Indian, Save the Man,”. Due to the government’s cruel action towards the Native Americans; for kicking them off their land for selfish reasons, such as land for new settlers and the discovery or iron ores, and the cultural genocide they were the root cause of, this action in history can be identified as…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ghost Dance History

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Indians performing would dawn themselves in “Ghost shirts” detailed with images of eagles and buffalo (EWH, Massacre At Wounded Knee,1890). On June 20, 1890, Mrs. Z. A. Parker accounted the events that took place at a Ghost Dance at the Pine Ridge reservation, describing the environment to have “…a large pine tree in the center, which was covered with strips of cloth of various colors, eagle feathers, stuffed birds, claws, and horns-all offerings to the Great Spirit” (PBS,The Ghost Dance Among the Lakota). These spiritual ceremonies never directed any violence towards the white race. They focused on hypnosis, meditation, and dancing ceremonies. This, however, did not stop the Americans from becoming…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Wounded Knee Massacre

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The battle between U.S. military troops and Lakota Sioux Indians at Wounded Knee Creek in South Dakota on December 29, 1890 Pine Ridge Reservation, resulted in the deaths of many Lakota and Sioux men, women, and children. A number of incidents precipitated the massacre in Black hill Wounded Knee creek that changed everything. Native Americans (Lakota, Sioux) had suffered through decades of broken treaties (“The Dawes Act” 1887) lost lands, forced relocation, physical deprivations, and death. and the death of five settlers, cause unstable relationships between the United States Government and the Native American.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. Whites finally overcame resistance of the Plains Indians ultimately with various factors. The whites had a fire-and-sword policy that was the last step to shatter the spirit of the Indians. The railroad, diseases, locomotives, and the near-extinction of the Buffalo in the plains all contributed to the “taming” of the Plains Indians. The railroad sprang right through the heart of the West. Locomotives brought never ending amounts of white troops, farmers, cattlemen, sheepherders, and settlers in the Indians territories. The white people’s diseases killed off many of the Indians because of how little resistant their immune systems were. After the Indians resistance ceased, the Indians were forced into reservations in different territories and were practically almost ignored to death.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Manifest Destiny Thesis

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages

    At this point it is not necessary to say that the native Americans suffered a great injustice thanks to the manifest destiny but if the snatch of their lands was not enough neither the being forced to move still they lacked much to cross or in this case to suffer.Once the lands rapt what is what followed? Perhaps would be deprive them of their independence by putting them in federal reserves? Or take their children, their clothes and all their beliefs to be molded to white man's society and when they grew up they could be farmers? What would you say if were both? now if it is unfair. The government of the United States tried to mold the Native Americans as a white man due that they thought that they were helping and this was the only way to save them.Not everything was bad thanks to Dawes Act in the year 1887 that had the purpose to divide the land in allotments and to assign them to the native Americans to another of this would be given to citizenship of the United States provided they accepted the law.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays