Preview

Was Dieppe Worth It?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
878 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was Dieppe Worth It?
Was Dieppe Worth It?

On August 19th 1942, Allied forces from Britain and Canada tried to capture the port of Dieppe, in German controlled France. Over 6000 allied troops took part in the attack, and more that half were killed, wounded, or captured. The battle only lasted nine hours. Even though the raid was a failure, it taught the Allies important things about planning and carrying out an attack, and helped the Allies succeed on D-Day, June 6th 1944, with the invasion of Normandy. If Canada had not made the sacrifice at Dieppe, these lessons would not have been learned and the invasion of Normandy could have turned out to be as bad, if not worse, of a failure.
On the night of August 18th, almost 240 ships left British ports, carrying Allied troops to a raid that was supposed to gather intelligence, destroy German-controlled coastal defences, and show that capturing a port was possible. The next morning, the attack started at 5:00AM. Things started going wrong from the beginning. Ships carrying the No. 3 Commando operation ran into a German convoy that alerted coastal defences of an attack, and ended up being scattered. Most of the troops from those ships never reached shore, but the few who did were almost immediately overwhelmed. Two kilometres east of Dieppe, troops from the Royal Regiment of Canada approached Puys, a small seaside village. Because they were behind schedule, they lost the advantages of the cover of night and the element of surprise. Most of the soldiers were shot coming out of the boats, and were killed before they even hit the water. The few who made it to the wired seawall were forced to surrender after a few hours of pointless resistance. There where three platoons of reinforcements from the “Black Watch”, or the Royal Highland Regiment of Canada, who suffered the greatest loss of life by a Canadian battalion in a single day in the entire war. 200 men were killed at the scene, 20 died later from their wounds, only 33 made it back to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Sociology

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    By 1943 Canadians were forced to fight the desperate battles in Italy, they pushed into France and casualties were high. After the evacuation in Dunkirk France surrendered to Nazi…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In 1917, Canadian troops were asked to take Passchendaele Ridge. They had to break through the German lines near Ypres, Belgium. This Battle became known as the Third Battle of Ypres. The battle of Passchendaele just became a part of this larger battle. It was very important to capture the German occupied Belgium channel ports because most of Germany’s deadly submarines were operated from them. Through the three months of fighting the Canadians proved themselves as an elite fighting Corp and received honors reflecting that. In the end, 9 soldiers received the Victoria Cross in recognition of their outstanding effort at Passchendaele. This battle is remembered for its atrocious conditions, heavy causalities, and Canadian…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a common saying:” Nations are made in war.” According to many, Vimy Ridge was the first time when Canadians really felt a sense of national identity. Just like the famous comment made by Brigadier General Alex Cross "It was Canada from the Atlantic to the Pacific on parade. I thought …that in those few minutes I witnessed the birth of a nation." The Ridge was a key position of the German defence system in northern France. Here the four divisions of the Canadian advanced side by side for the first time. Here the young volunteers from across the nation trained and fought as “Canadians”, not just a part of the Empire. Here the commanders invented the “rolling barrage”. Here a full-scale replica of the battlefield was built and the soldiers trained day and night. At Vimy Ridge, the Canadians captured more ground and prisoners than any previous British attack. However, the battle at Vimy came at a high cost: the 16,000 casualties brought devastation to home while victory was celebrated and the conscription debate shook the fragile unity in the country. Anyway, Vimy Ridge showed that although Canada has never had a huge army or talked about patriotism all the time, her people can fight, and fight well when they need to.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Canada had many consequences after the battle to capture Vimy Ridge. The battle itself changed people's perspectives about Canada. Canadians earned a good reputation among the world for their significant victory against the Germans.They were known as “ tough, effective, and courageous fighters” (Eaton and Newman 169) The Canadian troops were exceptionally brave and were prepared for all kinds of assault. This battle was also the start for Canada to become a separate nation. After Arthur Carrie was promoted to become the commander of the Canadian military, the British was no longer required to command the Canadian soldiers (Eaton and Newman 170) This shows how the British believed that the Canadians can handle things by themselves without their help. Therefore Canada had countless outcomes from the battle for Vimy Ridge.…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    n World War 1 there were a lot of battles Canada participated in. These many battles made Canada a stronger nation that it is today. The battles that Canada participated in were; Battle of the Somme, Battle of Vimy Ridge, Battle of Second Ypres and Battle of Passchendaele. Out of these battles, the capture of Vimy Ridge by Canadian forces in World War 1 was the most significant moment in Canadian history.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It was one of the biggest turning points in the war; some say that this began the beginning of the end of half the war. Before the invasion of Normandy, the allies had to deceive the Nazis. Dwight D Eisenhower deserves a lot of credit for his role in the invasion. He tricked the Nazis into believing Pas-De-Calais was going to be the landing spot to start the invasion. Eisenhower and his troops went as far as deploying fake equipment, transmitting fake signals, and using a fake army. Once the allies had convinced the Nazis that the troops would be deployed in Pas-De-Calais, their next move was to deploy the actual troops in Normandy on June 5,1943. However, bad weather delayed their original plans by a day. On June 6, 1943 the allied troops were ready to surprise the Nazis. The allies successfully deployed 156,000 troops on June 6, and by June 11 they had 326,000 troops (both according to history.com). The Nazis were unprepared, their renowned commander Rommel was out on family leave during the invasion. So, Adolf Hitler commanded the Nazis instead; this proved to be fatal. Hitler was hesitant when choosing to make military moves. This led to the allies capturing Normandy and Cherbourg, a port. With 800,000 troops in Cherbourg, the allies continued their march down France. By August, the allies drove all of the Nazis out of Northeastern France. Because of this, Germany would no longer be able to build troops in order to…

    • 1971 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the night of August 18 1942, the allies set out 5,000 ships, 50,000 vehicles and 11,000 planes all in preparation for the coming battle the next day. With the help of the Canadians, British commandos and American rangers, they decide to bind together their military forces and take their plans into action when they surprised attack Germany at Dieppe, France. The goal was to attack a strongly defended port in Dieppe, guarded by top-notch and highly trained German soldiers. The Raid being Canada’s first involvement in World War II, not only did they intend to test Germany’s capabilities, but they saw it as an opportunity to put their allies to the test against Europe. Despite their hard efforts, many believe there were many different contributing…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    - All throughout Canada in the 20th Century there have been numerous events, actions, and decisions that we call defining moments. Canada has been through many battles, hard-chosen decisions, and changes that have changed the way Canadians live today. The second battle of Ypres, the life on the home front in World War Two, and the invasion of D-day helped enrich Canada with their contributions to food, fashion, religion, education, business, and politics. All these moments were significant for Canada and changed the way we Canadians live today.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vimy Ridge, a significant battle in Canadian history is worth the immense toll it took. The first reason why the lost lives were not all for naught, is that it constructed substantial evidence that Canada was militarily strong and intelligent. For instance, previous attempts by Britain and France to seize Vimy had failed but were conquered by Canadians in a matter of three days with thorough preparation and new strategies. This proved to other countries that Canada had its strengths and intelligence military wise and it increased Canada’s role in significance in World War I. Another reason why the battle at Vimy was worth the cost of lives it took, is that it introduced new strategic battle tactics. For example, the “creeping barrage” was an innovative tactic created by General Arthur Currie during the battle at Vimy. This new method of attack helped the Canadians capture Vimy and establish new ways of attack. Lastly, Vimy Ridge was worth the toll it took because it served as a step towards autonomy from the British Empire. For instance, Brigadier General Alex Ross claims, “I witnessed the birth of a nation.” The Canadians’ victory had showed its competence with independence as Canadians fought together as one nation rather than a dominion of the British Empire.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Colonial Attack Dbq 1775

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Inside Quebec the British had taken minimal casualties. The American troops had captured the city of Montreal on November 13th. Then early December they had joined the forces led by Arnold who had trekked through New England. During this battle and the siege on the city there had been French speaking Canadians on both sides.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Of 10 major battles, France won a majority of them. Their location was good. Canada was fortified with vast outworks of defense in the forests, marshes and mountains. They had the help of the Indians who knew the land far better than any European. In Europe, the tide turned for France and soon so did too in the Americas.…

    • 370 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Dieppe Raid

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Brian Villa’s article, “Unauthorized Action: Mountbatten and the Dieppe Raid” is, a factual recount of the events of the raid as they occurred. Throughout the article the author points out very few successes and many failures in the plan and as the raid progressed. Villa writes that the seed was planted for a plan to raid Dieppe when they realized that a number of small raids would not “scarcely satisfy the Soviet Union and the War Cabinet”. To compound the mistake, the 2nd Canadian Division was employed to form the majority of the attacking force. The Commander of the 2nd Canadian Division, J.H. Roberts, had served as a regimental commander in France. Neither he nor the men under him had seen combat and lacked the experience necessary to conduct the raid. Villa goes on to discuss the role of the Combined Operation Headquarters (COHQ) and the fact that it did not have the forces or the commanders for large operations. The COHQ was only one of many planners organizing the raid thus the plan became a “prescription for disaster.” The Canadian Commander relied on the “British advisors at COHQ and Home Force, whereas they thoroughly imbued with the principle of a commander’s veto, assumed that if Roberts…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The battle of Vimy Ridge started on April 9th, 1917 it is located in northern France with all four divisions of the Canadian corps attacking for the first time together. France attempted to take over Vimy Ridge but failed greatly with 100,000 dead. The planning and preparation were long, they spent the whole winter preparing they even made models of the trench system. A maze of underground tunnels was made to move troops and supplies safely and secretly.The plan was to have the troops closely follow a massive barrage of artillery fire on the German position. By doing this they gained the element of surprise.The Canadian troops were led by Lt.-General Sir Julian Byng and Major General Arthur Currie.Canadians won on the 9th and had control of the ridge by the 12th. This is an achievement because they lost in the battle of Somme and proved themselves in the battle of Vimy Ridge. They had better strategies like “leap frog” which was where they divided each other into 2 groups and while 1 fought the other rested and they switched back and forth. Canada’s military achievements during the war raised our international importance and helped earn us a separate signature on the Treaty of Versailles that ended the war. The biggest achievement is that they risked their lives for us to fight for us.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The allies even though they were surrounded by the German army still fought back and resisted even after the Belgian army surrendered (May 28). The Germans bombed and destroyed most of Dunkirk and its surrounding areas as they were kept a distance by the allies who had set a perimeter that slightly kept falling back until they got to Dunkirk where they were evacuated. Many allied troops died keeping the Germans out of Dunkirk but all these sacrifices helped save the life of approximately 338,000 men all these troops were saved in the span of 11 days, the Germans may have taken over Dunkirk but many allied troops were able to live another day and the evacuation also saved the British many soldiers who were able to fight another day. The battle of Dunkirk was important in WW2 because had the Germans sealed off and killed all those troops that were evacuated the whole momentum of the western front war would have gone to Germany. The Dunkirk evacuations moralized the British army as they didn’t suffer major defeat and were able to save the life’s of a lot of men. Had Germany killed all those men the outcome of the war on the…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “The Destruction of Convoy PQ17 27th June-10th July 1942” was written by Dr Milan Vego in 2015 and was published in the Naval War College Review in 2016. It is written from a military perspective, and records how, during the period 1941 to 1945, the Allies sent 42 eastbound escorted convoys and 36 westbound escorted convoys to and from the USSR port of Archangel. The convoys left from the East Coast of USA and from northern Scotland. In most instances, the convoys were escorted by destroyers and corvettes. However in the case of convoy PQ17, the escort did not keep up and British intelligence failed. When the weather cleared the Admiral of the British Navy realised the German military giant ship Tirpitz had left harbour. He concluded that it must be headed for Convoy PQ17 and based on contradictory information he gave an incoherent and unclear order to the boats in the convoy to “scatter”. In fact Tirpitz was not on its way to the convoy. The ensuing panic caused the ships in Convoy PD17 to flee in different directions. Many ships were sunk and many lives lost.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays