Preview

Victim from Birth Deaf Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
833 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Victim from Birth Deaf Essay
Eng 1a
5-23-13
Essay #1 In the article “Victims from birth” Wendy McElroy, ifeminists.com, is about Sharon Duchesneau and her deaf son named Gauvin. Duchesneau, being a lesbian, selected a sperm donor(along with her partner Candace McCullough). Duchesneau and McCullough are also deaf. The donor they selected was based on his family history of deafness to insure their son Gauvin would also be deaf. Duchesneau goes on to say that Gauvin “is not profoundly deaf… but deaf enough” (McElroy 1). Gauvin was born with slight ability hear to. Gauvin would be able to hear well enough to perform normal functions with help from a hearing aid. However, Duchesneau and McCullough made the decision not to supply a hearing aide for their son. McElroy states “A deaf lifestyle is a choice she [Deuchesneau] wishes to make for her son”(McElroy1). Duchesneau and McCullough acted inappropriately in withholding a hearing aid from Gauvin as he will face unnecessary limitations in his education, career, and social life. Gauvin will be faced with difficulties in his ability to learn through general education. The general education system is not set up to teach deaf children. The majority of students are not deaf. “[three] out of every 1,000 children are born deaf or hard-of-hearing every year” says Holley Heffley, R.N, in “Pediatric Cochlear Implants: Medical Miracle or Cultural Genocide?” Denying Gauvin a hearing aide hinders his ability to be taught by any teacher. Not ever teacher is capable of being able to communicate with a deaf child. The chances Gauvin will have to go further in his education are limited because he will not be able to hear. Deaf students are less likely to achieve successes in education compared to hearing students. As a deaf child, Gauvin will treated different through his schooling then other children. Being treated different effects people in a negative way. Ducheesneau and McCullough are putting Gauvin is a difficult situation by withholding a hearing
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Best Essays

    Yesterday and Today: Shaping The Hard of Hearing
    • 1511 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Yesterday and Today: Shaping The Hard of Hearing

    “Our greatest glory is not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.(“Brainy Quote)” -Confucious. The unique heritage of hard of hearing culture is very affluent and astonishing. Understanding the desires of others wanting to learn about the history behind the hearing impaired will come across critical events like the “Deaf President Now” movement that essentially granted Gallaudet University its first ever deaf president, learn about the expansion of personal hearing assistive technology past and present, read about the vicious segregation in schools for the deaf, and learn about the thousands of historical figures that were hard of hearing.…

    • 1511 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Comparing Carlin And Luczak's Poetry Analysis
    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Comparing Carlin And Luczak's Poetry Analysis

    Similarly, the Deaf child, however raised, has a Deaf heritage form birth. Most children who cannot communicate well in spoken language will, when allowed to, learn signed language, become acculturated to Deaf culture, marry Deaf, and identify themselves as members of the Deaf World. A distinguished otologist has contended that Deaf children start out in mainstream hearing society and enter the Deaf World in adolescence. Most children in the Deaf World cannot communicate with their parents who know no sign language, and while their home may be nurturing, it cannot be substantially acculturating. The anormality of having culturally different parents is then both a centrifugal and centripetal force in the Deaf World. At the same time, the anomaly propels Deaf people toward the Deaf World, since identification with the Deaf World offers pride, language, instruction, role models, a culturally compatible spouse, and more than cannot be had…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Reproductive Specialty Clinic Case Study
    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Reproductive Specialty Clinic Case Study

    Does it stop here or next do we start genetically modifying embryos so they are taller or smarter or faster. If genetic modifying is used too freely, many problems can arise. In some countries, couples may start to use it to select a certain gender, leading to an extremely uneven gender balance. The ethical side of this is that society strides for a “perfect society” and “perfect babies” and by genetically modifying babies it shows society’s intolerant attitude for the disabled. The disabled greatly resent the fact that people would genetically modify their child to fit society’s view. Society may feel that a deaf person may not led as fulfilling of a life as a hearing person. The disabled community is completely against this view. As it is, deaf students are a lot less likely than blind students to attempt to overcome their respective disability. The deaf students embrace their disability and immerse themselves into their surrounding and supportive community. Someone who is not a part of the deaf community cannot understand the deaf culture. This clinic believes that a hearing person is incapable of seeing this from a deaf persons perspective, while a deaf person is unable to see this from a hearing persons…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    American School For The Deaf Summary
    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages

    American School For The Deaf Summary

    In 1817, Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet, a Yale graduate and ordained clergyman, met the Dr. Mason Fitch Cogswell family and their deaf daughter, Alice. Embarking on a voyage to Europe to learn the art of educating deaf children. In Europe Gallaudet encountered the school for the deaf in Paris, France. He then enlisted Laurent Clerc, a talented deaf teacher to join back home to established the first permanent school for the deaf in the USA. The American School for the Deaf provides educational programs and services for deaf and hard-of-hearing students.…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Book Report Deaf Again
    • 1348 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Book Report Deaf Again

    Mark starts his story by talking about his mother’s natural birth. He was born in Pennsylvania to his deaf parents Don and Sherry Drolsbaugh. Mark was born able to hear and learned to talk and know a little how to sign because of his parents. This all changed when he was in first grade. Mark began to experience significant hearing loss. His grandparents were informed and Mark was taken to different doctors, audiologists, and speech pathologists to try to fix his deafness. Since Mark was not completely deaf, his grandparents held on tightly to what hearing and speech their grandson had left and to find ways to improve it. All the negativity that Mark dealt with towards being deaf, made him also feel negative towards his deafness. His Grandparents believed the way to improve Mark’s hearing was for him to keep attending school with children who could hear, because if he were to go to a school that would sign and help him accept his deafness it would “ruin” Mark’s chance at being able to be “fixed”. School was difficult for Mark because his classrooms contained more than twenty students and the information he had to learn would only go over his head. Mark would wear hearing aids, and because of this he was also ridiculed and made fun, because he was different. Mark would get into fights and have report cards saying that his behavior could be improved. Mark’s grandparents made a smart move and had Mark transfer to Plymouth Meeting Friends School, PMFS for short. It was a small school with two teachers and eight…

    • 1348 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Gm vs Ford
    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Gm vs Ford

    Initially a Deaf child’s journey begins with family and starts at birth but it’s not till the deafness is detected that important decisions start to be made. Interactions with the child are important as are the ways the child is interacted with. Choices have to be made by the family that will result in how a child is educated and socialized. These most important family influences can greatly help in positive development of the child or the lack of it. Some decisions that have substantial impact are: How will the child be educated? The choice between institutional and hearing schools. Should we opt for cochlear implants? These are just a couple many important decisions and choices that are made by the parents or caregivers.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Deaf President Now Movement Analysis
    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Deaf President Now Movement Analysis

    The Deaf President Now Movement at Gallaudet University was very interesting to watch. I never knew much about the movement until this ASL class, and I find this information to be important in learning history in the 1980’s. Now after researching information, the significance of the protest was definitely necessary for the deaf community/culture. In reading this article, I had never thought much about the deaf culture, even though I had seen deaf people in my work place. Looking back in time, I could not imagine what they could have possibly gone through protesting for their rights as deaf students, and how it must had affected them to fight for justice, when they should have been focusing on their education.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Cochlear Implant Culture
    • 1646 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Cochlear Implant Culture

    For example, when the cochlear implant first appeared on the market, it was met with indifference from the Deaf community members rather than the enthusiasm that medical professions expected. This was because they did not feel they were lacking and did not see the need of a prosthesis to effectively communicate (Blume 61). However, as the cochlear implant became more prominent, was approved for children, and was increasing implanted in deaf children born to hearing parents, there was greater dissent. For example, when one hearing mother approached the Deaf community considering implanting her child, “certain members of the deaf community…their feelings were so angry and so hurtful…[the parents] were called child abusers…and butchers” (Christiansen and Leigh 365). Through the perspective of the cultural view, this reaction is understandable. Deaf individuals feel a great sense belonging and pride in their culture like other cultural minority groups. To them, getting the implant would be denying the unknowing child the opportunity to be part of the Deaf culture. Additionally, their anger and opposition to a device with a goal to rid of deafness is not surprising. Many of them saw the cochlear implant as a step towards the “death of deafness” and the abolishment of their community and way of life (Christiansen and Leigh 368). Therefore, many of those holding the cultural view showed…

    • 1646 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Jerry Hassell
    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Jerry Hassell

    How the contemporary world indiscriminately treats deaf people like normal people is not a random incidence. This justly humanitarian treatment is a product of continued battle for Deaf recognition and rights in terms of education, communication, socialization, community, employment, etc. by influential people, some are deaf themselves, whose Deaf advocacy…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Sound And Fury Analysis
    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Sound And Fury Analysis

    I chose the documentary Sound and Fury as my topic. My current clinical practice area of interest is the family, and this film focuses on the aspects of the family. I am also interested in working with children, and I felt that choosing an ethical dilemma involving children might help me within my future practice. Although I have no history working with the deaf or people with cochlear implants, I found the concept to be very interesting. Sound and Fury allows us to look into the lives of the Artinian family. Peter and Nita are both deaf and their child, Heather, is deaf. Peter’s brothers name is Chris. Chris is married to Mary and they are both hearing. When their second set of twins is born, Peter III is deaf. Peter and Chris’ parents are…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    deaf culture
    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    deaf culture

    In order for a Deaf individual to rely solely on speech to communicate they must rely largely on amplification. Hearing aids or Cochlear implants are necessary for amplification. The majority of the Deaf Community has had a hard time accepting Cochlear implants in particular. These implants require extremely evasive surgery that can be done as early as under a year old. It is not hard to see why an optional surgery of this nature would cause controversy amongst Deaf and Hearing individuals alike. The Deaf Community has been more than open with their concerns about the surgery being performed at such a young age. This surgery has been done on children as young as under a year old. There are plenty of hearing people who find this type of extreme surgery in infants to be controversial as well. While the surgery amplifies the hearing of a Deaf person it is not a cure for Deafness. Cochlear implants have caused a wedge between those who chose to get them and those who do not. The Deaf Community feels that that the use of such implants will diminish Deaf Culture. Cochlear implants and hearing aids…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Cochlear Implants: Abstract Article
    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Cochlear Implants: Abstract Article

    In the article written by Robert Sparrow called, “Implants and Ethnocide: Learning from the Cochlear Implant Controversy,” the topic of cochlear implants is explored to a deeper level. This article takes the controversy a step further by bringing forward the question about genetic testing. Suggesting that if parents could have their unborn children tested for deafness, they would have a higher chance of getting an abortion and terminating the pregnancy. Furthermore, if people have this kind of attitude, members of society are molded into thinking and saying that perhaps people who are Deaf or have a hearing disability actually have something wrong with them, whereas people in the Deaf community embrace their culture and just see it as a part of who they are.…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Sociology and Disabilities
    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Sociology and Disabilities

    "If the technology became available for the deaf to hear completely, would you want your deaf child to have this technology?" It is every parent 's dream for their child to grow up healthy and happy. There are so many children in the world that do not have the ability to hear, and it is a horrible thing. Many would think it wrong for a parent to not want to give their child the gift of sight. If I had a child that was deaf, I would do everything in my power to help them get their hearing. If the technology was there to fix this disability, why wouldn 't anyone want their child to have it? "840 babies are born with a permanent hearing loss every year."(NDCS of UK). This is a horrible number to hear, that so many children will never be able to hear. If there was any technology able to restore a child 's hearing it would be a shame if the parents didn 't get it. "Deaf children face tremendous difficulties learning to read, write and communicate with the hearing world around them."(NDCS of UK). Not only would you be giving your child the gift of hearing by using this technology, but you will also help child to be able learn on the normal level of other children.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Deafness And Genetic Testing
    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Essay On Deafness And Genetic Testing

    Genetic engineering, or eugenics, is another proposed method of correcting Deafness which arouses much anger and controversy in the Deaf community. Deafness has a variety of root causes, and its genetics are complicated, but is known that for some people, it is caused by the gene connexin 26, as well as many other recessive, harder-to-trace genes (Leigh 49). Diagnostic testing of a Deaf or Hard of Hearing baby is becoming routine, but it is prenatal testing that inflames both the Deaf and Hearing communities. Genetic testing can determine whether a baby may be disabled, Deaf, or otherwise different, and can give parents the chance to make an informed decision about next steps. There are many examples of hearing people who wish only to have a hearing children, and Deaf people wishing to have…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Personal Narrative: My Hardships Of Being Deaf
    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Personal Narrative: My Hardships Of Being Deaf

    Would you pick which one would it be going blind or going deaf? That is a question everyone jokes about and say they would go blind for whatever reason or deaf for whatever reason. People never stopped to think about what if I did go deaf or blind. The world is a beautiful place with a lot of sights to see and a lot of sounds to hear. People go through a lot of hardships in life and they always had to prevail through the hardships. Their perseverance through the hardships inspires everyone to be who they are.My hardships in my left happen last year in Fall break when I lost my hearing in my left ear. I never let that get me down even tho it happened so quickly. I prevailed through it with making jokes about it, not acting any different with my friends and family, and to make sure to make people smile and myself along as well.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More

Related Topics