Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Vegetarians vs. Meat Eaters

Good Essays
1598 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Vegetarians vs. Meat Eaters
Vegetarians versus meat eaters According to Kathy Freston, the New York Times bestselling author of "The Lean, Veganist, and Quantum Wellness", vegetarians and vegans have significantly longer life expectancy. Based on doubtful studies and media claims, vegetarians are trying to push us eliminate meat from our diet. But there are other findings, which conclude that a vegetarian diet conferred no more benefit than a diet that included plenty of unrefined plant foods together with animal protein. According to a recent report on the largest study on vegetarians and vegans, they live an average 8 years longer than the general population. The study was based on our leading causes of death, such as heart disease, cholesterol level, cancer, stroke, COPD, Alzheimer disease, kidney failure, and depression. According to this study, all mentioned causes of death may be prevented or even treated using plant-based diet. Statistic from CDS (Centers for Disease control and Prevention) shows that heart disease is a leading cause of death in the United States. A long-term study on older women's health was recently published, showing that "consuming the amount of cholesterol found in just a single egg a day may cut woman's life short as much as smoking five cigarettes daily for fifteen years, whereas eating a daily cup of oatmeal's worth of fiber appears to extend a woman's life as much as four hours of jogging a week." (Freston, 2012). In this study dietary cholesterol intake (only found in animal foods) was associated with living a lot shorter life and fiber intake (only found in plant foods) was associated with living a much longer life. According to Dr. Dean Ornish heart disease could not be only stopped but even reversed with a vegan diet, arteries opened up without drugs or surgery. It is a known fact that high cholesterol levels cause a build-up of plaque in our arteries which leads to heart disease, but it is hard to believe that eating one egg a day can be as harmful as smoking five cigarettes daily for fifteen years. One chicken egg has about 186 mg of cholesterol and all of it is in the yolk. However recommended daily limit on cholesterol in your diet varies from person to person. If you are healthy, it is recommended that you limit your cholesterol intake to 300 milligrams a day, but if you have cardiovascular disease, diabetes, or high blood cholesterol level, you should limit your dietary cholesterol to less than 200 mg per day. According to Dr. Thomas Bechrenbeck, eating eggs can increase you cholesterol, but eating up to four eggs on a weekly basis hasn't been found to increase your risk of heart disease. So, if you decide to eat an egg it is important to limit other sources of cholesterol on that day. When it comes to meat, it is a similar story, you have to watch for how much you can eat daily, in order not to increase your cholesterol. Any kind of 8-oz. steak has about 200 mg of cholesterol, which is a recommended daily limit by The National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute. So if your consider eating meat, you should not eat more when 8-oz of lean meat on any given day and avoid any other foods, which can contain cholesterol. According to American Heart Association on occasional 8-oz. steak won't significantly impact your heart health, but frequent or large servings do make a difference. Second biggest cause of death is cancer. According to the study on the subject of diet and cancer, "the incidence of all cancers combined is lower among vegetarians." But there is a different study from 2006, which found no differences in "cancer rates between vegetarians and non-vegetarians." (Who's Healthier - Vegeterians or Meat Eaters?, 2012). However, same study showed that vegetarians have lower body mass index, lower cholesterol level, and they also had 20% fewer deaths from ischemic heart disease. The European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition-Oxford study showed that in the comparison of vegetarians with meat eaters and after adjustment for age, sex, and smoking, the incidence rate ratio for all malignant neoplasm's was 0.89, but the incidence rate ratio for colorectal cancer in vegetarians compared with meat eaters was 1.39. So even thou vegetarian diet have lover incidence in some type of cancer, it shows increased ratio for colorectal cancer. Third place takes Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD), which is one of the most common lung diseases. According to vegetarians COPD can be prevented or even treated with the help of plant-based diet. However, some of these results are not definitive, and in some cases so different to other research, that we need to compare them to the work of other researchers. For example, vegetarian activists claims that COPD can be prevented or even treated with the help of a plant-based diet. In order, to ever prove, or deny this theory we have to know what is COPD, what causes it, and how it can be treated. COPD is a lung disease, which makes it difficult to breathe. Smoking is a leading cause of COPD. The other risk factors of COPD are exposure to certain gases or fumes in the workplace, exposure to secondhand smoke and pollution, frequent use of open fire without proper ventilation. There is no cure for COPD, but there are medications to treat COPD, such as inhalers, inhaled steroids to reduce lung inflammation, anti-inflammatory medications, oxygen therapy, and in some cases antibiotics. According to A.D.A.M. medical encyclopedia there are some things you can do to make it easier for yourself and that include "eat a healthy diet with fish, poultry, or lean meat, as well as fruits and vegetables. If it is hard to keep your weight up, talk to a doctor or dietitian about eating foods with more calories." (PubMed Health, 2011). So, there is no facts proving that vegetarian diet helps to prevent or treat COPD, it is quite opposite - the diet suggested by doctors should be higher in calories and should include animal protein. CDC statistics puts stroke in the fourth place in the cause of death chart. The strokes can be prevented if our diet is rich with potassium-rich foods, such as green leafy vegetables, beans, and dates. Alzheimer's disease is sixth leading killer. Once again, vegetarians claims, that those who eat meat are three times more likely to have Alzheimer's disease compare to long-term vegetarians. Diabetes is the next cause of death on that list. They say that plant-based diets help to prevent, treat and even reverse Type 2 diabetes. The list goes on together with the reasons, why vegetarian diets are so good for your health. Let's take a look at some other researches on the subject of that topic. A Dutch review on this subject showed that vegetarian diet had no more benefit than a diet which included unprocessed plant foods, such as vegetables, fruits, and nuts, together with animal protein. Another study confirmed that vegetarian diets are associated with nutrient deficiencies, such as vitamin B12, iron, zinc and calcium. Red meat is well-known as an important dietary source of protein and essential nutrients including iron, zinc and vitamin B12. According to Alison J. McAfee, a significant amount of evidence supports the role of lean red meat as a positive moderator of lipid profiles with recent studies identifying it as a dietary source of the anti-inflammatory long chain (LC) n−3 PUFAs and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA). The moderate amount of lean red meat is a part of balanced diet, which positively influences nutrition intake and fatty acid profiles. One more study which showed positive correlation between meat eaters and healthiest population was conducted by a Slovakian research. This study showed that healthiest people of Northern Europe live in Iceland, Scandinavia and Switzerland populations, which consume a lot of animal protein. Based on all the different studies and reports everyone should have a choice to pick the right diet, which suites his/her needs. I do agree with Dr. James Lavelle, which states that vegetarians diets are healthier, but when it comes to overall mortality, there is no difference in vegetarians versus non-vegetarians. I think that vegetarians should not put so much emphasis on they believe that vegetarian diet is healthier compare to meat eaters, because vegetarian diet is not always healthy. Some vegetarians load up on foods like processed veggie burgers, processed veggie cheese, and other processed veggie-based foods. This kind of food would not give you nutritional benefits your body needs. So even if you pick vegetarian diet you still need to watch what you eat in order to be healthy. So what diet to pick? Some people follow a semi vegetarian diet — also called a flexitarian diet — which is primarily a plant-based diet but includes on occasion or in small quantities meat, dairy, eggs, poultry and fish. I believe that everything should be in moderation. We should eat more green leafy vegetables, fruits, legumes, and nuts, but limit grains and other starchy foods. Unprocessed animal protein, such as chicken, turkey and fish should be also included in the diet. Red meat should be included, but limited to a few 8-oz. portions per week. Diets, which uses a lot of unprocessed plant food together with a limited amount of animal protein provides long lusting health benefits like lowering BMI (body mass index) and cholesterol level. More plant based especially should be used for those with Diabetes.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    According to Alexandra Sifferlin and other scientists, “the saturated fat and cholesterol that clogs arteries, vegetarians may be at a lower risk for chronic diseases overall,” which then will decrease the chance of dying young (Sifferlin, “7 Reasons Vegetarians Live Longer”). Due to the fact that too much comsumption of meat can clog these systems, vegetarians decide to illiminate the entire food to be safe and consume other proteins instead. Another risk that will be lowered is heart disease. When the arteries are clogged in the heart, it can oftem stop working or even stop all together, and can also call for a heart transplant. Eating the right foods such as fruits and vegetables, can help any person better their chances and lowering the risk of having a bad heart. Later researchers decided to study the risk of different types of cancer in a vegetarian and realized that they had “ a low risk for cancer overall and discovered that a vegetarian diet may have protective benefits” (Sifferlin, “7 Reasons Vegetarians Live Longer”). Meat eaters have more of a risk of getting certain cancers due to what is in the meat and how it is used in the body. Being overweight can be a factor into any disease or cancer. How much a person weighs has to do sometimes with how much fat is on the body and when eating meat, an abundant amount of fat can be built up. People who are obese normally have a higher risk of getting diabetes which is what eating meat can cause. Being a vegetarian will not completely illiminate the risk of diabetes, but it will lower the chance of it happening. Overall being vegetarian has many benefits if that person gets enough nutrients and takes care of their body. As well as lower the risk of harmful things in the body, vegetarians also think about the treatment of animals and the cost of the meat…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first article I read talked about eggs helping you control a hunger. They claimed that eggs are healthier alternative to control your hunger. They did a study on a group od obese indiviuals who ate eggs with toast and low car jelly, and the second group ate a bagel with cream cheese and nonfat yogurt. Study showed that the group eating eggs was statisfied longer, which in return had them eating less. The second article I read talked about how eggs don’t affect your cholesterol. They had two diferent groups of healthy adults. The first group ate eggs for breakfast and the second group ate oatmeal. The study showed that eggs didn’t affect there cholestreal, it didn’t rise or lower it.…

    • 751 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    One major controversy in our country as well as other countries is what the preferable lifestyle diet is. Many dietary experts claims that one of the best lifestyle diets is the vegetarian diet. A vegetarian diet is defined as a person who does not eat or does not believe in the eating of animals, or in some cases, anything deriving from an animal. Usually with a person who is on a vegetarian diet, he or she will eat only foods from plants like vegetables and fruits. Research states that the reasons why vegetarianism is a superior life style choice is due to the fact that being a vegetarian allows a person to be healthy, stops pollution, saves animals, as well as saves money.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Everyday millions of people are consuming hazardous rations. Meat is consumed in huge amounts every year. The nutritional benefit of consuming less meat, body systems that are improved, and the horrors that are not discussed when meat production occurs will enlighten one and change lifelong choices. Vegetarianism contrary to popular belief is the healthier life style choice and one that will not be regretted.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Individuals that follow a vegetarian diets are at a subject to, “ lower blood cholesterol levels. Lower risk of heart disease, lower blood pressure, lower risk of hypertension, lower risk of type II diabetes, lower BMI (Body Mass Index) and can have an overall lower cancer rate”.…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This source is an interview with Nutrition Researcher Dr. Neal Bernard. He focuses on the vegetarian diet to be the healthiest overall. He recommended on vegan diet to be straight forward diet plan with no strict calorie counting or portion control because a vegan diet contains less calorie and could be helpful in losing weights. Infants, children, and adolescence, everybody can have lower risk of diabetes. Especially girls will have less risk of breast cancer later in life following a vegetarian diet.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vegan Diet vs. Paleo Diet

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Those who follow the Vegan diet, more commonly known as “vegans”, believe that people should not consume or use products made from animals. They think humans should coexist with animals and feel like an animal’s life should be treated with respect. For this reason, the diet is mostly plant based and the majority of vegans end up consuming fewer calories than normal. This has given the vegan diet a reputation as more of a weight loss plan ("Vegan Diet" par. 2) but some do it strictly for health (Forks Over Knives).…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vegan Diets

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Being vegan is a really challenging thing to do. It cuts out most of if not everyday food. It’s not just a way to eat but it’s a lifestyle choice. It affects what you wear, how you think, and what you buy. A lot of people have questions about this choice and why thousands of people all over the world are starting to become vegans. A new Oxford University study states that “Cutting your meat and dairy intake can improve your health—and quite possibly save your life.” People ask what the difference between a vegetarian and a vegan is. Vegetarian diets, which contain no meat (beef, pork, poultry, or fish and shellfish), are naturally low in saturated fat, high in fiber, and full of vitamins, minerals, and cancer-fighting compounds. A multitude of scientific studies have shown that vegetarian diets have remarkable health benefits and can help prevent certain diseases, such as cancer, diabetes, and heart disease. We encourage vegetarian diets as a way of improving general health and preventing diet-related illnesses. Vegan diets, contain no animal products (meat, dairy, eggs, or other animal products), are even healthier than vegetarian diets. Vegan diets contain no cholesterol and even less fat, saturated fat, and calories than vegetarian diets because they exclude dairy and eggs. Scientific research shows that health benefits increase as the amount of food from animal sources in the diet decreases, making vegan diets the healthiest overall. Another popular question is what do vegans eat? Vegan diets tend to be more colorful and varied than meat-based diets—vegans can enjoy just about every dish a meat-eater can by cooking with veggie burgers, "ham," "hot dogs," and "turkey" made out of soy and with less familiar staples such as tofu, tempeh, textured vegetable protein (TVP), and seitan, or wheat gluten. These can be added to spaghetti, soups, salads, lasagna, stir-fries, and chili. Many vegans take advantage of delicious ethnic cuisine, such as Chinese,…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Vegan: The new ethics of eating, Erik Marcus argues that a vegan diet is by far the healthiest, linking meat consumption to heart disease, cancer and obesity. Marcus…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With heart disease as the number-one cause of death in America, health experts are wondering how we can stop the epidemic of chronic diseases. Compared to a generation ago, the number of acute-disease’ deaths have fallen while the number of chronic-disease’ deaths have increased. With science and technological advancement in medical care, medical experts are able to find vaccines and medicines to prevent acute diseases, but the only way people can prevent chronic diseases is by changing their life style choices (Myers). While some Americans believe that an omnivorous diet that is balanced with consumption of both animal products and plants is better for your health, other Americans and I believe that a vegan/vegetarian diet is better for you in a westernized diet.…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Plants are rich in nutrients and vitamins and vegetarian eaters have a longer life span than the non-vegetarians. Plant kingdom is reach in, texture flavor and color. As Michael Pollan speaks of what Professor Joan Sabate, has researched “Sabate has done studies, comparing the longevity of both kinds of Adventists meat-eaters and vegetarians. He’s found that vegetarian Adventists live three to four years longer than non-vegetarian ones and six to nine years longer than the rest of us” (1:20:02-01:20:20). Meat should be eaten only in moderate amount and occasionally, as Michael Pollan depicts “Study shows that the more red meat you eat, the greater your risk of getting heart disease, diabetes and certain cancers” (01:16:09-01:16:17).…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eating Meat

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “If slaughterhouses had glass walls, everyone would be a vegetarian.” Paul McCartney stated in a video he made to motivate switching to vegetarianism. Like Paul McCartney, many people today are switching to a vegetarian or even vegan diet and with good reason. Environmentalists and scientists have shown, through extensive research, that meat industries are over-producing animal products, and in addition, are a major cause of environmental problems such as global warming and world hunger. Another good motive is the unimaginable cruelty these animals suffer, that represents torture one could never imagine for their own pets or peers. As importantly, being a vegetarian has numerous health benefits. Animal products contain bacteria and contaminants that have been shown to cause fatal illnesses. Cutting meat and animal by-products from your diet and adopting a vegan one is a healthy lifestyle choice because it can reduce a number of environmental impacts, it makes for a better ethical choice, and it can improve your personal health greatly.…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In a study completed in 2003, it was found that approximately 4% of Canadians follow a vegetarian diet (“American Dietetic Association,” 2003). This type of diet concentrates on the consumption of plants for food. The most common type is the lacto-ovo vegetarian diet, which restricts the intake of meat, poultry and fish, but allows the intake of eggs and dairy products (Vegetarian Diet, 2009). Many people become vegetarians because they feel it is wrong to kill or eat animals, but there are some that decide to follow a vegetarian diet because of its health benefits. One of these benefits includes attaining and maintaining a healthy body weight. Data has shown that people, who follow a vegetarian diet, are able to significantly improve their body weight. However, there are many risks associated with doing this. Despite the associated risks, it is believed that vegetarian diets are beneficial to weight loss as they improve overall biochemical, dietary and anthropometric measurements.…

    • 1987 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Vegans

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A. America has a meat-center diet and mainly because of that and the lack of exercise we are the fattest nation in the world. Obesity rates are increasing as well as the diseases that come with it. According to the American Diabetic Association 20.8 children and adults have diabetics, a disease that could be preventable or control with a healthy diet. And once again it endangers people’s health. The consumption of animal fats and proteins has been linked to heart disease, colon and lung cancer, osteoporosis, diabetes, kidney disease, hypertension, obesity and a number of other conditions.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vegetarian diets are based on cereals, whole grains, pulses, nuts, vegetables and fruits. Lacto-ovo-vegetarians do not consume any meat, poultry or fish but include eggs and dairy products in their diets. Vegans do not consume any food obtained from animals. Other vegetarian diets include fruitarians and macrobiotic diets that are more restricted. Reference to vegetarian diets usually implies lacto-ovo-vegetarians. A number of reasons can be attributed to preference for a vegetarian diet such as religious belief, economic status, personal health issues, environmental and ecological concerns. Vegetarian diets are typically higher in fiber, vitamin C and folate while lower in saturated fat and cholesterol. As can be expected a number of health benefits are attributed to vegetarian diet. Population studies have shown an inverse relation between vegetarian diet practices and incidence of cancer, cardiovascular disease and total mortality1. A number of epidemiological studies have demonstrated the low incidence of obesity, hypertension (high blood pressure) heart diseases, diabetes, cancer etc in vegetarians as compared to meat eaters. People who consume fish and other sea food also demonstrate some advantages of vegetarian diets. 2A 24% decrease in incidence of Ischemic heart disease (IHD) was found among vegetarians as compared to non- vegetarians. Plant foods, which are a good source of fiber, lower cholesterol levels, both low density lipoprotein (LDL) and total cholesterol levels. Lower rates of colon, prostate cancer and breast cancer are also observed in vegetarians. Phytochemicals are excellent anti-oxidants which act by metabolizing carcinogens in the body and lowering the incidence of cancer. Some other phytochemicals such as lignin and phytoestrogens in soy lower the incidence of hormone dependant cancers, such as prostate and breast cancer. This can explain the lower incidence of breast cancer in Asian women who consume soy…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics