Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Utilitarian Defense for Veganism

Good Essays
1623 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Utilitarian Defense for Veganism
A Utilitarian Defense for Veganism All around the world, the consumption of animal products, such as meat and milk, are common and accepted practices. The extreme diet of veganism is considered rare and outside of the social norm. To live a vegan lifestyle means refraining from eating meat, fish, dairy, honey, gelatin, and eggs. Those who take up this diet live in a world where they are considered outcasts and their diet is rarely accommodated for at restaurants, family gatherings, and so on. With these drawbacks, it can be questioned why anyone would be willing to give up the accepted, normal diet. Utilitarianism, a consequentialist ethical theory that concerns itself with happiness and the welfare of others, can account for why veganism is needed. If the vegan diet is more widely accepted and practiced, not only will less animals go through needless suffering, but the environment and people’s health will increase dramatically. Because of these reasons, veganism should be a custom everyone partakes in because it will increase the overall happiness for both animals and humans. The most basic question that needs to be addressed is why animals should be included in the moral community in the first place. They do not share the same psychological and complex lives as humans do, so to consider animals seems to be a little peculiar. Kant, a deontologist, offered a reason as to why animals should be considered in the moral community. For him, it is only because if a person has a cruel nature towards animals, the person is at risk to develop a cruel nature towards other humans. The reasoning behind Kant’s position has nothing to do with animals having any intrinsic worth or being able to experience pain or pleasure. Utilitarianism takes into account that animals can experience pleasure and plain, so therefore they must be included in the moral community. Quite different from Kant, Jeremy Bentham elaborates the utilitarian position by saying “the question is not, Can they reason? nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer?” (XXX). As noted earlier, animals are not the same as us; they lack the plans and projects that humans can create, they lack our rationality and all our higher faculties. Despite this, the utilitarian, including Bentham, recognize that animals do experience pain and pleasure. For this reason, because utilitarianism requires maximizing pleasure and happiness, animals must be included in our ethical thinking. Because animals are a part of the moral community and must be included in our ethical thinking, it must be examined how the demand for animal products is negatively affecting their wellbeing. Many had, or maybe some even still have, the idea that animals being raised humanely on factory farms. However, over the years, investigations that have been done raised awareness that this is not the case and this brief account will show just how. It is common that many of these factory animals never get to see sunlight or breathe fresh air until they are being sent for slaughter. In order to fatten them up and make them grow faster, these animals are fed drugs and hormones. They are also genetically altered to produce more milk or eggs than they naturally would. Due to growing much more quickly than they would in nature, it is not uncommon for them to cripple under their own weight. This can cause movement impossible, resulting in many deaths from the inability to reach food and water. Each species endures their own struggles inside factory farms. For example, cows are branded, their horns get cut or burned off, and the males are castrated. All of these happen without any anesthetics. Female cows are sent to dairy farms where they are repeatedly impregnated until their bodies give out and when this happens they are sent for slaughter. Another species that are raised in factory farms are turkeys. They naturally have a lifespan of up to ten years, however they are killed at five to six months of age. They are packed into tight spaces with each turkey having less than four square feet of space. Because this close confinement can cause them to scratch and peck at each other, portions of their beaks and toes are cut off with hot blades. Just like with cows, they are given no pain killers. It is only expected that if there was a way these animals are not kept in such horrible conditions if it would be okay to continue an animal product diet. If they can live a pleasure filled life, surely this would fit the utilitarian standard. They are not being harmed and to continue with the normal diet would be okay. This has already been done, according to the labels that are put on some animal products. It is becoming very common to see labels that claim the food is “free range” or “natural”. It is used to make the consumers feel like they are buying from a farm that is being humane to the animals being raised. However, this is not really the case. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) defines free range as “producers much demonstrate to the agency that the poultry has been allowed access to the outside”. Adopting a vegan diet will not only save animals from this fate and increase their happiness, but it will also increase human’s happiness. The environment is being damaged greatly to raise animals for slaughter. Thirty percent of the Earth’s land surface and seventy percent of all agricultural land is being used for livestock. Surely there could be a better way to use this land, such as growing more crops to feed humans. Also, seventy percent of all the grain and cereals that are grown are being fed to farmed animals. This means that not only could there be more crops being produced, but this seventy percent can be geared more towards humans consuming it. Not only would an animal-free diet provide more usable land, it would also help with the quality and supply of water. The animals raised for livestock produce about 130 times as much excrement as the entire population of the United States and, because there are no federal guidelines that regulate how factory farms treat, store, and dispose of animal excrement, the way they dispose of it causes water pollution along with destroying the top soil and contaminating the air. As noted in XXX, “meat alternatives would help to alleviate the global water crisis, since livestock production uses a tremendous amount of water” (FORBES). It takes more than 2,400 gallons of water to produce just one pound of meat while it only takes 25 gallons of water to produce one pound of wheat. Without the demand of meat, the supply of water would increase dramatically and could be used for other services. To go with a vegan diet would clearly solve a lot of the problems the environment is encountering. We would have more land that could be used in more productive ways and cleaner, larger supplies of water. Global warming is another environmental issue that is becoming more of an issue every year, and raising livestock largely accounts for why it is such an issue. What causes global warming is when greenhouse gases are released they trap solar energy which in turn warms the earth’s surface. Many put the blame on combustion of fossil fuels in cars and factories for why global warming is occurring. While this is the case, many do not see that factory farms play a huge role as well. Raising animals for food generates more greenhouse gases than all the cars and trucks in the world combined. A staggering fifty-seven percent of these gases are because of livestock and their byproducts. Also, to create room for factory farms means destroying forests. For example, it is the cause of seventy percent of deforestation in the Amazon region of Latin America. Not only does this cause harm to a ton of species, but this causes a release of carbon that was previously stored in the trees. The carbon that is released combines with oxygen, producing carbon dioxide. This allows more light energy in, and if enough of carbon dioxide is produce, it could raise the average temperature by almost three degrees Celsius. Although it does not seem like a lot, but this could be enough to melt glaciers, weather patterns, and other environmental disasters. If veganism were to be adopted, global warming would not be as big of an issue as it currently is because we would have no need to raise livestock. If we continue a diet that contains animal products, the environment is only being more damaged every single day. The Earth is our home and we need to take care of it. A world that is properly taken care of would increase happiness that may not seem so obvious at first, but in the long run global warming along with air pollution and water supply would be improved. A vegan diet would suffice for this, because there would be no need to raise a massive amount of livestock. Besides improving the environment, a diet free of animal products would help make everyone healthier. There have been enough studies to show that meat and any other forms of animal products is no good for the body. The normal diet of meat, eggs and dairy products is too high in cholesterol and saturated fats. This can cause a buildup of plaque in the arteries which in turn leads to blood flow to all areas of the body to be delayed. This can lead to health problems such as heart disease. Also, a diet that contains meat is associated with an increased risk for diabetes and certain cancers.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    People in today’s world are always looking for ways to stay healthy and be fit. It is very crucial to have a balanced diet so that disease is at a lower risk of appearing later in life, therefore, people in society have been creating diets geared towards their own interests. Two common forms of dieting are vegetarianism and carnivorism. Carnivores eat meat, while vegetarians substitute that protein for something else. Many tests comparing the two has proven that being vegetarian not only affects the body in a positive way, but is also good for the mind. Overall vegetarianism is a good way to stay healthy, have less risks of diseases, and help save resources here on Earth because of the harmful toxins from…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Animals from creation have been an essential integral part of human beings. They have frequently been, either directly or indirectly, used by humans to achieve their needs. Hence they are important part and great asset to humans. These animals do have lives different from that of humans and equally have some similar characteristics with humans like emotional feelings. This very fact puts humans in a difficult position of determining the amount of respect and regard that should be accorded to the animals. Some people agitate that animals should be granted same equal rights as human beings. Inasmuch as I quite agree that animals should be granted some rights in order to be free from cruel treatments by humans, the issue of granting them equal full rights as enjoyed by humans should not come up. An objective review of such factors as tradition, cultural believes, religious, socio-economic, and medical as well as salient natural features that distinguish animals from humans like morality, and ability to…

    • 1570 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animals Vs Vegetarianism

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Vegetarians do not eat any meat but still consume egg and dairy products. However, the egg and dairy industry may also raise their animals in poor conditions, even organic, free-range, or “certified humane” farms. The male infant laying hens “are invariably killed as soon as they have been sexed” because they have “no commercial value” (Mason and Singer 279). Price could still arise as an issue for many because similar to the free-range and certified humane meat, these types of eggs and dairy products are also generally more expensive. “Veganism is a sure way of completely avoiding participation in the abuse of farm animals” which is what Singer believes is the only sure way of avoiding the unethical implications of eating factory farmed food (Mason 279). Singer gives compelling evidence and asserts that going vegan, despite the other alternatives, is the only sure way to avoid taking part in the abuse of animals. Since vegans do not consume any animal based products at all, they completely ensure that they are not promoting the abuse of farm animals anywhere in the production process. He further maintains that no matter how drastic the change away from supporting the factory farming industry could be on the individual at first, not doing so simply because it is difficult is an unsound moral…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vegan Pros And Cons

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Veganism is a diet that refrains from the usage and consumption of animal products. As an increasing number of people become aware of the harsh treatment of animals on factory farms as well as the environmental consequences an increasing number of health-conscious, ethically conscious, and environmentally conscious people are becoming vegans. Thus, the vegan diet’s increasing popularity means that it is easier than ever to become a vegan and to find meat and dairy alternatives that make the vegan diet easier for some people who still crave specific animal products like cheese, milk, and meat.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animals deserve rights because just like humans, they feel excruciating pain, suffer and have feelings. One would argue that animals don’t experience emotions? But the answer is of course they do. It is emotions that allow animals to display various behavior patterns. According to the theory of utilitarianism, all sentient beings should be given consideration in the society and this includes both animals and humans. Also, animals cannot speak for themselves and for this reason they should be treated equally, protected and given the same respect as human beings. Peter singer’s approach also supports the argument on equal consideration in that animals deserve the same respect as human beings but just in a different view. In today’s society humans exploit animals for milk, meat, fur, scientific experimentation etc. and animals are constantly injured or killed. Their pain and sufferings should be taken into consideration, as this unjust treatment is morally unacceptable. Similarly speciesism is an…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immanuel Kant Analysis

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Talking about animals and how ethics is applied to them is something that varies greatly depending on which philosopher you’re talking to. Some philosophers state that humans are superior to animals based on the fact that humans can use reason to make choices, while animals default to their instincts for their choices. This would mean that animals are merely instrumental to humans and can be used to serve the needs of humans in any way they see fit. Kant doesn’t differ much on how he thinks about animal mainly because Kant believes that good will is the only inherit good and as animals do not have good will they naturally don’t share the same values as humans, but were Kant differs is in how he thinks the treatment of animals effects humans as Kant stated, “With regard to the animate but non-rational part of creation, violent and cruel treatment of animals is far more intimately opposed to a human being’s duty to himself, and he has a duty to refrain from this; for it dulls his shared feeling of their suffering and so weakens and gradually uproots a natural predisposition that is very serviceable to morality in one’s relation with other men.” When comparing these ideas of ethics on animals with Kant’s ideas of how ethics are applied to animals we can see the…

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How can one person can save 33,000 gallons of water a month? Some may say it is impossible, but the answer is simple - vegetarianism. A vegetarian is a person who does not eat meat of any kind. There are many reasons a person may decide to go vegetarian including ethical, health, or environmental. Vegetarians can be traced back into early history but, in today’s world, vegetarianism is on the rise as a concern for climate change is too. Major portions of the population are taking a stance against meat producing industries and changing their diets. Meat production is a huge contributor to pollution and climate change. Eating meat can also have a toll on one’s health. In order to change the course of rapid climate change, the population has…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is Veganism? According to Dave Gil and De Rubio veganism is “an extension of vegetarianism that avoids all animal products, including dairy, eggs, fur, leather, wool, down, and cosmetics or chemical products tested on animals”(1). People are vegan for many different reasons some being religious reasons, personal reasons, ethical reasons or other people who believe it is better for the environment and human health. For me, being vegan is more about the benefits for the environment and for the health of the humans. Veganism has a huge benefit on the environment and on human health. The humans who do not sustain the vegan lifestyle could very well be taking down the planet one hamburger at a time. Therefore, it could be correct to say that being vegan is the solution to creating a brighter and more sustainable future for the existence of human life on Earth.…

    • 2018 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Omnivore Diet Benefits

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Industrial farmers appear to be more concerned with massive profit margins, than they do with producing quality food in providing meat and vegetables: “The cruelty of the factory farms—the cages are small, the slaughter is violent” (Foer 67). Spiritually, I cannot tolerate the brutal methods of animal treatment, which industrial ranchers and meat producers tend to follow in the 21st century. Therefore, it is important to follow an ethical version of the Standard American Diet, which provide the healthiest and most ethical production of food for human health. I believe that all living things should be treated with respect and reverence for what they provide, which sustains my own life through the sacrifice of their own. These are important aspects of the omnivore diet, which can be sustainable in the modern world. I follow a code of ethics in terms of how animals should be processed for consumption. The problem with eating meat is not necessarily eating the meat itself; it is respecting that another life form has given me life. This is why I support organically produced foods that will be processed through ethical farming methods within the general framework of the Standard American…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From pollution and climate change to protection against major diseases, such as Cancer, Type II Diabetes, and Obesity, all of them major concerns in the 21st century(Curfman, 2009). Trying to find a cure in medicine and not succeeding, well what if medicine is the wrong way to go when trying to find cures ? Mother nature has the ability to give us all kinds of cures, it’s been used for thousands of years for healing and relieving our suffering. Even with all of the advances in 21st century medicine and knowledge, we still have all these problems in the world(Strumillo). However, we as a community have the power in our hands to change and reduce all of our world problems. Most of our health problems come from how our diets have become so poor in nutrients and quality. When walking in a fast food…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Meat vs. Vegan

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Sunaura and Andrew Taylor’s “Is It Possible to Be a Conscientious Meat Eater?” is an informative essay about the dirty side of the meat industry. They speak out of the physical abuse and poor living conditions endured by animals raised solely for the purpose of consumption. Because of the inhumane treatment towards animals, Taylor talks about a vegan solution and the many benefits associated with it. Animal cruelty is a sensitive topic that readers can easily be persuaded to either side. But, for the purpose of this essay, the reader can be swayed towards being a conscientious consumer. As mentioned already, animal rights and veganism will be discussed.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Everyday millions of people are consuming hazardous rations. Meat is consumed in huge amounts every year. The nutritional benefit of consuming less meat, body systems that are improved, and the horrors that are not discussed when meat production occurs will enlighten one and change lifelong choices. Vegetarianism contrary to popular belief is the healthier life style choice and one that will not be regretted.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Although animal moral considerability has peaked the interest of many contemporary philosophers, such as James Rachels and Peter Singer, the question is really an age-old question that can be traced back to Plato and Aristotle. Immanuel Kant has probed the question of whether an animal has moral considerability. Kant continuously makes the distinction between humans and animals throughout his best-known contributions to moral philosophy. Therefore, I will address and present the counter-argument to the charge of speciesism, one of critical arguments of the animal rights movement, through a Kantian lens.…

    • 1830 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are multiple arguments for or against weather we should eat animals or not. On one side there is the argument that we should exploit animals for food because we need it to survive and make us happy. On the other hand some people are completely against exploiting animals and say that we should treat them just like we treat other human beings. And finally there are people in the middle who agree that for some things like food we need to exploit animals but for other things like experiments or amusement we should not. I will show you the arguments of the three sides and how utilitarianism is relevant within them in the paragraphs to come.…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vegan Diet vs. Paleo Diet

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Those who follow the Vegan diet, more commonly known as “vegans”, believe that people should not consume or use products made from animals. They think humans should coexist with animals and feel like an animal’s life should be treated with respect. For this reason, the diet is mostly plant based and the majority of vegans end up consuming fewer calories than normal. This has given the vegan diet a reputation as more of a weight loss plan ("Vegan Diet" par. 2) but some do it strictly for health (Forks Over Knives).…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays