Preview

Under The Persimmon Tree Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
680 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Under The Persimmon Tree Analysis
Imagine the experience of living under the rule of a violent group of terrorists, with no freedom whatsoever. This is what it is like to Najmah in the book Under the Persimmon Tree, by Suzanne Fisher Staples. In this realistic setting, Najmah, the main character, loses most of her family due to the brutality and imposition of the Taliban. The novel depicted the Taliban as dangerous and strict, which is interchangeable for what the Taliban is like in reality. Staples used the Taliban conflict to deepen the reader's understanding of the impact of conflict on people's lives. In the novel Under the Persimmon Tree, the Taliban is accurately shown as destructive, forceful, and extremely strict. Najmah, along with many other Afghanistan and Pakistan inhabitants, are terrified of the Taliban because of, “how they lock the people of entire villages inside their houses and burn them to the ground,” (Staples 12). She also knows “how they slaughter men like goats, slitting them open and leaving their blood to soak into the ground,” (12). To inform her reader of how dangerous the Taliban is, Staples rightly depicts the Taliban as highly murderous. But not only that. Additionally, Najmah …show more content…
They took Najmah’s brother, Nur, and her father, Baba-jan, away from her to, “come and fight with the Taliban,” (Staples 17). Not only that, but when Najmah finds her mother, Mada-jan, after a bomb was set off by the Taliban in Golestan, “she stares with glassy, dead eyes,” (67). Habib, “lies motionless a few feet behind her, facedown in the dirt,” (67). The bomb killed both her mother and brother, not to mention destroyed her home. These events led to the conflict of Najmah being all alone with nowhere to turn. If, in the novel, the Taliban was not depicted as being so violent, then there would be little to no conflict remaining in Najmah’s

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Afghanistan is a country full of war and depression, a place where no child should grow up in. Oppression and restriction are displayed when Mahtab explains what she is experiencing during her long trip on the painful truck. ‘She rubbed her freezing hands together and pressed them into her mouth, sucking the life back into them…all she could taste was diesel and dust.’ Also the personification is presented with Mahtab desires (‘Mahtab wanted to…yell as if her heart and lungs would burst. But her throat was a closed and choking trapdoor.’) Mahtabs pain and needs demonstrates how her childhood is presented in the novel and the challenges she will have to face. In one passage in the novel, Mahtab’s father was to leave his family and to give a major role to Mahtab, which is responsibility; to help her mother while father is…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Najmah now must become strong both, mentally and physically to protect them from the Taliban. (STEWE-2) Najmah thinks of the words of her father as she thinks that her mother and Habib would be in danger, “I get up and walk silently on the balls of my feet to the wall at the end of the house, where I left Baba-Jan’s large, curved knife that I use to cut wheat and grass. I creep to the purdah with it clutched in my hand and push aside the curtain just far enough to see Uncle Mohiuddin standing with his back to the house” (Staples 57-58). Najmah feels…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    (AGG) There are many accidental deaths, bombings, raids, shots fired, etc. today that have changed people forever, for the best or for the worst.(BS-1) In the book Under The Persimmon Tree, nonfiction usage of American Involvement leaves main characters with traumatic memories and anxiety. (BS-2) These symptoms become the root of internal character conflict and change. (BS-3) Since the characters were forced to deal with their conflicts, they were able to learn and grow from their experiences.(TS) It is clear that the author uses non fiction topics to create an environment of danger, which shapes character change.…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The political discourse and historical tragedies that affect a country can cause turmoil in the lives of the citizens that reside there. The people of Afghanistan have been forced to cope with the chaos of their country which has left them traumatized and inconvenienced. In the novel, The Kite Runner, each character has their lives drastically changed as the events of Afghanistan's past world issues create hardship, grief, and difference for the lives of Amir, Sohrab and Farid.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Afghanistan’s troubled times resulted in the Taliban’s takeover and the suffering of the Afghan people which would challenge the people to face great adversity in the time to come. The characters would have to seek redemption despite the circumstances in Afghanistan and its society’s standards. In the books A Thousand Splendid Suns and The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini betrayal allows the theme of redemption and self-sacrifice as well as the perseverance in the face of adversity to develop, these themes are shown through the characters Amir and Miriam.…

    • 89 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book the Taliban, affects Najmah and Nusrat and causes their lives to become more chaotic. They cause…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Najmah had been through many things in the book the Taliban always had an impact on what she was going to do next. " I sit in the dirt besides them quietly, not crying ,not thinking ,not even aware that I am breathing. I must have sat for a long time although I have no recollection of the time passing" (62). If Najmah does not have a mother then she must go and travel alone to find her brother and father. This makes it harder for her because the Taliban ruined her family now she realizes that all of the things that her and her brother have seen shocking, "suddenly I realize that the things Nur and I have seen these past three months make us many ages older because the world we knew has come to an end" (252). Najmah soon turns to remember and think about her family "I retreat into thought of my father and brother wondering where they are wetsuit they have died or if the Taliban force them to kill people " (staples). These people have suffered through so much because of the Taliban they have had gruesome experiences and lost almost all their family…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As I read the first two pages of chapter twenty I pictured what Amir had witnessed and felt an overwhelming feelings of empathy, sorrow and gratefulness that I would mostly never have to see that in my life and how when he walked through his old neighborhood all his old memories would forever be haunted by ruined and death ridden place he once called home. This is another window that shows the reader another daily event Afghan’s witnessed walking through there own or old neighborhoods. For example it said, “I had a friend there once,’ Farid said ‘he was a very good bicycle repairman. He played the tabla well too. Then Taliban killed him and his family and burned the village.” This quote was an example of one of the several thousand Afghan’s who have seen or heard of family, friends or neighbors killed by the Taliban for a plethora of unknown reasons. This two pages reveal to the audience one out of plenty troubling and horrendous ordeals that people dealt with for possible all their lives living in Afghanistan after the war.…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Change In Najmah's Life

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages

    (STEWE-1) Najmah’s uncle is a horrible person and wants her parents land. “I hate him for thinking my mother and I would run away, so that he might steal our land”(Staples 59). Clearly the uncle is not here to help because he just wants their precious land. (STEWE-2) When Baba-jan was taken away he wished for Najmah to keep the land. “It was our father's last wish that we should keep our farm from the hands of the Taliban or Uncle. It is where our fathers bore them made their lives, and it is our duty to make our life there and the lives of our children and children's children”(Staples 256). Clearly going back to their land in Golestan is the right choice not just because her father asked her to but the land has been used by generations of her family. (SIP-B) Nur returns and now that Najmah has a male she can claim the land. (STEWE-1) When nur return obviously Najmah’s first wonder was if Baba-jan is alive or not even though she has a feeling on what the answer will be. “Baba-jan is dead,” he says softly, his voice cracking. I knew he would say these words before they formed in his mouth”(Staples 253). In Nur’s return Najmah finds out that Baba-jan is gone but at the same time she feels relieved that she won’t have to go on with…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Under the Persimmon Tree the author Suzanne Fisher Staples shows how cruel the Taliban can be. With the murdering, stealing, and ruining lives, Najmah’s life is ruined by the Taliban when they take her father and brother. “‘To repay us for having helped our enemy, you must come and fight with the Taliban.’” (Page 17). Because the Taliban has taken most of her family, Najmah’s…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    (AGG) The author of “Under The Persimmon Tree” often uses symbolism throughout the book. (BS-1) The author of UTPT uses the stars to give Najmah a superstitious belief, and give her hope and guidance to drive her towards her goals. (BS-2) The stars are used to help Nusrat accept loss, she looks to them for hope and guidance, and they have a religious meaning to her. (BS-3) The author uses changes in the stars to convey events and changes in Najmah’s life. (TS) The stars are used to portray changes in the characters lives, and the author uses them to give the characters hope, guidance, and an important meaning, as well as the ability to deal with loss.…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Under The Persimmon Tree

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Taliban have created a war in their homeland, which in turn causes civilians to pay for their behavior, as “many people have been killed by American bombs” (Staples 172). The Americans have no choice but to bomb these areas to protect their own citizens, and sometimes civilians might get in the way. The lives of innocent Afghans have been ruined and “you can tell by looking at them that they have no food and little clean water, all they live on is dreams of their farms, which no longer exist” (Staples 186). The Taliban are greedy and have no feelings towards people other than themselves. Rumors have been spreading around villages that “they lock the people of entire villages inside their houses and burn them down and how they slaughter men like goats” (Staples 12). These terrible acts have turned lives upside down and brought havoc upon a once peaceful place. The people are constantly abused by the Taliban, and “many are missing a hand or a foot or an eye. So many of them have terrible wounds or scars” (Staples 185/186). The way the Taliban treat women is disappointing. Najmah has heard how they “whip women whose shoes make a sound on paving stone" (Staples 180). The Taliban have scared the women so much that they "hide their bangles away because if they're caught wearing any jewelry it will be stolen and they will be beaten” (Staples 180).…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children of the Taliban

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Because these people have been living daily with war, many of them have become accustomed to the sound of explosions and gunfire. For example, when the children were being interviewed, gunshots and bombs went off, yet the two little girls were completely calm. Depending on their influence, people either begin to grow resentment for the Taliban, the Pakistani government, or the United States. When civilians get hurt from U.S. missile strikes, the Taliban use the aftermath to recruit…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Long ago, people used to live peacefully without any bothersome or uneasy feelings, but since the Taliban came, a large number have been pinned down on with the most arrogant threats. In the novel Under the Persimmon Tree, the treatment of characters presented by the author is so difficult to ponder sympathetically about, since it is beyond worse than imagined.…

    • 60 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Taliban Essay Example

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As I started to think about what aspect of terrorism I wanted to write a paper on, it occurred to me that I didn't really know much about the Taliban group. Which is one of the major terrorist groups in today's society. So I am going to try and explain this group the best that I can. In couple different aspects, one is what their rules are, two how they treat women, and three what types of terrorist acts they have committed. The Taliban group is a group of men who formed in 1994 in the country of Kandahar by Islamic students who took a radical approach to interpreting Islam. The Group also believes in strict Islamic rules. According to them the men must have beards four fingers in length, there shall be no music, Nintendo, and women should not be allowed to do anything other than stay home and watch the children and clean the house. This Taliban group when first started had about twenty to thirty thousand men involved. The group now controls about 80% or two thirds of Afghanistan land. Prior to the war no one other than the NMA (Northern Military Alliance) has really put up a fight or even thought about taking down the Taliban. The only thing that has challenged the Taliban group is the Northern Military Alliance and the only positive gain they have had was to keep their one-third part of Afghanistan. The only thing left to do for the Afghan people is either to give in to the dominating Taliban group or turn to the NMA and help get their country back to the pre-Communist era that it was before the Taliban group took over.…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays