Preview

Two Kinds By Amy Tan Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
883 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Two Kinds By Amy Tan Analysis
Mother Knows Best Have you ever wondered why parents often force their children to do things that their children feel are either unnecessary for their age level? One narrator feels the same way when she complains to her mother, “You want me to be someone that i'm not”(Tan 231). In the story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan, a daughter explains the obstacles she has conquered in her childhood. In this story, Jing-mei, the protagonist has a rough and complicated relationship with her mother. Her mother has always wanted her daughter to be a prodigy. However, Jing-mei claims that she is not and will never be the extremely intelligent and talented daughter her mother saw in her. After a careful analysis of the story, the reader understands how Jing-mei’s …show more content…
After Jing-mei finally accepts the fact that she could have been something incredible, there is a sense of guilt and despair. The narrator adds, “It looked more difficult than I remembered. I played a few bars, surprised at how easily the notes came back to me”(Tan 233). Jing-mei now figures out that this is something that she has always had a talent for. Playing the piano was Jing-mei’s purpose, she had took far too long to open her eyes and see the opportunity that she could portray. It was not until the narrator reached thirty that she accepted that she could be something great but the opportunity passed her up before she knew it. Before her mother died, she have Jing-mei the same piano from when she was younger. The protagonist is shocked and does not want to accept the gift, she believes that her parents would miss it. Jing-mei questions, “Are you sure? I mean i wouldn’t want you and dad to miss it?”(Tan 232). Jing-mei is puzzled that her parents are wanting her to have the piano. For Jing mei to realize her talent, it had to be done the hard way. Overall, the feelings Jing-mei has towards her mother have changed which is what makes this story so intriguing. There is a lesson in this story that should be recognized. We often believe that our mothers push us to work so hard only to aggravate or bother us. The truth is, there is reasoning behind all of this. One young lady unfortunately did not realize this until it was too late. With this, she faced the sad outcome and the knowing that all along her mother's hopes and dreams died with her. Mother knows

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The story Two Kinds is about a Chinese girl, Jing-Mei, who lives life trying to find herself under her over-bearing mother’s envisions and high expectations of what she feels Jing-Mei should become. The subject of the mother-daughter dynamic and lack of obedience is revealed from the beginning of the story; as well as the fact their relationship is rather conflicted. Throughout the story Jing-Mei is very obstructive to the ideas her mom puts forth. Her constant acts of disobeying and rebelling against her mom orders, express how the tension arose between Jing-Mei and her mom. The fact her mom had an extremely difficult life in China until she lost everything and moved to America, explains and sort of justifies why she was so obsessed with Jing-Mei excelling and making something of her, life in addition to her desire of wanting to be able to brag. Unfortunately, rather than allowing Jing-Mei to find something she was comfortable with and make an independent decision of what she wanted in her life, she forced activities and ideas on her which eventually resulted in Jing-Mei becoming rebellious. As Jing-Mei became rebellious, her mom implemented her…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    <br>At the talent show, Jing-Mei's practicing habits show, and she truly learns what her mother wants. She was supposed to play "Pleading Child." In getting ready for the show, Jing-Mei would cheat and never really listen to what she was playing. When it came to the recital, Jing-Mei was so confident that she could pull it off that she started hitting wrong notes and realizing it. She had felt her mother's shame. As a result of the talent show massacre, Jing-Mei didn't want to play the piano anymore. Then, when her mother wants her to practice, she decides that she defiantly won't.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the short story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan, with the use of epiphany and turning points the reader is able to see the protagonist’s growth and change in personality throughout the story. The protagonist, Jing-Mei and her mother emigrated from China to the US, thus the family struggled in adapting to the new culture and lifestyle. Heavily influenced by the opportunities and hopes with a new life in US, Jing-Mei’s mother wanted Jing-Mei to become a prodigy like the other girls on television. Jing-Mei was determined and eager to prove to her mother she was a prodigy, and thereby had full confidence in herself. She believed “[her] mother and father would adore [her and she’d be] beyond reproach.” (pg4). As Jing-Mei’s mother quizzed Jing-Mei with countless questions and tests, Jing-Mei started getting frustrated by her mother’s disappointments and “something inside [her] began to die” (pg 5).…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Then her mother was watching The Ed Sullivan Show on TV one day, her mother was fascinated by the music that she was hearing form the Chinese girl that was playing a piano. Jing-nei was not worried she knew they did not have a piano and they could not afford to buy one. Few days after watching the little girl play on TV, Jing-nei’s mother told her she would be taking piano lessons and piano practice. When her mother told her this, she felt as though she had been sent to hell. Jing-nei ask her mother why she didn’t like her for the way she was? She was not a genius, and she couldn’t play the piano. She told her mother even if she could, she wouldn’t go on TV if they paid her a million dollars Her mother told her she wanted her to be her best (Kirszner, Mandell,…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She does not have the mindset of trying to fix the relationship between her and her daughter. The daughter, in this case ,Amy Tan, feels like her mother pressures her into something she does not want. The daughter cries, “You want me to be something that I’m not” (Tan 141-142). Tan tries to tell her mother she does not want to act like the traditional Chinese obedient daughter. In contrast, the mother feels there is only one way. Her daughter must act like the traditional obedient daughter. Her mother counteracts, “Only one kind of daughter can live in this house. Obedient daughter ”(Tan 141-142). The mother gives her daughter no other option. This creates even more tension between the mother and daughter. The mother does nothing to try and compile with her daughter’s commands. Tan exemplifies the tone of hopelessness and bitterness with her mother. To conclude, this relationship contains no characteristics of a successful mother-daughter relationship. Therefore, the tension between the two will forever be evident and the relationship might never be resolved.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “How could I resist?” she later said about that day. It was when everyone was fleeing when the Japanese were taking over Kweilin, and we were left on the side of the road. Mei Ching, and her husband were poor at the time, but they still picked us up off of the side of the road. Although, there was writing on the back of the photo, Mei Ching and Mei Han could not read. By the time someone was able to read the note to them, they had already grown to love us. Instead of taking us to the address on the back of the photo, they took care of us. She told us that we were born into a great family, and that she was going to take us back to see our real mom and grandparents. She showed us the picture of our parents. My sister Chwun Hwa and I felt an immediate connection to our parents.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After Jing Mei and her mother both gave up on Jing Mei becoming a prodigy, her mother told her that she “could been genius…” and that she “just not trying…” (Tan, 143). This shows that all that time the Jing Mei thought her mother wanted her to be something different than what she was, she really just wanted her to try and do her best at everything she could. Though she went about it the wrong way, Jing Mei’s mother always meant well. A similar problem occurs with Mike and his father Billy in Friday Night Lights. Mike’s father treasured Mike more than anything, even his brother tells him that he was “the most special thing in his life” (Bissinger, 74). Billy always pushed Mike to be his best, telling him he had to go to college, and how much he wanted him to play for Permian. After Billy’s death, however, Mike wanted to leave Odessa, and Joe Bill talked him out of it, using the “power of Permian football” (Bissinger, 74) to make him stay. This shows that where Mike found his father’s wishes a tough thing to do, Billy always meant well. Mike stressed over trying to make his father proud, but all Billy really wanted to do is give Mike incentive to trying to be…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once one becomes part of the parents only club, one is expected to make the right decisions for one's child. Which is, giving one's child a chance at every possibility to obtain success. But, how much of it is truly for one's child and how much is for one's own personal fulfillment? In the short story by Amy Tran ‘Two kinds” we see into the life of a young Chinese American and her mother, who wishes for nothing less than her daughter to be a protege. As readers learn about how Mother goes about with this desire, one comes to question her motives. Does she want this because she believes this is truly what her daughter needs or, does she want this for herself, in order to fill a void left by her past? This selfish desire causes a clash between mother and daughter.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This story shows the struggling relationship between mother and daughter. Although the mother wants the daughter to be a great prodigy, the daughter wants to be her own person with her own personality.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The mother of Jing-mei had high hopes for her daughter in Amy Tan’s essay “Two Kinds” to become a prodigy when coming here in America. Tan states, “My mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in America” (pg.18, paragraph 1) that since they’re in America her mother aims for Jing-mei to be a successful prodigy. Her mother had lost everything back in China and starts a new life in San Francisco with Jing-mei and make her an actress in the beginning. Tan also states, “.. I was excited as my mother, maybe even more so.” (pg.19, paragraph 8) this conveys that Jing-mei was also very hopeful in the beginning of her mother’s idea of becoming a prodigy. Later in this essay, Her mother had ventured talents for Jing-mei to become a girl…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    These unattainable dreams often make the children feel inferior and breeds anger that causes them to reject the parent’s pressure. In the novel The Joy Luck Club, Suyuan Woo is constantly finding ways to test her daughter, Jing-Mei’s, abilities. These tests ranged from memorizing state capitals in a set amount of time to performing complicated multiplication problems in her head or memorizing an entire page from the bible in three minutes. The mother forced test after test on her daughter with high expectations. After one particular test failure, Jing-Mei could see her mother’s disappointment. This upset Jing-Mei to the point, where as she put it after crying in front of a mirror “The girl staring back at me was angry, powerful” (Tan 134). Mrs. Woo had pushed her daughter to such a state of anger Jing- Mei told herself “I won’t let her change me, I promised myself. I won’t be what I’m not” (Tan 134). By the time Mrs. Woo requested her daughter to learn to play the piano, a skill she could have learned through time, Jing- Mei was already in the mindset she would not do anything her mother asked. This rebellion is what happens when a parent places too much pressure on their child often leading to failure as the child refuses to conform to their parent’s…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan tells of the main character Jing-mei Woo’s childhood and the effects of her mother’s high expectations for her life. In…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Belonging Trial Paper

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Furthermore, as she comes to the realization of her connection to Chinese culture. The use of irony “but today I realize what it means to be Chinese. I am 36 years old. My mother is dead and I am on a train… I am going to China” exhibits her attempts to rekindle her ties with her culture. There is a sense of isolation evident as her mother was her last correlation to her heritage and in order…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Joy Luck Club Identity

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Suyuan had to make the hard decision to leave her twin babies on the side of the road in hopes some kind stranger would take them in, that way she would not have to see them die. Suyuan searches for her babies all through her life in America, sending multitudes of letters; they finally get in touch with her two months after she has died. Because her mother is not alive to meet her children, Jing Mei takes her place and the trip enables her to finally recognize her Chinese ancestry. The minute she enters China she "feels different" and can realize that she is "becoming Chinese" (306). At fifteen Jing Mei believed she was only as Chinese as her "Caucasian friends" (306). Yet her mother counters thoughts, telling her: "Once you are born Chinese, you cannot help but feel and think Chinese" (306). Once in China Jing Mei decides her mother was right and she "has never really known what it meant to be Chinese" (307). She has never understood her mother or her heritage. This trip is the connecting link to understanding her life. She begins to feel natural in China, thinking to herself on the train: "I am in China… It feels right" (312). Jing Mei sees the landscape, the people, the histories, and the families in China and sees where her mother was speaking from all of those years. She knows a "little percent" of her mother know (15). It becomes "obvious" to Jing Mei to see what "part of [her] is Chinese"; it is "in her family, in her blood"…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believed that Jing-Mei’s mother’s friends at the club referred her as a rabbit because they weren’t expecting her dying. This is related to a rabbit because you would never know when the rabbit is going to die. I also feel like that her mother died like a rabbit because when a rabbit is dying, they die right away like how her mother probably didn’t have time to get better. Her mother died young because she still had business to do. If she was older, she would have a lot of free time. Since Jing-Mei’s mother was in charge of Joy Luck Club, I felt like that was one of the business that she had to cover. Now that she is gone, there isn’t anyone there to replace her.…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays