Preview

To What Extent Was the Rebellion of the Northern Earls the Most Significant Rebellion in the Tudor Period

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1170 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Was the Rebellion of the Northern Earls the Most Significant Rebellion in the Tudor Period
To What Extent was the rebellion of the Northern Earls the most significant rebellion in the Tudor Period

To some extent the rebellion of the Northern Earls was the most significant rebellion in the Tudor period because they had proven to be a serious threat as the rebellion was lead by two of the leading families, Northumberland and Westmoreland. But despite this, I don’t think it was the most significant rebellion because if we put the fact they wanted to release Mary Queen of Scots, there was no purpose to the rebellion because there was no popular enthusiasm to replace Elizabeth with a foreigner or restore the Pope, and also the Earls (Northumberland and Westmoreland) were cowards to a point because as soon as they heard rumours that the queen had summoned massive forces for them, they turned around and headed back north instead of facing them. In my personal opinion, I think that the Pilgrimage of Grace was the most significant because it showed how to raise a large scale rising in a small period of time and it also showed the divided opinions of the people, as there were a variety of reasons; Religion, Political, Social and Economical.

The rebellion of the Pilgrimage of Grace, Henry’s reign, was perhaps the revolution in rebellions because although the Lancashire rising had raised 10,000 rebels in 10 days it was going to be like the calm before the storm because the rebels that fought for their beliefs in the Lancashire rising was about to be intensified with the Pilgrimage of Grace. The Pilgrimage of Grace managed to raise 30,000 rebels and actually managed to worry the government because they soon realised that the rebels were going to fight for their beliefs until death. The government was completely caught off guard with this rebellion as they didn’t expect a rebellion so soon after the rebels had been sent home by the Government’s Herald in Lancashire. In all the Pilgrimage of Grace was one of the better executed and planned rebellions in the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Tudor governments can be considered to have dealt poorly with rebellion on account of repeated noble support for rebellions throughout the period. The support of the nobility was crucial to maintaining control of the localities and additionally, noble support of a rebellion could increase the risk of a rebellion overthrowing the monarch. This was due to the likely contribution of funds to bolster supplies and troops with the involvement of retainers and experienced foreign mercenaries. Lack of noble co-operation with the government could also increase the threat of rebellion. This can be seen in the Cornish rebellion of…

    • 2557 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tudor governments during the Tudor period dealt with rebellions in different ways, whether most governments underestimated the threat posed by them will be dependent on how well and effectively they reacted and responded to theses rebellions. Most Tudor Monarchs were either not prepared or faced the consequences of their most serious errors, however factors that will have to be taken in consideration are how governments consulted with their advisers, how governments gathered information, the role of communication to nobles and officials in rebellious areas and the time bought when they had limited resources. How well governments dealt with rebellions before they became too dangerous and the decisions to raise troops will also be considered, as they too decide whether or not most Tudor government underestimated the threat posed by rebellions.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American Revolution was sparked by a myriad of causes. These causes in themselves could not have sparked such a massive rebellion in the nation, but as the problems of the colonies cumulated, their collective impact spilt over and the American Revolution ensued. Many say that this war could have been easily avoided and was poorly handled by both sides, British and American; but as one will see, the frame of thought of the colonists was poorly suited to accept British measures which sought to "overstep" it's power in the Americas. Because of this mindset, colonists developed a deep resentment of British rule and policies; and as events culminated, there was no means to avoid revolution and no way to turn back.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    DBQ PILGRIMAGE OF GRACE

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Pilgrimage of Grace participants were Catholics who were against the Protestant Reformation. They made armed demonstrations and protests from 1536 to 1537 against Henry VII, head of the Anglican Church, and Thomas Cromwell his Lord High Chancellor. Cromwell implemented a series of policies that included the confiscation of Catholic Church lands. The goals of these participants were to stop the Protestant Reformation and give more rights back to Catholics. They had concerns with the protestants growing more powerful and having a protestant King in Henry the VII. The goals of the Pilgrimage of Grace were to give power back to the Catholic Church in Europe and take credibility from Proestants, but instead their concerns of the Protestant Reformation overshadowed them and their goals were not reached.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The revolution of 1688 happened when the Catholic king James II was overthrown by the Protestant prince William of Orange. When the news that James had been overthrown in England reached Boston they prepared for their own revolution. These outbreaks caused a change in church and state policy that was huge, leading to the Toleration Act that would endure in to the nineteenth century.2…

    • 591 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Pilgrimage of Grace is regarded as the most serious rebellion in Tudor dynasty. It is a rising against reforms of Henrician government took place in Yorkshire on October 1536. The rebels were discontent about the government's new policies accompanied by Reformation. In this popular rising they expressed their grievances in December Petition (Bush, 1996). Its participants did not constrained to commons; evidence showed that gentlemen and clergy also protested against the government since their interest were eroded in terms of property and liberties (Bush 2009, p.150). Although the traditional historical view regards the Pilgrimage of Grace as a revolt which fought for the defence of Catholicism and angry with religious changes initiated by King Henry VIII, scholars like Davies…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To an extent, Opposition to the religious reforms by Henry VIII wasn’t overly serious, the opposition did have some potential to cause damage but the danger was never severe enough to undermine the Tudor dynasty or threaten the omnipotent once of the “Most Christian King”. Opposition was only as serious as the support it had, which is why The Pilgrimage of Grace of 1536 was the most dangerous form of opposition. Henry ensured that disapproval from his kingdom would never threaten to undermine the longevity of the Tudor dynasty by using Cromwell’s key weapon: The Treason Act of 1534. This allowed Henry to eradicate any opposition that had potential to threaten Henry. The religious changes came to a halt in 1540, where Henry sends out a strong deterrent message by executing the architect of the religious changes, Cromwell.…

    • 1958 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The rebellion was an example of the failure of the Articles of Confederation, and served as solid proof that supported the federalists' claim. The rebellion made the Americans recognize the weaknesses of their government, and showed them why it should be altered.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The marchers that were in the Pilgrimage of Grace were peasants, according to Doc 3. The peasants were devoted Catholics who wanted people to be Catholic and love god in Document1. These devoted Catholic peasants did not view Henry Viii whose started everything as the central “bad guy” of this whole thing, but they viewed Thomas Cromwell as a traitor that should be exiled from this place in Document 6.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Glorious Revolution of 1688: fighting between religious and political groups came to a halt with the Church of England was made the reigning church of the country.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bacon's Rebellion was a similar revolt in the fact that it the revolters were not happy in the way the colony was being ran and they felt that they should have gotten more opportunities and rights. Nathanial Bacon a poor ex-indentured servant was extrmely unhappy about the way the colony was being run and he wanted to be able to obtain land as well as get payback on Indians that had raided a nearby area. Bacon temporarily took control on the colony for several years and because of his uprising more land was available for indentured servants and people believed that they could actually change the way their colony was being ran. This rebellion was similar to the Paxton Boys Revolt as it also had to do with the discontent of a lower class group in society, as well as anger towards specific groups of hostile Indians.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion was a key factor in the role of the multiple rebellion’s, mainly the western rebellion. The people wanted religion to change back to the previous Catholic beliefs as seen under Henry 8th, “the most formidable opposition to the reformation that England saw” (Caramani), Wyatts revolt also had religious motives such as many believing the marriage of Mary and Phillip would result in Catholic changes such as the return of the pope, this would scare and frustrate many after a protestant change had taken place across the country, this would especially affect the Gentry class as many may be prosecuted as heretics, much like the Spanish Inquisition but in Britain “Religious fear…may have converted widespread dislike of the marriage into open revolt”. Religion however did not play a role in Kett’s rebellion, as that was more of a socially and economically motivated rebellion.…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The least important rebellion in this country was Bacon’s Rebellion because it really did not do much at the time. Bacon’s Rebellion was a thousand Virginians who rose up against the rule of Virginia Governor William Berkeley. Berkeley had recently refused to retaliate for Indian attacks on western Virginia settlements. This prompted some to take matters into their own hands, attacking Native Americans, chasing Berkeley from Jamestown. They also torched the capital. Bacon’s and Shays’ Rebellion have a lot in common in the fact that both of the rebellions were started by farmers who were fed up with the government. Another reason why Bacon’s Rebellion is not that important because at the time there was no United States and it did not affect any other colonies.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Elizabeth I only saw three rebellions during her reign and one of those barely classed as a rebellion (Oxford), this is surprising seeing as before her there was a high rise in rebellions this was when the Western, Ketts and Wyatt’s took place. There were many contributing factors as to why there were fewer rebellions during Elizabeth’s reign but the main underpinning cause would be the changing attitudes of the elite. Before Elizabeth’s reign the nobles led dynastic challenges and grievance rebellions which sometimes had the support by thousands of Englishmen of all different social classes. Rebellions led by the nobles were particularly more destructive due to how manipulative they could be in twisting the causes so that they get more support. It was the changing attitudes and roles of the nobility and the way they supported the government that decreased the rebellions. Other factors included there being a better welfare state and the country having religious stability that meant that rebellions became an event which one only used as a last resort for people with nothing to loose, an example of this was the Essex rebellion in 1601.…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Level

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There were three main rebellions in Henry VIII’s reign as king; The Lincolnshire Rising, The Pilgrimage of Grace and Cumberland Rebellion. These rebellions were all connected because each one triggered off the next one. The three main factors that set off the rebellions were the economic state of the country, the political state and the religious activities at the time.…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays