Preview

To What Extent Is Gerardo a Sympathetic Character in ‘Death and the Maiden’? Should His Priority Be with His Wife or Work?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1371 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Is Gerardo a Sympathetic Character in ‘Death and the Maiden’? Should His Priority Be with His Wife or Work?
To what extent is Gerardo a sympathetic character in ‘Death and the Maiden’? Should his priority be with his wife or work?

In the play ‘Death and the Maiden’, Gerardo’s character represents the new democratic government(of which he is a member) and his wife, Paulina, is an individual affected by the horrors of the recently ended dictatorship, in which many people were tortured and killed. Gerardo faces the problem throughout the play, whether or not he should support his wife’s views or take a diplomatic stance and side with the opinions that accompanies his job. Paulina is struggling with the idea of moving into a democracy without justice being brought to those who took part in the torturing and murders in the dictatorship, as the new government is not investigating the cases that did not result in death. In contrast, Gerardo is standing for a democracy moving forward, and although understands the pain Paulina suffered, thinks more rationally about leaving the past behind, instead of thinking about the complicated emotions Paulina and many others feel are tied up in the past. The question as to what extent Gerardo is a sympathetic character is a complex one. Can he be both a sympathetic character to the views of the democracy and also to his wife’s suffering and need for tangible justice. Also the diction sympathetic, does not just mean his sympathetic character towards others but also his likeability as a character.
Gerardo is a man of the government and wants a smooth transition into democracy. Therefore he believes that the act of kidnapping and even the threat of death cannot occur in his home as he is meant to set an example, ‘who should be showing exemplary signs of moderation and equanimity.’ His point is sensible, and saying that if this happened across the county, the transition from dictatorship to democracy would not be achieved. Gerardo points out how killing Gerardo will cause another wave of pain, to his family and guilt for Paulina,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Killing His Wife

    • 630 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the introduction of this chapter, we learn that on November 28th, 1595 Gaspar de Peralta, a judge for the Royal Audiencia of Charcas, answered a call from his next-door neighbor’s house. Once he entered the house, he found a domestic horror scene. Having entered the bedroom, Peralta found his chief scribe and the secretary of the audiencia (Fernando de Medina) standing over the bloody bodies of his wife and her lover, Beatriz Gonzalez. Fernando de Medina (the Husband) immediately confessed to murdering his wife and her love. He proceeded to tell the judge of his wife’s long- term affair with Beatriz Gonzalez. Fernando de Medina believed that it was his right to defend his honor. One of the first documents was a statement from Medina, saying that in no point in time in the twenty-seven years or so of marriage had he given his wife a reason to be unfaithful. In the document he explained that over the twenty-seven years he had moved from place to place and he always provided his wife with everything she’d ever needed. She provided him with two children and they all were all well taken care of. The last and final move though was she meets her “new suitor” in the garden. He goes on to say that Gonzalez and his wife would use any opportunity and location to be together. They used his (the husband) home, or the lovers, she would either wear her own clothes or try to hide their relationship and wear men’s clothing. In this passage the husband feels he has to defend his honor because he found out that all of his servants were aware of this affair.…

    • 630 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Based on a character’s actions alone, many could be seen as evil or immoral. However, characters are not as black and white as they seem. Infact, many complex characters fall in between the lines of inherently untainted or inherently reprobate. In Charles Dicken’s novel, A Tale of Two Cities, Madame Defarge is a character who could, based solely on her actions, be considered evil or immoral. Yet, the full scope of her character leaves the reader feeling more sympathetic.…

    • 97 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Arguably the most radical aspect of ‘Tis Pity is the degree of sympathy that Ford affords his two protagonists; unlike other Renaissance plays in which characters’ incestuous desires are portrayed as extensions of their villainy or political greed, Ford’s tragedy makes the love of a brother and sister its central subject, and could be conceived as doubly radical in that this relationship is supposedly based on mutual affection rather than the norms of economic necessity and caste which governed marriages during this era. However, over the course of the play this relationship is shown, as Ronald Huebert attests, to be a ‘fantasy of constancy’; Giovanni is unable to control his all-consuming passion, asserting his authority over his sister in increasingly patriarchal terms and finally butchering her and his unborn child in the gory coup de théâtre of the play’s denouement[1]. If Giovanni’s fantasy of possession demonstrates how the need to represent desire can distort one’s sense of self, Annabella seems to present an alternative: the possibility of fashioning one’s identity and retaining control of one’s desires. Stephen Greenblatt argues that ‘Self-fashioning is achieved in relation to something perceived as alien, strange, or hostile’, and…

    • 2988 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    : "Don Lazaro, you've got five boys in Comitan teaching the campesinos how to read. That's subversive. That's communist. So tonight, you have to kill them." Don Lazaro, the mayor of the war torn village, San Martin Comitan, seems to have no choice but to carry out this heartless command. His response is indicative of a desperate man searching for answers, yet already resigned to carrying out the task at hand. "What can I say? --you tell me!" cries an anguished Don Lazaro to the villagers. Is he pleading for their understanding, or asking for a miraculous solution that would alter the path that lay before him? It is this uncertainty that, when coupled with melancholy foreshadowing, leaves the reader at a suspenseful crossroad; suspecting that events are transpiring, but doubtful as to the outcome.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Loyalty In Don Chipote

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Here, the novel reveals the unequal friendship between Don Chipote and Pitacio by displaying Pitacio’s exploitment of his host’s generosity. For example, Don Chipote offers his friend hospitality along with food and shelter as a testament to his kindness. Instead of expressing appreciation for this gracious gesture, Pitacio takes advantage of the situation in order to benefit himself. The fact that he tells lies to his friend in order to receive food for the coming days makes matters worse since he intentionally misleads Don Chipote. This dishonesty damages the friendship between the two characters because one side is using the other person for personal gain. In this example, the text highlights the negative trait of dishonesty and manipulation that constitute a faulty and unequal friendship. In addition to the negative traits of dishonesty and manipulation, Pitacio exhibits unreliability in keeping his promises. One could argue that by Pitacio staying behind in Mexico to help Don Chipote’s family while Don Chipote is away, he exhibits good friend characteristics. However, the text undermines this opinion when it notes that “[g]ood buddy Pitacio was more than happy to do this—for the first few months” (Venegas 129). In this moment, the text…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The different educational level of Rodriguez and his parents has made it difficult for Rodriguez to communicate with them as he were mostly into books. He felt ashamed on how his parents could not answer; understand his homework questions or what he had been studying. At some point, Rodriguez intentionally tries to hurt their feelings because he thought he hates them for unable to be there for him intellectually. After finding the pleasure of education and knowledge at school, he expect some reactions on sharing his thoughts and reflections with his parents but unfortunately, the lack of abilities his parents possessed made him unsatisfied, unfulfilled and upset with their condition. “His academic success distances him from a life he loved, even from a memory of himself (Rodriguez)”.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movement has become stronger and the government wants to contain the progress. People are getting arrest left and right. Patrias family starts to become imprisoned, her sister, husband, and child. Patria quickly becomes frantic and trys to think of ways to get her soon out of prison. As time goes on and her son is still in prison, this man from the SIMs starts to stop by at the house. In the beginning, Patria despises him coming by the house. He talks to her about her husband and attempts to anger Patria. Over time Patria and Pena became acquaintances and nice with each other. Still all Patria wants is to get her son out of prison. She decides to use her acquaintance with Pena to ask for help, “I had planned to make an impassioned plea, but no words came out of my mouth….Suddenly, it all came out, along with the tears. How I had read in the papers about El Jefe excusing minors, how my baby boy had just turned eighteen in prison, how I wonder if there was anything at all Pena could do to get boy pardon,” (Alvarez 216). All Patria wants is to get her son out of prison. That she goes as far as to ask a person who was part of the government that is imprisoning her family, but the thought of her son in prison for anymore time is too much for Patria. Patria has courage to go to a member of the SIM, risking her own life to save the life of her son. Every action as its own outcome. The outcome of Patria asking Pena to see if he can get her son released from prison payed of in the end. Pena was able to make a few calls and get Nelson released from prison. A few weeks after Patria asks Pena for help. Pena stops by and tells her news about Nelson. As soon as Pena leaves Patria goes to her families and tells them, “Nelson is coming home,” (220 Alvarez). Pena was able to pull of getting her son released from prison. Patria is getting her son back. She can now stop worrying that she…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bless Me Ultimas

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Following a horrific shooting of the towns sheriff by Lupito, a damaged and disturbed returning Mexican G.I. – Antonio witnesses Lupito’s own murder on the river by his father, and a group of towns men seeking vengeance for the senseless murder of the sheriff by Lupito. Here, Antonio sees how Narciso, the town drunk is kinder even than his own father, as Narciso tries to prevent the group of men from killing Lupito – but fails.…

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, every character has their purpose in the play. For example, the side character, Mercutio, is essential to the play. He is a relative of Prince Escales, but mostly, he is Romeo’s friend and confident. He is an influential character to Romeo and the directions of the play takes. Mercutio has a significance influence to the play because Mercutio’s existence brought more drama to the play, his actions have often started many events in the play and most importantly, his death is the one of the climaxes and the turning points in Romeo and Juliet.…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Othello is a tragic hero whose jealousy is cleverly manipulated by the maleficent Iago, transforming him from a noble figure to a disturbed murderer. In keeping with the tragic genre, Shakespeare depicts a sequence of events through which bring about Othello’s decline. The playwright slowly escalates the emotional intensity of the play as Othello becomes more obsessed and less rational. The audience experience a range of emotions as the emotional escalation created is at last over.…

    • 2160 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In nearly every tale, the story line contains multiple characters whom depict both good and “evil” qualities. In other words, they reveal opposite interpretations. These drastic differences can be drawn due to the lack of specifics in the reading. One interpretation may portray a character as pure and innocent. In another, they may appear at fault. Shakespeare’s famous play, Hamlet, illustrates this notion through an accumulation of characters. Of the many, Ophelia may strike one as the innocent virgin, or rather the selfish and corrupt whore. An overall analysis may be useful in determining which portrayal is more accurate.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From when the narrator is ten years old, we are shown glimpses of hope through his actions and personality. After being told by his panicked father that ‘the future is a hospital, packed with sick people, packed with hurt people’ the narrator simply wants to know how to ‘prepare’ for that. This naïve courage displayed by the innocent ten year old foreshadows the determination he will show as he grows older, whilst experiencing reoccurring trauma. After meeting Margo, the narrator is forever hopeful of securing her as a long-term partner in life. He is deeply in love with her, ‘It’s like wanting her to be here becomes so strong it almost makes me forget she’s not’ but finds it hard to put his feelings into action, anticipating the probable rejection from strong-willed and decisive Margo, ‘Silently, I ask her to marry me’.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Lit

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Esperanza is not a significant supporter of the gender positions that continue to keep women in her neighborhood demoralized. The men on Mango Street abuse not only their wives but also their daughters and imprison them in the home. Many times just being a woman can cause reason for such abuse. This is a fact that can be observed in the beatings which unfortunately Sally continuously gets, and also in the rape of Esperanza. Esperanza presents us with an analysis of the way men and women relate to each other and refuse to abide by the demands applied to her sex by marriage or perhaps acting in a womanly way. For our character, disobeying gender position and staying independent is considered an act of rebellion as well as a source of power.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Finally, Paquette deserves the most amount of pity and the least amount of admiration. “ His wife was crazed with jealousy...I did not love” (24, pg 99). Paquette , who is never happy, chose to be a mistress which can make the reader to pity her rather than admire. Paquette’s character can be questioned or weather or not she should be admired based on her past decisions. However, she can be admired for getting through the daily beatings and continue life even though she is never happy.…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Alternatively Desdemona is revealed to be the ideal woman, Cassio even admits“She is indeed perfection.” Othello often makes remarks on her beauty and her wit. Even when he thinks she has betrayed him, he cannot help himself from looking upon her fondly even stating that she is “so delicate with her needle: an admirable musician: O! she will sing the savageness out of a bear: of so high and plenteous wit and invention:—“ despite Desdemona’s perfection Othello lets himself be manipulated into thinking she is unfaithful to him, and he kills her. Emilia, while not as perfect as Desdemona appears to be an obedient wife to Iago. She even gives him Desdemona’s handkerchief without knowing the reason he wants it, when stealing the handkerchief she says “what he will do with it Heaven knows, not I; I nothing but to please his fantasy.” In the end of the play however, she chooses to honour Desdemona and she exposes her husband's treachery as opposed to supporting it. Iago kills her due to this one moment of disobedience. Through the killing of Emilia and Desdemona at the hands of their husbands and the fact that Bianca lives, Shakespeare reveals what he thinks of the relationships husbands have with their wives. He is exhibiting how women are never good enough for their husbands. Desdemona and Emilia are honest women, but in Desdemona’s case Othello believes she is having an affair and to him this is inexcusable. Emilia is killed because Iago sees it as a fit punishment for her disobedience and her lack of support of his dishonesty. Bianca on the other hand has no husband and thus she appears to follow no rules but her own and suffers no dire consequences because she has no one ruling over her. Shakespeare is showcasing the oppression that husbands had over their wives. On top of that Shakespeare is suggesting…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays