Preview

To What Extent Can Eddie Be Described as a Tragic Hero in ‘a View from the Bridge' by Arthur Miller?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2443 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Can Eddie Be Described as a Tragic Hero in ‘a View from the Bridge' by Arthur Miller?
In writing ‘A View from the Bridge', Arthur Miller wanted to create a modern Greek tragedy. An Ancient Greek tragedy was a play where fate brings about the downfall of the characters involved. It has many other generic features which Miller has incorporated into his modern version. The character of Alfieri is used in the traditional chorus role, and Eddie is often likened to a tragic hero, the main character who contributes to their own downfall through a flawed personality, typically described as their "tragic flaw". The traditional Greek tragedies would have been performed in amphitheatres, in which the audience would look down on the actors. Not only is this similar to the way Alfieri looks down from the bridge, it is also similar to the way that Greek tragedies involved a strong sense of destiny controlled by the Gods, symbolised by the looking down. Miller uses the idea of destiny to great effect in ‘A View from the Bridge'.

Miller has used the idea of inevitability about the plot to great effect in ‘A View from the Bridge'. It is the fate of Eddie that Miller concentrates on, in keeping with Greek tragedy where the fate of the tragic hero is unavoidable. Alfieri is used to enforce the idea of destiny, as he is an onlooker in the play. Indeed the whole play is set in the past, with Alfieri's monologues saying what has passed, and the scenes involving the other characters shown as flashbacks. This adds to the sense of inevitability about the fate of Eddie, as the audience know what is going to happen as soon as Alfieri says ‘This one's name was Eddie Carbone', the was clearly indicating that he is dead. Alfieri also refers to fate's ‘bloody course', which immediately introduces us to the idea of destiny. It is an ominous statement as it suggests that from the outset there will be no fairytale ending to the play, and it gives the sense that unavoidable tragedy will occur. Alfieri's speech clearly shows how helpless outsiders such as himself are; he refers to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    In order to gain a better and more detailed understand of the qualities required for a tragic work, we should look to the discussion of tragedy found in Aristotle’s Poetics. He defines tragedy as “an imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and possessing magnitude; and effecting through pity and fear the catharsis of such emotions” (Aristotle). Aristotle goes on to describe the tragic hero as a character that has the ability to induce our sympathy and terror, especially since he or she is not necessarily good or evil, but instead, the character is a mixture of both qualities. Through the course of the play, the tragic hero will experience suffering through a change in happiness to despair because of an error or mistaken act. The error itself is led by the hero’s hamartia and regarded by some scholars as his or her tragic flaw. The hamartia eventually causes a recognition known as anagnorisis and a reversal in action known as peripeteia.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aristotle was not only a scientific genius, but someone who carved the path for the way we depict plays and furthermore, how we write them. Aristotle made it a mission to read the plays of his era, while doing so he discovered many similarities among them, creating a tragedy. A tragedy is a form of drama that is composed of three basic parts: values, characters, and a conclusion. A value is what will determine the fate of the tragic character in the play, usually the value is represented by a supernatural power. While the character has to display certain characteristics like nobility either by birth or action, it is most noted for the characters downfall. The downfall occurs either by limitation of knowledge or by a tragic flaw within…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tr Agedy

    • 806 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Miller defines tragedy as the consequence of “man’s total compulsion to evaluate himself justly”. In other words, a tragedy focuses on the journey of the tragic hero, who enlightened to their place in the world seeks to correct whatever distance exists between their position in life and what they deserve to be treated as.…

    • 806 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Classification and definition of tragedy are among many things widely disputed in the all too equivocal realm of composition and literary studies. These erroneous concepts happen to be directly correlated in Aristotelian theory which leads us to his definition of the tragic hero. Aristotle’s conceptualization of tragedy and all that it encompasses is widely revered and accepted; setting the standard previously and contemporaneously. The interpretation of his definition of tragedy is ambiguous, but generally states that tragedy should evoke pity and fear within the viewer for the purpose of catharsis, or purgation of senses sequencing the climax of a tragedy. (Battin) This elicits his definition of the tragic hero, which states that a character of exceptionally high stature is relegated (literally, figuratively, or both) and is forced to succumb to misfortune due to some flaw of character or failure to find/some deviation from the moral and righteous path, which is referred to as the hamartia. (Myers) However, he cannot be of paramount virtue or righteousness for this would objectify him, in turn isolating him from human perceptivity and compassion though he must be of high or noble character. The hamartia at some point must be realized by the character and this experience is known as an anagnorisis; it is to be noted that the relationship between these aspects of the tragedy is in itself ironic. Moreover we cannot define the tragic hero without giving heed to irony, which may find its origin in ancient Greek playwriting and sustains its prevalence in modern times. (Hutchens) Irony allows us as the audience to collectively comprehend the situation on a level that the characters themselves can not. Oedipus Rex, Othello, and Death of a Salesman are three tragic and relatively prominent plays, all written in different time periods, which can be examined comparatively with Aristotle’s philosophy of the tragic hero and may draw certain parallel to one another by means of…

    • 3232 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Both plays encompass dramatic irony in which the audience knows something that the characters are unaware of. Aristotle thought tragedy had to be upon a high figure such as a king or a queen and had to fall to an ultimate low. He believed if someone did not have any sort of power than no one would really care what happened to them. He needed a figure to fix tragedy upon that everyone could understand how devastating it would be to suffer the loss that they had. Miller believed that there could be tragedy of the common man and at a level that all normal people could relate to. He wanted to show that tragedy happens in everyone's lives and that just not people of higher positions or rank became it. I agree with Aristotle’s theory being more valid even though I do believe in everyone experiencing tragedy. It is more tragic to me if someone of higher power experiences tragedy because it does not just affect themselves, but it also affects everyone they have power and rule…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The word “tragedy” evokes connotations of sadness, death, and irony. In literature, a tragedy is a plot in which the protagonist, also called a “tragic hero”, because of some inherent flaw in his/her character, dies. In the Poetics, Aristotle wrote that the purpose of Tragedy is to evoke a wonder born of pity and fear, the result of which is cathartic. As audience members we should sympathize with the protagonist, possibly recognizing in him/her our own human weaknesses. Because tragedy is built around an internal conflict of character, identification with the protagonist is crucial to success. For example, if we cannot understand Romeo’s naive, unsophisticated notion of love, what poignancy does his death have?…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the other hand, another type of tragic hero exists, the modern tragic hero. This type of hero is a product of a clash between the individual and the social environment. Arthur Miller, the famous playwright said, "each person has a chosen image of self and position, tragedy results when the characters environment denies the fulfillment of this self concept." (LATWP, 640). This is a contrast from Aristotle's classic tragic hero because the hero is no longer born into nobility but gains stature in the action of pitting self against cosmos, and the tragedy becomes, "the disaster inherent in being torn away from our chosen image of what and who we are in this world." (LATWP, 640).…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It was created to be presented in an active storytelling that would take advantage of “people's pity, fear, and catharsis of passions” (Karayannakos). Through time it received specific guidelines such as the use of embellished language and the order of its parts. It is noted that “tragedy is the imitation of life itself, it was to give the spectator a chance to despise, pity, and love the leading actor” (Karayannakos). Emotion was a key part of its delivery, capitalizing on the pit of despair and punishment that the character must endure before the spectator can feel that justice has been served. Modern theatre highly profits from this theme as it reappears a limitless amount of times. (Cartwright) It draws inspiration from the Greeks with the use of doom, and how one sacrifice is atoned for another. Perhaps one of the most recognized poets of the 17th century, William Shakespeare made sure to incorporate emotions and human nature into his plays. One of the greater examples of modern tragedy, Romeo and Juliet, plays on the themes of love which leads to sorrow in the lead character’s story. The two lovers are overcome with passion and put aside all values, which epitomizes the Greek use of despair and arrogance. (Chapmen) Modern theatre has drawn enough inspiration from ancient Greek theatre to conflate on both naturalism and drama.…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miller makes this meeting between Alfieri and Eddie powerful and disturbing in many ways, mainly with the many climaxes when we feel Eddie is going to explode with anger and frustration but Alfieri calms him down with his appeasing words. This extract is a very gripping part of the play because it helps us understand both characters in different lights.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arthur Miller also defines a tragedy is having a character that is willing to lay down their life. The character is willing to give everything they have in order to obtain the position they feel they have and deserve. This is what brings tragic situation to a tragedy and makes the tragic hero a great person for the role. In Death of a Salesman, Willy is willing to end his life so that his family will gain some money and so that maybe his son will see how liked and popular he says he…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    "A view from the bridge" is a play scripted by Arthur Miller in 1955. The play is based in a city called Brooklyn which is situated in the state of New York. A view from the bridge is presented to the audience by a prominent character called Alfieri. Alfieri is the most significant character in the play because he is known as a good lawyer, a good friend to Eddie Carbone (a longshoreman) and surprisingly he is also the narrator. Alfieri is obviously the most significant character in the play.…

    • 34360 Words
    • 138 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The relationships in ‘A View from the Bridge’ are very complex as because of people’s attitudes back then. There is secrecy, suspicion, love and concern. Eddie is weirdly attracted to Catherine and his relationship with his wife Beatrice deteriorates.…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Macbeth a Tragic Hero?

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Macbeth is the main character in Shakespeare's play ‘Macbeth’. The play is a tragedy, therefore, the question arises; is Macbeth a tragic hero? Macbeth’s not only guilty of regicide, he also kills his best friend, an innocent family, and anybody else who he feels is a danger to his thrown. If we were to leave it at that, we could even name him a villain. However a tragic hero does not necessarily have to accomplish any good deeds, like the typical person we would call a hero today. The great Greek philosopher Aristotle had a couple of characteristics that he believed made a tragic hero, and Macbeth meets his criteria.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Works of tragedy have been around since the earliest times of Greece, if not longer. In these tragedies, the downfall of the "tragic hero", or the main character destined to fall, is portrayed to the audience. In one of the most famous tragic plays ever written, Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare gives the downfall of many characters. Given the case, there have been many arguments about who the tragic hero really is. Despite the fact that the play is named after Julius Caesar, the tragic hero of Shakespeare's play is Marcus Brutus.…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shakespeare's "Anthony and Cleopatra" and "Macbeth" are the studies of a tragic hero; a hero who falls from grace due to 'hamartia'. Explore the tragedies as a commentary on the infallibility of man.…

    • 2578 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics