The Theological Motifs Undergirding the Book Steps to Christ: a Study of the Leading Motif in Ellen White's Approach
The Theological Motifs Undergirding the Book Steps to Christ: A Study of the Leading Motif in Ellen White’s Approach
Bela Djulai
Submitted to Dr. Gunnar Pedersen and Jan Barna In partial fulfilment of the requirements for the module Principles and Methods of Theology
23 June 2009
Newbold College in Partnership with the University of Wales, Lampeter
INTRODUCTION Stating the Problem of the Paper It is well known that Ellen White1 is coming from a Wesleyan background.2 In recent years some Adventist theologians suggest that there is an influence of Wesleyanism on Ellen White’s theology.3 Therefore, this paper investigates the question of the nature and degree of this influence, particularly in the book Steps to Christ. I will try also to access Ellen White’s theological motifs and her leading motif with some of Wesleyan background and compare it. Stating the Purpose of the Paper The purpose of this paper is to investigate Ellen White’s leading motif and to uncover possible influences behind the structure and content of Steps to Christ from Wesleyanism. Therefore the main research question is to what degree has been the structure, the content and the leading motif of the Steps to Christ influenced by Wesleyan soterology. Methodology of the Paper In this paper I will analyze the structure and the content of the Ellen White’s Book Steps to Christ in the light of a proposed leading motif. Then, I will research for possible Wesleyan influences behind the book. Finally, in the light of discovered similarities I will provide a critical comparison in order to point out Ellen White’s leading motif. Limitations and Delimitations of the Paper I will limit myself to the Ellen White’s book Steps to Christ and only in a limited way go beyond the message of the book to illustrate some of the points. In terms of Wesleyan theology I will not cover in detail the Wesleyan theology, but only its soteriological aspect.
1
Ellen White (1827-1915) the most prominent
Bela Djulai
Submitted to Dr. Gunnar Pedersen and Jan Barna In partial fulfilment of the requirements for the module Principles and Methods of Theology
23 June 2009
Newbold College in Partnership with the University of Wales, Lampeter
INTRODUCTION Stating the Problem of the Paper It is well known that Ellen White1 is coming from a Wesleyan background.2 In recent years some Adventist theologians suggest that there is an influence of Wesleyanism on Ellen White’s theology.3 Therefore, this paper investigates the question of the nature and degree of this influence, particularly in the book Steps to Christ. I will try also to access Ellen White’s theological motifs and her leading motif with some of Wesleyan background and compare it. Stating the Purpose of the Paper The purpose of this paper is to investigate Ellen White’s leading motif and to uncover possible influences behind the structure and content of Steps to Christ from Wesleyanism. Therefore the main research question is to what degree has been the structure, the content and the leading motif of the Steps to Christ influenced by Wesleyan soterology. Methodology of the Paper In this paper I will analyze the structure and the content of the Ellen White’s Book Steps to Christ in the light of a proposed leading motif. Then, I will research for possible Wesleyan influences behind the book. Finally, in the light of discovered similarities I will provide a critical comparison in order to point out Ellen White’s leading motif. Limitations and Delimitations of the Paper I will limit myself to the Ellen White’s book Steps to Christ and only in a limited way go beyond the message of the book to illustrate some of the points. In terms of Wesleyan theology I will not cover in detail the Wesleyan theology, but only its soteriological aspect.
1
Ellen White (1827-1915) the most prominent
Bibliography: ‘A Plain Account of Christian Perfection’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Works of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Baker Publishing Group’, Wikipedia Free Encyclopedia, (2009) [accessed 17 April 2009] Boda, Mark J., Gordon T. Smith, Repentance in Christian theology (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 2006) Bounds, Christopher, ‘John Wesley’s Doctrine of Salvation: Part Four’, Out of Bounds, (2006), [accessed 12 May 2009] ---, ‘John Wesley’s Doctrine of Salvation: Part Two’, Out of Bounds, (2006) < http://cbounds.blogspot.com/2006/08/ john-wesleys-doctrine-of-salvation_07.html> [accessed 12 May 2009] ---, ‘The Wesleyan Way of Salvation’, [accessed 12 May 2009] Dieter, Melvin E. and others, Five Views on Sanctification, (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2006) 29 Douglass, Herbert E., ‘The Great Controversy Story in Steps to Christ’, His Righteousness in the 1888 message, (2009) < http://www.msc1888.org/articles/theGCstoryinSC.htm> [accessed 14 April 2009] ---., ‘Understanding How the Books Where Written’, The Ellen White’s Estate, Inc., (2009) [accessed 10 April 2009] Fry, Stanley A., A New Vision of God for the 21st Century: Discovering the Essential Wesley for Pastors and Other Seekers (Bloomington, IN: iUniverse, 2005) Harper, Steven, Way to heaven: The Gospel According to John Wesley (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2003) Kent, John, Wesley and the Wesleyans (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002) Knight, George R, A Search for Identity: The Development of Seventh-Day Adventist Beliefs, (Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald Publishing Association, 2000) ---, Meeting Ellen White (Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald Publishing Association, 1996) La Rondelle, H. K., Perfection and Perfectionsim (Berrien Springs, MI: Andrews University Press, 1984) Lee, Keith, ‘A Study of John Wesley’s “The Way of Salvation” – a dialogue with contemporary theologians’, [accessed 12 May 2009] 30 Lewis, Gordon R. and Bruce A. Demarest, Integrative Theology (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1996) Mann, Mark H., Perfecting Grace: Holiness, Human Being, and the Sciences (Continuum International Publishing Group, 2007) Oden, Thomas C., John Wesley’s scriptural Christianity: a plain exposition of his teaching on Christian doctrine (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1994) Rakestraw , Robert V., ‘John Wesley as a Theologian of Grace’, Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 27.2 (1984):199. Rogers, Jay, ‘John Wesley – The Highway of Holiness’, The Forerunner [accessed 20 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#3] Three: Awake Thou That Sleepeth’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied – Theology The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#5] Five: Justification by Faith’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied – Theology The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#9] Nine: The Spirit of Bondage and Adoption’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#11] Eleven: The Witness of the Spirit’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#14] Fourteen: The Repentance of Believers’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009]. ‘Sermon [#18] Eighteen: The Mark of the New Birth’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#43] Forty-three: The Scripture Way of Salvation’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009]. ‘Sermon [#57] Fifty-Seven: On The Fall of Man’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#58] Fifty-Eight: On Predestination’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009]. ‘Sermon [#85] Eighty-Five: On Working Out Our Own Salvation’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#106] One Hundred Six: On Faith’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#107] One Hundred Seven: On Gods Vineyard’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] ‘Sermon [#128] One Hundred Twenty-Eight: Free Grace’, Wesley Center Online: Wesley Center for Applied Theology – The Sermons of John Wesley – 1872 Edition (Thomas Jackson, editor), (2009) [accessed 12 May 2009] Shepherd, Victor, ‘Theology of John Wesley’, Sermons and Writings of Victor Shepherd, (1998), [accessed 12 May 2009] Whidden, Woodrow W. ‘Adventist Theology: The Wesleyan Connection’, Biblical Research Institute, (2005), [accessed 15 January 2009] 33 ---, ‘Ellen White on Salvation’, Assurance, (1999 -2008), [accessed 20 May 2009] White ,Arthur L., Ellen G. White, 6 vols (Hagerstown, MD: Review and Herald Publishing Association, 1984) White, Ellen Gould, Steps to Christ (Mountain View, CA: Pacific Press Publishing Association, 1956) Winters, Daniel, Steps to Christ, (2004), [accessed 17 April 2009] 34