Preview

The Shame of Paying College Athletes

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1013 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Shame of Paying College Athletes
Benjamin Carter
Mrs. Narcisi
English 9
2/27/2011

The Shame of Paying College Athletes Definition of college-A constituent unit of a university, furnishing courses of instruction in the liberal arts and sciences, usually leading to a bachelor's degree (dictionary). College was made for learning and in preparation for rest of your life; not for just a pay check. (Daugherty) Bob night states “Paying college athletes diminishes the value of an education.” (Daugherty). Not only does a paying college athlete diminish the value of an education, but also destroys the purpose of college sports. A salary should only be given to athletes that are at a professional level. Young college athletes don’t yet know the value of money and should be treated as such. College athletes should not be paid, due to the fact that most colleges would not be able to afford paying every player in their program, schools already provide free education and scholarships for athletes, and paying athletes is against NCAA regulation. First of all, athletes should not be paid because most colleges (besides big name schools) would not be able to afford paying all their players in their programs; not just football and basketball players. “Out of the 120 FBS (formerly named Division 1) schools, only twelve broke even or made a profit after an athletic season”(Bokshan).If only twelve broke even how are these schools expected to cough up enough money to pay their players. They are not. If the National College Athletic Association or NCAA changed their rules, and forced all colleges to pay their athletic players; most would quickly fall into dept, and have to cut their entire sports program just to save their schools from having to close down. Leaving the college no choice, but to cut into their general funds; meaning cutting back on funding for academic education. Many Universities like Miami of Ohio are going through huge budget

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    For example, some less popular teams like swimming, tennis, or volleyball don’t earn the universities much money, and the bigger sports like basketball and football make up for the lost revenue. So why would pay the athletes if entire teams are struggling to survive?…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to the article Jalen Rose describes reasons why the college players should be paid to play. This isn’t the first time that this has come up before, but it seems to have more steam every time it comes up in a conversation. There’s always going to have someone like Cam Newton that receives money improperly. Each college athlete should be paid a stipend of $2000.00 per semester. All the college athletes’ coaches and the schools they go to, but they are the ones that get the money and the athletes don’t get any of the money. They treat these college athletes like servants. They can’t have even a part-time…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    NCAA Cost Deficit Analysis

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Universities and NCAA Division I athletic programs are closely connected in many ways. One of the main ways these two are connected is based on finances. There are several financial positions that are established. While all points display problems with the finances, these perspectives are different problems. One perspective is that financial spending is usually not self-sustainable with rising costs, showing a need to use as many resources as possible to keep the programs alive. Some think that the limit of resources should be better distributed to academic spending. Some think that there are resources that are available for students to be paid as employees. My position is that some spending should be cut away from athletics, as it is proven…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The short answer to this question is no. Paying the athletes can only make these athletic teams more competitive. This system would give the teams that never envisioned playing for a championship a chance to go after the star players, and actually having as chance to get them. People are afraid of change, but the world is changing all around us.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Supporters of paying college athletes proclaim that players should be paid simple because their hard work makes money for other people. (“Paying College Athletes” para.6) Hard work and a lot of time comes with being a college athlete, and college athletes wish to see a compensation for the hard work. Although, some college athletes believe they should get a financial compensation for their hard, the effort of some of the athletes would be affected if they were to get paid. Kristi Dosh, ESPN's sports business reporter, argues that paying college athletes could destroy competitive balance, because the most successful schools would be able to offer much bigger paychecks.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In recent years, colleges throughout the nation have come across plenty of controversy concerning the idea of whether or not athletes should be paid to play sports in college. To this day the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) deems this a violation of their rules, and that is no matter what the amateur status of the players who make college athletics a billion-dollar business is not going to change (“Associated Press”, 2013). Even though the issue is constantly being debated and to some the answer remains "up in the air" still to this day (Dabad, n.d.), I think the answer is quite simple on why college athletes shouldn’t be paid.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    For years the question, “Should college athletes be paid?” has appeared in the debatable world. College athletes across the nation have argued that they deserve compensation for the particular sport in which they participate in. “We deserve a check for what we do,” Southern Miss football player, Urell Johnson stated. “Win or lose, our sport is our job. We work all day, every day. If you think about it, the athletic department brings in the most revenue to the university.” Non-athletes, such as students (like myself) and faculty, have disagreed with the idea of reimbursing athletes who are still in college. Paying college athletes would be absurd, being that it would be too expensive, produce avaricious athletes, and most of all, it would be injustice to every other young adult attending college.…

    • 2104 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Thank College Players for Play-off Success” the Editorial Board talks about how the player in college sports get the least amount of money. They state that “Television networks are making a mint. Coaches are pulling in obscene sums. Bowl associations are living large. And all of them owe some of their fortune to the low labor costs for people who matter most: the players.” The source says that many people say that the players are being payed with a great education, but some don’t even want that education because they want to play sports. This source also gives example of things we could do instead of putting them on payroll. For example, taking better care of the players, shortening the season, and offer scholarships that cover every aspect of attending college. They state that “These ideas would cost money. They might prompt some colleges to drop football. For that reason, schools would balk. But they're already extracting too much from players for too little.”…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In some cases,a college’s athletic program is its main source of income. For example they can make money on selling items that show the athletes’ names or pictures on them; they sell tickets to the sporting events; and they get many donations from alumni and other fans and companies which want to support the athletes. Even though the colleges make money on all these things, they share none of it with the athletes. If it were not for the athletes, the school would not make money on any of those things. The college would not suffer financially if they gave each athlete a small salary in addition to their scholarship.The salary might make the athlete happier about playing the sport and they would try harder while playing or practicing. The practices or training that are required of the players consume most of their time – even in the off season they still have some sort of training.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The common argument to college athletes being paid is that they are “Student Athletes.” Taylor Branch the writer of The Shame Of College Sports agrees that the NCAA makes “Student…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    College athletes who already receive scholarship money should not be paid by the university to play sports.…

    • 672 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Paying student-athletes is not a good idea because college sports teams may not be able to afford to pay the athletes.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Student Athletes Get Paid

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Department of Education” (Gaines). The fact that Texas A&M made about 192.6 in one year has people thinking what the school does with that money and why they do not give it to the students in the form of of payment. Even though pay the atheths would be difficult because not all of the sports teams from different schools make the same amount of money, people still believe it could be possible. Paying the athletes could help them out financially and this would not only benefit the athlete but also their families. For example, in the article Progress forward? An Analysis of Whether Student-Athletes Should Be Paid by Christopher M. Parent, shows how a University of Southern California student athlete that came from a low income family could have been benefited from the sport he played if he would have gotten paid. Since the only money he received was from the Pell Grant, he would give the leftover money “from school to his family” in an effort to help them out (Parent 227). While he was starving with now food in his refrigerator, “on the USC campus they were selling [his] jersey, making money off of it” meanwhile he could not “afford to…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Paying College Athletes

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages

    When it comes to college athletics, there always will be a problem that arises. It is one of the most controversial topics there is. One of the main issues within athletics is the idea of whether to pay college athletes or not. Several studies have been done along with articles from various sources. This has been on the rise especially since “March Madness” is coming up. “March Madness” may only consist of three weekends, however, an 11 billion dollar deal is made to televise the games (Wilbon). This is when you have to take the time to sit back and contemplate whether these college athletes really are getting the fair end of the stick. Under NCAA laws it is forbidden to pay these athletes for their performance yet at the same time they clearly are talented enough to have a profitable market.…

    • 1443 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Toulmin Argument

    • 796 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One reason college's athletes should not be paid is that they receive money from scholarships and basically go to school for free. Hypothetically speaking, a high school student who is very good at football received several offers (scholarships to play at their school) from very big name schools. He accepted an offer to a large university and now, is the starting defensive end for them. He goes to school, gets his education for free and also gets to play the sport he loves. Statistics involving total scholarships and revenue to the schools seem to be similar as the revenue feeds the scholarships. Playing for such a big school in football some people may say that scholarship money isn't enough because tuition is small compared to the money they bring in. The money that they bring in goes towards their scholarships, food, and clothes they wear. With all that is earned, a big chunk goes toward them and the free education and traveling. Some athletes don't get as much attention as ones from bigger schools. Athletes from smaller schools still receive attention and money, just not on as large of a scale.…

    • 796 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays