If one reads Homer 's "Iliad" and "Odyssey," and Virgil 's "Aeneid", he gets to realize that the ancient concept of people 's interaction with Gods is totally deprived of fear in any form. In all three masterpieces, Gods are basically described as humans, with all their strengths and weaknesses, although being immortal. Humans often revere Gods, but not out of fear they simply respect their superiority. Many historians suggest that one of the main reasons, which enabled Greek and Roman civilizations to reach extraordinary heights in the fields of culture and science, is the fact of their religious liberalism.
Let us to take a closer look at all three poems, so it 'll be easier for us to find common religious motives in all of them. Homer 's "Odyssey" is one of the finest examples of ancient Greek literature. Along with "Iliad" it represents an ultimate expression of ancient spirit, which we still use as a standard while assessing the cultural legacy of our own Western civilization.
Modern historians doubt whether the same author wrote these two epic masterpieces. The main reason for this is that "Odyssey", stylistically and conceptually, is much different from "Iliad". First one is a high tragedy, its storyline based on the events of Trojan War. The style of this poem is very noble and there is no place for petty human weaknesses.
The action takes place at the time when city of Troy was being besieged by Achaeans. Achaean leader Agamemnon takes Chrysies as his prize. She prays Apollo, who sends a plague on Achaeans. Achaean hero Achilles asks his mother sea-nymph Thetis to ask Zeus to punish Achaeans for being ignorant towards Achilles:
"God of the silver bow, thy ear incline,
Whose power encircles Cilla the divine;
Whose sacred eye thy Tenedos surveys,
And gilds fair Chrysa with distinguished rays!
If, fired to vengeance at thy priest 's request,
Thy direful darts inflict the raging pest:
Once more attend! Avert the wasteful woe,
And smile propitious, and unbend thy bow" (The Iliad, Book 1, 27)
Homer makes it clear that the only reason for Achaeans to suffer great losses is the fact that Gods turned away from them. One of the most important motives of "Iliad" is fatalism. Yet, poem 's mortal characters do not simply accept that they can 't really oppose to the will of Gods. They exploit the fact that there is no unity among Olympians to their own advantage.
In the end, the situation returns to a status quo, when both parties agree to sign a truce.
This happens after the death of Hector, who is being killed by Achilles, while wearing an armor suit made by Olympian God Hephaestus Gods play an important role in "Iliad". Along with Zeus and Apollo, there are lesser divine beings that actively participate in the plot, such as Thetis, Xanthus, Diomedes and Athena. Gods are just like men - they can suffer and feel sorry for their actions:
"We everlasting gods . . . Ah what chilling blows we sufferthanks to our own conflicting wills whenever we show these mortal men some kindness" ( The Iliad, Book 5, 36)
The poem "Odyssey" is much different from "Iliad". The main character Odysseus has all the mental traits that we usually attribute to regular human being. Although, he is frequently in contact with Olympian Gods, we see him being more independent. His attitude changes, as he is being put through numerous trials and tribulations on his way home. "Odyssey" tell us a story of regular person, who will use his brain to succeed in situations, where using naked force would lead to failure. After having realized that he is being confronted with Olympic gods, who 're actively trying to prevent him from coming home, Odysseus never changes his objectives. He will go as far as denying their authority, in the major act of transgression.
Nevertheless, Odysseys attitude towards the Gods is far from being ignorant. Just like the characters of "Iliad", he recognizes their power of authority:
"Enjoyment of the good the gods provide.
From God 's own hand descend our joys and woes;
These he decrees, and he but suffers those:
All power is his, and whatsoever he wills,
The will itself, omnipotent, fulfils" (The Odyssey, Book XIV, 57)
When Odyssey gets imprisoned at Calypso 's island, he has no choice but to ask Zeus himself for help. Zeus sends Hermes to rescue him. Still, when sea-God Poseidon finds him sailing home, he sends a storm to destroy his ship. Nevertheless, Odyssey manages to survive but he wouldn 't be able to do this if Goddess Athena hadn 't helped him.
It appears that human-Gods relations in "Odyssey" are even more intense than
They are in "The Iliad". The other Greek Gods that play important roles in poem are: Aphrodite, Apollo, Ares, Athena, Hades, Hera, Hermes and Persephone.
Virgil 's "Aeneid" shows us how ancient Romans used to percept surrounding reality.
Author tells us a story of Aeneas, one of the survivors from the sacked city of Troy, who sets out on the quest to fulfill his God 's given destiny to found the city of Rome. The biggest difference between this poem and Homer 's masterpieces is that Virgil doesn 't attribute many of human psychological traits to Gods. This is very typical for Romans they thought of their Gods as often being even deprived of gender.
Sea storms prevent Aeneus from reaching Italy; instead he disembarks to Africa, where he falls in love with Phoenician princess Dido. After staying there for a while, he finally manages to get to Italy, where he meets local king Latinus. Although, it appears that two leaders like each other and there is nothing that might turn them into the enemies, it nevertheless happens, as Gods have different plans:
"Aeneus, remember by your strength to rule
Earth 's peoplesfor your arts are to be these:
To pacify, to impose the rule of law,
To spare the conquered, battle down the proud." (Aeneid, VI.11511154)
Gods want Aeneas to embark on historical mission there is no place for personal feelings. Virgil 's hero also has to deal with God 's wrath; queen of Gods Juno constantly tries to create him problems, yet her motivations aren 't personal.
Goddess Venus, on the other side, helps her son Aeneas and prevents him from getting hurt, whenever she can. The king of Gods Jupiter doesn 't get directly involved in Aeneas 's case, yet he 's aware of his destiny and author make it clear that Jupiter favors Aeneas. The God of Sea Neptune is also on the side of Aeneas, who 's able to safely reach the shores of Carthage, after storm dies down as a result of Neptune 's involvement. Among other Roman Gods that interact with Aeneas, we can name Mercury, Aeolus, Cupid, Allecto, Vulcan, Saturn and Minerva.
The role of divine beings in all three poems can hardly be overestimated. What separates these poems from later Christian literature is the fact the Gods actively participate in people 's affairs and there is no judgment found on them
Bibliography:
1. Homer. "The Odyssey". Translated by Fitzgerald, R. Garden City, NY, Anchor/Doubleday, 1961
2. Homer. "The Iliad". Translated by Lattimore, R. University of Chicago. 1951.
3. Vergil. "Aeneid". Translated by Williams. T. Boston. Houghton Mifflin Co. 1910.
The Outline
1) P. 1, Short introduction of the topic.
2) Pp. 1 2, Homer 's "Iliad" analysis.
3) Pp. 2 3, Homer 's "Odyssey" analysis.
4) Pp. 3 4, Virgil 's "Aeneid" analysis.
Bibliography: 1. Homer. "The Odyssey". Translated by Fitzgerald, R. Garden City, NY, Anchor/Doubleday, 1961 2. Homer. "The Iliad". Translated by Lattimore, R. University of Chicago. 1951. 3. Vergil. "Aeneid". Translated by Williams. T. Boston. Houghton Mifflin Co. 1910. The Outline 1) P. 1, Short introduction of the topic. 2) Pp. 1 – 2, Homer 's "Iliad" analysis. 3) Pp. 2 – 3, Homer 's "Odyssey" analysis. 4) Pp. 3 – 4, Virgil 's "Aeneid" analysis.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The role of the gods as aloof medlers in human affairs is evident in the 1st book of the Iliad. They take roles as protectors of mortals, and they use their mortals to attack and annoy each other. One example is Achilles who is filled with hate and grief after the abduction of his prize. He asks his mother the sea nymph Thetis for help in showing Agamemnon is as an incompetent commander so the Greeks distrust and hate him. Thetis agrees, mostly because her son’s “life is short” (1.436), and calls to Zeus for a favor. The resulting plea is successful, and Zeus promises to “destroy Greeks by the thousands” (1.592). Zeus’ wife Hera, the patron goddess of the Greeks, hears and becomes angry. Zeus disregards her anger and forces Agamemnon to attack…
- 144 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
As all cultures do, the Greeks had beliefs as to how they came to be. These beliefs stretched out into their daily lives and where they went after they died. They worshipped many gods and goddesses, each one having a different sort of specialty. Their rituals included animal sacrifices, myths explained their origins, and they had festivals to celebrate their gods as a way to please them. Not everyone believed firmly in the gods and goddesses, though. Some were even noted as skeptics. However, religion played a large role in the government of Ancient Greece, therefore, as a whole, the theory of the gods and goddesses was widely accepted.…
- 646 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Odyssey and O’ Brother Where Art Thou have many similarities and differences. The poem and the movie have different settings and time periods. The movie is more of a comedy, and the poem is more of a dramatic story of an epic hero on a long journey. The poem and movie have the same main stories, but some of the details are changed. The Odyssey and O’ Brother Where Art Thou compare and contrast because of the storylines, the time periods and settings, and…
- 342 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Complete the matrix section and the question section on the worksheet for each week. For each culture, identify the starting and ending dates of the culture, the structure of government, the role of the city government, and type of law created by the culture. Describe how the culture viewed the relationship between gods and people and how it defined citizenship. List the major events the culture experienced.…
- 1672 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Religion has played a large role in many societies throughout all of history, and this statement does not exempt the Ancient Grecian city-states. This idea is represented through the examination of civilizations such as ancient Athens, Greece in which a polytheistic religion was seen to have dictated much the civilization’s citizens’ lives; religion affected the culture of ancient Athens in regards to art, ceremony and rituals, politics, civil rights, and daily practices.…
- 1504 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
The Homeric epic, the Odyssey, is set in the peaceful years following the Trojan War, and concerns the returning heroes on their journeys home, in particular Odysseus of Ithaca. Odysseus is an epic hero; he displays courage, superior strength, and leadership, all qualities that people admire. While displaying these archetypal heroic traits he also displays his weaknesses as a man, particularly his excessive pride, which actually make him easy to relate to. So by demonstrating his strengths, and overcoming his weaknesses he becomes an epic hero, not only in Homer 's time but in the 21st century as well. Yet these archetypal heroic qualities are not his only heroic qualities, in order to win his battles and find his way home he needed to display other qualities such as cunning, shrewdness, and ingenuity.…
- 1215 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Homer. “The Odyssey” Retellings, Clarke, M.B. and A.G. Clarke. McGraw Hill. New York, NY. 2004. 256-257…
- 2192 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The Odyssey is both the second story in a two-book trilogy written by Homer some time in 700B.C. and an incredible story of an epic journey filled with sorrow, temptation, and a hero journeying home. Similarly to Homer’s Odyssey, The Epic of Gilgamesh(which was written by an unknown author) is also a story involving gods, goddesses, temptation, and a journey to and from Gilgamesh’s home. These two day old stories share many similarities, such as the strings of temptation being strung in the hero’s hearts which exists in addition to their strive to be powerful, as well as their genre, they of course share several differences as well.…
- 386 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Homer. The Odyssey. Holt McDougal Literature Grade 9. Ed. Janet Allen et al. Evanston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2012. 1204-1265. Print.…
- 985 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Homer and Virgil are both astounding writers of epic poetry. Homer with his Iliad and Virgil with his Aeneid. However when you look below the surface the Aeneid and the Iliad are startlingly similar, in particular that of Aeneid Book 5 and Iliad book 23 which both focus on the funeral games. However though there are structurally similar, ultimately the narratives of both books are very different, so in effect Virgil is not simply copying Homer. This is evident from the different views and values portrayed, the timelines of both books and the ideas depicted.…
- 1034 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
It has been known that the Romans and the Greeks have had many interactions with each other, whether it would be due to trading or just plain traveling, the stories of their myths have crossed each other in one way or another. This is may be the reason why there are many similarities between Greek and Roman Mythology. Even though a Greek god or goddess may have a different name in Roman Mythology they still performed similar tasks and were worshiped for similar reasons. I will compare and contrast Greek gods with their Roman equivalences to see how similar they truly are to each other. Probably the most famous Greek god, Zeus, was the god of all gods. Born to Cronus and Rhea, he was the ruler of the sky, and had the power to create thunderstorms and lightning as well as earthquakes. As the story goes he overthrew his father, Cronus, and became the ruler of Mount Olympus to head the new line of Gods. Jupiter, also known as Jove, was very much like Zeus. He was the predominant power holder among the Roman Gods. According to Tripp, Jupiter is a "contraction of two words meaning Heavenly Father.'"(Pg. 332) He ruled the sky, controlled all of the weather, and had thunderbolts as a weapon. Tripp also wrote "Jupiter's cult and his general character were, however, well established in Italy before the Greek religion became influential there." (Pg. 333) This implies that the idea of Zeus, Jupiter and Jove had very little influence on each other since they were created before the Greek myths and Roman myths had started to cross paths. Hera, the wife and sister of Zeus, was the goddess of marriage, childbirth, and the queen of the heavens. She gave birth to Ares, Hebe, and Eileithyia. She also gave birth to Hephaestus, but it has been believed that she bore him without the aid of Zeus. In Ovid's Metamorphoses, she was extremely jealous of the affairs that her husband had and she often tormented or harmed Zeus's mistresses. Juno, the feminine version of…
- 1490 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In the Odyssey by Homer, an epic story is told. Odysseus, the king of Ithaca, was sent to fight in the Trojan War. After Odysseus and his crew had won the war, they set sail on their long journey home. Their journey lasted 20 years and they had to overcome many tragic obstacles along the way. Eventually, Odysseus makes it home to his beloved wife, Penelope, only to find his homeland has been taken over by suitors. The tale of Odysseus's long journey home, the Odyssey qualifies as an epic poem.…
- 729 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Religion has always played a vital role in human society. As our earliest stories and poems indicate, questions of gods, divinity, immortality, and creation existed in ancient cultures and pervaded many facets of daily life, including literature. In The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Leiden Hymns we see not only this literary preoccupation with questions of divinity, but also stories and attitudes that foreshadow contemporary Abrahamic religions––Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. However, this is not to suggest that religion is so universal that there are not meaningful differences across time and cultures. In observing these differences, we might look particularly at the ways in which the gods are represented in Gilgamesh and The Leiden Hymns in…
- 1451 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In order to properly compare and contrast the mythological aspects of Aeneid with Iliad and Odyssey, the authors must first be examined as their writing style and personal history influences their stories. Homer, the author of Iliad and Odyssey, was both a poet and an entertainer, and is revered as one of the greatest Greek authors who lived. He was spontaneous and easily captivated his audiences with his stories of Greek gods and heroes, although he was a man of humble decent with no political aim to his poetry. His works were originally presented orally and later dictated. (Powell, 2009).…
- 509 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Literature throughout world history contains many of the same themes and motifs. The works that will be discussed in this paper: Homer’s The Iliad, Aristophanes’ Lysistrata, and Ovid’s Metamophoses, all contain common themes. The first theme is love, whether it is the love between a man and a woman, parent and child, or the love of siblings. Love is a driving force for many of the characters in these works. The second theme is sex, whether it is symbolic or literal, forceful or complaisant. Sex is not always the main theme of a story, but the sexual overtures are dominant in many of these works. Finally this paper will discuss the intervention of the gods. The gods play a major role in world literature. Sometimes a character acts in a certain way so the gods will not be upset. Other times, the gods intervene personally to alter the way life is lived by the mortals. This paper will discuss how love, sex, and the gods are the driving forces of many of the characters in the works of historical literature.…
- 2160 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays