Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Odyssey comparison

Powerful Essays
1380 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Odyssey comparison
I believe that the main human conflict of the Odyssey is perseverance. Throughout the novel it shows Odysseus’s multiyear journey back home from the Trojan War with his comrades even after most of them die on the journey. The modern work that I will be comparing the Odyssey to is O Brother, Where Art Thou. Both of the works are about the perseverance of a group of men that are encountered by numerous people that get in the way or attempt to stop them from accomplishing their mission.
The similarities between O Brother, Where Art Thou? and Homer's Odyssey are numerous, ranging from the obvious to the obscure. The only direct reference is the line of text shown at the beginning of the film, "O Muse! Sing in me, and through me tell the story...", which is one translation of the first line of the Odyssey. In addition to this, there are a few characters in the film that share names with similar characters in the Odyssey, Ulysses which is the Latin form of the Greek name Odysseus is the first name of the film's main character, Ulysses Everett McGill. Menelaus 'Pappy' O'Daniel, who releases the group of men at the end, shares his first name with the King of Sparta who fought alongside Odysseus at Troy. Pappy O'Daniel's rival in the election is Homer Stokes, who shares his first name with the author of the classical text. Odysseus' wife was named Penelope. Penny, a shortened version of Penelope, is the name of Everett’s wife. The blind man in the radio station may also represent Homer, the author of the Odyssey who was also blind. Just as Homer was the first to record the story of Odysseus, the blind radio station operator is the first to record Everett and his group.
Similarities between Odysseus and Everett Odysseus' pride works against his success. Such as when he yells his name and hometown to Polyphemus the Cyclopes and now knowing that, Polyphemus is able to ask Poseidon to cause more trouble for Odysseus. All throughout the film Everett applies a product to his hair, suggesting his pride, and in one scene after he refuses to be baptized, viewers learn that the smell of the pomade is how the dogs are able to track the group so easily. Pete even mentions that, had Everett agreed to be baptized, "At least it would've washed away the stink of that Pomade." Parallels between Penelope and Penny at the end of the film, Everett's wife sets him a near-impossible task of retrieving a ring. At the end of the Odyssey, Odysseus still has a quest left as well: he must string the bow and fire it through a row of 12 axes. Odysseus tested Penelope’s faith by first appearing before her in disguise, and Penelope does not recognize him, until he later reveals himself. Everett appears in disguise on stage when the group sings "Man of Constant Sorrow." Penny also does not recognize him until he reveals himself to her. There are also comparisons of the monsters and others met by Odysseus. Big Dan Teague is related to Polyphemus the Cyclops. In the Odyssey, the cyclops falls asleep drunk and has his eye put out by Odysseus and his crew with a sharpened log. In the film, Big Dan is almost blinded by the sharpened pole of the Confederate flag but catches it, only to be crushed underneath the flaming cross that Everett releases. The falling burning cross then drives the pointed stake into Teague’s only good eye, therefore completing the parallel to the Cyclops. The Sirens on the island try and lure Odysseus and his men with their singing. In the film they do the same and hypnotize Everett, Delmar and Pete, and coerce them to drink alcohol until they pass out. The sorceress Circe successfully turns the companions of Odysseus into pigs. In the film, the group of sirens goes and turns Pete into a toad. The blind black man on the railroad push car could be a parallel to Nestor, who is consulted by Odysseus' son Telemachus. As another parallel Homer himself was according to tradition blind and bearded. The merciless sheriff is perhaps analogous to Hades and his hound echoes Cerberus. A link between Satan and Poseidon may be being made when Everett mentions that Satan carries "a giant hay fork" (a trident); both figures are often depicted with just such an instrument.
The travelers' siege in the Hogwallop barn relates to Odysseus's dangerous time between Scylla and Charybdis when Everett helplessly cries "Damn! We're in a tight spot!". There is a trance-like progression of worshippers seeking to be baptised. Their quietness draws a parallel with the Lotus-Eaters of the Odyssey. Immediately after Delmar is baptized, he proclaims he will only follow "the straight and narrow from here on out." This may be an allusion to the crew of Odysseus no longer wanting to continue on their quest after an encounter with the Lotus-Eaters.
At one point George Nelson shoots at a herd of cattle. Odysseus and his fellow travelers slaughter the cows of the sun god Helios. Odysseus warns his men against killing the sacred oxen. Delmar warns Nelson, "Oh, George, not the livestock!" In addition to this, in the Odyssey Odysseus' ship is struck by a thunderbolt killing all but him. In the film, George is sent to be executed in the electric chair. During the parade to the execution, someone leading a cow behind the mob yells, "Cow killer!!!"
George Nelson is a parallel to Agamemnon, who persuaded Odysseus into joining the Greeks against Troy, while Nelson enlisted Everett and the boys as accomplices in his bank-robbing spree. When the guys sneak into the city hall towards the end of the movie, they disguise themselves by wearing beards. This could reference how Odysseus sneaks into his hometown dressed in beggars clothes with long hair and beard. The scene in the theater, when Pete tries to warn Everett and Delmar, parallels Odysseus' descent into the underworld, Hades. Delmar, believing that Pete had died, mistakes him (and thus also the other people in the theater) for a ghost. In this scene Pete parallels Tiresias in the underworld. Another underworld parallel is the KKK's cross-burning ceremony. Pete, Delmar, and Everett fall down a steep incline (hence, a descent), and rise bathed in the red light of the flames of the Klan's ceremony. The flames, chanting chorus of a song and the grand wizard in his red robes all suggest a hellish place. Everett's daughters stand for Odysseus's son Telemachus. In the film, Everett first meets his daughters again, before he meets his wife, as Odysseus first meets his son, and later on Penelope. The movie follows the theme of “in media res”, which means "in the middle of things." The Odyssey begins by telling of Odysseus being trapped on Calypso's island without telling how he became trapped there until later in the epic. The film begins with Everett, Delmar, and Pete escaping from the labor farm without telling how they arrived there in the first place. The dialogue in a scene between Everett and his daughters also use a reference to its ancient influence. Using Latin terms, one of the girls says that Waldrip is bona fide, and Everett responds that he is the pater familias. The girls also use the word suitor twice. In the scene where the trio and George Nelson are sitting around the fire after the robbery at Itta Bena, there are Greek columns in the background. Everett also comes back to stop the marriage and fight Vernon, much as Odysseus comes back to kill the suitors. Everett, however, is badly beaten by Vernon. These examples tie together the fact that the novel the Odyssey and the movie O Brother, Where Art Thou are connected. The directors of the movie claim to not have read the book and used it as an influential piece but how can you get such a similar result without having that background knowledge. This source supports my claim here (http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/mou/summary/v007/7.3.siegel.html). Though some view it as a loose comparison I believe just like many other people that it was a heavy influence.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    One of the strongest allusions in O’ Brother Where Art Thou? and The Odyssey are the parallels between the characters Big Dan to Polythemus, Penny to Penelope, and Everett to Odysseus. In the movie Big Dan was a tall and quite large man; this adverted to Polythemus the Cyclopes in the book The Odyssey. Both Characters had a large and burly build with one functioning eyes. Big Dan terrorized Everett and his two companions by “killing” one of them. Polythemus trapped Odysseus and a few of his men in a cave and took many of the men’s lives. After Everett’s encounter with Big Dan he started to feel for others and experienced sorrow and sympathy because he lost one of his companions. He learned how important having people to count on was. Another allusion made in O’ Brother Where Art Thou? is how Penny signified Penelope from The Odyssey. Both Penny and Penelope were in search of suitors after their husbands left. Penelope’s husband, Odysseus, went to fight a war while Penny’s husband, Everett, was taken as a criminal. In the end both wives ended up taking back their original husbands because the men proved their loyalty. Last but not least is the allusion between the characters. Everett and Odysseus. The two characters start out being stubborn and self-centered. Everett was concerned about his self-image. One line he says over and over again is…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many similarities between the characters of Odysseus from “The Odyssey” and Everett from “O Brother Where Art Thou”. One similarity is that both characters are on a journey home to their families. To portray, Everett says “Me an’ the old lady are gonna pick up the pieces and…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The movie “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” explains the story of Odysseus in “The Odyssey” through a more modern storyteller. In fact, the movie uses very similar character names so today’s audience can easily relate the movie to the original poem “The Odyssey.” For example, Ulysses is Latin for the name Odysseus. Even Odysseus wife’s name is Peggy, while Ulysses wife’s name is Penny. These similarities are shown throughout the movie not only with character names, but also with the original myths in the stories. Most of the same myths in “The Odyssey” are shown in the movie as well, such as the story of the Cyclops, the Sirens, and many more. While the myths are told differently in the movie, they still maintain the underlying story that was being told. The movie the “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” is a modern depiction of Homers “The Odyssey,” which shares several similarities that show the journey of Odysseus to his family in a modern day more realistic setting and shows the relevance and power of the story to today’s audience through examples in the story of the Teiresias, the Cyclops, the Sirens and Circe, and the transformation into an old man.…

    • 1874 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Both Odysseus and Everett are considered epic heroes. The film “O’ Brother Where Art Thou” is based on the adventures of Odysseus from “The Odyssey”. They both have similar challenges, but also have differences in the details. Such as, the enemies they face, the time they are from and how they try to fix their relationship with their wives. Both the poem and movie are similar to each other, but they aren’t absolutely the same.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Odyssey, is a legendary tale written by David Adams Leeming. This epic tells the story of a wise man named Odysseus who struggled to return back to his homeland, Ithaca, after the fall of Troy. In comparison to the text, the movie "O Brother Where Art Thou," has a similar plot and is based on The Odyssey. In the movie, Ulysses Everett McGill is the main character played by George Clooney. Everett and Odysseus both encounter different struggles in their journeys throughout the movie and the book; however, both characters ' main goal was to be reunited with their families back home.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie “O Brother, Where Art Thou” is remarkably similar to Homer’s “Odyssey” in both plot and character description. Many stories and movies have been based on the same plot as The Odyssey, but one movie in particular did a wonderful job in comparing the two stories, “O Brother, Where Art Thou.” “O Brother, Where Art Thou” is about a man who has to break out of jail to stop his wife from marrying another man and includes his voyage home. “The Odyssey” is about the adventures and misfortunes of Odysseus These two movies, with many of the same events occurring in both allows for the works to be compared easily and thoroughly. Although there is some differences.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One day, in the far away land of Olympia, lived two gods named Zeus and Poseidon. Zeus and Poseidon are brothers, but Poseidon prefers not to be seen by other mortals or gods. Therefore, he was already mad Zeus for bringing him to Olympia, but little did they both know that it was about to all go down hill. Just before Zeus pulled Poseidon out of the ocean, he saw a mortal girl named Ara. Ara is a very beautiful woman and most people are attracted to her. Besides the fact that Zeus has already had three affairs, he had to win over the heart of Ara. That leaves us where we are now with Zeus and Poseidon. Poseidon is now out of the ocean and refused to go into town.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The part I liked most about O Brother, Where Art Thou in relation to the Odyssey is the way George Clooney's character brings out the silver tongue aspect of Odysseus' act. He uses jargon and 'big words' that befuddle and charm anyone he directs his words toward. For example, in one of the first scenes of the movie, Everett tries to befuddle the other escapees into electing him as their leader by throwing difficult words at them. To be honest, I was surprised they understood him enough to understand that he was asking to vote on the matter. I never really understood what Odysseus being the smartest and most strategic of group meant while reading the Odyssey. However, O Brother, Where Art Thou did a wonderful job of bringing out this characteristic of Odysseus in a modern context in which the audience could understand better.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Homer’ s story The Odyssey tells of a triumphant hero named Odysseus and how his heroism saves his entire crew from the sirens. On the other hand, (“O Brother Where Art Thou”?) is not about bravery, but about being under the influence of the women's beauty and magical alcohol. Finally, Margaret Atwood's poem “Siren Song” talks about the women who are called the “sirens” the women who are part human and part bird, they sing the most beautiful song to get the men to crawl over board.…

    • 106 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two men, though part of different stories, travel long journeys to return home. Their paths face many obstacles and trials. How do their stories compare? The main characters are Odysseus, from Homer’s, The Odyssey, and Everett from O Brother Where Art Thou, directed by Ethan and Joel Coen. Though O Brother Where Art Thou, is based on The Odyssey, the two share many similarities and differences, such as the characters’ encounters with others, conflicts faced in the stories, and characteristics of the major characters.…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As Odysseus escapes the cyclops, he tricks him by getting him drunk and stabs Polyphemus with a wooden spear in the eye. Once the escape is complete, Odysseus yells back at Polyphemus telling him his name is Odysseus and he was the son of Laertes. "But I would not listen to them, and shouted out to him in my rage, 'Cyclops, if anyone asks you who it was that put your eye out and spoiled your beauty, say it was the valiant warrior Ulysses, son of Laertes, who lives in Ithaca.” This quote is stated from The Odyssey book 9. This quote from the Odyssey concludes that Odysseus states with all passion, his name and his relative to the cyclops. By doing this he has committed an act of hubris.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story, The Odyssey, by Homer is about King Odysseus of Ithaca and his long journey and struggles to get back home. He was known as a strong, courageous and cunning warrior. He left home to fight in the Trojan War that lasted 10 years. On his journey back to Ithaca he meets up with different setbacks that ends up taking him 19 years to return home. While he is gone a group of wooers try to marry his wife Penelope and kill his son Telemachus. Odysseus creates a plan to disguise himself as a beggar and take back his throne. Odysseus almost losses Ithaca and everyone he loved. He is justified in killing all of the wooers to keep his wife Penelope, save his son Telemachus’ life and getting rid of every wooer that hurt his family to take back his…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Odyssey” , by Homer is an epic poem telling the journey of Odysseus on his way back home to Ithaca. Homer wrote the Odyssey to show how heroic Odysseus is and how he served as a model for all his people. His message to the people was that it takes more than just strength to be a hero. All heroes have different qualities that define them and Odysseus had the traits of a H…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Odyssey, written by Homer, describes an epic hero to be a mortal male, someone who goes on along, dangerous expedition, also who is very brave, intelligent, and responsible. He will face many conflicts yet always manages to prevail. Odysseus possesses all these traits and demonstrates it throughout the entire Odyssey, such as when Odysseus and his men become trapped in a Cyclops’ cave and he needs to figure out a way to escape using his intelligence as well as when he must think up how he is too make it passed a deathly part of the ocean that lures you to your death with divine, angelic songs, and also having to decide between the death of…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Lord of the Rings and Odyssey are two very weird stories in my opinion. The two stories include several similarities. The most noteworthy similarity of the two that were in common was the use of themes. Both included similar themes such as, life, death,power, brotherly love, myth, temptation, and journey.…

    • 1538 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays