Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Misperception of Women in the Postwar Era

Powerful Essays
2469 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Misperception of Women in the Postwar Era
The Misperception of Women in the Postwar Era In the years between 1945 and 1960, modern history's typical view of American women is that of a subordinated, suppressed and acquiescent group struggling to obtain the ideas of domesticity and conservatism portrayed by popular culture. Many assumptions are made about changing gender roles and their affects upon women as a whole during this period. To us, women in the postwar era are most easily and commonly represented by the image of the ideal wife and mother, who spends her days maintaining the perfect household in which she lives and caring for the family she loves. Much is made of the changes that occurred during World War II, when women occupied a large portion of the workforce, and in the 1960's, when the feminist movement came to fruition. The changes that took place between these periods are often neglected or simply not noticed, but more often they are overshadowed by the dominating stereotype of the homemaker. Many women of the time did not fit the mold of housewife, and were actually continuing the feminist movement that was given new life with symbolic figures, such as Rosy the Riveter, during World War II. Contrary to popular belief, the feminist movement saw great changes in the 1950's. In Not June Cleaver, Joanne Meyerowitz says "historians have long acknowledged that increasing numbers of women sought and found wage work, albeit in traditionally female jobs, in the postwar era." The feminist movement did not simply disappear after women returned to their homes at the end of the war, but rather remained as a somewhat underground fixture of the cultural climate. According to William H. Chafe, author of The American Woman: Her Changing Social, Economic, and Political Roles, 1920-1970, "the most striking feature of the 1950's was the degree to which women continued to enter the job market and expand their sphere." Though these changes did in fact occur, they seem to have been disregarded in favor of the victimized image of women that we know today, party due to such popular books as The Feminine Mystique, by Betty Friedan. Though The Feminine Mystique was an astounding accomplishment as a protagonist for the feminist movement, it used the stereotype of the submissive woman of the time to force social change and inadvertently became the widely-accepted version of events. According to Friedan, postwar cultural influences urged women to retreat into the home and give up the accomplishments gained during the war, and few protested.
In researching the postwar era, I have discovered that this version of events is not entirely accurate, that it is actually more of a gross misconception than a simple generalization. Many magazines, which were all very popular and widely read at the time, contained interpretations of gender and women's role in society and challenged traditional ideologies; many of these were written by men as well as women. They reached hundreds of thousands of Americans and were read by members of many demographics. Though magazines of the 1950's can also be used to paint the opposite picture and seem repressive rather than progressive, this only adds to the contradictory nature of the times and further suggests that they were times of change. Some of these articles supported women's presence in the home and duties of motherhood, while others encouraged women to seek public success. The fact that both sides of the debate were being argued displays the fallacy of Betty Friedan's generalizations; women were not being forced into domesticity, but given the opportunity to obtain professional recognition. Though many women did choose to remain in the home, a significant number were part of the workforce and actively participated in the furthering of the women's movement as well.
In a review of The Feminine Mystique, featured in the New York Times Book Review, Lucy Freeman states, "despite the baby boom and despite discrimination in employment, education, and public office, married women, black and white, joined the labor force in increasing numbers, and both married and unmarried women participated actively in politics and reform." It is my belief that women were much more diverse in their choices and that their role in society was much more complex than is often acknowledged.
In a sample of articles written in the 1950's, collected by Joanne Meyerowitz, many concerns were expressed regarding the postwar economy, but journalists repeatedly defended paid employment for women. One article began with the statement, "most American working women need their jobs. That's the stark and simple reason why hiring and firing policies arbitrarily based on sex discrimination don't make sense."4 The argument for women's wage work was often supported by the plain and simple fact that they needed money, but by the 1950's, encompassed both personal satisfaction and economic benefits. Articles commonly promoted part-time and full-time work and included opportunities for older women. According to one article, "a part-time job can bring a feeling of full-time usefulness and satisfaction." Another article suggested tax breaks for child-care expenses and flexible hours for working mothers.5 These articles supported paid employment and represented it in a positive light for both women and society. Many articles described the rewarding job possibilities and the practically unlimited opportunities supposedly available to women.
Although these articles suggest a consensus, a debate did exist concerning the ideals of achievement outside of the home versus domestic duties. While some authors recommended that women give up careers for their homes and motherhood, others encouraged them to seek public success. Careers themselves were not often discussed in detail, which indicates that postwar popular magazines rarely addressed controversial issues. Sometimes an article would warn readers not to sacrifice marriage for career, or offer a statement from an un-married career-woman such as "I like my life the way it is," but generally, serious consideration of the issue was avoided.6
More middle class women were entering the labor force by the 1950's, inciting journalists to look more closely at their concerns. Some journalists proposed a "modern woman's life cycle," assuming that mothers of young children would work part-time and pursue careers after their children had grown up or if they divorced. These journalists often discussed the difficulty of combining career and motherhood. Other authors suggested that women work for as long as they could because older women experienced difficulty in attempting to reenter the workforce.7 Of course, many acknowledged that married women would pursue a variety of interests in different periods of their lives.
Surprisingly, postwar magazines were, for the most part, in favor of women's participation in politics. The Ladies' Home Journal, not considered a feminist magazine of the times, was extremely positive in its view of women in politics. The magazine even began a monthly segment encouraging women's involvement in politics. One article, by activist Margaret Hickey, even went so far as to state, "Make politics your business. Voting, office holding, raising your voice for new and better laws are just as important to your home and your family as the evening meal or spring house cleaning."8 Margaret Hickey seems to rationalize women's political activism by relating its benefits to their domestic lives, but still stresses the importance of their participation outside of the home, beyond voting. Another article asked women to "enter actively into politics as a primary responsibility."9 Yet another article, titled "They Do It . . . You Can Too," directly appealed to mothers and housewives, commending women politicians who balanced their duties as mothers of babies or small children and still found "time and ways to campaign and to win elections." The same article also referred to the personal satisfaction gained from holding political office, claiming that "there is great pride of accomplishment and the satisfaction of ‘doing a job.'"10
The Ladies' Home Journal was so emphatic in its encouragement of women politicians that it even argued that inherent gender differences made women more proficient in government. Some authors claimed that women and mothers are better suited to the field of politics because they are more peaceful and "civilized" than men. They associated women's natural instinct as protectors and voices of morality with an affinity for peacekeeping and eradicating corruption. As one article stated, "cleaning house has always been a woman's job." Gender differences were used here to encourage women to move beyond the home rather than push them back into it.11 In the postwar American world, women's public participation was indeed incorporated into popular culture.
Individualism was sometimes mentioned in association with issues of domestic life and marriage. The conflict between domestic life and public life was expressed, by some authors, as a conflict between individuality and gender roles. Traditional gender roles, in which women were primarily devoted mothers and obedient wives, were pitted against modern roles in which women were individuals. Significantly, these authors did not always agree with the idea of women as submissive nurturers, as Betty Friedan may have led us to believe. They believed that an ideal marriage was an equal partnership, in which both partners exchanged the duties traditionally associated with either the man or the woman. One article, featured in a 1958 Coronet magazine, insisted "the healthy, emotionally well-balanced male . . . isn't alarmed by the fact that women are human, too, and have an aggressive as well as a passive side . . . He takes women seriously as individuals."12 This article, along with others, actually denounced men who behaved in a superior manner. As another article stated, "The dominating husband and submissive wife are things of the past."13 Although ideas such as this were expressed ardently, many also believed that individualism could be taken too far and disrupt modern marriage. Men may have taken on more domestic activities and women may have pursued work outside of the home, but men remained the main sources of income and women continued to be the keepers of the home. Generally, popular postwar literature did not seem to challenge marriage or the sexual division of labor. Individualism may have been mentioned simply so that authors could dismiss it. In most popular magazines, strictly feminist or antifeminist views rarely appeared. Most articles drew from both positions and the majority did not fall into either side. The antifeminist view did appear occasionally, but so did the opposing "women's rights" stance. Antifeminist authors proclaimed that domesticity was a woman's only way to obtain fulfillment. They argued that women should not compete with men, but rather depend on them. These conservative antifeminists claimed that men and women are fundamentally different and that attempts to reduce or obscure this difference could only lead to unhappiness. They labeled ‘modern women' neurotic, narcissistic, unfeminine, domineering, nagging, lazy, materialistic and spoiled.14 The opinions expressed by these traditionalists were by no means typical. Only a small percentage of articles expressed such extreme views. Antifeminist sentiments were more often rejected than embraced. This was an era of positive thinking and magazines reflected this by commonly presenting more positive representations of women. "Women's rights," or feminist viewpoints, were also expressed. They observed women's subordinate treatment and sought to challenge this. While the antifeminists focused on traditional, domestic ideals, women's rights advocates promoted women's right to pursuits outside of the home. Strangely, both feminist and antifeminist authors recognized a decline in women's participation in domestic activities and described the modern housewife as unhappy. However, feminist articles denounced subordination to men and isolation in the home. They respected women who attained positions of public responsibility and leadership. They also sought out and fought against discrimination in the workplace and in politics. In a Harper's article, Agnes Rogers states "There would be a healthier distribution of civic energy if more attention were paid to individuals as such and if it were not assumed that men hold the executive jobs and women do what they are told."15 These articles paid less attention to gender roles and sometimes accused men of misogynistic behavior. Women's rights articles were not as common as their antifeminist counterparts, but could be taken to the same extremes and seem offensive to the opposing audience. Through the 1950's, neither position seems to dominate public opinion in popular magazines.
According to Betty Friedan, women's passionate search for individual identity ended in the late 1940's. She said that the postwar magazines subordinated women and kept them isolated in their homes by adopting a popular antifeminist view. My research suggests otherwise. Articles focusing on motherhood and marriage actually seem less common in the 1950's than those concerning women's journey into the workplace and out of the home. Women were, in fact, much more diverse in their choices and that their role in society was much more complex than is often acknowledged. This is just as evident if not more so than any opposing perspective. Maybe the success of The Feminine Mystique was that it struck a chord in women because the themes it presented were already present in the mass culture. Though many remain unaware, the feminist movement did indeed see great changes throughout the 1950's.

Bibliography

Joanne Meyerowitz, Not June Cleaver: Women and Gender in Postwar America, 1945-1960 (Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1994), 4. William H. Chafe, The American Woman: Her Changing Social, Economic, and Political Roles, 1920-1970. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1972), 218. Lucy Freeman, review of Feminine Mystique by Friedan, New York Times Book Review, April 7, 1963, 46.
4 Frances J. Myers, "Don't Take it Out on the Women," Woman's Home Companion, January 1946, 12.
5 Millicent C. McIntosh, "Busy Women Have Time Enough," Ladies' Home Journal, June 1952, 47.
6 Evelyn Sager, "Profile of Success," Ladies' Home Journal, March 1952, 104.
7 Elsie McCormick, "When an Older Woman Wants a Job," Ladies' Home Journal, January 1954, 120.
8 Margaret Hickey, "What's the U.S. to You?," Ladies' Home Journal, April 1950, 23.
9 Margaret Hickey, "We Can't Let the Children Down," Ladies' Home Journal, March 1952, 104.
10 Margaret Hickey, "They Do It . . . You Can Too," Ladies' Home Journal, April 1956, 70.
11 Dorothy Thompson, "A Woman Says, ‘You Must Come into the Room of Your Mother Unarmed,'" Ladies' Home Journal, February 1946, 24-25.
12 John Kord Lagemann, "How to Pick a Mate," Coronet, February 1958, 116-117.
13 Gretta Palmer, "What Kind of Wife Has He?" Reader's Digest, March 1948, 37-39.
14 Marlene Cox, "How to Prepare Your Daughter for a Divorce," Ladies' Home Journal, May 1946, 174-175, 216-217.
15 Agnes Rogers, "The Humble Female," Harper's, March 1950, 59.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    During the 1840’s and ‘50’s, women from both the North and the South had unwavering roles that they played in their societies. Northern society bustled into wealth and culture. The homes were made more luxurious, adorning many intricate patterns, lush fabrics and intense colors. Higher standards for living were put into perspective, and women were the cornerstones to hold them in place. Women in the North were under the direct authority of their husbands, although few freedoms were allowed. Families were dependent upon the husband as the sole income of the house; workingwomen were considered a lower-class standard and only did so out of necessity. Many women were uneducated past an elementary level and encouraged to marry young. In the household, women were the cogs in the great oiled machine of family life. Though their education did not advance academically, women were deemed the “domestic guardians” of the home. Women “learned to place a higher value on keeping a clean, comfortable, and well-appointed home; on entertaining; and on dressing elegantly and stylishly.” (Chapter 10, Page 258) Women even developed a special female culture revolving around romance novels and magazines featuring shopping, homemaking, and domestic concerns of the modern housewife.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This period (1940’s) was a time of many tumultuous changes for the nation in general, such as World War 1 and the Great depression. Each of these factors significantly influenced women’s roles in both the family and the work force. Expectations of women were greater and more settled in the 1940’s. Young women then were expected to marry at a young age, usually around eighteen years of age. Although you may think that that was too young of a time to marry, in my opinion it kept women from running around with many kids and no father. At least they were a family. Women were expected to work hard in factories and domestic services. However, most women were having duties at home doing chores, babysitting, educating their children and run the house while the husband was not there. Society thought that doing these things would be a “successful women” (Sophia Cassey,) which they were somewhat right. If you look at these women, they became very successful hardworking women, making money and still taking care of home and nothing has changed.…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The roles of women took a big turn and have developed into new roles for them today in modern society. According to Erika Cox in Life in the 1950’s, “Life in the early 1950’s was still very strict. Women were still obligated to the status of housewives and men were the main breadwinners in the family.” In the 1950’s and 60’s housekeeping and raising a family were considered ideal female roles. Women were expected to be perfect, in every way. Everyone wanted the perfect TV family and a wife who would gladly wash the dishes and do the housework. In 1950s Daily Life, Kayla Allen writes “Women were the ones who had to cook and clean. They had dinner on the table before their husbands came home from work. That lets them know that their wives are concerned for their needs.”For example, other than women having dinner ready, they also had to take care of the children, keep the house organized, and happily wait for their husband to come home from work. In our television programming of today, we see women taking the jobs of men. Women are now able to get an education and become police officers, join the military, and many other things. Females are now able to take the role of a female along with the role of a male. They have now become the housewife and the breadwinner in the family.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The typical American woman during the 1930’s was shown in the world as a housewife, they were portrayed as women happy to stay home, clean and care for the children. They were typically seen as women who were very well dressed to do house hold chores and…

    • 672 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1950s vs Today

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Secondly, life has improved for women today because now women are taken more seriously in the business world. In the 1950's, the fact that a woman was even attending college was uncanny and paranormal, and the few brave women that chose to learn further were not taught mathematics and science (fields they were later going to succeed in) but home economics and cooking. Additionally, during the 1950’s, because housekeeping and raising a family were considered ideal female roles, only two out of five…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The misnomer that very few women had jobs back in the 30's and 40's, is not true. In fact, the majority of women had jobs. Even during the Great Depression, almost all women leaving school looked for jobs, and eventually found one. Of the women born in 1915, 91% had a job by 1938, which was relatively good compared to the 96% of men in the work force. Most women, however, quit their jobs after getting married so by 1939, there were millions of housewives with a variety of job experience. The untapped resource of high school and college women made for potential recruits for the wartime labor force (Campbell, p.73).…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Wwii Impact on Women

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages

    With life hard on women already holding the home together while their husbands were in the war, they were forced to fill the spots that were usually held by men. Being in the workforce and doing jobs they would have never imagined doing such as: working in the factories, in transportation, and in government. These would have never been offered to women if there were men available. To get these women interested in getting involved, the “government teamed up with industry, the media, and woman’s organizations in an effort to urge them to join the labor force: their agenda: telling women it was their “patriotic duty” to go to work.” While doing these non-traditional jobs they still did jobs traditionally performed by women such as: sales and clerical, nursing, and teaching. “Nearly a million women were hired by the federal government and women's share of federal jobs increased from 18.8 per cent in 1940 to 37.5 per cent in 1945. Many women earned higher incomes than ever before, yet their wages were still not comparable to male pay. Women increasingly joined labor unions; the proportion of union members that were women raised from 9.4 per cent in 1940 to 21.8 per cent in 1944 .This shows just a few jumps in percentages that women went from just in those few years. Especially the percentage of women actually enlisting in the military rose…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Role of Women in Wwii

    • 4604 Words
    • 19 Pages

    Hartmann, Susan M. The Home Front and Beyond: American Women in the 1940s. Boston: Twayne Publishers, 1982.…

    • 4604 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    World War Two has often been described as a turning point in the battle for equality between men and women. From the beginning, women were always struggling to gain status, respect, and rights in their society. Prior to World War Two, a woman's role in society was seen as someone who cooked, cleaned, and gave birth. The years during and following the war marked a turning point in the battle for equality. Women, for once, were being seen as individuals with capabilities outside the kitchen, and we're for the first time given a chance to prove themselves. On December 7, 1942, Pearl Harbour was bombed and FDR (Franklin D. Roosevelt) declared war. This marked the entry of the US into World War Two, a war which has been going on in Europe for almost 2 years prior. The start of World War II opened a new chapter in the lives of women living in America. From coast to coast, husbands, fathers, sons and brothers were shipped out to fight in Europe. With the entry of the US and the absence of large quantities of men, the demand for supplies increased, and women were called out of the kitchen and into the workforce. Posters, banners, and jingles were all aspects that helped encourage women's entrance into the workforce. Millions marched into factories, offices, and military bases. The demand for labour was so great, that a poll taken that year showed that only 13% of the population opposed females entering the workforce. Women's occupations varied from war nurses and cooking for the army, to making bombs and making weapons. Other occupations flourished, as well. Women photographers, writers, and reports were for once given a chance. The war offered women opportunity never given to them before. The war has given women a chance to show what they can do in the world, and they have done well. Women were given freedom and a chance to live the American dream.…

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With World War Two long over women still remained in the workforce, but it took a long time for them to be viewed as equals. Most people also expected women to the workforce to make room for the men returning from war. The exact opposite happened and the women stayed in the workforce, with the intent of remaining in their jobs. Though some people saw women as a nuisance in the workforce. ”What’s become of Rosie the Riveter?” asked Frieda S. Miller in the New York Times of May 5, 1946. She answered: “Yesterday’s war worker (is) today’s housewife.”(Foner 478-479)”. With women remaining on the workforce most jobs were filled and the amount of available ones was limited. The view of women in society was changing and no one knew what was going to happen next, especially with government propaganda everywhere. “The Saturday Evening Post’s wartime cover glorifying “Rosie the Riveter” was supplanted by covers featuring Norman Rockwell’s idealization of the housewife. (Foner 478-479)”. With the government controlling the majority of the news propaganda was everywhere. Their main objective was to try and get women to go back to staying at home and letting men rejoin the workforce. But as time went on people eventually accepted that women were going to remain in the workforce. Though women remained in the workforce many were fired from their jobs, with the only excuse being they belong in the house not a…

    • 1574 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The role of women in American society changed from the traditional homemaker to modern-day breadwinners owing to the outcomes of various events that occurred from the end of the Civil War in 1865. However, this paper will analyze and discuss the various events such as suffrage, the professional barrier held by the male counterparts, and societal discrimination. In addition, the enactment of State laws that illegalized wife battery, equal payment, in addition to the decision by the Supreme Court to allow Belva Lockwood to be the first women to testify before it in 1879. These events formed the basis of the significant events that shaped the make-up of the modern women since 1985.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rosie The Riveter Thesis

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rosie the Riveters show the courage women had to serve their country even with society stigmas are against them. The propaganda used during World War 2 shows the evolution of advertisement over a couple of decades. I chose these three articles for the detail of involvement women had during the war. After World War 2, social standards for women would change, creating a chain reaction across the nation for equal rights, broken segregation and stigmas to be tested. Introducing females into the work force has slowly dissolved the stereo types regarding fragile stay at home…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    While most American men were off fighting for their country during World War II, it was the women who brought home the bacon every night. Since males weren’t around to support their families, females had to step up. House-wives and many other females started working for the first time, and all because of the media and propaganda that the government used to persuade them. Rosie the Riveter, one piece of propaganda during World War II, was a major reason behind women joining the work force and proving, for a short time, what they were capable of.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The changing roles of women throughout history has been drastic, and none more so than the period during and after World War II. The irrevocable changes that occurred once the war started and women went to work were unprecedented.…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Life in 1950s

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages

    For women in the 1950s, life was centred on the family and domestic duties. During the war women became accustomed to the workforce, and the return of men marked the end of their working life. Women who held wartime jobs were expected to return home to their family and resume their roles as mothers and produce what is now known as the ‘Baby Boomer generation’. With most women leaving the workforce, many well-paying jobs became available for returning war veterans. With women taking the back seat in society, the push for equality was on the rise.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays