Preview

the lottery and Harrison Bergeron

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1393 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
the lottery and Harrison Bergeron
People have been participating in governing their countries either directly or indirectly since a sort of politics came into being. A small number of people can monopolize authority and abuse it for the sake of their own benefits unless masses of people take part in governing their countries. Therefore, their participation plays very crucial roles in their societies. By not taking their political actions, they can become passive. It can result in unfavorable societies. The Lottery and Harrison Bergeron stories criticize reckless obedience made by people in two societies described in very sensational manner. Purpose of this essay is to analyze how the stories describe passive societies in order to criticize a blind obedience by comparing and contrasting two stories. Both stories have more similarities than differences between the society structures and more differences than similarities among the characters for criticizing a blind obedience for authorized power.

Similarities between two society structures in the stories will be discussed in this part. First, there are cruel policies in both societies. In the Lottery story, a person who picks up the lottery paper is supposed to be stoned to death. In the Harrison Bergeron story, outstanding people are supposed to be equipped with handicaps depending on their ability. Even though, those policies look very anti-ethical, people in both societies never question and just obey them. The people show typical blind obedience to readers. Second, both societies have their own specific purposes with the cruel practices. In the Lottery story, the villagers do the lottery to ensure their good harvest as Mr. warner said “Used to be a saying about Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon”. (The Lottery, par 33) And, the writer of Harrison Bergeron story says “ They were equal every which way.” (Harrison Bergeron, par 1). The society intends to make people equal in this story. The next similarity is that powerful authorities

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Both “Young Goodman Brown” and “The Lottery” tell stories of towns that are stuck following a social norm or tradition. Both stories end badly for a main character. Brown ends up distrusting everyone he cared for, and Tessie ends up dead. It is through irony and symbolism, that Nathaniel Hawthorne and Shirley Jackson posit the notion that blindly following a social norm or tradition can lead to…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this semester, we’ve read “The Lottery” and “Harrison Bergeron” from the textbook. They are two short stories; “The Lottery” was written by Shirley Jackson, and “Harrison Bergeron” was written by Kurt Vonnegut. This essay is to compare the similarities and differences between them.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "The Lottery" reminds us to look to tradition with scrutiny because not questioning our own actions can lead to things that go against our morals. "The Lottery" demonstrates this by showing the villagers calmly congregate to commit murder in order to prevent a bad year for the crops. We as readers see this as a crazy and horrifying , (also inefficient,) way to secure that the crops grow, whereas the villagers see this as a necessary ritual only because it is traditionally done. There is even evidence in the story that they don't need to act this way in that some of the neighboring villages no longer practice this ritual and the success of their harvest is somewhat equal to those who still practice. The villagers ignore that because they believe…

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “ The Lottery”, written by Shirley Jackson, shows the corruption in a village whose people treat life with insignificance. Through the use of literary devices, Jackson portrays how practices in traditions can be barbaric;ultimately, resulting in persecution.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These stories have some similarities, but also have many differences, for example, the setting. The setting of “The Lottery” is set in the past, around 1948 in a small village of around 200 people, who are a little more barbaric than nowadays. The setting of “Harrison Bergeron” takes place around 2080, in Middle America. In both stories, the main character gets punished for going against their society’s way of life, and both die while their families watch.…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, comparing. In the first story that I read, “Charles”, the boy in the story was very good at fooling his parents into thinking that he was a good kid at school and that the other boy, Charles, was very bad. In the second story “The Lottery”, the plot in general fooled you into thinking that the reason they were gathering in town was for a lottery that was good. Both of these stories have a plot that is very misleading and tricky. Second, the author of these books is the same, Shirley Jackson! Finally, a common form of writing is used in these short stories, plot twists. In “The Lottery” Jackson starts off the story with people in the town square, setting the mood of anticipation. Our expectation is that…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both the short story and the movie share the ideology of blindly believing and conforming to traditions. In “the Lottery”,an annual ritual consisting of human sacrifice is mandatory for better crops. The tradition in “the Lottery” has been carried on for decades, and yet no one seems to know when it even originated. As ruthless as it sounds, it has been proven in the story that every year, the winner of the lottery gets stoned to death in exchange of the wellbeing of the village. This tradition may seem entirely merciless in the reader’s perspective, but is viewed as a proper ritual by the community. Likewise, in “The Village”, by M. Night Shyamalan, the elders have established a village across the woods away from the town due to the loss of their loved ones earlier on in their lives. It is commonly believed that “Those we do not speak of” existed in the dark woods to prevent people from leaving the village. The elders create imaginary “monstrous” creatures that live in the dark woods, in order to conserve the village from evilness. The youngsters in the village have been greatly influenced by this ritual that it is beyond forbidden to enter the dark woods, and that death will be resulted by doing so. Both the short story and the movie exist a tradition…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The story of The Lottery is also more civilized because everyone in it thinks having the…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The stories I have read: "The Lottery", "Never" and "Harrison Bergeron" all can be similar by one certain theme. I believe that theme would be change. All of these stories' characters needed change in their lives. In "Never" the main character was hopeless and felt trapped and unhappy with her life. She needed to change this routine by seeing the world in a better light or leaving her past behind and catching the train mentioned in the text. In "Harrison Bergeron", the main character, Harrison fights for the right of being individual and change the law that is enforcing it. The traditions may be needed to change in "The Lottery" as innocent people were stoned to death for getting the wrong slip of paper.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Richard Abcarian and Marvin Klotz (2007), editors of Literature: The Human Experience, works with a theme of conformity and rebellion often "feature a clash between two well-articulated positions, in which a rebel, on principle, confronts and struggles with established authority" (p. 312). “The Lottery” and “Two Kinds” equally share the theme of conformity and rebellion and each contains a female protagonist who personally experiences rebellion and conformity in some form. In “The Lottery”, the entire village has confirmed to an antediluvian ritual stoning for more than 77 years; a ritual kept intact by the belief that a personal sacrifice will bless the village with a good crop harvest. Mrs. Tessie Hutchinson, the protagonist, has participated in the village’s ritual wholeheartedly for years until her family is selected. Tessie immediately rebels against the lottery, claiming the drawing was unfair and attempting to add more people to her household in order to reduce her chances of being selected until she is stoned to death by her village. “The Lottery” illustrates the dangers of conforming to group thinking while the protagonist individually rebels against the group and the ritual once her life was at stake.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Lottery” the narrator describes the setting as a beautiful, warm summer day where the town’s people are gathering for what seems to be a typical social event. The reader anticipates a positive outcome as the narrator describes the day and the characters dispositions. However as the story reaches its climax, the reader realizes that the outcome is not positive at all. The winner of the lottery is to be stoned to death. The author’s intention of this story shows how people become blind to the outcomes of their traditions because of their obsession with traditions. In Richard Connell’s, “The Most Dangerous Game” and Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” the characters are portrayed as normal human beings with normal behaviors, but as both stories unfold, the characters are shown to be evil with an enjoyment for murder. In “The Most Dangerous Game” humans are hunted, as mere animals, to serve as the perfect prey to satisfy a desire for challenge. In “The Lottery” the townspeople are forced to participate in a ritual that will result in the death of an unwilling participant to satisfy a belief that the sacrifice of one of their own will guarantee a bountiful harvest. By comparison, the elements of violence and cruelty demonstrate the self-centeredness that abounds in each…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many societies have traditions that are questionable. In Spain there is the dangerous running of the bulls and in China there has been the very painfull foot binding, but these traditions are child's play compared to some. The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, Is about a post war society divided into 12 districts who each send two teenagers to fight to the death once a year in The Capital. The Capital runs the games and reap the fruits of the 12 district's labor. The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson is about a small American town in the 1800s, that keeps order and sanity by selecting one town member to be stoned to death each year. Anyone can be selected, even children. In the end, everyone, including family members join in the killing. In these stories, it is evident that The Lottery and The Hunger Games are different in atmosphere and society, but are similar in the way that they follow tradition.…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In “The Hunger Games,” the district really never has a say so on that is selected, but yet everyone gathers to watch. Similarly in “The Lottery” villagers gather to select a ticket to find one villager to be stoned to death. In “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, the events of the narrative seem to suggest that traditions are a normal part of society. However a close look at the use of irony and foreshadowing demonstrate the lack of normalcy in the community. The tension in these readings ultimately indicates complacency in our society with the status quo until we become the victims.…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    People, past and present, have potentially selfishness and madness. When someone gets in trouble unfairly, people could protest against unfairness or could obey the unfairness. “The Lottery,” is a short story written by Shirley Jackson in 1948, shows dark sides hidden in people’s minds. This story was influenced after the World War Ⅱ, so people’s brutality from the war is reflected to this story. In this story, there is an annual lottery that the result of winning is stoned. Jackson uses symbolism to imply that blind obedience to tradition can be dangerous and people’s unconscionableness.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Betrayal is the first similarity between the two stories, “The Veldt” & “The Lottery”, this is since both stories have characters that have betrayed their own people. The Veldt & the Lottery have their differences and similarities throughout the story. In the Veldt, the children have betrayed their own parents, while in “the Lottery” Tessie Hutchinson’s supposed “friends” wanted to stone her to death over a lottery ticket. The children and the villagers betrayed their own kind because they wanted their own way instead of another. I believe betrayal is cruel, especially on your own kind which is considered a traitor, which has happened towards the end of each story.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays