Preview

The Holy Household Lyndal Roper Analysis

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
275 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Holy Household Lyndal Roper Analysis
In the book the Holy Household Lyndal Ropers main argument is that the urban reformation was a religious ideology and a social movement that is understood to be in the terms of gender. The reformation was not ultimately affected by gender, but was at the core of the reformation. Granting many historians have contended the reformation was a movement, in which it raised the status of women, and claiming to be the spiritual soil from which progressive feminism drew its strength, Roper argues this is a profound misunderstanding. If women had been given the chance to preach or write books their moment was brief and had typically passed by 1530. Roper argues that in urban Germany the reformation merged to an older conservative tradition in which

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the nineteenth century, the legal rights of women and men were highly affected by gender and race, both positively and negatively. In the book, “Kingdom of Matthias,” by Paul Johnson and Simon Wilentz, they describe the life of two females, Isabella Van Wagenen and Isabella Matthews Laisdell which whom were affected by slavery and high influences of higher power from men. In the nineteenth century it was believed that males were to support the family by working and earning a wage as a husband was to provide for his wife and a father to provide for his children (Fahs 1/5). Also, during the nineteenth century women were seen to be working in homes and supporting their husbands by cleaning the home, raising the children, and cooking meals (Fahs 1/5). Furthermore, the dominant notion of marriage can be described as a paternal decline for as time progressed many young men realized they could not inherit the farm which coincided with the fact that young women would only inherit a small dowry resulting in a change of how marriage was based on affection instead of parental influence (LEB 222). However, the notion of motherhood had changed overtime with less childbearing as they were planned which allowed more attention to the children allowing them to move to middle-class. The nineteenth century explores many areas of society that are affected by people’s gender and race whom are brought together by religious beliefs, families, and friendships.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Late Medieval Ages are characterized as a series of events occurring concurrently that expressed a crisis of the symbol of security pertaining to the Roman Catholic Church. The Medieval Church had total control over the people who, regardless of social standing, believed in the existence of God, heaven, and hell. According to the document Lindberg provided, the people were instructed from an early age that only through the Roman Catholic Church were they allowed to be received into the light of God and entrance into heaven (The European Reformations Sourcebook, 9). Lindberg’s The European Reformations Sourcebook identifies contemporary accounts or documents, which express the late Medieval Church, the Church’s problems, and the fulfillment of reforms. Martin Luther, with his radical…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Damned Women: an Analysis

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Many forms of literature paints us an interesting portrait of women in Puritan society. by Women,s roles, specifically concerning religious conviction, are very interestingbjhighlighted…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    I admire Radford Ruether’s argument for female inclusion in Church leadership. Her citation of historical factors that led to the conception of a patriarchal line of command works to nearly discredit the Church’s stance. I think she attacks an issue that is holding the Church back from gaining legitimacy in the modern world: their utter dismissal of…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Preacher’s Daughters is a reality television show aired on Lifetime. The show follows religious families dealing with typical teenage rebellion and extreme parental expectations. All while following their strict spiritual values. With either one or both parents in the ministry, their daughters are pressured to set a good example for the church at all times. Preacher’s Daughters exemplifies patriarchal dominance by the shaming and pressure the fathers put on their daughters.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a time period where change was inevitable and rapid, the revolutionizing image of females as a gender sky rocketed from the events during 1815-1860. The Second Great Awakening embarked on a rebellion against issues that had been overlooked by some, and disregarded by others for years. Issues included prison reform, the temper cause, the crusade to abolish slavery and most significantly, the women’s movement. The thing that sparked women’s movement through the Second Great Awakening was the fact that middle class women, the wives and daughters of businessmen, were huge enthusiasts of religious revivalism. Making up the majority of new church members, it became the feminization of religion. Charles…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gender roles were shaped by the Domesticity and Private Spheres Ideology which said that women should devote themselves to their homes, their husbands, and their children while men were to go out and get jobs, take part in politics, and other aspects of the outside world. It was said that men and women had different functions to perform under God. Society’s peace depended on these roles and if women began taking part in men’s activities there would be crisis. Young girls were to be under the supervision of their fathers, or brothers in some cases, until they were married and then they belonged to their husbands. Married women were considered legal incompetents because they did not have a sufficient brain to participate in legal affairs. For a while people did not have a problem with this arrangement because it portrayed women as noble and superior. Around the 1850s church attendance became very low and many more women than men begin attending services. Women took over the church in a sense because while men had world affairs and politics, women did not have such commitments and so they adopted the church to have a place of their own in society.…

    • 2184 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hollitz Chapter 11

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages

    1. The first essay clearly shows the impact that an ideology of domesticity on women in New England in the 1830’s. The writer at first calls this time period a “paradox in the “progress” of women’s history in the United States”. During this time apparently two contradictory views on women’s relations to society clashed, unusually, those two being domesticity, which essentially limited women, giving them a “sex-specific” role that they must abide to, this mostly being present at the home with their husbands and whatever kids they may or may not have had at that time, and feminism, which essentially tried to remove this domesticity, trying to remove sex-specific limits on women’s opportunities and capacities, trying to get them an increased role in society, not be defined to the home, and not have any limits on what they could do, and most of all be equal to men. This is because in New England, women were victims who were subjects of the painful subordination that came as an add-on with marriage during this period, as well as in society. They also experienced a huge disadvantage in education and in the economy, as well as the denial of their access to official power in their own churches, and impotence in politics. Essentially, the wife at this time, was defined by her husband, and she in no way, shape, or form could have a role that was more significant than her husband, let alone even as much as her husband in the societies that were present, and that they were a part of during this time period, best demonstrated by New England in 1835. She couldn’t sue, contract, or execute a will on her own, and divorce may have been possible, but quite rare. In fact, the public life of women was just about minimal, and none of them voted. Looking back, it was actually worse then than in 1770, as thanks to universal white male suffrage that was present during this period, their roles in society became heavily conspicuous, and in the…

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The individuals that often suffered the most from social injustices were women. The ideal woman of this time, according to scholars such as Christine de Pizan, and Castiglione, was often regarded as one that was well educated, well versed in the classics, able to dance, compose music, and be elegant in nature; however, they were barred from seeking fame, fortune, and were disallowed to take part in public life. For the most part, women contributed little to nothing towards political, economic, and social influences. “Scholarship, like most public activities of this time, was considered a man’s field during the Renaissance and the centuries that preceded it” (Zophy 76). “Indeed, only 186 European laywomen have been identified as book owners during the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries” (Zophy 76). Only women that belonged to the elite were allowed to engage in such activities, and even then, it was quite rare; if you were a laywoman, then your options were ever more limited; it was either marriage or the cloister, and even with this, they were still harshly oppressed by men. To be a woman of the renaissance, meant a life full of rough and jagged paths; it was a life full of many quarrels and obstacles to be traversed in order to make a name for…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women were underpaid, expected to stay at home to run the household, and abused, all without others taking a second glance at the morality of these situations. From the 1830s to approximately the 1860s, women who chose to work in mills made about three to three and a half dollars a week; this was about one third to half of a man’s wages (Dublin, Working Class Women). At that time, three to three and half dollars was much more than a farmer’s daughter could earn but was still not enough for a single person to live off of. (Dublin). A single woman making low wages could only afford to pay their rent; they were unable to buy extra necessities such as food or clothing. Due to low income and being unable to support themselves, a woman's goal was to get married. After marriage, she would be supported by her husband’s income and no longer had to worry about the financial burden alone. Consequently, married life could be considered almost as hard as the life of a single woman. Women were still required to get a job after marriage to help pay for needs. Women also tended to eat less than their husbands and children to ensure their family was their main priority and was managed adequately. Women who failed to manage the household sufficiently or those who spent too much money were often abused. The abuse would go unintervened unless a man beat another man’s wife or death was suspected. (Working Class Women). Women of this time were second rate compared to men and had much less important than males. This caused tension among feminists who believed that men and women should be treated equal. With this in mind, those same women who saw the unequal treatment of women during this time in history, were probably women who started the fight for women’s…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through European history, women have occupied a back seat in all forms of innovation. During the Protestant Revolution and Enlightenment periods, women were considered subservient to men and lesser beings. Women of the 1700s were not permitted to own property or pursue professions in law, medicine, or education. Through the Reformation and the Enlightenment, the experiences of women in Europe stayed the same in the sense of independence and roles in society, but changed in the senses of increased literacy, inclusion in academia, and the development of feminist ideals.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Women in Art

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As far back as the eighteenth century during the Enlightenment period, women were seeing gender differences made within society and some, as did the British writer Mary Wollstonecraft who wrote “A Vindication of the Rights of Women” 1792. She argued that women be have fuller participation in the political process and be better wives and mothers if they were educated (Benton & DiYanni, p 420). Although this was only the beginning of the fight for women’s rights, literature was, like most others forms of art, an active participant in the moves as we’ve seen throughout history. As we know, women continuously were deemed as second class citizens who were not able to own property, work, or do anything short of having and taking care of the children in the household other than being readily available for sex as the man deemed necessary.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reformers such as Luther and Calvin gave women the ability to divorce husbands, a right not previously given in the Renaissance. Women were also free to worship religions as they chose. These reformers still did not give full credit to the women and clergy positions were only held by men. The teaching that all people should read the Bible caused an acceptance of women reading the Bible for themselves: an ability not given before the Reformation. The view of higher standing women before the Reformation, as expressed in Castiglione's The Courtier, was that women are to be feminine, kind, subordinate to men, and that they only reason they should receive education was to entertain men. This principle was changed over time because women’s education in reading was faith-based and not a way to entertain men.…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In particular when we examined Puritan culture and rules through short stories and a sermon through authors alive at the time. During such a controversial time in history like anyone before or after there were the people who rebelled because they didn’t fit into a society role or mold of what they were supposed to represent in Puritan Culture. “Adultery, John” (Miller, The Crucible, 1302) In these stories we are shown that women throughout a majority of history have…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Western Europe during the late eighteenth century, single women had almost no protection under the law, and married women lost their legal identity. Women couldn’t vote, sign contracts, retain a lawyer, have rights over their children, or inherit property. Mary Wollstonecraft caused a sensation by writing A Vindication of the Rights of Woman. She declared that both women and men were human beings endowed with inalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. She insisted women should be free to pursue professional careers, enter business, and vote if they wished. She called for women to become educated. “I speak of the improvement and emancipation of the whole sex,” (Wollstonecraft 253) she declared. “Let woman share the rights, and she will emulate the virtues of man; for she must grow more perfect when emancipated” (281). Mary Wollstonecraft is often referred to as the Mother of Feminism, and her beliefs produced a major shift in the way women were viewed. She inspired change throughout the Western world. If she had not challenged the status quo, modern women would not enjoy the liberties…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays