Preview

The Glass Menagerie and What's Eating Gilbert Grape Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
924 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Glass Menagerie and What's Eating Gilbert Grape Essay
The Glass Menagerie and What’s Eating Gilbert Grape? The Glass Menagerie was written by Tennessee Williams and What’s Eating Gilbert Grape was written by Peter Hedges. The first main difference between these two works is that The Glass Menagerie was a memory play that premiered in 1944 and What’s Eating Gilbert Grape was a novel in 1991 that was later adapted into a film in 1993. The main factor in The Glass Menagerie is that the characters and the story mimic the author’s own life, which he includes himself, his mother and sister as the representation of the characters in the play and how his emotions are depicted towards his family. What’s Eating Gilbert Grape is separate and not inspired by the author’s life, but instead about a man named Gilbert that has to take care of his disabled brother and his obese mother, which gets in the way when love walks into his life. The similarities and differences that both stories have are the characters and the themes, such as escapism and the interactions between the main character and his family. The character, Amanda, from The Glass Menagerie is similar to Gilbert’s mother, Bonnie, from What’s Eating Gilbert Grape because their characteristics are alike and their major role in their respective stories. For Amanda’s character, “Don’t say crippled! You know that I never allow that word to be used!” (80) and “One Sunday afternoon in Blue Mountain-your mother received-seventeen!-gentleman callers! Why sometimes there weren’t chairs enough to accommodate them all” (33). This shows that Amanda really cares about her daughter, Laura, and that she depends on Tom to take care of the family, by having a job and paying the bills. The difference between Amanda and Bonnie is that Amanda dwells in the past and annoys Tom by exaggerating the stories to him. For Bonnie’s character, after Arnie gets arrested for climbing up the water tower, Bonnie finally leaves the house after 7 years and orders the policemen inside the police

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Of Mice and Men Essay

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages

    a) in this passage, what methods does Steinbeck use to present Curley's wife and the attitudes of others to her? Refer closely to the passage in your answer.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Glass Menagerie is a wonderful autobiographical play written by Tennessee Williams. The play is placed in the 1930s in St. Louis. The play is a memory from Tennessee Williams; he explains that since its from memory there may be some unreliable information given. Throughout the story there is several uses of symbolism, including the glass menagerie, the Wingfield’s fire escape, and pleurosis.…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In addition to the first scene of The Glass Menagerie, Amanda talks about her gentlemen callers and how she was a teen girl: “One Sunday afternoon in Blue Mountain-your mother received- seventeen! Gentlemen callers…My callers were gentleman all! Among my callers were some of the Mississippi Delta- planters and sons of planters” (123). Amanda wants to lives in the past of been a teenager because she wishes she was still a teenager with a beautiful…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    They both have similar qualities that relate in each story. In Steinbeck's novel, Of Mice and Men, the time period is set in the 1930s. In the movie Whats Eating Gilbert Grape, it is set more in the modern times. The characters act and are similar in a lot of ways. Gilbert is a teenager that is struggling to support his family after his father killed himself. Gilbert relates to George because they are both constantly having to take care of someone else. George is always having to take care of Lennie. Lennie is also a mentally handicapped man who is the reason why they are in trouble most of the time. Lennie and Arnie are exactly the same. They both have a "fatherly" figure that is always there to take care of them and they both are diagnosed with mentally retardation.…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Of Mice and Men Essay

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Of Mice and Men was an inspiring book written by John Steinbeck about George and Lennie trying to get by in the Great Depression. George and Lennie had been friends for a very long time and had grown to depend on each other. Throughout the book Lennie asked George to tell him about them, about how they were going to get a place and live together, and how Lennie would get to tend the rabbits. They never got to do that, as life would have it, reality got in the way. In the end of the book George betrays his best friend and kills Lennie. I believe it was consider murder for multiple reasons the first being that you never ever kill somebody, the second is that George said that he could live in peace by himself if Lennie weren’t around and the last being that Lennie was mentally challenged and he didn’t know what he was doing.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In these two stories, the relationship between mothers and their sons are very important and key to the story. These two relationships are very similar and different at the same time. In both stories, the father figure is missing in the family. The mothers expect their male child to step up and take charge like a father figure would. In The Glass Menagerie, Amanda, the mother, wants Tom to step up and take care of the family (especially his sister Laura) like her husband never did. She wants Tom to turn out like a man who is exact opposite of her husband who left her family to survive on their own. On the other hand, Mama in A Raisin in the Sun wants her son, Walter, to turn out to be the man her husband was. She cherished her husband and thought so much of him. Even when she received $10,000 for his death it was not enough. Mama believed that his life couldn't be measured by money. I am sure that Amanda would've given up her husband for $10,000 any day.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The glass menagerie is a superb work of art by Tennessee Williams. It is a play that highlights the various realities and desperations of its characters in their response to a confused society. Williams has an admirable talent for creating a play that’s genre is serious and has a tragic ending; yet he keeps the story interesting to the audience whether it be through reading it as a text or in the theater.…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Glass Menagerie is a “memory play” and it was the first of its' kind. To achieve this type of play, Tennessee Williams included many, precise stage directions in his script. The stage directions-lighting, music, pictures on a screen-were important factors in setting the play apart and making it the success that it was. In the 1973 movie remake however, a lot of these stage directions were ignored, such as the pictures on a screen, the lighting and the focus on characters. This stripped the play of its individuality, leaving it plain and very lacking.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Glass Menagerie, by Tennessee Williams, we embark on the task of seeing a family living in the post WWII era. The mother is Amanda, living in her own world and wanting only the best for her son, Tom. Tom, a dreamer, tired of Amanda's overbearing and constant pursuit of him taking care of the family, wants to pursue his own goals of becoming a poet. He is constantly criticized and bombarded by his mother for being unsuccessful. This drives him to drinking and lying about his whereabouts, and eventually at the end of the play, he ends up leaving. An example of Amanda and Tom's quarrel I when he quotes, "I haven't enjoyed one bit of this dinner because of your constant directions on how to eat it. It's you that makes me rush through meals with your hawklike attention to every bit I take."(302) Laura, on the other hand, is shy and out of touch with reality because of a slight disability, in which she is comforted by her glass menageries. Amanda, sees Laura as fragile, like glass, and hopes she can find her a gentleman caller to take care of her and the family. In this play, Amanda, wants the best for her children, but should realize that they have their own lives.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gilbert Grape was the one appointed to caring for Arnie since he is the only man left in the house since Mr. Grape committed suicide seven years ago. Mr. Grape’s death left their mother, Bonnie, severely depressed and morbidly obese. Bonnie has not left the house in seven years, and her weight has left her incapable of caring for Arnie for years. Although it is obvious that Bonnie does feel guilty about leaving the care of Arnie completely up to her children, it is at times apparent throughout the movie that Bonnie and the children make it sound like Arnie may be the cause behind the death of Mr. Grape and the reason for the depression and current condition of their mother. It is evident throughout the movie the stress the Grape family is under. They are always arguing, and all of their arguments seem to revolve around one thing; Arnie.…

    • 2714 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel that I chose to write my essay on is "Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe", By Flannie Flagg.I chose to write my essay on this book because the author uses past events to help show how they have affected future scenarios. The message is that love is love. The author uses the plot to convey the message by having Idgie and Ruth both lose Buddy, who is Idgie's older brother and Ruth's lover. They both feel pain and remorse over Buddy's death but, in different ways, all at the same. Over time, Ruth and Idgie begin to love each other as sisters. So does Evelyn, a character that plays a different part in the book later in Idgie's life. Evelyn is a middle aged woman that comes to Idgie's nursing home to visit her own mother-in-law who has a dislike for her. Over time, Idgie tells Evelyn her story through the hardships and happiness through parts of her life. They quickly become the best of friends, almost like sisters to one another. Evelyn feels almost as deep of a…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Families are shown to be important in the film “What’s Eating Gilbert Grape?”/ Within the movie there are three main types of family that we, as views, see. There are the nuclear family, two children with their natural parents, the single parent family and an extended or unorthodox family. The film suggests that the newer form of family, the extended family, is needed.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Love is one of the most powerful forces in the world, and one of the most difficult to describe. It is one of those emotions that words do not seem to justify a person may feel it, but may not be able to explain it. However, that does not mean that people do not know that love is out there. Many people believe that everyone has one true love somewhere in the world, and spend their lives searching for that person. Love is not difficult to find though. It exists in many forms, including love between family members, friends, different races, and even the love for oneself, both in the novel Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Frannie Flagg and in one's own life.<br><br>The first and most basic form of love is found in the family. From the time a child is born, in usual circumstances, that child is loved unconditionally. A person grows up with their family, and is able to express who they really are. Because of this, ties within the family are usually quite strong. Take for example the relationship between Idgie and Buddy: Idgie (Imogene), a dare-devilish tomboy, and her older brother Buddy are quite close until Buddy's untimely death. Idgie takes his passing with difficulty: "You never saw anybody hurt so much. I thought she would die right along with him" (Flagg, p.37). Another example of the love felt within a family is Stump (Buddy Jr.), who is Ruth's son, Ruth herself, and Idgie. Stump's father is murdered, and grows up with Ruth and Idgie as his parents. Ruth and Idgie do everything possible to try and keep Stump happy. In fact, when Stump is feeling self-conscious about being with a female in the sexual sense, it is Idgie who arranges for him to have intercourse with a friend of hers: "'It's just that I'm scared, Aunt Idgie. I'm just plain scared'" (Flagg, p.266). "The door of the cabin opened, and a freshly bathed, powdered, and perfumed woman with rust-colored hair and apple-green eyes said, 'Come on in, sugar,' as Idgie drove away" (Flagg, p.267).…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In attempting to create a modern-day movie adaptation of The Glass Menagerie from the original play, a parallel element would still be conveyed to the audience- inner and intra personal struggles of the past continue to be those of the present. If produced in the present day, the new version would have seemingly subtle changes such as new speaking styles, characters, and sets that will allow it to become modernized. Some original parts of the play such as "dated" dialogue, character traits, and settings will be discarded, but the original vision of Tennessee Williams will remain intact by keeping elements essential to recounting the Wingfield Family struggles.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Of Mice and Men Essay

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As human beings we understand that murder is wrong, but there are occasions when murder would be a more compassionate and humane choice for the victim than what they would otherwise face. This is illustrated perfectly in the novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. The central character, George, was morally justified in killing his friend Lennie, because his motives were born out of compassion.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays