Preview

"The Decisive Reason for the Advance of Bureaucratic Organization Has Always Been Its Purely Technical Superiority over Any Other Form of Organization (Weber)" Discuss

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1364 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"The Decisive Reason for the Advance of Bureaucratic Organization Has Always Been Its Purely Technical Superiority over Any Other Form of Organization (Weber)" Discuss
Bureaucratic organization has been manifested in the human administration system for over 5000 years. The history has written that such organization has been invented in the times of the Egyptian dominant. The creation of a bureaucratic system raise from the monarchy, the ruling of one principle monarch has established a figure that can be seen as the start of the bureaucratic organization.

The early establishment of bureaucratic administration were seen and put in to practice in the system of the hierarchy structure, ruling by the king down to each step of his sub ordinate. The civilian had no practice to say or voting right to the country policy and its development. In that time it was very much a class divided matters, the ruling class for example king politicians and royal bloods were among the people that practice and execute all the policies. Civilians at that time live under the control of the law which were controlled by the upper ruling class. It has been gathered that the corruption level was high; the practice ruling class used benefits and powers to serve their own demands.

The next point that we going to look at; are the reform in the nineteenth century. At this time the last module of the bureaucratic system has been attacked that it is technically inefficient, it is solitary to remember that it was it self an improvement compare to early reform. It is recommended to: abolition of patronage and the substitutions of recruitment by open competitive examination under the supervision of a central examining board; reorganization of official staffs of central department in broad classes to deal with intellectual and mechanical work respectively; and filling higher post by promotion from inside based on merit.( Hughes, Owen) In this period of time the public administration organization recruitment policy has developed, the understanding of bringing in high skill workers reflected the development of the world education standard. It is obvious that in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The bureaucratic model is more focus on setting goals. Bureaucratic have a higher clientele but are selective with who is inducted into their group. All orders come from the boss in order to execute the next chain of events. The most important operation in the business is hierarchy. In order for the plan to be successful, all members must fully understand their role. This process is crucial for the structure…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Busi 3103 Notes

    • 5946 Words
    • 24 Pages

    - Bureaucratic organizations: organization design based on clearly defined authority and responsibility, formal record keeping and uniform application if standard rules…

    • 5946 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bureaucratic structures stick to a strict hierarchy system when it comes to their management. Pre-bureaucratic structures lack in standards and are found more within small scale, start p companies. This structure is usually centralised and there is only one key decision maker. The communication within this structure is all done in one-to-one conversations; this type of structure can be really helpful for small scale organisations as the founder has full control over all the decisions and operation’s. Bureaucratic structures have a certain degree of standards and are found within organisations…

    • 1940 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Project Schedule

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Bureaucracy consists of an organization characterized by: specific job functions and a strict vertical hierarchical structure. Bureaucratic structure introduced a shift in the archetype of society just before the 19th century. Max Weber, known for his thoughts on capitalism and bureaucracy, contributed greatly to this archetype. The classic bureaucratic model, according to Weber, is described as having such characteristics as: political neutrality, vertical structure, specific job responsibilities, and well-written impersonal documentation, which is used to ensure functional reliability. (Weber M. , 1978) This essay will concentrate on the vertical structure and the rigid tasks and knowledge of the bureaucratic model, to show that an organization can become too big and rigid to be effective in daily tasks.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cyrus The Great Monarchy

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Bureaucracy is a way of a administratively organizing large numbers of people who need to work together.” (handout) Bureaucracies are not as wasteful as you think . They help ensure that thousands of people work together in compatible ways. This helps define people's role with hierarchy. The king was the supreme head of state.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our book defines bureaucracy as, "a formal organization with a hierarchy of authority and a clear division of labor; emphasis on impersonality of positions and written rules, communications, and records"(177). There are five characteristics of bureaucracies, which are, "1. Clear levels, with assignments flowing downward and accountability flowing upward. 2. A division of labor. 3. Written rules. 4. Written communications and records. 5. Impersonality and replace ability"(177-178). Unfortunately, things rarely work as one intends. When there is a noticeable difference in the way a bureaucracy is intended to operate and the way the bureaucracy actually operates, this is known as, "ideal versus real bureaucracy"(179). It is when we get the real and not the ideal, where we run into the dysfunctions of bureaucracies.…

    • 389 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The classical theory is the earliest form of management that perceived that a set of universal principles would apply to all the organizations in all situations to achieve efficiency and organization's goals. Scientific management and bureaucratic theory were one of the several components of the classical school of organization. Important pioneers among them are Frederick Taylor and Max Weber. The classical theories have been contested of little relevance to work and organization today simply because today’s organizations have moved from industrial revolution to the information age due to the fast-paced change in technology (Toffler, 1984). Although bureaucracy has been synonymous to red tape and has negatives effects such as “rigidity, alienation and low commitment” (Adler, 1999, p.37) and dehumanizing people (Grey, 2009), the characteristics of bureaucracy such as specialization, hierarchy of authority, system of rules and impersonality (Stewart, 1986) as well as evidence of ongoing existence of this management method, bureaucracy is proved to remain noteworthy. This essay will examine the situation presented in organization today, and determine whether bureaucracy and scientific management can be considered as old fashioned, out of date and of little relevance to work and organization today.…

    • 2652 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Congress and Bureaucracy

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In ordinary usage, “bureaucracy” refers to a complex, specialized organization composed of non-elected, highly trained professional administrators and clerks hired on a full-time basis to perform administrative services and tasks. Bureaucratic organizations are broken up into specialized departments or ministries, to each of which is assigned responsibility for pursuing a limited number of the government's many official goals and policies those falling within a single relatively narrow functional domain. The departments or ministries are subdivided into divisions that are each assigned even more specialized responsibilities for accomplishing various portions or aspects of the department's overall tasks and these divisions are in turn composed of multiple agencies or bureaus with even more minutely specialized functions. Bureaucratic organizations always rely heavily on the principle of hierarchy and rank, which requires a clear, unambiguous chain of command through which “higher” officials supervise the “lower” officials, who of course supervise their own subordinate administrators within the various subdivisions and sub-subdivisions of the organization.…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The bureaucracy was meant to have been an area of major reform, however now it was posing a social and slight political problem. Peter I had made an attempt to modernise Russia by bringing in the civil service to a full scale. However, it was nepotism; a major problem throughout Russian society; that allowed people to get jobs. The better the family connections,…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Bureaucratic organizations operate more like businesses. There is a formal structure, a hierarchy. There are many rules and procedures that the leaders set in place to keep the lower ranking members in place. This allows the leaders of the organization to be the ones make the decisions,…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea that public administrators should be restricted to only laid down rules in the discharge of their duties is debatable, and dependent on the type of specific duties they have. Max Weber made it clear when he defined the roles for public administrators to discharge their duties. The original model of public administration spread all through the industrialized world at that time and assisted in the relative success of the industrialized economies. Guy Peters also summarized the principles of the original model by listing the major characteristics of that model. Apolitical civil service; rules and hierarchy; permanence and stability; institutional civil service; internal regulation; and finally internal and external organizational quality are all in Peters’ works.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cons of Bureaucracy

    • 260 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One of the major weaknesses of bureaucracy is that it would eliminate the autonomy that the workers are used to having by standardizing work procedures, and by adopting clearly defined rules that instruct that them on how to work in every possible situation. This ‘standardization’ leads to the formation of routine tasks, which may eventually lead to the creation of a dissatisfied work force due to low levels of job-enrichment and self-actualization being achieved from completing the task. Moreover, bureaucracy leads to an obsessive concern with following the rules, which inhibits modification and hence restricts people from exercising intelligent judgment causing problems in situations that don’t precisely fit the rules. Therefore in the case of the instrument assembly team of Agem Electronics Corporation, bureaucratic measures would be unsuccessful as the tasks done by this team involve constant and spontaneous changes and modifications as various different problems arise repeatedly. Thus, the implementation of bureaucratic measures would make it harder for the team to exercise the judgment and rather they would be forced to comply with the rules set by the organization, which may not work well in certain situations. Additionally, bureaucracy would lead to an exponential increase in the number of administrative functions and make the organizational structure more vertical; there would be an increased formalization and departmentalization, with centralized authority and narrow spans of control which would inherently cause communication issues and inter-departmental conflicts of interest leading to serious problems in the day to day running’s of the company in the long…

    • 260 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Abstract: The theory of bureaucracy was proposed and published by Marx Weber (1947). Although there are some studies on this perspective were discussed before him, those theories did not form as systematic theory. After Weber, the issue of bureaucracy becomes a hot topic in the field of social organization. Almost all well-known scholars such as Martin and Henri have published their views on it. Bureaucracy adapted as the traditional organizational model during industrial society, essentially, bureaucracy could exist rational. This essay firstly will review the principle of bureaucracy in organization based on organizational design perspective. Secondly, it will analyze the strengths and weakness of bureaucracy made by Weber, focusing on Weber’s contribution for large contemporary organization design their structure and consider the attitude of those organizations toward bureaucracy: confirmed, rejected, adapted or added to. Finally it will consider the performance of bureaucracy organization in modern society with examples.…

    • 3354 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Birokrasi

    • 3956 Words
    • 16 Pages

    Bureaucracy by definition is a group of workers in private and public organizations such as civil service employees of Malaysian government. Historically bureaucracy is the name of an organizational form often used by both sociologists and organizational design professionals. Therefore we can say that bureaucracy has an informal usage by many people such as “there’s too much bureaucracy where I work” to reflect common set of characteristic features or attributes like “red tape” or “inflexibility” that frustrate people who deal with or who work for organizations they perceive as “bureaucratic” We believe that by the time you had finished reading this part of the module you read would note whether your organization matches the description.…

    • 3956 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Personnel Management

    • 11017 Words
    • 45 Pages

    Public Personnel Management: An Introduction People of a country are an important asset for it, so is the case with organisations. The successful functioning of an organisation depends on its manpower and quality of leadership. The manpower by itself does not contribute to the development of an organisation; it has to be converted into human resources through systematic planning, adequate training and proper education. Without the growth of human resources called the human capital, goals and objectives of an organisation can never be achieved. Human capital can be defined as the sum total of knowledge, skills and aptitudes of the people in the society. Development of human resources poses a major challenge for the developing countries and least developed countries. Manpower planning is an important tool for developing human resources. Investments in manpower planning whether made by government or a, private organisation belong to the individual and do not depreciate. In fact they increase with the passage of time. Thus human resources are an important part of the total resources of an organisation. Though financial resources, physical resources (the work place, machinery etc.) and technological resources are also very important, it is the human resources which are most vital as they generate the other resources. Adequate utilisation of human resources would automatically lead to optimum utilisation of financial, physical and technological resources. No organisation can achieve the desired goals without effective management of all its resources, but human capital is the most essential element of an organisation. As personnel administration deals with the management of the human resources, the study of its concept, nature, scope and development assumes importance. 1. Concept, Nature and Scope of Public Personnel Management The tasks of government are increasing everyday. Development and welfare orientations have led to…

    • 11017 Words
    • 45 Pages
    Powerful Essays