Preview

The Collaborative Coercion Theory

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1179 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Collaborative Coercion Theory
Theorist Mark Colvin utilized previous theories in the conception of deferential coercion theory in 2000. According to Dolu and Büker (2010), most of the early research came from the problematic coercive measures and noncompliant behavior in a New Mexico prison (p. 3). In addition, Dolu and Büker (2010) refer to coercion as “a power creating fear or anxiety that induces or threatens a person to do something. This power can exist in relations between individuals as well as in larger social contexts that are not directly related to individuals” (p. 3). Colvin, with the help of other theorist, asked about the relationship between coercion and criminality, and if the two had an effect on each other. Through their observations and research …show more content…
6). To that end, Colvin concluded that ‘both impersonal and interpersonal coercion are positively related to delinquent involvement” (p. 6). It is evident that the theorist attempted to validate his hypothesis through the application of an empirical study. The deferential coercion theory relates to the parental theory by the present deficits. Parental social bonds, and school social bonds where among the deficits. The differential coercion theory is yet a small branch of the Social Bond Theory and Social Control Theory. In another attempt to validate the theory based on the parental theory, one can examine and analyze the policy implications that follow. For example, Dolu and Büker (2010) explain how parents should “develop a strong social bond to legitimate institutions and especially to the family, children should be disciplined in a consistently non-coercive fashion” (p. 7) in order to retract from criminal behavior. This can be done through training programs. Simply put, criminal behavior can be reduced through consistent, non-coercive controls. This sub-theory relates overall due to the interactions, both personal and interpersonal, relationships individuals have with one or others, much life Social Bond Theory and the attachment, or involvement one has in …show more content…
However, the parent must ne absent of delinquent behavior as well. Implementing parenting programs that focus on building a cohesive relationship between the parent and the child will, according to Hirschi, reduce the likelihood of that child becoming deviant. Making children go to school will build attachment, involvement, and commitment in the academics, sports, and relationship. Additionally, the implementation of after-school programs, or programs in school that drive the adolescent to become committed to an activity reduces crime. Programs include: Boys and Girls Club, Big Brothers/Big Sisters, after school sports, education centered afterschool-care, Boy Scouts, Girl Scouts, any program that involves a commitment. These programs are designed to not only implement an attachment, but also offer a commitment to a club or sport that would in turn reduce the urge to commit crime because they could jeopardize their position or rank. Commitment can also be closely related to involvement. Positively utilizing the adolescent’s time to implement sports, clubs, recreational activities, can implore involvement and provide the child with many activities that detracts their involvement in crime. In addition, involvement with conventional individuals presents a role model that embodied certain beliefs and conventional norms that reduce crime. Lastly, a policy implication that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Have you ever watched the news and seen that the most shocking crimes committed are by young juveniles and in rare cases small children? Do you wonder why they did it? Many of us do not realize the type of background and the type of lifestyle they lived in before the crime was committed. A lot has to do with how these young juveniles are being raised and the type of environment they are surrounded by. Juvenile delinquents are teens and children, since they are so young the way they learn is by visualizing what surrounds them. But most importantly, are these juveniles receiving the support from their loved ones? The film, Boyz N the Hood explores the elements of belief, involvement, attachment, and commitment through Hirschi’s Social Bond Theory.…

    • 2286 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    General Strain Theory

    • 2128 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Hirschi described social bonding theory as, “Elements of social bonding include attachment to families, commitment to social norms and institutions (school, employment), involvement in activities, and the belief that these things are important” (Alston 1995). Forming social relationships is one of the most important aspects to staying out of criminal activities. The four basic principle elements of this theory are attachment, commitment, involvement, and beliefs. Attachment is the degree of value an individual holds in a society. The most important attachment most individuals form is family. Family helps to form an idea of what the world is from a very young age. They teach how to behave in specific situations and what is wrong or right. With attachment, an individual learns what to expect from society as well as what the society expects from him or her. A person who doesn’t form a strong attachment to family or society has trouble fitting into the norms (Alston 1995). Commitment is said to be the second step to attachment. One has to commit to the norms of society and uphold to expectations. An individual without a strong attachment will find it difficult to commit. The third element, Involvement is giving importance and time to society. Its engrossing oneself and participating in conventional activities. Finally, beliefs are the the rules and certain values of society a person has to follow. For example, having a monogamous relationship is a norm in the United States. Not following this norm or any other norm causes an individual to deviate from society. They become outcasts and lose their sense of responsibility to society. This in turn encourages that individual to participate in criminal activity and deviance (Alston…

    • 2128 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From this first component, the greater attachment to a loved one and stronger emotional bonds are to parents or teachers, the less likely individuals are to become involved in delinquent behaviours (Hope & Paat, 2015). Given Justin Bourque’s mother acted as both mother and teacher, the argument can be put forward that the dual role she played in his life aided in the level of strain between them. Travis Hirschi’s second component of his social bonding theory is commitment, to which he states that one is…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The juvenile justice system should adopt a permanent focus on rehabilitation to ensure the future success of our nation’s young people. Juvenile criminal and delinquent behaviors do not emerge randomly. We have learned over the past few decades that a number of factors, (individual, family, peer, and community) affect whether a child will engage in delinquent or criminal activity. Research has clearly shown that the more risk factors experienced by youth, the greater their likelihood of involvement in criminal activity. Conversely, protective factors such as developing close relationships with parents and teachers can offset the negative effects of risk factors. [ (U.S. Department of Justice Programs Office of Justice Programs, 1999) ]…

    • 1888 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Bond Theory Essay

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to the article, Juvenile Delinquency in the High Schools of Ankara, Turkey, the social bond theory was tested on juvenile delinquency in Turkey, a developing country. They surveyed 1,730 students regarding how many times they have used force on teachers; hitting other students; fist fighting; attacking someone; carrying knife, bat, etc.; using force on students; sexual harassment; etc (Ozbay, 2006). The result was that the attachment to teachers, conventionality of peers, family supervision, school commitment, belief, and school involvement are statistically significant and have negative influence on total delinquency (Ozbay, 2006). This study further proved that the lack of presence of a social bond can increase one’s risk of committing…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The greater the investment of time, the more likely the parent will actually practice the learned skills, and the more likely the child will refrain from criminal acts. By requiring the families that volunteered for the study to physically attend sessions at a facility, SAAF promoted voluntary involvement, which also deters their availability to become involved in juvenile delinquent activities. Then…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Therory

    • 2288 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The way individuals learn to interact with society as children tends to predict how they will interact with society and respond to its environments as adults. There are social theories that help the understanding of why individuals choose deviant behaviors and how they progress through life. Social process theories view criminal and deviant criminal behaviors as evolving mechanisms learned through societal interaction. Social development theories view deviant and criminal behaviors as part of a maturation process. Social theories are conclusions that have come about based on the response of individuals to their environments, what they have been taught, what they have learned through their experiences, and how they react to those experiences in society. Social process theories views criminality as s function of people’s interactions with various groups and institutions in society. A person’s behavior is greatly influenced by the positive and negative reinforcements of their behavior. This influence can be referred to as the differential reinforcement theory.…

    • 2288 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In today’s society it is essential to understand the occurrence and prevention of juvenile crime. Numerous teenagers are becoming juvenile delinquents and society needs to know why. This paper will identify five concepts on which Team C believes to be the most significant social facts in the occurrence and prevention of juvenile delinquency. The paper will discuss recommendations for the future in which families, the community, law enforcement, probation and/or courts can help reduce juvenile delinquency.…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    These programs have been introduced by the Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act of 1974 to homes who find value in the services provided. In the absence of parents, the programs have been able to teach specific skills, educate, and occupy the time of unattended youth so that they can become integrated into society without being involved in delinquency. After taking part in either program, the youth have become better prepared to take on the challenges of life. The most important takeaway is the success and continuous accomplishments of delinquency prevention programs within our…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Civic Engagement

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Another effective strategy steers kids from crime by equipping parents with tools to better manage their children’s behavior and keep them on the right track. Other strategies focus on getting a head start by offering quality pre-kindergarten and home visitation/parent coaching programs. The inner cities are no longer the exclusive domain of gangs and their…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    CAROL A. ZIMMERMANN, CAROL A.. (2007) ROUTINE ACTIVITY THEORY AND THE HANDLING OF CHILDREN AND POLICY MAKERS. Using the Routine activity approach Gottfredson et al.(2007) explores how school programs and staff function using the after school program as its focal point furthers or regresses prosocial behavior. Gottfredson et al.(2007) questions whether the presence of a respectful guardian decreases the likely hood of delinquent activities, and talks about kids with too much free time and no structured or planned time turn to alternate activities such as Delinquency, which involves abusing drugs and victimizing others.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Youth Gangs In Canada

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Teenagers and young adults join youth gangs for many reasons. Reasons a teenager would join a gang include family factors such as parental abuse or even a lack of supervision, school factors meaning if a adolescent has early school failure, he is more likely to become a violent person, "Early school failure is predictive of subsequent violent behaviour" (Maguin & Loeber, 1996). As well as the neighbourhood one grows up in plays a factor in their future behaviour, so does many other factors. That is why programs are created to revolve around the issue at hand. "Street gang crime has many different causes and facilitators. This means that solutions to the problem must also be multi-faceted and involve a combination of prevention, intervention, and suppression programs." (Linden 5). The government uses the Prevention method to start with. This targets young kids who are at risk of joining gangs. Within the prevention program expands with even more programs to resolve the issue encouraging a young child or teenager to join gangs. Ranging from recreational programs such as summer camps to parental training to provide the correct skills need, there is a prevention program for any issue. Although not all these programs are not guaranteed to work, it is almost a trial and error scenario, "While there are some consistent patterns in the research…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juvenile delinquency has become a very predominant occurrence in today’s society. In 2010, there were 6,531 arrest for every 100,000 youths age 10 to 17(Knoll, C, 2010). While it may be that youth are being processed through the criminal justice system more today than ever, rather than actually committing more forms of crime and delinquency (Puzzanchera, Adams, & Sickmund, 2010). Youth are however experiencing increased participation with the criminal justice system are creating problems for parents, schools, communities, and other children who are in the presence of juvenile delinquents. Two of the biggest aspects influencing juvenile delinquency are the family structure that the child is exposed to and the relationship they have with their…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    At the core of the traditional role of the police in our society is the ability and need to exercise coercion in performing some of their functions. With some unknown frequency and severity, law enforcement officers use various forms of verbal and physical coercion in performing their everyday functions of enforcing the law and maintaining order. How and when the police use and do not use physical force influence the immediate accomplishment of police functions. The use of force also affects public attitude that sustain or undermine the legitimacy of the police and the entire system of justice.…

    • 3095 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays