Ms. Lowry
English 1102
January 19, 2013
Down Goes Banking Up Comes Problem-Posing
In the article “The Banking Concept of Education,” Friere claims that the teacher and student’s relationship is fundamentally narrative in which the students are somewhat being trapped in the system of “Banking Education”. Freire goes on to say that education is suffering from narrative sickness, which means that information is being repeated constantly to the point where it has no meaning to it or that it is lifeless. “Students are becoming alienated when learning time is being generated from the teacher,” Friere argues. Students are becoming machine-like-creatures because they are not engaged into the lesson. Friere writes that “four times four is sixteen…The student records, memorizes, and repeats these phrases without perceiving what four times four really means” p.318. Students are too simply just repeating what they are told, but they really do not have an explanation or an understanding as of why the answer is that specific answer. Also the student works on storing the information that they were given, this causes their critical consciousness not to develop at the normal pace. I agree with Freire on this issue. A solution to this issue would be the Jasperian “split.” Instead of students taking mental notes, they could wright questions in regards to the lesson. For example, if I am writing an essay I would not just being aware of the essay I am writing but also questioning, why I am doing so. Overall I believe that “The Banking Concept” is rendering our development as students as well as teachers. It has caused many students to not think outside of the box, but to make them become a receptacle to be filled with narrative information passed on from our teachers, Friere explains. Teachers also have grown to become the superior opposite to the absolute ignorance of their students, but just like how the teacher can teach a student, the student can educate the teacher as well. This concept has made much of our generation into the norm. We need to think outside the box and to transform our generation into what we want to become of it.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The education system has caused students to become robots. Everyday they come into class, take notes and never once question the material they are learning. Paulo Freire states that “Education must begin with the solution to the teacher-student contradiction,” in his essay “The ‘Banking’ Concept of Education.” In order to solve this contradiction here at West Chester University; students need to start thinking critically and there needs to be a teacher-student partnership.…
- 218 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
His idea that the students are an "empty vessel" is at the core of the banking concept where the curriculum does not take into consideration the needs of the students as libertarians, the means by which men and women deal with reality in either a critical or creative way. He makes this point because in education today the information is chosen by the educator as the "depositor" and "deposited" into the student; "the scope of action allowed the student extends only as far as receiving, filing and storing; which the students patiently receive, memorize and repeat" (319). The more a teacher does this to his students the more reality is taken away from them to learn the true meanings of life. This can be related back to Freire 's argument against the education system, because one can only memorize things for so long, after that one will lose his true purpose in the world. To go against the system of education Freire has established new methods to turn the idea of education aroundThe method of education that Freire asserts as an alternative to the banking concept is to encourage students to question and pursue the world. He calls this his "problem-posing" method on education (325). This change in focus is facilitated by a shift in the student-teacher relationship; the student learns from the teacher, and the teacher learns from the students. This is a relationship where all…
- 1260 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Have you ever thought about that time when you were empty? I mean knowledge wise. It can be referred back to the infant stage or even that time in history class when you had no idea what imperialism was or what it is about. Well according to Freire this is where “ The Banking Concept” takes place. As he mentions on page 477, the banking concept is basically saying that students are empty containters that will be filled with education by their teachers.…
- 985 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Last week, I read an article called the banking concept of education which is written by Paulo Freire, a Brazilian author who contributed to the world greatly as an educator and influenced the field of education. What is banking concept? The banking concept is an example to describe a method that students are regarded as a container and to be filled with different kinds of information and knowledge by teachers. What the students can do is just accept the things that they learned and memorize it. Freire demonstrates that the students are regarded as a bank and teachers “deposit” the knowledge into them. The biggest problem of the banking concept of education is that the students will never think carefully and they will lose their creativity and imagination without their critical thinking. Students just acknowledged the world should be like and inhibited by too many restrictions of their study. Freire demonstrates that the banking concept of education supposes that all the students are innocent. However, learning form the teacher is the only method for the students. The problem between the educator and the students won’t disappear although there’s a new curriculum introduced. Freire thinks the most effective way to solve the problem is Problem-posing concept of education.…
- 1258 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
My own experience as a student has allowed me to develop multiple opinions about Freire’s concerns on conventional learning and his innovative idea of problem solving education. I believe that my reaction and opinion’s to Freire’s essay is moderate, I believe that if a student is only exposed to traditional learning then yes he or she will be crippled. However, in my experience as a student, I believe there are occasions where an environment of a teacher teaching and students listening totally appropriate. There needs to be a balance between nontraditional learning and traditional learning. Freire’s banking concept is an occurring event in today’s education but I wouldn’t necessarily go as far as diagnosing that it’s the problem that the education system needs to get rid of. I believe that there is value to both a problem solving way of learning and a traditional style of learning and students should be exposed to both during their education. I don’t believe we could…
- 3171 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
"The Banking Concept of Education": An Essay on Submissive Learning by Paulo Freire - Yahoo Voices - voices.yahoo.com…
- 1910 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In the essay a question of language by Gloria Naylor. She defines how the written and spoken language can give different meanings to a word. She considers language a powerful tool used by writers and everyday people, to express their feelings and capture reality and life.…
- 365 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Education is defined as “the act or process of imparting or acquiring general knowledge, developing the powers of reasoning and judgment, and generally of preparing oneself or others intellectually for mature life.” (dictionary 2013) I feel that this definition describes the “problem-posing” take on education in Paulo Freire’s essay “The Banking Concept of Education.” In his essay he describes two different methods of education, the “banking concept” where “the scope of the action allowed to the students extends only as far as receiving, filing, and storing the deposits” (Freire 63) and “problem-posing” where by “responding to the essence of consciousness intentionally rejects communiqués and embodies…
- 695 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
compare the use of open market operations, discounting and changes in reserve requirements to control the money supply on the following criteria: flexibility, reversibility, effectiveness, and speed of implementation.…
- 357 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In Paulo Friere’s article “The Banking Concept”, Paulo argues that the banking method is an efficient way of learning in the education system. The students are to sit down, stay quiet, received information, memorize it, and then remember it. Since this method requires them to simply memorize the information, the students don’t completely understand fully the information that they are taking in. The underlying message here about the banking concept is that the teachers feed students the information, acting as if they are completely informed about the whole subject, and then suggesting that the student knows nothing. There is no relationship established between the student and the teacher. The student…
- 928 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
$2,000 $100/(1 i) $100/(1 i)2 . . . $100/(1 i)20 $1,000/(1 i)20.…
- 264 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Mr. H. Day, the VP of management information systems of Old Family bank started to examine various areas of the bank which included turnover rates, attendance issues and productivity of each group within the bank. In his findings, Mr. Day didn’t find any startling facts except in the check-sorting and computer services department. In his findings, Mr. Day discovered that the check-sorting department ranked first as the most productive unit and the computer services came in last in productivity. Mr. Day decided to speak to each member of both respective departments to gain some insight into the dynamics of each group’s behavior (Brown, 2011 p. 141).…
- 565 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The banking industry in the emerging market economies: competition, consolidation and systemic stability - an overview…
- 21990 Words
- 88 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
www.aeaweb.org , the purpose of the association is to encourage economic research especially in the historical and statistical study of the actual condition of industrial life, the issue of…
- 415 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Money has two meanings. As an abstract notion it is a unit of account. As a concrete notion it is a medium of exchange…
- 618 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays