Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Specific Texts in High Schools

Good Essays
1020 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Specific Texts in High Schools
My generation of the Joes family has experienced a curriculum where students of different schools are able to read different texts but my parent's generation has experienced an entire nation following the same curriculum and reading the same texts. Having all students read the same books and follow the same curriculum has a greater benefit for all the students in the nation because everyone is on the same educational level. Being on this same educational level, all the students in the nation applying to colleges would be given the same opportunity. Although there are some cons to this idea such as the fact that teachers will no longer be able to have the amount of freedom to teach and their students might get bored of such a dry curriculum; the pros of an equal education where no one student from a state is better equipped for higher education because of their teachers choices outweighs the cons.

While freedom in education does open the minds of the students, an equal curriculum can encourage students of different states or counties to have more rigor in their courses. Under the most frequently required titles table, comparing just public schools with private schools, public schools are required to read Julius Caesar 70% of the time while private schools are only required to read it 42% of the time. This significance in the percentages can students in public high schools are more prepared with that aspect of literature while the students in private school have no knowledge about it. Without having this knowledge, students of public schools will be more ready in college if references are made to Julius Caesar while the private school students won't be able to make the correlation. An example of inequalities between counties would be Montgomery County and Frederick County. The curriculum in Frederick County is less vigorous but since they take AP courses there too, they could be getting the same grades as the student in Montgomery County who is taking a rigorous AP course. This inequality would show that the Frederick County students are equally or more capable than the Montgomery County students which is not true because the only reason that the Frederick County students are receiving the good grades is because of their easy curriculum. As indicated by Robert M. Fowler, "The cannon was appropriate to a centralized educational system, in which everyone studied the same subjects and the same texts in order to introduce into the standards of cultural life." This basic introduction to cultural life cannot be upheld if the students all over a nation are not required to read the same texts. My parent's generation is from Peru, in Peru; all the students all over the nation read the same texts and study the same material. This is beneficial because when its time for them to compete to get into a spot in college, all the students of the nation are equally prepared with the same amount of culture and knowledge. Reading the same texts all over a nation standardizes the education in positive aspect which encourages equality and forces student's education to be more rigorous.

People favoring a free curriculum identify the cons of a centralized education with the main focus being that the students are unable to experience greater knowledge if being limited to a curriculum based study. My generation in my family are the first to experience this free curriculum which allows all students of the nation to be able to study different texts. Although this does keep the class interesting because you are able to read different points of views, as a student I feel threatened because I am depending on what my teacher decides to teach. A reason for why centralized education isn't ideal for education systems are explained by George P. Landow. In his excerpt, he explains only some writers are granted entrance in the "literary canon" which allows these writers to get privileges over the rest. The privileges that these writers receive are the chance to be in Anthologies more often because they are "famous writers". By allowing a centralized education, teachers are indeed exposing their students to only learn the literature chosen by editors instead of literature that will truly open their students mind to greater arguments. In source D, The Norton Anthology claims to posses all the World's Masterpieces in one volume. These are only the literature that the editor believed were masterpieces thus not encouraging greater education or interest on the students. As Michael Greer has explained in source C, "teachers have to make their own decisions about what to include in a course and know that they can't trust anthologies to answer students' question about the nature and significance of poetry." He recommends teachers to teach the anthologies alongside other literature that will intrigue the mind of the students. In doing this, the educational value that the students are gaining is greater because they have both the required text and extra texts which allow them to understand the idea better.

Students through specific standardized texts receive the benefit of equality when attempting to achieve higher education. This higher education contains the pros that the curriculum can force some schools to push their students more since they have specific criteria to meet during the school year. Also, each student will be receiving a standardized amount of culture of different races and events that will help them throughout their lives. The cons of such a limited education is that teachers aren't going to be able to provide their students with the texts of her choice and thus some of the students will not be capable of understanding the material given. Also, with a free curriculum, the teacher doesn't expose themselves to the biases of editors and the influence of the literary cannon like centralized educators do. For this problem, the nation should include the anthologies in the curriculum and other related literature to allow some type of variety to the students. Overall, the pros do outweigh the cons since the ability to centralize education will benefit every student not just the "lucky ones" with the "good teachers".

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Educational Reform

    • 2855 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The United States has an extensive educational system that has been charged with accommodating the needs of an extensively diverse student population. U.S. educational institutions exist at all learning levels, from preschools for early childhood education to secondary education for youths, and post secondary education for both young and older adults. Education in the United States can be commended for the many goals it aspires to accomplish—promoting democracy, assimilation, nationalism, equality of opportunity, and personal development. However, because Americans have historically insisted that schools work toward these frequently conflicting goals, education has often found itself at the center of social conflict and the hot topic of political campaigns, mostly to no avail (Goldin and Katz, 2001). While schools are expected to achieve many social objectives, education in America is neither centrally administered nor supported directly by the federal government, unlike education in other industrialized countries. This system of decentralization has created a system of inequality in education that persists. The current system has created inequalities that have culminated into a generation of students that are not adequately prepared to meet the demands of a global workforce. Moreover, students in the current U.S. educational system are unmotivated and resistant to change due to irrelevant legislation and an overwhelmed system. The inequalities and inconsistencies have spawned many debates in the U.S. as the nation joins the global community (Goldin et.…

    • 2855 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Text Books

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages

    TEXTBOOKS English 1101 BNDL: ACP SSC - WADSWORTH BRIEF HANDBOOK Author: Kirszner Edition: 7th Copyright: 2012 Publisher: Cengage Learning ISBN: 9781285152332 New: $69.50 Used: $52.25 New Rental: N/A Used Rental: N/A…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Common Core Curriculum dictates the standards that need to be achieved by students and taught by teachers. The adoption of this curriculum means all should be uniform. Teachers should be teaching the exact same content, relatively at the exact same time. I believe this article brings up a great question; is the underlying objective of the Common Core, to make teachers teach to the test? Many of us believe so. I feel this article points out other issues that have a serious impact on a student’s performance. Poverty is one of the factors mentioned in the article that has an even greater impact to a students learning than memorizing facts would (Krashen, 2014).…

    • 188 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The curriculum of the public school system in America has transformed greatly over time. Its original roots that branch from early Puritan schools where the Bible was taught to where education was offered only to the privileged. Most schools had an educational system based on religious teaching methods. The government became involved, and developed an unconstitutional clause known as the separation of church and state. Schools were no longer simply based on training future theologians. A more structural foundation for the American educational curriculum incorporated reading arithmetic and writing. The main focus of schools was from teaching moral values. The American public school curriculum especially changed after the Civil Rights movement. Integration had an impact on how certain concepts were taught in the classroom as well.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When I asked my mom about which education system is better she was lightning fast in her response, “United States. And it’s not even close”. She was quick to rebuttal her own point and say that there are many downsides. She believes, like many educators, that the implementation of Common Core in 2009 has tied the hands of teachers behind their backs and restrained them from expressing their creativity in the classroom and making them comply with this “cookie cutter” way of teaching. Teachers are falling into the educational trap of teaching knowledge and teaching to test more than teaching to comprehension of the material and teaching applicable skills to prepare the child for excellence. Moreover, my mother was adamant in believing that Common Core has involuntarily coerced teachers to worry too much upon reaching their state mandated goals rather that recognizing what each child needs to succeed in the classroom and achieve their valuable education they are working so hard to…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A Nation At Risk Analysis

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Every student should receive an individualized education and that should be the end goal. However, instead of going down the route that every student should receive an individualized education then attempt to give every student the same education and educational opportunities is wrong. Every student in America is not going to receive the same opportunities. Not every family is wealthy or in poverty and not every family lives in the perfect mixture of urban and rural schooling systems. It should not be shamed that students are receiving executive elite schooling, parents want what is best for their child and there is nothing wrong with that. Granted it should be shamed that a child is receiving a poor education based on a poverty leveled school. The route that the education field needs to go down is individualism all the way through. Kids should be receiving an individualized education based on who they are as humans, not where they come from or what type of schooling they want to go to. If by ninth grade a child still does not like science, that kid should not have to continuously take science courses. Children should be able to explore what they want, if America wants passionate, hard workers, then America needs to let the students be passionate about something. Rural schools and urban schools are different and nothing is going to make them the same, but how we respond to it can change. Urban schools have lots of real world opportunities for children and half of the schools do not even take advantage of that because they are too busy meeting state and national standards. The truth is, the standards are there to give everyone the same educational opportunities and to promote an individualized education. Yet, the standards hinder students from doing just that. There should be a set of standards that teachers need to follow, otherwise there is anarchy. However, the standards should be a…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the things that the UNited States prides itself in is it's diverse culture. America is seen as the 'land of the free' where everybody is accepted as equals and can accomplish the "American dream" if they put their minds to it. While this may be true on a large scale, if you narrow your line of scope to American schools you would probably see something a little different.…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    High School Writings

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    High school teachers vary greatly through intellect, styles of writing, and specifics on how they want their students to write. Throughout high school many teachers want their students to follow a dedicated outline which denies them the right of finding themselves in writing. Writing in high school has lost its creativity due to lack of spectrum the students can write in. Few teachers had no specifics at all, and these are the teachers that help find what kind of writer a person really is. In my experience, I had a large variety of teachers who mostly helped me become informed in different ways to write. In high school I was taught a variety of ways to write, along with a few different formats; although…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While the U.S education has changed drastically since the amendment passed through Brown vs. Board giving access to education to all, schools throughout the U.S are anything but equal. Many of these schools in America are still racially segregated, which impacts students negatively. They are being deprived of quality education which can lead to other factors like increasing their chance of incarnation. Organizations like The National Coalition on School Diversity have helped pushed for desegregation and creating policies to improve education in the U.S. By understanding the causes of segregated schools and the need for change will allow a step forward in changing how education is brought to the mass population giving equal opportunity to all. This is done so through organizations like the NCSD goals and strategies that connect both academic and local advocacy organization allowed them to create policies and inform teachers and students about the injustice of racially…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Education and Equality

    • 2793 Words
    • 12 Pages

    This article discusses various lawsuits filed as advocates try to advance the cause of equal funding for education in the U.S. Demetrio Rodriguez began his fight for reform in 1969 as the chief plaintiff in a suit against the Edgewood Independent School District in San Antonio, Texas. In that year, he and a group of parents filed suit to protest the lack of funding for the schools their children attended. Appealing the decision in favor of the district, they took their case to the U.S. Supreme Court in 1973. The case became a rallying point for school reform across the country. In the years following the filing of the suit, their battle cry is a simple one: the inequalities in funding between public school systems must be eliminated if quality education for all is to be guaranteed. Lawsuits filed throughout the U.S. are meeting with a margin of success as they try to advance the cause of equal funding for education. Charging that states fail to provide a school system that offers proper instruction, the suits are forcing state governments to reconsider public school funding. While Ohio faces a complete overhaul of the school funding system, other states face the challenge of capital funding for the construction of new schools. The most visible element of the issue, have become the focus of many court…

    • 2793 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Summer Reading Writing

    • 345 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “My family has a good system. We communicate with notes on the kitchen counter” –pg. 14 Anderson. In Speak by Laurie Anderson Melinda’s family is not very close. They each have privacy and there isn’t much communication with each other. Eventually Melinda completely stops talking to her parents, but by the end of the novel they learn that they need to have communication to be a strong family. Melinda’s family was never really close, but after the incident Melinda and her family grow even father apart, however in the end, they grow close and learned to share their problems with each other, which they realize, is the way to be a strong family.…

    • 345 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Crow

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The contemporary public school system aims to provide all with a fair and equal education throughout a given local area.…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When I heard the name of non-educative literary text, honestly, I have no idea what to write. But, based on the name, I would like to define non-educative in my own view. Educative here I refer to literary works that has value meaning to be learnt by the reader in a positive way, which could lead the reader to take the benefits of reading, such as, expanding their knowledge in many aspects; language, culture, vocabularies, etc, build up their critical thinking so that the readers are being able to analyze or widen their way of thinking, and applying things inspired by reading itself, but again, in the so-called positive one. On the one hand, non-educative is somewhat the contradiction of educative. It remains having the same benefits but its impacts is different, tend to be in the negative way if I could say.…

    • 302 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    is regarded as the foremost prose satirist in the English language. Jonathan Swift died on…

    • 954 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Reading Lesson Plan

    • 339 Words
    • 3 Pages

    -T invites Ss to read the title of the reading textand elicits from them what…

    • 339 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics