Preview

Should Belgium Give Reparation Due To Economic Collapse

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
120 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Should Belgium Give Reparation Due To Economic Collapse
The other reason why Belgium should give reparations is due to the economic collapse that took place within the country and has left the country down and in insufficient money. According to Document 5 the Democratic Republic of Congo is 71 percent below the poverty while Belgium sits at’ 15.2 percent below the poverty line. This states that the same country that imperialism Congo barely under below poverty nationwide whereas Congo who was the victim of this downfall has suffered close to 100 percent of its population living in poverty. It can be said that the reason the Congo is still poor up to date and Belgium be wealthy is due to the effects that Belgium had on the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    6) How are decisions made in the Congo? How is it different than the Belgium system? Which do you think is more effective?…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In 1876, King Leopold II of Belgium began plans for international benevolent committees for the people of the Congo region. Though originally accepted as multi-national, scientific, and humanitarian propositions, they have of late become anything but. Soon after their conception, Leopold used these organizations to establish a sphere of influence and eventually Belgian sovereignty in the Congo Basin. The region is rich in ivory and rubber, and Leopold made use of those resources and others in expanding trade. Now, rubber is the colony's most profitable industry. However, the Congolese people benefit little from this.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    By reading Mark's article, “Reparations Reconsidered: A Reminder” the main points become evident once she speaks of the “reparations” imposed by the allies on the Germans after Germany’s defeat in WW1. Mark’s begins her article with the discussion of a session in December of 1968 between the American Historical Association “AHA” . Professor Gerhard Weinberg, of the AHA says that “the entire history of German reparations needs to be restudied” (356). Throughout the post-war world, everyone was quite mesmerized by the 132 billion marks fee that was “brutally” imposed on the Germans, when in fact they weren’t asked to pay anything resembling that sum. Relevant documents and memoirs show that the Germans weren’t forced to pay the 132 billion marks that the public was tricked into believing.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1793, France was at war with it’s surrounding countries; Austria, Prussia, Sardinia, Great Britain, and the United Netherlands. France turned to America for support because in America’s time of need, during The American Revolution, France aided America. France thought it was time for America to repay them. In response, the US drafted the Proclamation of Neutrality which said that they would not be taking any side in the war. Although some may say that America was obligated to aid France, America made the right decision to stay neutral, since America was vulnerable lacking a strong army, and they had no legal obligation to take action.…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    New France Failure

    • 2580 Words
    • 11 Pages

    During the 1400s the continent of North America was discovered by numerous different explorers, such as Giovanni Caboto, Columbus, and Jacques Cartier. This set off a great race for the ownership of this new continent, and France and England would fight over the country known as Canada. New France was first established by Jacques Cartier in 1534. While Montcalm deserves much of the blame for the loss of Quebec in 1759, New France, in fact, was destined to fall because of the policies and approaches that had been taken since the earliest foundations of the colony. The mercantilist standpoint of Jean-Baptist Colbert was also a large benefactor to the downfall of New France. This policy crippled New France and constricted its growth economically,…

    • 2580 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is due to the fact that he covered up many of is wrongdoings. First off, he falsely publicized trade statistics about the Congo’s imports and exports. Edmund Morel, a journalist who wanted to expose this vast destruction of human life, saw what the Elder Dempster ships were carrying. The Etat Indépenant du Congo’s trade statistics did not match what was on the boats. Moral noticed that about 80% of the imports going to the Congo did not have anything to do with trade purposes (such as weapons and military goods). Meanwhile, the Congo was exporting ivory, rubber, and other raw materials. Morel was one of the first people to catch onto the king’s scheme. Another reason why it took so long for the regime to be exposed is because Leopold destroyed the evidence of his actions. He went to extraordinary lengths to try to erase potentially incriminating evidence from the historical record. Researchers were not allowed to review anything that was bad for Belgium, but as Hochschild points out, everything was bad! Therefore, these atrocities went unknown for years because of the king’s active attempts to hide the evidence to preserve his own…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Government scandal is no shocking news, constant new conspiracies and power plays are all too frequently covered by the media for such a thing to be a surprise. The biggest scandal is covering up their own actions. Too much history is covered up by governments around the world. Selfishly, they hide their own shameful history to keep a good name and to stay in good graces with their subjects. In his final chapter of King Leopold’s Ghost, Adam Hochschild conveys how the transgression of the Flemish to the Congolese was erased. How is it that the people of both the Congo and Belgium have completely forgotten the horrors their predecessors endured and committed? For every secret that is uncovered, how many more are…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kingsolver builds this particular character in his image, rather than the image he sees himself to draw direct attention to Leopold. Price’s lust for power in conjunction with his monotheist ideals make him fit the mold Belgium created(Salvatore 159). Prices is unable to accept that “The laws of these people are part of what defines their culture, and by replacing their laws with Christian based laws, these people could lose what makes them who they are”(Wind 2). Price attempts to force the Congolese into his way of life, without fearing the cultural genocide he planned to complete. Price could not comprehend the truth; that the native Congolese saw no benefit in acquiring his help.…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For one thing, the natives became reliant on Belgium's government and could not control their political destiny at the end of colonization. They were so accustomed to the colonial administrators making all of the political decisions that when the Democratic Republic of Congo gained its independence, they did not know much about how to rule their independent country. The Belgians would not allow the natives to maintain government post during their rule causing the vast majority to not view the country as united. This quickly became a problem as one hundred twenty political parties emerged and people began to see themselves as members of an ethnic group rather than a citizen of the Democratic Republic of Congo. Likewise, inadequate leaders emerged which only caused more issues to arise and conditions in the country to worsen. The faults in the government after the Democratic Republic of Congo’s independence are a clear consequence of the country previously being colonized. They developed a dependency during their time as a colony and because of they were unsuccessful and maintaining an adequate…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Belgium saw them as an easy target with big profits and imperialized. Belgium, as a western nation, also agreed to the ideas of Social Darwinism, the belief that the white European was better than the rest of the people in the world, chiefly based on their physical features. Simply put, they were racist. Most Europeans fell into this belief, but the Belgian people took this to an extreme. They enslaved the native people of Congo in their own country and forced work upon them. Quotas and taxes were created to ensure certain amounts of raw materials were gathered and harsh punishments were put into action for those who didn’t complete or meet their requirements. According to Mark Twain, “The amount of rubber needed to meet the tax requires the men to work for up 25 days each month harvesting the wild rubber vines in the Congo forest” [3]. According to this that would leave only 5 days a month for “regular” life for the Congolese people. They did not have the time or resources to educate themselves, make money, or to develop. In 1908 the Belgian government gave the natives better treatment, by taking away the direct ownership of the nation from Leopold and they made it an official colony of the Belgian government [4]. This decision came through by putting humanitarian pressure put on King Leopold. Conditions improved, schools, hospitals, and roads were built, but the cruelty and racism was still their because of the history they had of it. Also, the punishment, crimes, and cruelty was all that the people understood because they were forced to live in it their entire lives, and it was a hard to shift back. Even in today’s world, this industrialization and these policies have left a scar on the Congos. In both the Republic of Congo and the Democratic Republic Of Congo there is still political unrest and constant violence. On December 17, there were 22…

    • 1768 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imperialism is the ideology that drives the Europeans in the “Heart of Darkness” towards the Congo for its ivory. In the Congo, the only things worth paying attention towards are those that provide monetary benefits, and this can be seen when Conrad states “Some, I heard, got drowned in the surf; but whether they did or not, nobody seemed particularly to care.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A key example of how reparations can be in other forms than money is memorialism. As pointed out by Dr. Nieftagodien, senior lecturer at University of Basel, “… Memorialisation is important in the same way that I think uncovering the past [is], making the past known to current generations is an important project … but I also think that it should be an area of contestation.” As Dr. Nieftagodien mentions, memorialism is important to recognizing the past, and it actually addresses the past more directly and honorably than money can. Though unpopular in the African American community, a great form of reparation is a formal apology from the United States; something that has yet to happen. This form of reparation has precedented success. The International Center for Transitional Justice brings us the prime example, “In 2010, the President of Sierra Leone formally apologized to women victims of his country’s 10-year armed conflict. This apology forms part of ongoing efforts to distribute modest compensation, rehabilitation and other benefits to eligible victims.” Dr. Noel Solani, researcher at Robben Island Museum perfectly encompases this point in saying “You can choose to give in monetary terms, but you can also choose to say how you remember this past as a form of giving back in the long term. Because money is something that you can take…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "(Article 2) In addition for some, last reason we can put this past us and be forgiven. “It seems fair to most of us that we now owe them some form of reparations in order to make up for the past”. This may be true, but in my opinion Natives should get their land instead of money, for the majority, the Natives lives revolve around their land. Land is…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A lot of people have different ideas of how our nation will succeed. One big idea that people continue to argue about is how our economy should be played out. It's either a good idea to give to the poor to make things fair, or keep your money to yourselves, or maybe it's a good idea to put a cap on the population so we don't have to give to the poor. I believe that we shouldn’t give to the poor because they will use our givings in a negative way, which would make us regret doing goods. Some people such as William Hogarth support the idea of not giving to the poor because they will use their money on something that they shouldn't be. William Hogarth painted a picture which was called "Gin Lane" to support his ideas. Some people such as Thomas Malthus and Garrett Hardin think that the population is too high to maintain a well kept economy.…

    • 2126 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imperialism Justified

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Imperialism can be justified based on certain intentions. When Leopold surreptitiously deceived African leaders into signing treaties giving them complete power over Africa, it demonstrated the first step of his desire for a colony. The main agent which triggered Leopold into dominating the Congo was because every other European power had their own colony, conveying a feeling of discontent in Belgium. This discontent was the cause of the imperialization of Africa. Based on evidence from documents, Leopold demanded large amounts of rubber to be brought to him in order to satisfy his wishes for Belgium. The fact that Leopold states “I have no other ambition than to serve [Africa] well” is contradicting to his actions later on, where he chops off the hands of thousands of those living in the Congo. Leopold’s bias towards Belgium’s profit is extreme to the point where he has halved the population of the Congo. Although Leopold’s intentions from the beginning were to ultimately modernize Africa and seek neutrality among the valley, he turned imperialism into an evil idea by violating human rights which guarantee each human life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. He exceeded the boundaries severing imperialization from abuse. However, imperialism is a case which can also definitely be justified if a country’s motives are purely to assist that country whether it is through modernizing, civilizing, or organizing the society in a region. Imperialism is not necessarily detrimental in all cases, but can be argued. For example, the Monroe Doctrine was introduced to the U.S. in 1823 to keep European world powers out of the developing Latin American countries, but “chronic wrongdoing” (President Roosevelt) in Latin America ultimately did require intervention. Therefore, it was fine if the U.S. got involved, not the European powers because of the Monroe Doctrine. This proves my point of how imperialism is fundamentally tolerable and fair to some extent.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays