AP English
Mrs. Hoeve
2/19/15
Written Evaluation:
Both of these stories deal with social and moral standards of behavior between the sexes. Which story, in your estimation, deserves the higher ranking of literary fiction? Which gives the greater insight into significant human values? Support your decision with reasoned and thorough analysis.
I believe that “A Jury of Her Peers” deserves a higher ranking of literary fiction. It shows a greater insight into differences between sexes considering significant human values. In “A Jury of Her Peers,” we see the difference between the men and the woman as the men only look at the external evidence for the murder. Meanwhile, the woman look at the thoughts that must have been going through Mrs. Wright’s head. The woman dug deeper and also found the evidence of the dead bird. You figure out Mrs. Wright’s motive for killing her husband while the men all have no idea why Mrs. Wright did it. The woman then hide the evidence because they realize that Mrs. Wright did it because Mr. Wright was holding her back taking away anything joyful in her life. When she married him, it seems that she went from this outgoing and vibrant woman to a secluded and quiet woman. Mr. Wright also didn’t allow much contact with the outside world as he didn’t want a telephone in his house and it seemed like Mrs. Wright never came out much.
Finally, you realize that Mr. Wright killed the bird and that this was the last straw for Mrs.
Wright as she decided that she was done and she killed him. The woman investigating Mrs.
Wright see her reasoning and understand why she did it. Because of this they try to help her and make her not charged with murder. You see the difference between men and woman nature as the woman use intuition and deeper thinking in order to empathize with the other people. The men only look at the outside and choose their actions based on what they see. Comparing this
story to “A Municipal Report,” we see that there is also this oppressing nature from Caswell towards his wife Azalea Adair. But this is more of a background plot that doesn’t get revealed until the end of the story. The story isn’t as focused on the differences between the sexes as compared with “A Jury of Her Peers.” In that story, there are two distinct differences shown between men and women, while in “A Municipal Report” there are men with good natures but also some with worse natures. This doesn’t show the literary fiction’s purpose of broadening, deepening, and sharpening the reader’s awareness of life. In the first story, we are shown an insight into the different human natures of men and women concerning the action of the story. In the second story, we see an insight into the characters natures, but these insights are not as deep and the insights don’t do as much to broaden our awareness of life.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
emotional connection with her husband. She worried about him every minute he was gone. He…
- 411 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Unfortunately, she makes it there and she thinks her father is late and but she sees his other car there. She leaves the place and goes into her car put on the radio only to find out that her father was murdered in his bed and the police were looking her because she confessed to the murder to her mother through email. The only thing was that she didn’t commit or confess to the murder and that her father couldn’t have been murdered in the house because she just left the house. Frightened she drives away paranoid and panic that the police will catch her because on the radio they told which car she was driving and the license plate number. She calls her mother her mother believes that she commits the murder and wants her to turn herself into the police.…
- 1185 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
While Mrs. Wright is helped by her friends to confiscate the weapon she used to kill her husband, Mary is bold enough to cook the frozen leg of lamb she had used to hit her husband at the back of his head. She further invites the Noonan, the police, and his friend “to eat the dinner she had fixed for her husband”. As Peters and Hale are searching for evidence at the Wright’s house, Mrs. Peters supposes that Mrs. Wright “slipped a rope around his neck that choked the life out of him.” The investigators in both stories are certain that the crime was committed by a person from inside the house, but they lacked the necessary information to link the…
- 585 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When Wright go to work, the boss told him to learn something here, but when he is going to seek opportunities to learn, his white coworkers warn him that he is black after all, and do not deserve to learn, then Wright reply politely. One day, he is framed that he does not call a white guy with “Mr.”, but he is black, so he cannot explain for himself but scuttle away, and never come back again as warned. When Wright is working in a store, he witnesses his boss and boss’s son drug a black woman into the store and beat her violently for inability to pay bills. The only thing Wright can do is standing there. After beating that poor…
- 548 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the story, they find several motives for why Mrs. Wright would kill her husband and sympathize the pain she goes through. As they look through Mrs. Wright’s closet to find clothes to give to her in jail, the two women observe how rugged and old her clothes appear, showing that Mr. Wright must not have been financially stable enough to provide her with the items that she desires. This extremely upsets Mrs. Hale, for she had known the unmarried Mrs. Wright, who was widely known to be beautiful, lively, and one of fashion. Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters also examine the kitchen of the house and find everything in a mess and every chore half-finished. While the men degrade her for not fulfilling her duties as a wife, the women support her and exclaim that “farmers’ wives have their hands full” (207). The stove in the poor conditioned kitchen is also used as a metaphor to Mrs. Wright’s relationship with her husband when the two women find it to be broken. The story states that Mrs. Hale thinks “of what it would mean, year after year, to have that stove to wrestle with, and Mrs. Peters replies, “A person gets discouraged—and loses heart” (210). This clearly exemplifies the…
- 1043 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
had seem a man. The lady name is Liza Jane. She goes into great detail about her husband. She tells Mr. Ryder how they were merry on the farm, and that they would be together forever. She tells him the whole story, how he was a free man and the owner of the farm was going to sell her husband to another farm to make some money. So Mrs. Jane told her husband about the news and that he had to go and she would find him later. So this man runs away. And now we are back to present time and Mrs. Jane tells Mr. Ryder that she was been all over the south looking for this man and it has been about 20 to 25…
- 988 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
After finding out about his Uncles assaults on Indian women, David see’s his uncle leaving the house whilst in the neighbours outhouse through a peep hole, that day when arriving home he finds that Marie Little Soldier had been murdered, Marie is an Indian that works in his home and had made the accusations on his uncle, David loved Marie in a young boy sort of way as there was only one kind of love for a 12 year old boy, She was young and beautiful and understood David.…
- 1328 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Alkalay-Gut, Karen. "Jury Of Her Peers: The Importance Of Trifles." Studies In Short Fiction 21.1 (1984): 1. Academic Search Complete. Web. 26 Sept. 2013.…
- 1423 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
One of the primary themes of Wright's autobiographical narrative involves the influence of racism on the personal interrelations not only among the individuals of the oppressed group but within the family itself. The first episode of the narrative, in which Wright at four years of age innocently burns down the family home, has no racial implications per se, but the response of his mother…
- 520 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Wright depicts the victimizing tendencies of the members of his dysfunctional family. In the beginning Wright a first notice something is wrong with his family when his father goes to work and never comes back. This instance confused Wright making him unstable and untamed without restrictions. The next time Wright sees his father is during court when his mother was asking him to pay child support. This…
- 958 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The story goes through her two failed marriages, ultimately leading up to her third marriage (and tragic ending) of her true love, Tea Cake. All throughout the story, a heavy, black dialect is used for the dialogue, making the story somewhat challenging to read. In Wright’s Black Boy, it is obvious that an autobiography is on these pages. It recounts Richard Wright’s life starting from when he burned his house down in Natchez, Mississippi, all the way through his life, ending with him going back to Chicago to be closer to his mother. Throughout the story, Wright gets into various accounts of trouble, prompting inevitable beatings from his elders. This is all happening while he gets a few jobs, writes a few published articles, and nomadically moves from place to…
- 1301 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
“A Jury of Her Peers” chronicles the discovery of and subsequent investigation into John Wright’s murder. The story begins on a cold windy day in Dickson County with Martha Hale, being abruptly called to ride to a crime scene with Lewis Hale, her husband; Sheriff Peters, the county sheriff; and Mrs. Peters, the sheriff’s wife. She rushes out to join them in the buggy and the group sets off. They arrive at the scene of the crime, the Wright’s lonesome-looking house. Immediately Mrs. Hale exhibits feeling of guilt for not visiting her friend Minnie Foster since Foster had married and become Mrs. Wright (the dead man's wife) twenty years prior. Once the whole group is safely inside the house, Mr. Hale is asked to describe, to the county attorney, George Henderson, what he had seen and experienced the day prior. Despite the serious circumstances, he delivers his story in a long-winded and poorly thought-out manner, tendencies he struggles to avoid throughout. The story begins with Mr. Hale venturing to Mr. Wright’s house to convince Wright to get a telephone. Upon entering the house he finds Mrs. Wright in a delirious state and comes to learn that Mr. Wright has allegedly been strangled. The women's curious nature and very peculiar attention to minute details allow them to find evidence of Mrs. Wright's guilt and of her provocations and motives, while the men are unable to procure any evidence. The women find the one usable piece of evidence: the dead bird in the box. It's stated that Minnie used to love to sing and her husband took that away from her. But now finding her bird is dead, it is evident Mrs. Wright killed her husband. The women, finding justification in Mrs. Wright’s actions, go about hiding what they find from the men. In the end, their obstruction of evidence will seemingly prevent a conviction. The story ends here, and does not move into the occurrences after they leave the…
- 334 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The play begins with a criminal investigation taking place at the home of Mr. and Mrs. Wright. Mr. Wright was found dead in their bed with a rope around his neck, with his wife being the largest suspect. Mr. Henderson, the county attorney, Mr. Peters, the sheriff, and Mr. Hale, a neighbor and friend to Mr. Wright, gather around discussing the matter, while Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale stand off to the side, patiently waiting to be a help to personal connection if the men see fit (1362). Throughout the story, the men make light of any problem or important matter that the women may have, or have to offer. They initially notice how dirty and untidy Mrs. Wrights home is, and because this is very unordinary for the women of that time period, 1916, that made Mrs. Wright that much more suspicious. The men also bring up that though Mrs. Wright is held for murder, she is too busy worrying about her perseveres, an unimportant matter to any of the men (1365). Glaspell connected her title with the theme of her story with a comment made by one of her male characters, Mr. Hale, "Well, women are used to worrying over trifles". As though any problem, or worry a women may have is unimportant and exaggerated compared to any "real" issue, that a man might have. Near the end of the story, the women feel sympathetic towards Mrs. Wright for they know how it feels to be a women and they feel that perhaps her actions were justified, for her husband did strangle her beloved bird. Though they have gathered much evidence to close the case, the men do not feel as if their input will be worthy of solving the…
- 1456 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The film moves to Mary Surratt being put on trial for housing these assassins in her boarding house. Her son John Surratt escapes from the investigation going on.…
- 1828 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
Mrs. Hale remembers Mrs. Wright as a girl; Minnie Foster. Mrs. Hale described the young girls, as "kind of like a bird herself – real sweet and pretty, but kind of timid and – fluttery." (Glaspell) If you notice, even the name Minnie belittles her. There are several indicators that Mr. Wright is abusive to his wife, but the people of their town see John Wright as a "good man." (Glaspell) Mrs.…
- 1700 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays